P005: Consultations in the emergency department: a systematic review

Abstract

Introduction: Consultation in the emergency department (ED) is a common component of emergency health care. Consultation is defined as a case in which an ED physician (EP) requests the services of another physician (consultant) for an ED patient to assist, advise, and/or transfer care when the care required is beyond the expertise of the EP’s practice. While consultation is generally considered required and beneficial for patient care, consultation can also have a negative impact by incurring delays in patient flow and disposition. These delays contribute to ED crowding, patient dissatisfaction and, in some cases, worse health outcomes. Using an a priori protocol and accepted methodology, the aim of this systematic review was to update a previous review on the same topic and determine the proportion of 1) ED visits that involve consultation and 2) consultation cases that result in admission. PROPSPERO registration number: CRD42017054054. Methods: Literature search involved multiple electronic databases (e.g., MEDLINE and EMBASE) and grey literature (e.g., Google Scholar and conference abstracts). Study selection was conducted independently by two reviewers and determined by consensus among the two reviewers with disagreements resolved by a third party. Data extraction was conducted independently by two reviewers and determined by consensus among the two reviewers with disagreements resolved by a third party. A descriptive analysis was conducted. Outcome measure data were aggregated and reported with suitable descriptive statistics such as raw or weighted mean, median, or proportion with 95% confidence interval. Results: Literature search yielded 1,584 studies, of which 65 were included. Two-thirds of studies were conducted in USA or Canada. Of the 65, 54 were focused on a particular patient group or consulting specialty (e.g., psychiatry) while 11 considered the general ED population. Of these 11, the median proportion of ED visits involving consultation was 26%. The median proportion of cases with consultation that resulted in admission was 60%. Conclusion: Consultations in the ED are quite common and many of these cases result in admission. Given their frequency of occurrence and increasing ED crowding, efforts to reduce consult delays and expedite disposition appear warranted.