Element contents
God, Soul and the Meaning of Life
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 25 April 2019
Summary
This Element critically explores the potential relevance of God or a soul for life's meaning as discussed in recent Anglo-American philosophical literature. There have been four broad views: God or a soul is necessary for meaning in our lives; neither is necessary for it; one or both would greatly enhance the meaning in our lives; one or both would substantially detract from it. This Element familiarizes readers with all four positions, paying particular attention to the latter two, and also presents prima facie objections to them, points out gaps in research agendas and suggests argumentative strategies that merit development.
- Type
- Element
- Information
- Online ISBN: 9781108558136Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication: 09 May 2019
Bibliography
Affolter, Jacob. 2007. ‘Human Nature As God’s Purpose’. Religious Studies 43: 443–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Audi, Robert. 2005. ‘Intrinsic Value and Meaningful Life’. Philosophical Papers 34: 331–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ayer, Alfred Jules. 2000. ‘The Claims of Philosophy’. Repr. in Klemke, E. D. (ed.), The Meaning of Life, 2nd edn. New York: Oxford University Press, 219–33. First published in 1947.Google Scholar
Baier, Kurt. 2000. ‘The Meaning of Life’. Repr. in Klemke, E. D. (ed.), The Meaning of Life, 2nd edn. New York: Oxford University Press, 101–32. First published in 1957.Google Scholar
Baker, Lynne Rudder. 2017. ‘Resurrecting Material Persons’. In Nagasawa, Yujin and Matheson, Benjamin (eds), The Palgrave Handbook of the Afterlife. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 315–30.Google Scholar
Belshaw, Christopher. 2005. 10 Good Questions about Life and Death. Malden, MA: Blackwell.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blessing, Kimberly. 2013. ‘Atheism and the Meaningfulness of Life’. In Bullivant, Stephen and Ruse, Michael (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Atheism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 104–18.Google Scholar
Blumenfeld, David. 2009. ‘Living Life over Again’. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 79: 357–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bortolotti, Lisa and Nagasawa, Yujin. 2009. ‘Immortality without Boredom’. Ratio 22: 261–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, Delwin. 1971. ‘Process Philosophy and the Question of Life’s Meaning’. Religious Studies 7: 13–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Campbell, Stephen and Nyholm, Sven. 2015. ‘Anti-Meaning and Why It Matters’. Journal of the American Philosophical Association 1: 694–711.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Camus, Albert. 1955. The Myth of Sisyphus, Justin O’Brian (trans.). Repr. London: H. Hamilton. First published in 1942.Google Scholar
Chappell, Timothy. 2009. ‘Infinity Goes up on Trial: Must Immortality Be Meaningless?’ European Journal of Philosophy 17: 30–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cholbi, Michael. 2015. ‘Immortality and the Exhaustibility of Value’. In Cholbi, Michael (ed.), Immortality and the Philosophy of Death. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield, 221–36.Google Scholar
Cottingham, John. 2005. The Spiritual Dimension: Religion, Philosophy and Human Value. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cottingham, John. 2008. ‘The Self, the Good Life and the Transcendent’. In Athanassoulis, Nafsika and Vice, Samantha (eds), The Moral Life: Essays in Honour of John Cottingham. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 231–74.Google Scholar
Cottingham, John. 2016a. ‘Theism and Meaning in Life’. European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 8: 47–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cottingham, John. 2016b. ‘Meaningfulness, Eternity, and Theism’. In Seachris, Joshua and Goetz, Stewart (eds), God and Meaning. New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 123–36.Google Scholar
Craig, William Lane. 2009a. ‘The Kurtz/Craig Debate’. In Garcia, Robert and King, Nathan (eds), Is Goodness without God Good Enough? Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield, 23–46.Google Scholar
Craig, William Lane. 2009b. ‘This Most Gruesome of Guests’. In Garcia, Robert and King, Nathan (eds), Is Goodness without God Good Enough? Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield, 167–88.Google Scholar
Craig, William Lane. 2013. ‘The Absurdity of Life without God’. Repr. in Seachris, Joshua (ed.), Exploring the Meaning of Life: An Anthology and Guide. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell, 153–72. First published in 1994.Google Scholar
Edwards, Paul. 1972. ‘Why’. In Edwards, Paul (ed.), The Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Volumes 7–8. New York: Macmillan Publishing Company, 296–302.Google Scholar
Ellis, Fiona. 2011. ‘Desire, Infinity, and the Meaning of Life’. Philosophy 86: 483–502.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fischer, John Martin. 1994. ‘Why Immortality Is Not So Bad’. International Journal of Philosophical Studies 2: 257–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fischer, John Martin. 2005. ‘Free Will, Death, and Immortality: The Role of Narrative’. Philosophical Papers 34: 379–403.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frankfurt, Harry. 1988. ‘The Importance of What We Care About’. Repr. in his The Importance of What We Care About. New York: Cambridge University Press, 80–94. First published in 1982.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Garcia, Robert and King, Nathan (eds). 2009. Is Goodness without God Good Enough? Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
Gordon, Jeffrey. 1983. ‘Is the Existence of God Relevant to the Meaning of Life?’ The Modern Schoolman 60: 227–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hammerton, Matthew. 2018. ‘Well-Being and Meaning in Life’. Presentation given at the First International Conference on Philosophy and Meaning in Life held at Hokkaido University in Sapporo, Japan.Google Scholar
Hartshorne, Charles. 1984. ‘God and the Meaning of Life’. In Rouner, Leroy (ed.), On Nature. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 154–68.Google Scholar
Haught, John. 2013. ‘Is Nature Enough?’ Repr. in Seachris, Joshua (ed.), Exploring the Meaning of Life: An Anthology and Guide. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell, 173–82. First published in 2006.Google Scholar
Hepburn, R. W. 2000. ‘Questions about the Meaning of Life’. Repr. in Klemke, E. D. (ed.), The Meaning of Life, 2nd edn. New York: Oxford University Press, 261–76. First published in 1966.Google Scholar
Hubin, Donald. 2009. ‘Empty and Ultimately Meaningless Gestures?’ In Garcia, Robert and King, Nathan (eds), Is Goodness without God Good Enough? Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield, 133–50.Google Scholar
James, Laurence. 2009. ‘Shape and the Meaningfulness of Life’. In Bortolotti, Lisa (ed.), Philosophy and Happiness. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 54–67.Google Scholar
Kahane, Guy. 2011. ‘Should We Want God to Exist?’ Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 82: 674–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kahane, Guy. 2018. ‘If There Is a Hole, It Is Not God-Shaped’. In Kraay, Klaas (ed.), Does God Matter? Essays on the Axiological Consequences of Theism. New York: Routledge, 95–131.Google Scholar
Kekes, John. 2000. ‘The Meaning of Life’. In French, Peter and Wettstein, Howard (eds), Midwest Studies in Philosophy, Volume 24: Life and Death. Malden, MA: Blackwell, 17–34.Google Scholar
Kershnar, Stephen. 2014. ‘Thad Metz’s Fundamentality Theory of Meaning in Life’. Science, Religion and Culture 1: 97–100.Google Scholar
Kraay, Klaas. 2018a. ‘Invitation to the Axiology of Theism’. In Kraay, Klaas (ed.), Does God Matter? Essays on the Axiological Consequences of Theism. New York: Routledge, 1–35.Google Scholar
Kraay, Klaas (ed.). 2018b. Does God Matter? Essays on the Axiological Consequences of Theism. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Kraay, Klaas and Dragos, Chris. 2013. ‘On Preferring God’s Non-Existence’. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 43: 153–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Landau, Iddo. 1997. ‘Why Has the Question of Life’s Meaning Arisen in the Last Two and a Half Centuries?’ Philosophy Today 41: 263–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lougheed, Kirk. 2017. ‘Anti-Theism and the Objective Meaningful Life Argument’. Dialogue 56: 337–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lutz, Matthew and Lenman, James. 2018. ‘Moral Naturalism’ (rev. edn). In Zalta, Edward (ed.), Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/naturalism-moral/.Google Scholar
Maitzen, Stephen. 2009. ‘Ordinary Morality Implies Atheism’. European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 2: 107–26.Google Scholar
Maitzen, Stephen. 2018. ‘The Problem of Magic’. In Kraay, Klaas (ed.), Does God Matter? Essays on the Axiological Consequences of Theism. New York: Routledge, 132–46.Google Scholar
Martela, Frank. 2017. ‘Meaningfulness As Contribution’. Southern Journal of Philosophy 55: 232–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mawson, T. J. 2013. ‘Recent Work on the Meaning of Life and the Philosophy of Religion’. Philosophy Compass 8: 1138–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mawson, T. J. 2016. God and the Meanings of Life: What God Could and Couldn’t Do to Make Our Lives More Meaningful. London: Bloomsbury Publishing.Google Scholar
Mawson, T. J. 2018. ‘God’s Possible Roles in the Meaning of Life’. European Journal for the Philosophy of Religion 10: 193–203.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Megill, Jason and Linford, Daniel. 2016. ‘God, the Meaning of Life, and a New Argument for Atheism’. International Journal of Philosophy of Religion 79: 31–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Metz, Thaddeus. 2013b. ‘The Meaning of Life’ (rev. edn). In Zalta, Edward (ed.), Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/life-meaning/.Google Scholar
Metz, Thaddeus. 2013c. ‘How God Could Assign Us a Purpose without Disrespect’. Quadranti 1: 99–112.Google Scholar
Metz, Thaddeus. 2015. ‘Assessing Lives, Capturing Naturalism, and Giving Supernaturalism Its Due’. In Morioka, Masahiro (ed.), Reconsidering Meaning in Life. Saitama, Japan: Waseda University, 228–78.Google Scholar
Metz, Thaddeus. 2016a. ‘Further Explorations of Supernaturalism about Meaning in Life’. European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 8: 59–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Metz, Thaddeus. 2016b. ‘Is Life’s Meaning Ultimately Unthinkable?’ Philosophia 44: 1247–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Metz, Thaddeus. 2017a. ‘Meaning in Life’. In Matheson, Benjamin and Nagasawa, Yujin (eds), The Palgrave Handbook on the Afterlife. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 353–70.Google Scholar
Metz, Thaddeus. 2017b. ‘Neutrality, Partiality, and Meaning in Life’. De Ethica 4: 7–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Metz, Thaddeus. 2018. ‘God’s Role in a Meaningful Life’. European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 10: 171–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Metz, Thaddeus. 2019. ‘Meaning’. In Oppy, Graham (ed.), Blackwell Companion to Atheism and Philosophy. Oxford: Blackwell, 355–66.Google Scholar
Morris, Thomas. 1992. Making Sense of It All: Pascal and the Meaning of Life. Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company.Google Scholar
Moser, Paul. 2016. ‘Affective Gethsemane Meaning for Life’. In Seachris, Joshua and Goetz, Stewart (eds), God and Meaning. New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 167–84.Google Scholar
Mulgan, Tim. 2015. Purpose in the Universe: The Moral and Metaphysical Case for Ananthropocentric Purposivism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Norman, Richard. 2006. ‘The Varieties of Non-Religious Experience’. Ratio 19: 474–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nozick, Robert. 1981. Philosophical Explanations. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Nussbaum, Martha. 1989. ‘Mortal Immortals’. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 50: 303–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Penner, Myron. 2015. ‘Personal Anti-Theism and the Meaningful Life Argument’. Faith and Philosophy 32: 325–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Penner, Myron. 2017. ‘On the Objective Meaningful Life Argument’. Dialogue 57: 173–82.Google Scholar
Penner, Myron and Arbour, Benjamin. 2018. ‘Arguments from Evil and Evidence for Pro-Theism’. In Kraay, Klaas (ed.), Does God Matter? Essays on the Axiological Consequences of Theism. New York: Routledge, 192–202.Google Scholar
Poettcker, Jason. 2015. ‘Defending the Purpose Theory of Meaning in Life’. In Morioka, Masahiro (ed.), Reconsidering Meaning in Life. Saitama, Japan: Waseda University, 180–207.Google Scholar
Purves, Duncan and Delon, Nicolas. 2018. ‘Meaning in the Lives of Humans and Other Animals’. Philosophical Studies 175: 317–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Quinn, Philip. 2000. ‘How Christianity Secures Life’s Meanings’. In Runzo, Joseph and Martin, Nancy (eds), The Meaning of Life in the World Religions. Oxford: Oneworld Publications, 53–68.Google Scholar
Salles, Sagid. 2010. ‘O Sentido da Vida e o Propósite de Deus’. Fundamento 1: 84–110. English translation is on file with the author.Google Scholar
Sartre, Jean-Paul. 1956. ‘Existentialism Is a Humanism’. Walter Kaufmann (trans.). Repr. in Kaufmann, Walter (ed.), Existentialism from Dostoyevsky to Sartre. New York: The World Publishing Company, 287–311. First published in 1946.Google Scholar
Scheffler, Samuel. 2013. ‘Death and the Afterlife’. In Kolodny, Niko (ed.), Death and the Afterlife. New York: Oxford University Press, 15–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schellenberg, J. L. 2018. In Kraay, Klaas (ed.), Does God Matter? Essays on the Axiological Consequences of Theism. New York: Routledge, 181–91.Google Scholar
Seachris, Joshua. 2009. ‘The Meaning of Life As Narrative: A New Proposal for Interpreting Philosophy’s “Primary” Question’. Philo 12: 5–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Seachris, Joshua. 2011. ‘Death, Futility, and the Proleptic Power of Narrative Ending’. Religious Studies 47: 141–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Seachris, Joshua. 2013. ‘General Introduction’. In Seachris, Joshua (ed.), Exploring the Meaning of Life: An Anthology and Guide. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell, 1–20.Google Scholar
Seachris, Joshua. 2016. ‘The Meaning of Life and Narratives: A Framework for Understanding and Answering the Question of Life’s Meaning’. In Seachris, Joshua and Goetz, Stewart (eds), God and Meaning. New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 13–34.Google Scholar
Seachris, Joshua. 2019. ‘Meaning of Life: Contemporary Analytic Perspectives’. In Fieser, James and Dowden, Bradley (eds), Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. www.iep.utm.edu/mean-ana/.Google Scholar
Singer, Irving. 1996. Meaning of Life, Volume 1: The Creation of Value. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Sinnott-Armstrong, Walter. 2009: ‘Why Traditional Theism Cannot Provide an Adequate Foundation for Morality’. In Garcia, Robert and King, Nathan (eds), Is Goodness without God Good Enough? Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield, 101–15.Google Scholar
Smith, Huston. 2000. ‘The Meaning of Life in the World’s Religions’. In Runzo, Joseph and Martin, Nancy (eds), The Meaning of Life in the World Religions. Oxford: Oneworld Publications, 255–68.Google Scholar
Smith, Quentin. 1997. Ethical and Religious Thought in Analytic Philosophy of Language. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Smuts, Aaron. 2011. ‘Immortality and Significance’. Philosophy and Literature 35: 134–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smuts, Aaron. 2013. ‘The Good Cause Account of the Meaning of Life’. Southern Journal of Philosophy 51: 536–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Steinhart, Eric. 2017. ‘Digital Afterlives’. In Nagasawa, Yujin and Matheson, Benjamin (eds), The Palgrave Handbook of the Afterlife. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 255–73.Google Scholar
Svenson, David. 2000. ‘The Dignity of Human Life’. Repr. in Klemke, E. D. (ed.), The Meaning of Life, 2nd edn. New York: Oxford University Press, 21–30. First published in 1949.Google Scholar
Swinburne, Richard. 2009. ‘What Difference Does God Make to Morality?’ In Garcia, Robert and King, Nathan (eds), Is Goodness without God Good Enough? Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield, 151–63.Google Scholar
Swinburne, Richard. 2016. ‘How God Makes Life a Lot More Meaningful’. In Seachris, Joshua and Goetz, Stewart (eds), God and Meaning. New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 149–64.Google Scholar
Taliaferro, Charles. 2016. ‘The Expansion and Contraction of the Meaning of Life’. In Seachris, Joshua and Goetz, Stewart (eds), God and Meaning. New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 137–47.Google Scholar
Taylor, Richard. 1987. ‘Time and Life’s Meaning’. The Review of Metaphysics 40: 675–86.Google Scholar
Taylor, Richard. 2000. Good and Evil. Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books. First published in 1970.Google Scholar
Tolstoy, Leo. 1884. A Confession. Louise Maude and Aylmer Maude (trans.). www.online-literature.com/tolstoy/a-confession/.Google Scholar
Tooley, Michael. 2018. ‘Axiology: Theism versus Widely Accepted Monotheisms’. In Kraay, Klaas (ed.), Does God Matter? Essays on the Axiological Consequences of Theism. New York: Routledge, 46–69.Google Scholar
Trisel, Brooke Alan. 2002. ‘Futility and the Meaning of Life Debate’. Sorites 14: 70–84.Google Scholar
Trisel, Brooke Alan. 2004. ‘Human Extinction and the Value of Our Efforts’. The Philosophical Forum 35: 371–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Trisel, Brooke Alan. 2012. ‘Intended and Unintended Life’. The Philosophical Forum 43: 395–403.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Trisel, Brooke Alan. 2016. ‘Human Extinction, Narrative Ending, and Meaning of Life’. Journal of Philosophy of Life 6: 1–22.Google Scholar
Waghorn, Nicholas. 2014. Nothingness and the Meaning of Life: Philosophical Approaches to Ultimate Meaning through Nothing and Reflexivity. London: Bloomsbury.Google Scholar
Waghorn, Nicholas. 2015. ‘Metz’ Incoherence Objection: Some Epistemological Considerations’. In Morioka, Masahiro (ed.), Reconsidering Meaning in Life. Saitama, Japan: Waseda University, 150–68.Google Scholar
Walker, Lois Hope. 1989. ‘Religion and the Meaning of Life and Death’. In Pojman, Louis (ed.), Philosophy: The Quest for Truth. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company, 167–71.Google Scholar
Wielenberg, Erik. 2005. Value and Virtue in a Godless Universe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Wielenberg, Erik. 2016. ‘Metz’s Case against Supernaturalism’. European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 8: 27–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wisnewski, J. Jeremy. 2005. ‘Is the Immortal Life Worth Living?’ International Journal of Philosophy of Religion 58: 27–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williams, Bernard. 1973. ‘The Makropulos Case: Reflections on the Tedium of Immortality’. In his Problems of the Self. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 82–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wolf, Susan. 2010. Meaning in Life and Why It Matters. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- 39
- Cited by