Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-j824f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T05:10:59.306Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“To Dispose of Wealth in Works of Charity”: Entrepreneurship and Philanthropy in Medieval England

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 August 2019

Catherine Casson  and
Mark Casson
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

While entrepreneurs are increasingly recognized as important participants in the medieval economy, their philanthropic activities have received less attention than those of the gentry and nobility. This article identifies the contribution that the study of medieval entrepreneurs can make to broader business history debates surrounding the identity of philanthropists and their beneficiaries, the types of causes they supported, and their impact on wider society. Philanthropic entrepreneurs used the profits of commerce to provide infrastructure, health care, and education to their local communities. Their patterns of philanthropy differed from those of gentry, lawyers, and administrators. Support for municipal infrastructure emerges as a distinctive feature of entrepreneurial philanthropy, reflecting a belief in the importance of trade networks and civic reputation.

Keywords

entrepreneurmerchantphilanthropycharitywelfaremedieval
Type
Research Article
Information
Business History Review , Volume 93 , Issue 3: Entrepreneurship and Philanthropy , Autumn 2019 , pp. 473 - 502
Copyright
Copyright © The President and Fellows of Harvard College 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

We would like to acknowledge feedback from the editors of the special issue, the other contributors, and the referees. Thanks also go to Craig Lambert.

References

1 Casson, Mark and Casson, Catherine, The Entrepreneur in History: From Medieval Merchant to Modern Business Leader (Basingstoke, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 For extended gentry families the number of members results in less precision on death dates, and so we include some where the dynasty was finishing in or just after 1500.

3 Previous work on philanthropy has often been based on wills and testaments, as described below, and assigned monetary values to the donations. These sources do not survive for many of the individuals in our study, and so information on their activities is derived from a wider range of records in which monetary values are rarely reported.

4 Maclean, Mairi, Harvey, Charles, and Clegg, Stewart R., “Organization Theory in Business and Management History: Present Status and Future Prospects,” Business History Review 91, no. 3 (2017): 457–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Wadhwani, R. Daniel and Jones, Geoffrey, “Schumpeter's Plea: Historical Reasoning in Entrepreneurship Theory and Research,” in Organizations in Time: History, Theory, Methods, ed. Bucheli, Marcelo and Wadhwani, R. Daniel (Oxford, 2014), 192–216Google Scholar; Akrivou, Kleio and Sison, Alejo José G., eds., The Challenges of Capitalism for Virtue Ethics and the Common Good: Interdisciplinary Perspectives (Cheltenham, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Jordan, W. K., Philanthropy in England, 1480–1660: A Study of the Changing Pattern of English Social Aspirations (London, 1959), 360–61Google Scholar.

6 Burgess, Clive, “‘By Quick and By Dead’: Wills and Pious Provision in Late Medieval Bristol,” English Historical Review 102, no. 405 (1987): 837–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Rosenthal, Joel T., The Purchase of Paradise: Gift Giving and the Aristocracy, 1307–1485 (London and Toronto, 1972)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jordan, Philanthropy.

8 Jordan, Philanthropy; 41-53.

9 Harvey, Charles, Maclean, Mairi, Gordon, Jillian, and Shaw, Eleanor, “Andrew Carnegie and the Foundations of Contemporary Entrepreneurial Philanthropy,” Business History 53, no. 3 (2011): 425–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jeremy, David J., “The Enlightened Paternalist in Action: William Hesketh Lever at Port Sunlight before 1914,” Business History 33, no. 1 (1991): 58–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jeremy, , Capitalists and Christians: Business Leaders and the Churches in Britain, 1900–1960 (Oxford, 1990)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 Maclean, Mairi, Harvey, Charles, Gordon, Jillian, and Shaw, Eleanor, “Identity, Storytelling and the Philanthropic Journey,” Human Relations 68, no. 10 (2015): 1623–52CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; Prochaska, Frank, Schools of Citizenship: Charity and Civic Virtue (London, 2002), 47Google Scholar.

11 Bekkers, R. and Wiepking, P., “A Literature Review of Empirical Studies of Philanthropy: Eight Mechanisms that Drive Charitable Giving,” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 40, no. 5 (2011): 924–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Maclean et al., “Identity.”

13 Jeremy, Capitalists and Christians.

14 The Oxford Dictionary of National Biography includes the following individuals who were entrepreneurs according to our definition but were not philanthropic (d. indicates deceased): Andrew Aubrey (d. 1356), Bartholomew Bosan (d. 1400), Nicholas Brembre (d. 1388), John Browne (d. 1476), Margaret Burton (d. 1488), William Cantelowe (d. 1464), John Causton (d. 1353), Hamo Chigwell (d. 1332), Walter Chiriton (d. ca. 1358), Gabriel Corbet (d. 1454), John Crab (d. ca. 1352), Richard Embleton (d. ca. 1333), James Falleron (d. ca. 1463), Hugh Fastolf (d. 1392), Alice Folston (d. ca. 1395), Adam Fraunceys (d. 1375), Simon Fraunceys (d. 1358), John Goldbeter (d. 1364), John Halle (d. 1479), Joan Hill (d. 1441), Ralph Holland (d. 1452), Nichola Irby (d. 1395), Marion Kent (d. 1500), Katherine Lakensnyder (d. 1394), Katherine Lam (d. 1484), Mark LeFayre (d. 1417/18), Richard Lyons (d. 1381), Gilbert Maghfeld (d. 1397), Thomas Melchebourne (d. 1356), William Melchebourne (d. ca. 1360), Isabel Nunhouse (d. ca. 1442), John Pecche (d. 1380), John Perbroun (d. 1342/43), Henry Picard (d. 1361), William de la Pole (d. 1366), Agnes Ramsey (d. ca. 1399), Richer Refham (d. 1328), Thomas Romeyn (d. 1313), William Servat (d. 1318/19), Robert Sturmy (d. 1458), John Wesenham (d. 1382), Robert Wilford (d. 1396) and Cecily Yharom (d. 1396).

15 Heath, John Benjamin, Some Account of the Worshipful Company of Grocers of the City of London (London, 1854)Google Scholar; Cooper, Charles Henry, Annals of Cambridge, vol. 1 (Cambridge, U.K., 1842)Google Scholar.

16 Raban, Sandra, “Mortmain in Medieval England,” Past and Present 62 (Feb. 1974): 3–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 Rosser, Gervase, The Art of Solidarity in the Middle Ages: Guilds in England, 1250–1550 (Oxford, 2015)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

18 Rosenthal, Purchase of Paradise, 9–10.

19 Swanson, R. N., Religion and Devotion in Europe, c. 1215–c. 1515 (Cambridge, U.K., 1995), 206–25Google Scholar.

20 Davis, James, Medieval Market Morality: Life, Law and Ethics in the English Marketplace, 1200–1500 (Cambridge, U.K., 2012)Google Scholar.

21 Rubin, Miri, Charity and Community in Medieval Cambridge (Cambridge, U.K., 1987), 1CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

22 M. R. Macdonald, “Clopton, Hugh (c. 1440–1496),” in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, https://www.oxforddnb.com/ (hereafter ODNB); Sharpe, Reginald R., ed., Calendar of Wills Proved and Enrolled in the Court of Husting, London, part 2, 1358–1688 (London, 1890), 595Google Scholar.

23 “Pious and Charitable Bequests” (1435), Florilegium Urbanum, Medieval English Towns website (hereafter FLU), last updated 20 Mar. 2004, http://users.trytel.com/tristan/towns/florilegium/lifecycle/lcdth19.html.

24 “The Wills and Testaments of Three London Grocers” (15th century), FLU, last updated 8 Jan. 2019, http://users.trytel.com/tristan/towns/florilegium/lifecycle/lcdth12.html.

25 V. Henn, “Lemberg [Limberg, Limburg], Tideman (c. 1310–1386),” ODNB.

26 Paul Strohm, “Twyford, Sir Nicholas (d. 1390/91),” ODNB; Lorna E. M. Walker, “Barantyn, Drew (c. 1350–1415),” ODNB; The History of Parliament (hereafter HoP), s.v. “Barantyn, Drew (d. 1415),” https://www.historyofparliamentonline.org/; Will of Drew Barantyn, citizen and alderman of City of London, TNA PROB 11/2B/82, The National Archives, Kew; Reddaway, T. F. and Walker, Lorna, The Early History of the Goldsmiths Company (London, 1975), 279–82Google Scholar.

27 HoP, s.v. “Canynges, William (d.1396).”

28 Anne F. Sutton, “Whittington, Richard (c. 1350–1423),” ODNB; HoP, s.v. “Whittington, Richard (d. 1423)”; Clive Burgess, “Canynges, William (1402–1474),” ODNB.

29 “Pious and Charitable Bequests,” FLU; HoP, s.v. “Whittington, Richard (d. 1423).”

30 HoP, s.v. “Welles, John III (d.1442)”; “Three London Grocers,” FLU; Heath, Worshipful Company of Grocers, 221–23.

31 Caroline M. Barron, “Eyre, Simon (c. 1395–1458),” ODNB.

32 HoP, s.v. “Welles, John III (d.1442)”; “Three London Grocers,” FLU; Heath, Worshipful Company of Grocers, 221–23.

33 Heath, Worshipful Company of Grocers, 223–24; Arnold, Richard, The Customs of London, Otherwise Called Arnold's Chronicle (London, 1811), xxxiiiGoogle Scholar; Lyte, H. C. Maxwell, Calendar of Patent Rolls Preserved in the Public Record Office: Henry VI, vol. 3, 1436–41 (London, 1907), 142, 232, 253, 345Google Scholar; Sharp, Buchanan, Famine and Scarcity in Late Medieval and Early Modern England: The Regulation of Grain Marketing, 1256–1631 (Cambridge, U.K., 2016), 142CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

34 Caroline M. Barron, “Forster [Foster], Agnes (d. 1484),” ODNB; Sharpe, Reginald R., ed., Calendar of Letter-Books of the City of London: L, Edward IV–Henry VII (London, 1912), 40Google Scholar.

35 Barron, “Eyre,” ODNB.

36 Harrison, David, The Bridges of Medieval England: Transport and Society, 400–1800 (Oxford, 2004)Google Scholar.

37 George Holmes, “Eastfield, Sir William (d. 1446),” ODNB.

38 Nicholas Martin Herbert, “The Borough of Wallingford, 1155–1400” (PhD diss., University of Reading, 1970), 150.

39 “Testaments of a Devout Husband and Wife” (1430s), FLU, last updated 16 Dec. 2010, http://users.trytel.com/tristan/towns/florilegium/lifecycle/lcdth16.html; Clive Burgess, “Chestre, Alice (d. 1485),” ODNB; Fleming, Peter, “Women in Bristol, 1373–1660,” in Women and the City: Bristol, 1373–2000, ed. Dresser, Madge (Bristol, 2016), 27Google Scholar; Burgess, “‘By Quick.’”

40 Rawcliffe, Carole, Urban Bodies: Communal Health in Late Medieval English Towns and Cities (Woodbridge, 2013)Google Scholar.

41 Lee, John S., “Piped Water Supplies Managed by Civic Bodies in Medieval English Towns,” Urban History 41, no. 3 (2014): 1–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

42 Creighton, Oliver and Higham, Robert, Medieval Town Walls: An Archaeology and Social History of Urban Defence (Stroud, 2005)Google Scholar.

43 “Wills of Two Southampton Mayors” (late 15th century), FLU, last updated 6 Jan. 2019, http://users.trytel.com/tristan/towns/florilegium/lifecycle/lcdth15.html; Chapman, A. B. Wallis, ed., The Black Book of Southampton, vol. 2 (Southampton, 1912)Google Scholar; HoP, s.v. “Soper, William (d.1458/9)”; James, Tom Beaumont, “Soper, William (d. 1459),” ODNB; Bradley, Helen, “Southampton's Trading Partners: London,” in English Inland Trade, 1430–1540: Southampton and Its Region, ed. Hicks, Michael (Oxford, 2015), 65–80Google Scholar; Platt, Colin, Medieval Southampton: The Port and Trading Community, A.D. 100–1600 (London and Boston, 1973), 257–58Google Scholar.

44 Pamela Nightingale, “Walworth, Sir William (d. 1386?),” ODNB.

45 Salzman, L. F., ed., A History of the County of Cambridge and the Isle of Ely, vol. 2 (London, 1948), 210–17Google Scholar; Sharpe, Reginald R., ed., Calendar of Wills Proved and Enrolled in the Court of Husting, London, part 1, 1258–1358 (London, 1889), 649–51Google Scholar.

46 MacKenzie, E., A Descriptive and Illustrative Account of the Town and County of Newcastle including the Vicinity of Gateshead, vol. 1 (Newcastle, 1827), 119Google Scholar; Raine, James, ed., Wills and Inventories Illustrative of the History, Manners, Language, Statistics Etc of the Northern Counties of England from the Eleventh Century, part 1 (London, 1884–1885), 164–67Google Scholar; HoP, s.v. “Thornton, Roger (d. 1430)”; Liddy, Christian D., The Bishopric of Durham in the Late Middle Ages: Lordship, Community and the Cult of St. Cuthbert (Woodbridge, 2008), 56Google Scholar.

47 “Three London Grocers,” FLU; Heath, Worshipful Company of Grocers, 208–11; HoP, s.v. “Chichele, Robert (d. 1439)”.

48 Serjeantson, R. M. and Adkins, W. R. D., eds., A History of the County of Northampton, vol. 2 (London, 1906), 179–80Google Scholar; Stephen O'Connor, “Pyel, John (c. 1315–1382),” ODNB; O'Connor, Stephen, ed., A Calendar of the Cartularies of John Pyel and Adam Fraunceys (London, 1993)Google Scholar; O'Connor, Stephen, “Finance, Diplomacy and Politics: Royal Service by Two London Merchants in the Reign of Edward III,” Historical Research 67, no. 162 (1994): 18–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar; O'Connor, Stephen, “Adam Fraunceys and John Pyel: Perceptions of Status among Merchants in Fourteenth-Century London,” in Trade, Devotion and Governance: Papers in Later Medieval History, ed. Clayton, Dorothy J., Davies, Richard G., and McNiven, Peter (Stroud, 1994), 17-35Google Scholar; O'Connor, Stephen, “Joan Pyel,” in Medieval London Widows, 1300–1500, ed. Barron, C. M. and Sutton, A. F. (London: 1994), 71–76Google Scholar.

49 Munn, Kenneth E., Hidden Portraits of Henry VII's Family and Court Depicted in the Stained Glass at St Mary's Church Fairford (n.p., 2016)Google Scholar; Herbert, N. M., ed., A History of the County of Gloucester, vol. 7 (Oxford, 1981), 69–86Google Scholar; Neale, John Mason, ed., Illustrations of Monumental Brasses, no. 6 (Cambridge, U.K., 1846), 115–32Google Scholar; Sharpe, Calendar of Wills, part 2, 1358–1688, 117–18; Charles Welch (revised by Roger L. Axworthy), “Lovekyn, John (d. 1368),” ODNB; Herbert, W., The History and Antiquities of the Parish and Church of St. Michael, Crooked Lane, London (London, 1831), 122–60Google Scholar.

50 Patricia H. Cullan, “‘For Pore People Harberles’: What Was the Function of the Maisonsdieu?,” in Clayton, Davies, and McNiven, Trade, Devotion and Governance, 36–52; “Whittington's Charity” (1420s), FLU, last updated 2 Nov. 2014, http://users.trytel.com/tristan/towns/florilegium/community/cmreli17.html.

51 Cooper, Annals of Cambridge, 105–6; Rubin, Charity and Community, 120–23; Salzman, ed., A History, 307.

52 Hodgson, J. C., “The ‘Domus Dei’ of Newcastle, otherwise St Katherine's Hospital on the Sandhill,” Archaeologia Aeliana, 3rd ser., 14 (1917): 191–220Google Scholar.

53 “Three London Grocers,” FLU.

54 Heath, Worshipful Company of Grocers, 213–21; HoP, s.v. “Sevenoak, William (d.1432)”; Pamela Nightingale, “Sevenoak [Sevenoke], William (d. in or after 1432),” ODNB.

55 Barron, “Eyre,” ODNB.

56 Cooper, Annals of Cambridge, 105–6; British Library Mayors and Bailiffs of Cambridge to 1380 Cole MS Addit. 5833: 126–35, The British Library, London; F. W. Maitland, Township and Borough (Cambridge, 1898), 134–41; Rubin, Charity and Community, 120–23.

57 Cooper, Annals of Cambridge, 216; Rubin, Charity and Community, 280.

58 HoP, s.v. “Whittington, Richard (d.1423)”; Sutton, “Whittington,” ODNB; Cooper, Annals of Cambridge, 170; Rubin, Charity and Community, 124, 191, 262–63; Palmer, W. M., ed., Cambridge Borough Documents (Cambridge, U.K., 1931), 152Google Scholar.

59 “Three London Grocers,” FLU; Heath, Worshipful Company of Grocers, 205–8; HoP, s.v. “Knolles, Thomas (d. 1435)”; Pamela Nightingale, “Knolles, Thomas (d. 1435),” ODNB.

60 “Pious and Charitable Bequests,” FLU.

61 Phillipp R. Schofield, “Spring Family (per. c. 1400–c. 1550),” ODNB.

62 Philanthropic lawyers are Richard Bank (d. 1415), the Catesby family (finished ca. 1500), Henry Green (d. 1369), William Hankeford (d. 1423), John Heydon (d. 1479), Richard Newton (d. 1448), Geoffrey Scrope (d. 1340), John Stonor (d. 1351), William I of the Stourton family (d. 1413) and William Yelverton (d. ca. 1477). Philanthropic administrators are Thomas Baumburgh (d. 1340), John Benstede (d. 1323), Ralph Boteler (d. 1473), Adam Brome (d. 1332), Richard Buckland (d. 1436), Thomas Burgh (d. ca. 1496). Nicholas Cantilupe (d. 1355), Thomas Camoys (d. 1420/21), William of Carleton (d. ca. 1311), Henry Cliffe (d. 1334), Robert Clitheroe (d. 1334), John Cobham (d. 1408), Ralph Cromwell (d. 1456), Hugh Despenser the younger (d. 1326), Joan Greyndour (d. ca. 1485), Walter Hungerford (d. 1449), Thomas Kent (d. 1469), Thomas Lisieux (d. 1456), Neil Loring (d. ca. 1386), Ralph Neville (d. 1367), John Newenham (d. 1390), John Pelham (d. 1429), Michael de la Pole (d. ca. 1389), Richard Ravenser (d. 1386), John Rochford (d. ca. 1410), Robert of Sadyngton (d. ca. 1361), Geoffrey Scrope (d. 1340), Henry Scrope (d. ca. 1415), Richard Scrope (d. ca. 1403), Ralph Stafford (d. 1372), Hervey Stanton (d. 1327), the Stourton family (finished ca. 1485), John Thorpe (d. 1324), John Tiptoft (d. 1470), John Wenlock (d. 1471) Roger Wodehouse (d. 1346), William Windsor (d. 1384), and Robert Wodelarke (d. ca. 1481). Philanthropic gentry families are d'Abenon (finished 1400), Abberbury (finished ca. 1475), Bek (finished ca. 1350), Catesby (finished 1505), Chaworth (finished ca. 1521), Cobham (finished ca. 1530), Culpeper (finished ca. 1540), Dinham (finished ca. 1500), de Dive (finished 1310), Kyme (finished ca. 1380), and Stourton (finished ca. 1485).

63 Rosamund Allen, “Cobham, John, third Baron Cobham of Cobham (c. 1320–1408),” ODNB.

64 Jeremy Catto, “Brome, Adam (d. 1332),” ODNB; Paul Brand, “Stanton [Staunton], Hervey (c. 1260–1327),” ODNB; J. H. Baker, “Wodelarke, Robert (d. 1481?),” ODNB; Philomena Connolly, “Windsor, William, Baron Windsor (1322–1384),” ODNB.

65 Nicholas Orme, “Greyndour [née Rigge; other married name Barre], Joan (c. 1400–1485),” ODNB.

66 Roger Virgoe, “Kent, Thomas (b. in or before 1410, d. 1469),” ODNB; Peter Fleming, “Cobham family (per. c. 1250–c. 1530),” ODNB.

67 Partington, Richard, “Cantilupe, Nicholas, third Lord Cantilupe (c. 1301–1355),” ODNB; Page, William, ed., A History of the County of Nottingham, vol. 2 (London, 1910), 105–9Google Scholar.

68 Gemmill, Elizabeth, The Nobility and Ecclesiastical Patronage in Thirteenth-Century England (Woodbridge, 2013)Google Scholar; Jones, Sarah Rees, York: The Making of a City, 1068–1350 (Oxford, 2013)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

69 Charles Kightly, “Hungerford, Walter, first Baron Hungerford (1378–1449),” ODNB.

70 Horrox, Rosemary, The De La Pole Family of Hull (Beverley, 1983)Google Scholar; Allison, K. J., ed., A History of the County of York East Riding, vol.1, The City of Kingston upon Hull (London, 1969), 11–85Google Scholar; Anthony Tuck, “Pole, Michael de la, first earl of Suffolk (c. 1330–1389),” ODNB.

71 A. Saul, “Perbroun [Perburn], John (d. 1342/3),” ODNB.

72 Fryde, E. B., “The English Farmers of the Customs, 1343–51,” Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 9 (Dec. 1959): 1–17Google Scholar; Sayles, George, “The ‘English Company’ of 1343 and a Merchant's Oath,” Speculum 6, no. 2 (1931): 177–205CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

73 Tawney, Richard H., Religion and the Rise of Capitalism (London, 1936)Google Scholar.

74 Hodgson, “‘Domus Dei,’” 191–220; HoP, s.v. “Thonrton, Roger (d.1430)”; MacKenzie, Newcastle; Burgess, “Chestre,” ODNB.

75 O'Connor, “Pyel,” ODNB; “Merchant Benefactor,” St. Mary Redcliffe Church website, accessed August 2, 2019, http://www.stmaryredcliffe.co.uk/william-canynges.html.

76 Anthony Smith, “Heydon [formerly Baxter], John (d. 1479),” ODNB.

77 MacKenzie, Newcastle, 242; “The Stained Glass of All Saints,” All Saints Church, (North Street, York) website, http://allsaints-northstreet.org.uk/stainedglass.html.

78 Holmes, G. A., “The ‘Libel of English Policy,’” English Historical Review 76, no. 299 (1961): 193–216CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Sutton, “Whittington,” ODNB; Wright, Thomas, ed., Political Poems and Songs relating to English History Composed during the Period from the Accession of Edward III to That of Richard II, vol. 2 (London, 1861), 178Google Scholar; C. M. Barron, “Richard Whittington: The Man behind the Myth,” in Studies in London History Presented to Philip Edmund Jones, ed. A. E. J. Hollaender and W. Kellaway (1969), 197–248; Alan J. Drosdick, “In Danger of Undoing: The Literary Imagination of Apprentices in Early Modern London” (PhD diss., University of California, Berkeley, 2010).

79 Monckton, Linda, “The Myth of William Canynges and the Late Medieval Rebuilding of St. Mary Redcliffe,” in “Almost the Richest City”: Bristol in the Middle Ages, ed. Keen, Laurence (Leeds, 1997), 57–67Google Scholar; Restoration of the Church of St. Mary, Redcliffe Bristol: An Appeal … (Bristol, 1842)Google Scholar, http://www.stmaryredcliffe.co.uk/restoration-appeal-1842.html; “The Canynges Society,” St. Mary Redcliffe Church website, http://www.stmaryredcliffe.co.uk/the-canynges-society.html.

80 Johnson, Richard, The Nine Worthies of London (n.p., 1584)Google Scholar.

81 Brewer, Anthony, The Love-Sick King, An English Tragical History with the Life and Death of Cartesmunda, the Fair Nun of Winchester (n.p., 1655)Google Scholar.

82 Jeremy, Capitalists and Christians.

83 Prochaska, Schools of Citizenship, 47.

84 These debates are summarized in Lawrence Stone, review of Philanthropy in England, 1480–1660: A Study of the Changing Pattern of English Social Aspirations, by Jordan, W. K., History: The Journal of the Historical Association 44 (1959): 257–60Google Scholar; Stone, review of The Charities of London, 1480–1660, by Jordan, W. K., English Historical Review 77, no. 303 (1962): 327–29Google Scholar; D. C. Coleman, review of Philanthropy in England, 1480–1660, by Jordan, W. K., Economic History Review 13, no. 1 (1960): 113–15Google Scholar; and Alan Everitt, review of Social Institutions in Kent, 1480–1660: A Study of the Changing Pattern of Social Aspirations, by Jordan, W. K., Economic History Review 15, no. 2 (1962): 376–77Google Scholar. For later critical assessment, see Bitte, William. G. and Lane, R. Todd, “Inflation and Philanthropy in England: A Re-Assessment of W. K. Jordan's Data,” Economic History Review 29, no. 2 (1976): 203–10CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Coleman, D. C., “Philanthropy Deflated: A Comment,” Economic History Review 31, no. 1 (1978): 119CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For a partial defense of Jordan, see Hadwin, J. F., “Deflating Philanthropy,” Economic History Review 31, no. 1 (1978): 105–17CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Wilson, C., “Poverty and Philanthropy in Early Modern England,” in Aspects of Poverty in Early Modern Europe, ed. Riis, Thomas (Alphen aan den Rijn, The Netherlands, 1981), 253–79Google Scholar.