Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T10:55:48.465Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Instrumental Value Arguments for National Self-Determination

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 December 2017

HSIN-WEN LEE Open the ORCID record for HSIN-WEN LEE [Opens in a new window]
HSIN-WEN LEE*
Affiliation:
University of Delaware
*
*<hwl@udel.edu>
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

David Miller argues that national identity is indispensable for the successful functioning of a liberal democracy. National identity makes important contributions to liberal democratic institutions, including creating incentives for the fulfilment of civic duties, facilitating deliberative democracy, and consolidating representative democracy. Thus, a shared identity is indispensable for liberal democracy and grounds a good claim for self-determination. Because Miller’s arguments appeal to the instrumental values of a national culture, I call his argument ‘instrumental value’ arguments. In this paper, I examine the instrumental value arguments and show that they fail to justify a group’s right to self-determination.

David Miller soutient que l’identité nationale est indispensable au bon fonctionnement d’une démocratie libérale. L’identité nationale apporte une contribution importante aux institutions démocratiques libérales, notamment en créant des incitatifs pour l’accomplissement des devoirs civiques, en facilitant la démocratie délibérative et en consolidant la démocratie représentative. Ainsi, une identité partagée est indispensable à la démocratie libérale et justifie adéquatement la prétention à l’autodétermination. Parce que les arguments de Miller font appel aux valeurs instrumentales d’une culture nationale, j’appelle ses arguments des arguments de «valeur instrumentale». Dans cet article, j’examine ces arguments de valeur instrumentale et je montre qu’ils ne justifient pas le droit d’un groupe à l’autodétermination.

Keywords

National identityself-determinationself-governmentcivic dutydeliberative democracyrepresentative democracyinstrumental value argument for rights
Type
Original Article/Article original
Information
Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review / Revue canadienne de philosophie , Volume 58 , Issue 1 , March 2019 , pp. 65 - 89
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Canadian Philosophical Association 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Booth, W. James 2013 “Maîtres Chez Nous: Some Questions about Culture and Continuity—A Response to Alan Patten’s Rethinking Culture: The Social Lineage Account.” American Political Science Review 107 (4): 866–874.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Buchanan, Allen 1997 “Theories of Secession.” Philosophy and Public Affairs 26 (1): 31–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Caney, Simon 1997 “Self-Government and Secession: The Case of Nations.” Journal of Political Philosophy 5 (4): 351–372.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
De Schutter, Helder 2011 “Federalism as Fairness.” Journal of Political Philosophy 19 (2): 167–189.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gilbert, Paul 1996 “National Obligations: Political, Cultural or Societal?,” in National Rights, International Obligations, edited by Caney, Simon, George, David, and Jones, Peter. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, pp. 102–118.Google Scholar
Hurka, Thomas 1997 “The Justification of National Partiality,” in The Morality of Nationalism, edited by McKim, Robert and McMahan, Jeff. NY: Oxford University, pp. 139–157.Google Scholar
Kymlicka, Will 1995 Multicultural Citizenship. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Margalit, Avishai, and Raz, Joseph 1990 “National Self-determination.” Journal of Philosophy 87 (9): 439–461.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mill, John Stewart 1991 “Considerations on Representative Government,” in On Liberty and Other Essays. NY: Oxford University Press, pp. 205–467.Google Scholar
Miller, David 1995 On Nationality. NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Miller, David 1996 “Secession and the Principle of Nationality,” in Rethinking Nationalism, edited by Couture, Jocelyne, Nielsen, Kai, and Seymour, Michel. Canadian Journal of Philosophy Supplementary Volume 22: 261–282. Calgary: University of Calgary Press, second printing 2000.Google Scholar
Miller, David 2005 “Reasonable Partiality Towards Compatriots.” Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 8 (1-2): 63–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Miller, David, and Ali, Sundas 2014 “Testing the National Identity Argument.” European Political Science Review 6 (2): 237–259.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moore, Margaret 2000 “Nationalist Arguments, Ambivalent Conclusions,” in Nationalism and Ethnic Conflict, edited by Miscevic, Nenad. Chicago, IL: Open Court, pp. 177–196.Google Scholar
Nielsen, Kai 1997 “Cultural Nationalism, Neither Ethnic nor Civic.” Philosophical Forum 28 (1-2): 42–52.Google Scholar
Nielsen, Kai 1998 “Liberal Nationalism and Secession,” in National Self-Determination and Secession, edited by Moore, Margaret. NY: Oxford University Press, pp. 103–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Norman, Wayne 1998 “The Ethics of Secession as the Regulation of Secessionist Politics,” in National Self-Determination and Secession, edited by Moore, Margaret. NY: Oxford University Press, pp. 34–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Norman, Wayne 2006 Negotiating Nationalism—Nation-building, Federalism, and Secession in the Multinational State. NY: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Patten, Alan 2014 Equal Recognition: The Moral Foundations of Minority Rights. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Putnam, Robert 1993 Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Rawls, John 1971 A Theory of Justice. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, reprinted 1999.Google Scholar
Raz, Joseph 1986 The Morality of Freedom. NY: Oxford University Press, reprinted 2009.Google Scholar
Sanders, Lynn 1997 “Against Deliberation.” Political Theory 25 (3): 347–377.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tamir, Yael 1993 Liberal Nationalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Taylor, Charles 1985 “Alternative Futures: Legitimacy, Identity, and Alienation in Late Twentieth Century Canada,” in Constitutionalism, Citizenship and Society in Canada, edited by Cairns, Alan C. and Williams, Cynthia. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, pp. 183–229.Google Scholar
Von Hofer, Hanns 2003 “Prison Populations as Political Constructs: The Case of Finland, Holland and Sweden.” Journal for Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention 4 (1): 21–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yack, Bernard 2012 Nationalism and the Moral Psychology of Community. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Young, Iris Marion 2000 Inclusion and Democracy. NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar