Introduction
Wrangel Island, Russia, is part of the vast Beringian landmass that was not covered by ice during most of the Pleistocene. It lies at the border between the East Siberian and Chukchi seas and is a small mountainous island, with a maximum length of about 150 km, an area of about 7600 km2, and both a varied landscape and a varied climate, which is clearly seen in the structure and composition of the plant communities between various parts of the island. Compared to similar islands in the Arctic, Wrangel Island has much richer fauna and flora (Stishov Reference Stishov2004; Khruleva et al. Reference Khruleva, Shamshev and Sinclair2021, and references therein).
Most of Wrangel Island is in the Arctic tundra subzone (Figs. 1–4). The island’s broad middle belt is the southern variant of the Arctic tundra subzone, and this is flanked by belts of the northern variant of the Arctic tundra subzone. There are small enclaves of warmer climate within the southern Arctic tundra subzone variant, and these are northern variants of typical tundra subzone. The cool, foggy northeastern and southwestern seacoasts have the harshest environment on the island, indicative of the southern section of the polar desert zone. These subdivisions of Wrangel Island are based on Kholod’s (Reference Kholod2013) geobotanical studies. This division of subzones and the terminology used by Kholod (Reference Kholod2013) have been criticised (Matveyeva Reference Matveyeva2014); however, this does not change the general picture. Note that the 180° longitude meridian runs through Wrangel Island, resulting in most of the collection points being registered as west longitude, but sites 1 and 6 in the western end of the island are registered as east longitude.
The Tipulidae (Diptera) of Wrangel Island are quite rich for an Arctic island and include at least 15 species, most of which belong to the genus Tipula Linnaeus (Khruleva Reference Khruleva, Sokolov and Korneeva1987; Lantsov and Chernov Reference Lantsov and Chernov1987). Here, we contribute to knowledge of the fauna of Wrangel Island by adding information on the three species of the subgenus Tipula (Arctotipula Alexander) now known to occur on this island: T. (A.) besselsoides Alexander, 1919, T. (A.) oklandi Alexander, 1922, and T. (A.) salicetorum Siebke, 1870. The female of T. (A.) oklandi is illustrated for the first time, and we present an illustrated key to the adults.
Material and methods
Specimens from the following institutions were studied for this project: Canadian National Collection of Insects, Ottawa, Canada (CNC; Bradley Sinclair) and Zoological Institute, St. Petersburg, Russia, (ZISP; Emilia Nartshuk). The global distribution maps for T. (A.) besselsoides, oklandi, and salicetorum were based on specimens borrowed from 18 institutions in North America and Europe for further work on Arctotipula (Brodo and Lantsov, unpublished data).
Field collecting of Tipulidae was undertaken in various years during a survey of the entomofauna of Wrangel Island. In 1983–1994, material was collected by O.A. Khruleva by individual capture of specimens and by pitfall traps. In 2011, 2014–2016, and 2018–2019, yellow pan traps and sweeping were added; during this period, staff of the Wrangel Island Nature Reserve also took part in collecting. Over all these years, a total of more than 4000 adult specimens of Tipulidae were collected. Arctotipula species, however, were collected in only nine of 16 seasons, and only 45 specimens in total were collected. The more recent specimens, collected from 2011 to 2019, were preserved in 70% ethanol. Specimens collected earlier from 1983 to 1989 were placed between cotton layers. Subsequently, all specimens collected since 1983 were mounted on their side on paper points and pinned by Lantsov before being examined. Material from 2011 and 2015 was identified by V.I. Devyatkov, and the specimens are housed in the Institute of Systematics and Ecology of Animals, Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Novosibirsk; all other material is in the collection of V.I. Lantsov.
Genital morphology was studied by clearing terminalia in potassium hydroxide solution (10%) and preserving them in glycerine, pinned below their respective specimen, in a microvial. Specimens studied by Brodo were further cleared in lactic acid after being submerged in potassium hydroxide solution and before being placed in glycerine: lactic acid neutralises any remaining potassium hydroxide and thus prevents the fading of specimens. Specimens were studied by Lantsov using an Altami microscope, and measurements were made using an MBS-10 microscope (Lytkarino Optical Glass Plant, Moscow, Russia) with a scale installed in the focal plane of the 8× eyepiece (division value of scale: 0.1 mm at 8× magnification). Photographs were taken by Lantsov with a Canon EOS 450D digital camera (Canon Inc., Ōta, Tokyo, Japan) and Sigma 17–70 mm F2.8–4.5 DC Macro (Sigma Corporation, Kanagawa, Japan) and TAMRON SP 70–3000 mm F/4–5.6 DI VC USD lenses (Tamron Co., Ltd., Saitama, Japan), connected with Rodenstock Rodagon 1:2.8 F = 50 mm lenses (Rodenstock GmbH, Munich, Germany). Brodo used a Wild M5 stereo microscope (Wild Heerbrugg AG, Gais, Switzerland), as well as a Zeiss Compound Microscope (Carl Zeiss AG, Oberkochen, Germany), and photographs were made with a Nikon Coolpix 4500 digital camera (Nikon, Minato, Tokyo, Japan) attached to the Wild M5. Photographs were subsequently modified for publication using Adobe Photoshop Elements 9 (Adobe, Inc., San Jose, California, United States of America), and plates were prepared using PowerPoint (MicroSoft, Redmond, Washington, United States of America). Photos of habitats and the map of Wrangel Island were made by Khruleva.
We use the terminology of morphological features presented by Cumming and Wood (Reference Cumming, Wood, Kirk-Spriggs and Sinclair2017).
Results and discussion
The subgenus Tipula (Arctotipula)
As its name implies, Arctotipula is mainly an Arctic and northern boreal subgenus, with some species occurring at high altitudes in mountainous regions (Savchenko Reference Savchenko1961; Brodo Reference Brodo and Harrington1990; Gelhaus et al. Reference Gelhaus, Podenas and Brodo2000; Oosterbroek et al. Reference Oosterbroek, Brodo, Lantsov, Starý, Bocher, Kristensen, Pape and Vilhelmsen2015). The subgenus is small, with 38 species and subspecies currently recognised. Of these, 14 are known from Russia (Oosterbroek Reference Oosterbroek2022) and only four occur in the tundra zone (Lantsov and Chernov Reference Lantsov and Chernov1987). Species of the subgenus Arctotipula have been found in the mountainous countries of Central Asia (Tuva), Eastern Siberia, and Mongolia, but they have not yet been found in the mountains of Central Europe (Alps) and the Caucasus (Dufour Reference Dufour1986; Lantsov Reference Lantsov2007). Two species with arcto-montane distributions were previously recorded from Wrangel Island: T. (A.) oklandi Alexander (Savchenko Reference Savchenko1961, p. 325, as T. (A.) ciliata) and T. (A.) salicetorum Siebke (Khruleva Reference Khruleva, Sokolov and Korneeva1987, p. 29; Lantsov and Chernov Reference Lantsov and Chernov1987, p. 26). An entity listed as “Tipula (Arctotipula) sp. (prope T. miyadii (Al.))” was included by Khruleva (Reference Khruleva, Sokolov and Korneeva1987); the term “prope” is Latin for “near.” We have established here that this specimen belongs to T. (A.) besselsoides Alexander, a newly recognised addition to the Wrangel Island fauna.
Adults of this subgenus can be recognised by their generally dark grey head and thorax, both covered with long dense setae, and dense setae on the coxae (Fig. 7A, B). Wings are unpatterned but lightly tinted and have a dark pterostigma that is enhanced by whitened areas on either side, and the calypters are glabrous. Antennae in both sexes are shorter than the thorax, and the scape is the longest segment and is densely covered with long setae; flagellomeres are almost cylindrical but slightly broadened at the attachment of the verticils (Fig. 7B). Males have the epandrium and hypandrium separated almost to the base. The epandrium is glabrous basally, and this section is usually obscured by the overlying eighth tergite, leaving only the densely setose distal section visible. The epandrium has a distal emargination, and the setae on either side and below this emargination are arranged in a characteristic pattern for Arctotipula, with their tips pointing towards the middle so that the lateral setae point towards the middle at a 45° angle (or less) and the central setae point caudally, with a gradual variation of slope in between (Figs. 7C, D; 9A; 10A, B). Ventrally, the hypandrium is divided shallowly or more deeply almost to its base; there are no lobes or other structures on either the hypandrium or on the eighth sternite. Females tend to be a few millimetres longer than their respective males but with abdomens in scale with that of the males. The female terminalia are reduced in length and narrower than the preceding segments.
Arctotipula larvae are also quite distinctive and easily separated from the larvae of other subgenera of Tipula by the five conical swellings on abdominal segments 2–7 – one on each venter and two in the pleural membrane on each side. The six lobes on the spiracular disk are conical, covered with minute hairs or glabrous and with a small group of setae at the lobe tips. The spiracles are relatively small and spaced far apart. The fourth-instar larva of T. (A.) salicetorum was described by Hofsvang (Reference Hofsvang1979) and Podeniene et al. (Reference Podeniene, Gelhaus and Yadamsuren2006). The latter reference also included descriptions and beautiful illustrations of four other species of Arctotipula from Mongolia. Gelhaus (Reference Gelhaus1986) described T. (A.) sacra Alexander from North America. The larvae of T. (A.) besselsoides and T. (A.) oklandi are still to be discovered.
Arctotipula larvae are entirely aquatic (Pritchard and Hall Reference Pritchard and Hall1971; Hofsvang Reference Hofsvang1979; Gelhaus Reference Gelhaus1986; Lantsov and Chernov Reference Lantsov and Chernov1987; Lantsov Reference Lantsov1997), yet except for T. (A.) conjuncta conjuncta Alexander (Podeniene et al. Reference Podeniene, Gelhaus and Yadamsuren2006), they lack the long fringe of setae around the lobes of the spiracular disk that is usually associated with aquatic species such as Angarotipula Savchenko and Prionocera Loew (Brodo Reference Brodo2017). The fringe of setae on the flexible lobes of these latter two aquatic genera allows the lobes to fold together and trap an air bubble over the spiracles, thus allowing the larvae to breathe. The spiracular lobes of Arctotipula are stout and unable to fold together. Pritchard and Stewart (Reference Pritchard and Stewart1982) showed that gas exchange occurs through the enlarged, thin-walled lobes on the spiracular disk, not through the spiracles, and suggested that the conical lobes on the abdominal segments may also be a source for oxygen uptake.
What we know about the Arctotipula larval life cycle is based on the excellent work by Pritchard and his colleagues (Pritchard and Hall Reference Pritchard and Hall1971; Pritchard Reference Pritchard1976; Pritchard and Stewart Reference Pritchard and Stewart1982) studying the immatures of T. (A.) sacra Alexander in the foothills of the Canadian Rocky Mountains, Kananaskis, Alberta, Canada. The black eggs are laid singly into the mud at pond edges or on floating mats of filamentous algae; each egg has a coiled filament that unfurls as an anchoring device. There are four instars, which is typical of other Tipulidae. Larvae usually overwinter for two years, first as a third-instar larva and a second winter as a fourth-instar larva (Pritchard and Hall Reference Pritchard and Hall1971). When the fourth-instar larva is ready to pupate, it crawls out of the water and into the damp substrate on the shore (Pritchard and Hall Reference Pritchard and Hall1971). These earlier findings suggest that Arctotipula species on Wrangel Island might need more than two years before pupation, given the harsh climate recorded for this island.
Fourth-instar larvae of Arctotipula are quite large, 28–42 mm long and about 4–8 mm wide (Gelhaus Reference Gelhaus1986; Podeniene et al. Reference Podeniene, Gelhaus and Yadamsuren2006). They live in shallow, highly oxygenated water and graze on the microflora in benthic sediments (Pritchard and Hall Reference Pritchard and Hall1971). The content of the midgut and the anatomy of the digestive system of the fourth-instar larvae of T. (A.) salicetorum Siebke, from the Taymyr Peninsula, Russia, were studied by Lantsov and Chernov (Reference Lantsov and Chernov1987). They found the remains of stonefly and chironomid larvae in the midgut. Predation was shown to be the dominant type of feeding in these specimens. In the Tuva ASSR, Russia, T. (A.) salicetorum was found in the highlands; the larvae develop along the edges of lakes and feed on detritus (Saaya Reference Saaya2021). Based on these findings, the biology of this subgenus has significant plasticity and probably varies within each species as well as in different parts of their ranges. Larvae and adults of crane flies, including the subgenus Arctotipula, make up a significant part of the trophic base of fish and semiaquatic insectivorous birds (Chernov Reference Chernov1985; Lantsov and Chernov Reference Lantsov and Chernov1987).
Distribution of Arctotipula species on Wrangel Island
The collection localities for the three species of Arctotipula are indicated by black numbers and symbols on the map of Wrangel Island (Fig. 1). More detailed and comparative information on the subzones, nature of the collection sites and their numbers, dates of collection, and the collectors for the recorded specimens are indicated in Table 1. The numbers of the collection sites in Table 1 correspond to the numbers in Fig. 1.
Zonal variants: nAT, northern variant of Arctic tundra subzone; sAT, southern variant of Arctic tundra subzone; nTT, northern variant of typical tundra subzone. Locality refers to the numbered collection sites (Fig. 1). Approximated coordinates are given in square brackets. a. s. l., above sea level; Collectors: OKh – O.A. Khruleva; UB – U.V. Babiy; LP – L.A. Potenko; AR – A.A. Rodionov.
Tipula (Arctotipula) besselsoides is newly recorded as occurring on Wrangel Island, even though it was the most abundantly collected of the three Arctotipula species on the island (Fig. 1). Adults were collected at six different localities, indicated by the black circles on the map (Fig. 1). The oldest specimen that we studied was a female from Rogers Bay (locality 5), collected on 10 July 1939 by Portenko (ZISP). We think that this is the same female specimen referred to as T. (A.) ciliata Lundstrom by Savchenko (Reference Savchenko1961, p. 327). No identification label was placed with this specimen. The other 36 specimens were collected in the island’s vast river valleys, mainly on pebble and sandy–pebble floodplains, with or without clumps of vegetation. From 1983 to 1989, eight adults were collected in all zonal variants except in the harshest climate in the polar desert zone. In the northern variant of the typical tundra subzone, represented on the island by three isolated enclaves (Fig. 1), the species was collected in locality 6 in the west and in locality 8 in the north but not in the warmest enclave in the centre of the island, despite the fact that research was conducted there for four seasons, from 1991 to 1994. In the current century, this species was rediscovered in localities 8 (2018) and 5 (2019), and it was additionally found in two more areas that had not been studied before (localities 1 and 7). The majority of adults were collected in 2019 during a special survey of Arctotipula habitats in river valleys. Two large series were collected in different variants of the Arctic tundra subzone: the northern (Neozhidannaya River, (Fig. 2), southwestern part of the island; locality 1) and the southern (Nasha River (Fig. 3), southeastern part of the island; locality 5). Thus, T. (A.) besselsoides is widely distributed on Wrangel Island; however, not counting 2019, it was mainly collected as singletons. Wrangel Island is the only Russian locality for this species, but it has been collected in considerable numbers in the Arctic regions of North America and in Greenland (Fig. 4; Brodo Reference Brodo and Harrington1990; Oosterbroek et al. Reference Oosterbroek, Brodo, Lantsov and Starý2007, Reference Oosterbroek, Brodo, Lantsov, Starý, Bocher, Kristensen, Pape and Vilhelmsen2015).
Tipula (Arctotipula) oklandi was found in 2015 in the enclave of the typical tundra subzone located in the warmest central part of Wrangel Island, locality number 10 (black asterisk, Fig. 1). It was collected in two habitats (pebble floodplain and at the edge of a high river terrace with a tundra–steppe–like sedge–forb community) about 300–400 m apart from each other along the river valley. The specimens were identified by V.I. Devjatkov.
A female identified as T. (A.) ciliata Savchenko (= oklandi) collected at Rogers Bay (locality 5) on 10 July 1939 by Portenko (Savchenko Reference Savchenko1961, p. 327; Lantsov and Chernov Reference Lantsov and Chernov1987, p. 26) is here identified as T. (A.) besselsoides and was mentioned above. An earlier record of this species from Wrangel Island is erroneous, but new material confirms its presence here. It is the rarest of the three species and has been collected elsewhere in Russia only on Novaya Zemlya, Taymyr Peninsula, in the Sakha Republic (near Verkhoyansk) and on the Northern Kurile Island of Paramushir, in Sakhalin Oblast (Savchenko Reference Savchenko1961; Lantsov and Chernov Reference Lantsov and Chernov1987; Fig. 5). It was mistakenly recorded from North America under the incorrect assumption that T. (A.) alascaensis Alexander is a synonym of T. (A.) oklandi (Brodo and Lantsov, unpublished data). Specimens cited by Savchenko (Reference Savchenko1961) from the tundra of Eastern Siberia (Kotelny Island, the lower reaches of the Yana and Indigirka rivers) have been found to belong to other species (Brodo and Lantsov, unpublished data) and so are not shown on the present study’s map. Currently, Wrangel Island is the northeasternmost point of detection of this species.
Tipula (Arctotipula) salicetorum is also rare on Wrangel Island. It was collected in 1985 and 1989 at three sites in the northern and eastern parts of the island, in the northern variant of the Arctic tundra subzone, a region with a harsh climate. More recently, it was found only once in the northern enclave of the typical tundra subzone (Mamontovaya River, locality 9; see black squares, Fig. 1). Specimens were collected on substrates similar to those the other two species were collected on. Tipula (A.) salicetorum has the most widespread distribution of the three species, extending across Sweden, Norway, Finland, scattered localities in northern Russia, and across subarctic North America from Alaska to Quebec (Fig. 6). It was not found in Greenland (Oosterbroek et al. Reference Oosterbroek, Brodo, Lantsov and Starý2007, Reference Oosterbroek, Brodo, Lantsov, Starý, Bocher, Kristensen, Pape and Vilhelmsen2015).
The composition of the Arctotipula species on Wrangel Island is a vivid example of the role of the geographical location of this island. Here, we find a species with a wide Holarctic distribution (Tipula (A.) salicetorum), a species for which Wrangel Island is the extreme easternmost locality (T. (A.) oklandi), and a species for which Wrangel Island is the westernmost locality (T. (A.) besselsoides). That the latter species is the most numerous and widespread on the island is quite unexpected.
The presence of species with a predominantly North American distribution is one of the features of the island’s biota. Among Diptera, examples are known from the families Agromyzidae (Nartshuk and Khruleva Reference Nartshuk and Khruleva2011, Reference Nartshuk and Khruleva2018), Muscidae (Sorokina and Khruleva Reference Sorokina and Khruleva2012; Sorokina and Tridrikh Reference Sorokina and Tridrikh2021), Syrphidae (Barkalov and Khruleva Reference Barkalov and Khruleva2021), Empididae (Khruleva et al. Reference Khruleva, Shamshev and Sinclair2021), and Hybotidae (Khruleva et al. Reference Khruleva, Shamshev and Sinclair2021). Since 2000, the species from the families Agromyzidae, Empididae, and Hybotidae are most numerous in the warmest central enclave of the northern variant of the typical tundra subzone, whereas Tipula besselsoides has never been found there.
Tipulid collections on Wrangel Island were made in seasons with different weather conditions. The last years of research fell during the period of warming of the Arctic climate, which began in the 2000s. Unlike the always-numerous mesophilic species Tipula (Pterelachisus) carinifrons carinifrons Holmgren, 1883, and Tipula (Vestiplex) wrangeliana Stackelberg, 1944 (Khruleva Reference Khruleva, Sokolov and Korneeva1987 and unpublished data), species of the subgenus Arctotipula were rare in collections throughout the entire period of research. The data obtained do not allow us to talk about a noticeable increase in their numbers in a changing climate, although in recent years, a rapid increase in the number of some other groups of Diptera has occurred on Wrangel Island (Khruleva and Zinchenko Reference Khruleva and Zinchenko2017; Grichanov and Khruleva Reference Grichanov and Khruleva2018, Reference Grichanov and Khruleva2020; Nartshuk and Khruleva Reference Nartshuk and Khruleva2018).
Key to the adults of Tipula (Arctotipula) known from Wrangel Island
-
1. Conspicuous setae on head and thorax (Fig. 7A, B); wings tinted, unpatterned, distal wing veins glabrous or with scattered, difficult-to-see macrotrichia; antennae with relatively long setose scape, flagellomeres with longest verticils longer than respective segments (Fig. 7B). Males: epandrium glabrous basally, densely setose distally with setae arranged in a characteristic pattern with tips pointing towards the middle (Fig. 7C, D). Females with relatively short and narrower terminalia, with ninth tergite wrapping around base of tenth tergite; cerci weakly to moderately sclerotised; eighth sternite with lateral extensions Tipula (Arctotipula) 2
-
–. Thoracic setae generally short, not particularly obvious; wings variable, often patterned and usually with conspicuous setae on distal wing veins; antennae variable. Male: epandrium usually with short, scattered setae over the entire surface, setae generally with tips pointing caudally. Female terminalia if reduced, ninth tergite not wrapping around base of tenth tergite; cercus and hypogynial valves generally longer and more heavily sclerotised other subgenera of Tipula
-
2. White setae on head and thorax. Male epandrium with short truncate distal lobes, somewhat attenuated distolaterally, lobes separated medially by squarish gap, with blackened toothed bar beneath, usually visible in gap (Fig. 10A, B); inner gonostylus with narrow distal portion bent at right angles to broader base, with triangular blackened patch medially (Fig. 10C). Female with reduced terminalia, cerci pale, unsclerotised, and usually folded over hypogynial valves in pinned specimens, broad lobes on eighth sternite obscuring much of the terminalia laterally (Fig. 10D) salicetorum Siebke
-
–. Brown setae on head and thorax. Male epandrium with rigid rounded or narrow distal emargination, with pale ventral sclerite behind distal lobes; inner gonostylus with sharply pointed blackened hook behind or lateral to distal beak. Female with sclerotised cerci usually horizontally aligned, hypogynial valves quite visible 3
-
3. Male epandrium with circular medial emargination between short distal lobes (Fig. 7C, D); inner gonostylus with subrectangular distal beak (medial view), with prominent sharply pointed hook behind and with flattish cushion of setae medially at base (Fig. 8A–C). Female with cerci subequal to tenth tergite, roundly expanded near base; rounded shoulder on eighth sternite; hypogynial valves relatively short and broad, length from tip to rounded shoulder subequal to width at base (Fig. 8D); ventrally, shoulder appears perpendicular to valves, usually with second, step-like shoulder below (Fig. 8E) besselsoides Alexander
-
–. Male epandrium with deep, narrow, reinforced slit medially (Fig. 9A). Inner gonostylus with broadly triangular distal beak in medial aspect, obscuring smaller sharply pointed hook that sits lateral to, rather than behind, distal beak; protruding flat-topped extension at base densely covered with long setae with many shorter setae between (Fig. 9B, C). Female with cerci somewhat longer than tenth tergite, smoothly and narrowly broadening towards base; projecting shoulder on eighth sternite with almost horizontal distal edge; hypogynial valves elongate, length from tip to rounded shoulder longer than width at base (Fig. 9D); ventrally eighth sternite broader medially with irregular profile (Fig. 9E) oklandi Alexander
Acknowledgements
Olga A. Khruleva was supported by RFFR project No. 20-04-00165. The authors are sincerely grateful to A.R. Gruzdev, Director of the Wrangel Island Nature Reserve, as well as reserve staff I.P. Oleinikov, U.V. Babiy, and A.A. Rodionov for their help in the field investigations and for collecting insects. The authors also thank V.I. Devyatkov, Kazakh Institute of Fish Research, Altai Branch, Ust-Kamenogorsk, Kazakhstan, for the opportunity to include material he determined. They are sincerely thankful to Nadya V. Matveyeva, Komarov Botanical Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, St. Petersburg, Russia, for her professional comments concerning geobotanical data. The thoughtful editing and helpful comments from the subject editor and the three reviewers are much appreciated and have improved this manuscript.
Competing interests
The authors declare none.