Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T06:43:24.210Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Entrepreneurs and Their Businesses during the Mexican Revolution

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 February 2013

María del Carmen Collado
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Most of the academic work on the Mexican Revolution (1910–1920) has focused on sociopolitical and military affairs; few scholars have considered the economic aspects of the period. Even though business historians know now that the Revolution did not bring generalized chaos or total destruction of manufacturing, we still need more research on economic issues. This article analyzes the evolution of the businesses of the Braniff family, as well as their involvement in politics once the regime of Porfirio Díaz collapsed. It examines the Braniffs' political ideas, their strategies to gain power, and their support of the political faction favorable to their interests. The article exposes the tactics the family used to guarantee the safety of their businesses, the losses they suffered, and the new ventures they made after the Revolution.

Type
Articles
Information
Business History Review , Volume 86 , Issue 4 , Winter 2012 , pp. 719 - 744
Copyright
Copyright © The President and Fellows of Harvard College 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Katz, Friederich, La guerra secreta en México, vol. 1: Europa, Estados Unidos y la Revolución Mexicana (Mexico City, 1982), 33–35Google Scholar.

2 Womack, John, “La Revolución, 1910–1925,” in Historia Económica de México, ed. Cárdenas, Enrique (Mexico City, 1992), 394–99Google Scholar.

3 Haber, Stephen, Industria y subdesarrollo: La industrialización de México, 1890–1940 (Mexico City, 1992), 184–86Google Scholar.

4 Haber, Stephen, Razo, Armando, and Maurer, Noel, The Politics of Property Rights: Political Instability, Credible Commitments, and Economic Growth in Mexico, 1876–1929 (New York, 2003), 124, 158, 170CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Notario Agustín Pérez de Lara, No. 62, Deed no. 921, 23 Oct. 1906, Archivo Histórico de Notarías del Distrito Federal, Mexico City (hereafter cited as AHNDF).

6 Espejel, Laura, “Luces y sombras de un proyecto empresarial: La Compañia Papelera San Rafael y Anexas,” in Los inmigrantes en el mundo de los negocios, ed. Meyer, Rosa María y Salazar, Delia (Mexico City, 2003), 155Google Scholar.

7 Notario Agustín Pérez de Lara, No. 62, Deed no. 921, 23 Oct. 1906, AHNDF. All the data from his properties in 1905 come from his will.

8 Collado, Maria del Carmen, La burguesía mexicana: El emporio Braniff y su participación politica, 1865–1920 (Mexico City, 1987), 81–82Google Scholar.

9 Villegas, Daniel Cosío, Historia moderna de México: El Porfiriato–La vida política interior, vol. 2 (Mexico City, 1972), 410Google Scholar; Kuri, Ariel Rodríguez, La experiencia olvidada: El ayuntamiento de México–Política y gobierno, 1876–1912 (Mexico City, 1996), 69Google Scholar.

10 Díaz forced his cabinet to resign on March 24, retaining only Limantour, the visible head of the científicos, and González Cosio, his Minister of War. However, this effort was insufficient and failed. Guerra, François-Xavier, México: Del Antiguo Régimen a la Revolución, vol. 2 (Mexico City, 1993), 304–6Google Scholar.

11 Letter from Óscar Braniff to C. A. Coffin, 18 Apr. 1911, 812.00/1589, National Archives and Records Administration, Records of the Department of State Relating to Internal Affairs of Mexico, 1910–1929, Washington, DC (hereafter cited as NA).

12 Letter from Francisco Vázquez Gómez to Federico González Garza, 14 Apr. 1911, Binder 16, File 1525, Fondo CMXV, Archivo Federico González Garza, Centro de Estudios de Historia de México CARSO, Mexico City (hereafter cited as AFGG).

13 Letter from Óscar Braniff to C. A. Coffin, 18 Apr. 1911, 812.00/1589, NA.

14 Villegas, Daniel Cosío, Historia moderna de México: El Porfiriato—La vida politica exterior, vol. 2 (Mexico City, 1963), 401–2Google Scholar.

15 “Revelaciones sobre la caida de Díaz,” Excélsior, 2 Dec. 1960, Óscar Braniff Archive, Biblioteca Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City (hereafter cited as AB).

16 “Declaration of Mr. Óscar Braniff,” 1911, Binder 18, file 1817, Fondo CMXV, AFGG.

17 Telegrams from Óscar Braniff to José Y. Limantour, 22 Apr. and 4 May 1911, AB.

18 Telegram from Óscar Braniff to José Y. Limantour, 4 May 1911, AB.

19 Espejel, , “Luces y sombras de un proyecto empresarial,” 148Google Scholar.

20 Óscar, Braniff, Observaciones sobre el fomento agrícola considerado como base para la ampliación del crédito agrícola en México (Mexico City, 1910)Google Scholar.

21 This institution was created with a governmental loan to grant credits to small farmers, but since its creation in the Porfirian regime, its funds were used to buy the problematic loans from commercial banks. The Maderista regime used the “Caja” to rediscount unguaranteed loans and commercial paper from the banks, turning them into liquid cash. Maurer, Noel, The Power and the Money: The Mexican Financial System, 1876–1932 (Stanford, 2002), 49, 66, 139Google Scholar.

22 “The Great Error of Gen. Diaz,” The Evening Mail, 22 May 1913, AB.

23 Letter to Eduardo Hay, Secretary of Foreign Affairs, 26 Oct. 1936, File 3296–25, Archivo Histórico de la Secretaria de Relaciones Exteriores, Mexico City (hereafter cited as AHSRE).

24 Cerda, Octavio Magaña, “Historia documental de la Revolución,” El Universal, 20 Jan. 1951Google Scholar.

25 See Collado, , La burguesia mexicana, 126Google Scholar. Katz, , La guerra secreta en México, vol. 1, 129–30Google Scholar.

26 Ulloa, Berta, La revolución intervenida: Relaciones diplomáticas entre México y Estados Unidos (1910–1914) (Mexico City, 1971), 48–52Google Scholar.

27 Woodrow Wilson to the Department of State, 26 Apr. 1912, 812.00/3732, NA.

28 There is no figure of casualties of the event, but according to reliable sources around five hundred people were killed on the first day of attack. Knight, Alan, La Revolución Mexicana: Del Porfiriato al nuevo régimen constitucional, vol. 1 (Mexico City, 1996), 540Google Scholar.

29 Letter from Óscar to Tomás Braniff, 10 Apr. 1913, AB.

30 Letter from Óscar Braniff to Felix Sommerfeld, 2 Jan. 1915, AB.

31 Letter from Óscar Braniff to William Jennings Bryan, 27 Apr. 1913, AB.

32 Letter from A. B. Farquhar to Óscar Braniff, 25 Apr. 1913, AB.

33 Letter from Óscar Braniff to Felix Sommerfeld, 2 Jan. 1915, AB.

34 Telegram from Óscar Braniff to Araiza, 27 May 1913, AB.

35 Ulloa, , La revolución intervenida, 63–64Google Scholar.

36 Telegram from Óscar Braniff to De la Barra and Toribio Esquivel Obregón, 26 May 1913, Telegram from Esquivel Obregón to Óscar Braniff, 28 May 1913, AB.

37 “Se aclara el misterio de la junta celebrada ayer en la casa de don Thomas Braniff,” El Universal, 24 June 1913, AB.

38 Meyer, Michael, Huerta: A Political Portrait (Lincoln, 1972), 96–101Google Scholar. The followers of Félix Díaz and Huerta signed this pact in the American Embassy in Mexico City during the military coup that overthrew Madero.

39 Knight, , La Revolución Mexicana, vol. 2, 625Google Scholar.

40 Estañol, Jorge Vera, La Revolución Mexicana: Orígenes y resultados (Mexico City, 1957), 331–32Google Scholar.

41 Knight, , La Revolución Mexicana, vol. 2, 625Google Scholar.

42 Letter from Óscar Braniff to John Bassett Moore, 24 July 1913, AB.

43 Memorandum, I. E.786-R, File 38 (12), 124, AHSRE. The consular reports of Carrancistas contained the dubious information that Óscar Braniff and Alonso Mariscal Piña had contacted Wilson, offering him five million pesos in gold to recognize Huerta in June 1913.

44 Estañol, , La Revolución Mexicana, 132Google Scholar.

45 His brother-in-law Luis Bermejillo asked Óscar to find a new power of attorney in Mexico. Telegram from Toribio Esquivel Obregón to Óscar Braniff, 28 May 1913, AB.

46 The Zapatistas attacked San Rafael because Porfirio Díaz had seized the communal properties of the woods of Tlalmimilulpan and Hueyapan and given them to the paper mill. Espejel, , “Luces y sombras de un proyecto empresarial,” 148–50Google Scholar.

47 Letter from Francisco González Garza to Venustiano Carranza, 9 Apr. 1914, Binder 32, File 3160, 1914, Fondo CMXV, AFGG.

48 “The Great Error of Gen. Diaz,” The Evening Mail, 22 May 1913, AB. Braniff's criticisms implicated the científicos.

49 “President Must Change Policy to Solve Mexican Problem, says O. J. Braniff,” New York Herald, 14 Sept. 1913, AB.

50 Letter from A. B. Farquhar to President Wilson, 13 Dec. 1913, AB.

51 Letter from Óscar Braniff to William Jennings Bryan, December 1913, AB.

52 Memorandum to the US government, 1914, AB; written communication from Óscar Braniff to Wilson, AB.

53 Letter from Óscar Braniff to A. B. Farquhar, 4 Jan. 1915, AB.

54 Katz, Friederich, Pancho Villa, vol. 1 (Mexico City, 1998), 362–64Google Scholar. Sommerfeld was also the chief of Madero's secret service.

55 Letter from Óscar Braniff to Felix Sommerfeld, 2 Jan. 1915, AB.

56 The Compañía Ingeniera Importadora y Contratista S.A., was successor to G. & O. Braniff. File 16-12-33, AHSRE.

57 Document by Conrado Pelayo, 1 Sept. 1914, File 16-13-139, AHSRE.

58 Lorenza Braniff, Confiscation of two houses and two haciendas, File 16-13-139, AHSRE.

59 Y. L. Pesqueira to the Senior Officer of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 29 Oct. 1914, File 16-13-139, AHSRE.

60 Señora Lorenza Braniff's complaint about the occupation of the house at no. 12, Benito Juárez Street, 4 Jan. 1915, File 16-14-10, AHSRE.

61 Complaints by the Minister of Brazil to the Mexican government, 1914, File 16-13-103, AHSRE.

62 Knight, , La Revolución Mexicana, vol. 2, 752Google Scholar.

63 Letter to Sr. Cardoso de Oliveira from Venustiano Carranza, 7 Oct. 1914, File 16-13-103, AHSRE.

64 Copy of deed, undated, unnotarized, papers of Tomás Braniff, held by his heir Elita Boari, Mexico City.

65 Letter from Crawford M. Bishop to Óscar Braniff, 27 Oct. 1938, private archive of Tomás Braniff.

66 Letter from Salvador Martínez Alonso to Isidro Fabela, 4 Dec. 1914, L. E. 808 R. File 1, p. 16, AHSRE.

67 Óscar Braniff to Arturo Braniff, 18 Dec. 1913, AB.

68 Óscar Braniff to Felix Sommerfeld, 15 Jan. 1915, AB.

69 Letter from John D. Rodgers to Cándido Aguilar, 13 Apr. 1915, File 12-27-5, AHSRE.

70 Letter from Óscar Braniff to Felix Sommerfeld, 1 Mar. 1915, AB.

71 Memorandum, 21 July 1915, AB.

72 Typewritten document on recognition of Carranza (n. p., n. d.), AB.

73 Memorandum, 24 Jan. 1916, AB.

74 Letter from Lansing to the Secretary of the Interior, with memorandum by Tomás Braniff annexed, 812.00/20 000, NA.

75 Letter from Óscar Braniff to Leon Canova, 6 Mar. 1916, AB.

76 Flores, Jorge, “La conspiración contrarrevolucionaria de los hermanos Braniff,” in Novedades, 16 Jan. 1966, ABGoogle Scholar.

77 Katz, , Pancho Villa, vol. 2, 270Google Scholar.

78 Letter from Federico González Garza to Roque González Garza, 4 Feb. 1919, Binder 48, File 4777, Doc. 1, 1919, Fondo CMXV, AFGG.

79 Letter from Federico González Garza to Miguel Díaz Lombardo, 3 Feb. 1919, Binder 48, File 4772, Doc. 1, Fondo CMXV, AFGG.

80 Espejel, , “Luces y sombras de un proyecto empresarial,” 151Google Scholar.

81 Haber, , Razo, , and Maurer, , The Politics of Property Rights, 171, 175Google Scholar.

82 Notario Agustín Carreño, No. 48, Deed no. 4442, 14 Apr. 1925, AHNDF.

83 Notario Agustín Carreño, No. 48, Deed no. 13313, 19 July 1928, AHNDF.

84 Muñoz, Jorge Jiménez, La traza del poder: Historia de la politica y los negocios urbanos en el Distrito Federal de sus orígenes a la desaparición del Ayuntamiento (1824–1928) (Mexico City, 1993), 159Google Scholar.

85 Haber, , Razo, , and Maurer, , The Politics of Property Rights, 175Google Scholar.

86 Bortz, Jeffrey L., “The Legal and Contractual Limits to Private Property Rights in Mexican Industry during the Revolution,” in The Mexican Economy, 1870–1930: Essays on the Economic History of Institutions, Revolution and Growth, ed. Bortz, Jeffrey L. and Haber, Stephen (Stanford, 2002), 282Google Scholar.

87 Collado, , La burguesía mexicana, 163Google Scholar.