2 - Mocking or Mirthful? Laughter in Early Modern Dialogue

Summary

Rideo, risi, ridere, to laughe: also to skorne or mocke

Rire: laugh, tighie; geere, fleere, mocke, ieast, or scoffe at: make himself merrie with

Introduction: The Ambivalence of Laughter

Early modern dictionaries not only capture the ambivalence of laughter: through the preponderance of negative synonyms that they list – scorn, mock, jeer, fleer, scoff – they also encapsulate its strong association with derision, a word etymologically linked to the Latin ‘ridere’. This derisive strain is evident, for instance, in the way that – in the example above – Randle Cotgrave chose to group ‘ieast’ with verbs utilising the preposition ‘at’, rather than ‘with’. Even his onomatopoeiac ‘tighie’ (‘tee-hee’) is far from neutral, defined by the OED as indicating ‘the sound of a light laugh, usually derisive’. It is this disdainful perception of laughter that dominates early modern discussions of the phenomenon. As Quentin Skinner notes, ‘with the recovery of the classical theory of eloquence – one of the defining achievements of Renaissance culture – the classical theory of laughter was likewise revived’. This was a theory that associated laughter, above all, with contempt: Plato's Republic ‘foreshadows the central principle of Aristotle's analysis when he declares that laughter is almost always connected with the reproving of vice’; Cicero's De Oratore restricts laughter ‘to matters that are in some way either disgraceful or deformed’; Quintilian's De Institutione finds that laughter ‘has its source in things that are either deformed or disgraceful in some way’. Thomas Wilson consequently drew on a long-established tradition when he declared in 1553 that: ‘The occasion of laughter, and the meane that maketh vs merie […] is the fondnes, the filthines, the deformitee, and all suche euill behauior, as we se to bee in other.’

Regarded as a ‘merie’ response to regrettable things, there is thus a duality to early modern conceptions of laughter. This can be seen in Laurent Joubert's Traité du Ris, initially written in Latin in the 1550s and first printed, translated into French, in its complete form in 1579.