Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gxg78 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T03:52:20.320Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Gentlemen Dissenters: The Social and Political Meanings of Rational Dissent in the 1770s and 1780s

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

John Seed
John Seed
Affiliation:
Roehampton Institute of Higher Education
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Conventional wisdom has long maintained that eighteenth-century religious dissent was a significant source of opposition to the Hanoverian status quo. For Trevelyan, for instance, dissenters were ‘vigilant champions of liberty and critics of government’. The high political visibility of rational dissenters in oppositional movements in the 1770s and 1780s – in opposition to the American war, the Test and Corporation Acts, slavery and the slave trade, the existing electoral system – has been particularly noted. However in recent years the political significance of religious dissent has been questioned. Roy Porter warns that the zeal for reform among dissenters should not be overestimated: ‘Not till the 1780s, and then only amongst a hothead minority, did Nonconformity show a potential for political radicalism.’ John Brewer has argued that the dissenting group associated with Hollis, Price, Priestley and ‘the small, snug, dissenting coterie of Newington Green’ marks one tradition of political opposition in the eighteenth century. But, largely confined to intellectual critique, remarkably uninvolved in the day-to-day cut-and-thrust of political action even evincing a patrician alarm at popular direct action, its contribution to political change was far less significant than the Wilkite movement.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 28 , Issue 2 , June 1985 , pp. 299 - 325
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1985

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Trevelyan, G. M., History of England (London, 1926), p. 451Google Scholar.

2 Plumb, J. H., England in the eighteenth century 1714–1815 (London, 1950), p. 133Google Scholar; Brown, PeterThe Chathamites (London, 1967)Google Scholar, part 2; Robbins, C., The eighteenth-century Commonwealthman (New York, 1959)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lincoln, A., Some political and social ideas of English dissent (Cambridge, 1938)Google Scholar.

3 Porter, R., English society in the eighteenth century (London, 1982), p. 196Google Scholar.

4 Brewer, J., ‘English radicalism in the age of George III’, in Pocock, J. G. A. (ed.) Three British Revolutions: 1641, 1688, 1776 (Princeton, 1980), pp. 342–3Google Scholar.

5 Bradley, J., ‘Whigs and Nonconformists: “Slumbering radicalism” in English politics 1739–89’, Eighteenth Century Studies, IX, 1 (1975), 2–3Google Scholar. For a vigorous but overheated argument that they were unrepresentative see Davie, D., ‘A Day with D.N.B.’, Dissentient Voice (Notre Dame, 1982), pp. 94–108Google Scholar.

6 Bradley, , ‘Whigs and Nonconformists’, pp. 3–5, 9Google Scholar.

7 Ibid. pp. 15–23.

8 Phillips, J. A., Electoral behaviour in unreformed England: plumpers, splitters and straights (Princeton, 1982), pp. 286–305Google Scholar.

9 Ibid. p. 304.

10 Anon., ‘Dissenters admonished’, The Protestant Dissenters Magazine, 1 (1794), 105Google Scholar.

11 For an account of the emergence of unitarianism from religious dissent see Seed, John, ‘The cole of unitarianism in the formation of liberal culture 1775–1851: a social history’ (University of Hull, Ph.D., 1981)Google Scholar. I use rational dissent, as did contemporaries, to designate those dissenting congregations, usually presbyterian in origin, which were in the process of becoming Unitarian hot which embraced an internal diversity of theological opinions.

12 Bebb, E. R., Nonconformity and social and economic life (London, 1935), p. 57Google Scholar.

13 Wilson, C., England's apprenticeship: 1603–1763 (London, 1971), pp. 340–1Google Scholar.

14 Gilbert, A. D., Religion and society in industrial England: church, chapel and social change 1740–1914 (London, 1976), pp. 60ffGoogle Scholar.

15 For detailed documentation of size and geographical distribution of Unitarian congregations see Seed, , ‘Unitarianism’, pp. 51–9Google Scholar.

16 Corfield, P., The impact of English towns 1700–1800 (Oxford, 1982), pp. 130ffGoogle Scholar.

17 Ward, G. A., Journals and letters of the late Samuel Curwen… (New York, 1842), p. 136Google Scholar.

18 Baker, T., Memorials of a dissenting chapel (London, 1884)Google Scholar, passim.

19 Aikin, J., A description of the country from thirty to forty miles around Manchester (London, 1795), pp. 181–4Google Scholar.

20 Axon, E., ‘Harrison Ainsworth's maternal ancestors’ Transactions of the Lancashire and Cheshire Antiquarian Society, xxi (1911), 111–13Google Scholar; Wadsworth, A. P. and Mann, J. De Lacy, The cotton trade and industrial Lancashire 1600–1780 (Manchester, 1931), pp. 244–7Google Scholar.

21 Axon, E., ‘The Bayley family of Manchester and Hope’, Transactions of the Lancashire and Cheshire Antiquarian Society, VII (1889), 194–9Google Scholar.

22 Sale announcement in Manchester Guardian, 12 May 1821

23 Hadley, G., A new and complete history of the town and country of the town of Kingston-upon-Hull (Hull, 1788), p. 801Google Scholar.

24 For members see Baptismal registers of Bowl Alley Lane chapel 1744–1827, P.R.O. non-parochial Registers RG4/3752 and Whitaker, W.One line of the puritan tradition in Hull: Bowl Alley Lane Chapel (London, 1910)Google Scholar. For Pease family see: Pease Manuscripts, Wilberforce House, Hull; Wildridge, T. T., Old and new Hull (Hull, 1884), pp. 155–8Google Scholar; will of J. R. Pease, Borthwick Institute, York: Prerog. April 1807.

25 Philips, M., ‘The Old Bank (Bell, Cookson, Carr and Airey) Newcastle’, Archaeologica Aeliana, 2nd ser., xvi (1894), 455Google Scholar.

26 , R. E. and Carr, C. E., The history of the family of Carr of Dunston Hill, Co. Durham and the collateral lines in England (London, 1893), 1, 46–7, 60–4, 66–8Google Scholar.

27 ‘Register of the minister and people who regularly assemble in Hanover Square Chapel, Newcastle 1782’, Hanover Sq. Chapel MSS, Vestry of the Church of the Divine Unity, Newcastle-upon-Tyne; Baptismal reg–sters of the chapel in P.R.O. nonparochial registers RG4/1777.

28 Turner, W. letter quoted in Run, J. T. (ed.), Memoirs and correspondence of Joseph Priestley II 1787–1804, in Works of Joseph Priestley, ed. Rutt, J. T., 1 (London, 1832), p. 85nGoogle Scholar. All subsequent references to any work by Priestley are to this first and only edition of his collected writings and are cited by title of specific work, edition, then Works, volume and page.

29 Clarkson, H., Memories of merry Wakefield (Wakefield, 1889), p. 165Google Scholar. For the congregation see ‘Minute Book of Westgate Chapel Wakefield’, Archives Dept, Wakefield Central Library.

30 Ibid. pp. 47–50; Walker, J. W., Wakefield, its history and people (3rd edn, London, 1966), II, 465Google Scholar.

31 Pope-Hennessy, J., Monckton Milnes: the years of promise 1809–51 (London, 1949)Google Scholar gives a useful sketch of the family's history. See also Taylor, K. (ed.), Wakefield district heritage (Wakefield, 1976), pp. 74–6, 78–9, 140–1Google Scholar; Wilson, R. G., ‘The Denisons and Milneses: eighteenth-century merchant landowners’, in Ward, J. T. and Wilson, R. G. (eds), Land and Industry: the landed estate and the Industrial Revolution (Newton Abbot, 1971), pp. 162–5Google Scholar.

32 Catalogue of the Crewe Muniments, ‘Part II: Bawtry and Austerfield estates’ (National Register of Archives, 1972), pp. 208–9Google Scholar for his land holdings. See also Clarkson, , Memories, p. 45Google Scholar; Taylor, K., Wakefield, pp. 74–5Google Scholar; Wilson, R. G., ‘Denisons and Milneses’, p. 163Google Scholar.

33 Axon, E., ‘Buxton Chapel’, Transactions of the Unitarian Historical Society, III, 4 (1926), 325–7Google Scholar. This journal is here after cited as TUHS.

34 Quoted in Nicholls, J., Literary anecdotes of the eighteenth century: comprizing biographical memoirs…, IX (London, 1815), 379Google Scholar.

35 Belsham, T., Memoirs of the late Rev. Theophilus Lindsey… (London, 1812)Google Scholar.

36 Ibid. p. 111 n.

37 Journals etc…of Curwen, p. 278.

38 Lindsey to William Tayleur, 29 Nov. 1788, Unitarian College MSS, John Rylands University Library, Manchester.

39 ‘A Lawyer’, ‘The deeds of Essex Street Chapel’, TUHS, I, 3 (1918), 261–2Google Scholar.

40 Seed, , ‘Unitarianism’, pp. 91–2Google Scholar.

41 Belsham, memoirs, pp. 322f; see also Belsham, , Uncorrupted Christianity unpatronized by the great: a discourse…on the decease of Augustus Henry, duke of Grafton (London, 1811)Google Scholar.

42 See Knight, F., University rebel. The life of William Frend 1757–1841 (London, 1971), 1Google Scholar.

43 For detailed counts of dissenting voters in the early 18th century see ‘The John Evans list of dissenting congregations and ministers 1715–29’, MSS 34.4, Dr Williams's Library, London.

44 Even dissenting ministers were subject to Walpole's attentions: from 1722 the Crown disbursed sums of money to a committee of London ministers who in turn distributed small sums to needy ministers or their widows. Thus there was, as Short remarks, a ‘Walpolean skeleton hanging in the dissenting closet’. See Short, K. R. M., ‘The English Regium Donum’, English Historical Review, LXXXIV (1969), 59–65, 71CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also Priestley, , Memoirs, 1, 229n–30nGoogle Scholar.

45 Bushrod, E., ‘The history of unitarianism in Birmingham from the middle of the 18th century to 1893’ (University of Birmingham, M.A. thesis 1954), pp. 11, 211–12, 222Google Scholar; Dent, R. K., Old and new Birmingham: a history of the town and its people (London, 1878–1980) 1, 217–18Google Scholar.

46 T. Baker, Memories, passim; The court leet records of the manor of Manchester, VII, 1756–1786 (Manchester, 1888)Google Scholar; VII, 1787–1805 (Manchester, 1889).

47 Clark, G. R., History of Ipswich (London, 1830), 242Google Scholar.

48 Murch, J., History of presbyterian and general baptist churches in the west of England (London, 1835), PP. 178ffGoogle Scholar.

49 Bonham-Carter, V., In a liberal tradition. A social biography 1700–1950 (London, 1960), pp. 17–19Google Scholar; Namier, L. and Brooke, J., The House of Commons 1754–90, 1 (London, 1964), 297–9Google Scholar.

50 Quoted in Namier, & Brooke, , House of Commons, 1, 355Google Scholar.

51 Richard Milnes to Rockingham, 15 Jan. 1745, and Rockingham to Milnes, 13 Oct. 1746 Crewe MSS M2/362 and 409–10, Archives Dept, Sheffield Central Library. (I should thank Mary, duchess of Roxburghe, for permission to consult these papers.)

52 Pemberton Milnes to Fitzwilliam, 24 Feb. 1784, Wentworth Woodhouse Muniments F34/43, Archives Dept, Sheffield Central Library. (I should thank Earl Fitzwilliam and his trustees for permission to consult these papers.)

53 P. Milnes to Fitzwilliam, 17 Feb. 1784, WW MSS F34/38.

54 J. Milnes to Holmes, April 1780, Yorkshire Association Papers M25/271, Archives Dept, York City Library.

55 See list of committee members in Wyvill, C., Political papers, 11, 322–4Google Scholar.

56 Stephen, L., ‘The Shores of Sheffield and the Offleys of Norton Hall’, Transactions of the Hunter Archaeological Society, V (1943), 7–8Google Scholar; obituary of Shore, Samuel, Gentleman's Magazine, XCVIII, 2 (1828), 640–1Google Scholar; Wyvill, , Political papers, 1, 300–1, 305 and II, 323Google Scholar.

57 Wilson, R. G., Gentlemen merchants: the merchant community in Leeds 1700–1830 (Manchester, 1971), p. 168Google Scholar; Yorkshire Association papers, loc. cit. for correspondence of Leeds rational dissenters.

58 Wilson, , Gentlemen merchants, pp. 150, 245Google Scholar.

59 John Lee to Rockingham, 18 Sept. 1769, MSS R 1–1229; Rockingham to John Lee, 19 Dec. 1779; this letter and one hundred others to and from Lee are, for some reason, in the John Clements Library of the University of Michigan at Ann Arbor but some of the contents are detailed in an Appendix to Handlist of correspondence of Charles, the second marquis of Rockingham, WW MSS, loc. cit.

60 Pares, R., King George III and the politicians (new edn, Oxford,. 1967), p. 40Google Scholar.

61 Quoted in Albemarle, Lord, Memoirs of the marquis of Rockingham (London, 1852), II, 224Google Scholar.

62 Quoted in Brooke, J., The House of Commons 1754–90: an introductory survey (new edn, 1968), p. 167Google Scholar. The whole question of dissenting influence on M.P.s in the 1780s is usefully discussed in Ditchfield, G. M., ‘The parliamentary struggle over the repeal of the Test and Corporation Acts, 1787–90’, English Historical Review, LXXXIX (1974), 55–77Google Scholar. See also Brooke, , House of Commons, pp. 169–70Google Scholar.

63 Blake, W., ‘The Laocoon’, Blake: complete writings with variant readings, ed. Keynes, G. (Oxford, 1969). P. 775Google Scholar.

64 The Journal of John Wesley, ed. Curnock, N. (London, 1938), IV, 244Google Scholar.

65 See, for instance, Gordon, A., Cheshire Classis minutes 1691–1745 (London, 1919)Google Scholar.

66 Priestley, J., The proper constitution of a Christian church…towhich is prefixed a prefatory discourse, relating to the present state of those who are called rational dissenters (London, 1782)Google Scholar, Works, XV, 53; see also Coomer, D., English dissent under the early Hanoverians (London, 1946), pp. 12, 16, 54Google Scholar.

67 McLachlan, H., ‘Diary of a Leeds layman 1733–86’, TUHS, IV, 3 (1920), 263Google Scholar.

68 Priestley, J., Institutes of natural and revealed religion (London, 1782)Google Scholar, Works, II 323–4.

69 Enfield, W., The principles and duty of protestant dissenters considered, in a sermon preached at the ordination of Rev. John Prior Estlin… (London, 1778), p. 23Google Scholar.

70 Cappe, N., ‘On the incompatibility of the love of pleasure with the love of God’, Discourses chiefly on devotional subjects by the late Rev. Newcome Cappe (York, 1805), pp. 162–3Google Scholar. The sermons in this collection were all written and preached before 1791.

71 Le Breton, P. H. (ed.), Memoirs of Lucy Aikin (London, 1864), p. 197Google Scholar.

72 See MrsWare, Hibbert, The life andcorrespondence ofthe late Samuel Hibbert Ware (London, 1882), PP. 1–39Google Scholar.

73 Priestley, J., Considerations for the use of young men and the parents of young men (London, 1775)Google Scholar, Works, xxv, 77 – here quoting from his own earlier writing, see Works, II, 35–6.

74 T. Nicholson to M. Nicholson, 13 Sept. 1790, Nicholson Letters, Unitarian College MSS, Ipc cit.

75 See DrJohnson, 's comments in Boswell, J., The life of Samuel Johnson LL.D(Everyman edn, no date), II, 388Google Scholar.

76 Holland, P., A sermon delivered at Pudsey…at the ordination of William Turner Jnr. (Wakefield, 1782), p. 17Google Scholar.

77 Ibid.

78 Priestley, J., Letters to a philosophical unbeliever (2nd edn, London, 1787)Google Scholar, Works, IV, 356.

79 Wood, W., ‘On courtesy’, Sermons on social life (London, 1775), p. 76Google Scholar.

80 Priestley, J., The proper constitution… loc. cit. p. 46Google Scholar.

81 Axon, E., ‘Thomas Barnes’, TUHS, V, 1 (1931), 89Google Scholar.

82 Robberds, J. W., A memoir of the life and writings of the late William Taylor of Norwich (London, 1843), I, 149, 151Google Scholar.

83 Quoted in Gilbert, A. D., ‘The growth and decline of Nonconformity in England and Wales with special reference to the period before 1850: an historical interpretation of statistics of religious practice’ (University of Oxford, D.Phil. 1973), p. 154Google Scholar.

84 ‘Original letter from the Rev. Job Orton’, Protestant Dissenters Magazine, VI (1799), 53Google Scholar.

85 Palmer, S. (ed.), Letters to dissenting ministers and to students for the ministry from the Rev. Job Orton… (London, 1806), 1, 154Google Scholar. See also p. 200.

86 Priestley, J., An appeal to the serious and candid professors of Christianity… (London, 1770), Works, III, 315–16Google Scholar; Memoirs, 1, 200. See also 'No Enemy to Learning. ‘To J.H.’ Protestant Dissenters Magazine, I (1794), 504Google Scholar.

87 Weber, M., The protestant ethnic and the spirit of capitalism, trans. Parsons, T. (London, 1930), p. 174Google Scholar.

88 See Ward, W. R., Religion and society in England 1790–1850 (London, 1972), pp. 10–11Google Scholar.

89 McLachlan, H., ‘Diary of a Leeds layman’, loc. cit., p. 265Google Scholar.

90 Fuller, A., The calvinistic and socinian systems examined and compared as to their moral tendency… (revised edition, London, 1802)Google Scholar; The principal works and remains of the Rev. Andrew Fuller (London, 1852), p. 391Google Scholar. ‘Socinian’ was a synonym for Unitarian.

91 Rogers, N., ‘Money, land and lineage: the big bourgeoisie of Hanoverian London’ Social History, IV, 2 (1979), 454Google Scholar.

92 Fuller, A., Calvinistic and socininian systems, p. 409Google Scholar.

93 Priestley, J., The proper constitution…, loc. cit., pp. 49–50Google Scholar.

94 Weber, M., ‘The protestant sects and the spirit of capitalism’, Gerth, H. H. and Mills, C. Wright (eds), From Max Weber: essays in sociology (1948), p. 306Google Scholar.

95 Smiles, S., Thrift (popular edn, London, 1901), p. 98Google Scholar.

96 Cragg, G. R., Puritanism in the period of the great persecution (London, 1957)Google Scholar.

97 An abstract of proceedings of the deputies and committee appointed for the support of protestant dissenters from the commencement of the institution (London, 1796), pp. 8ffGoogle Scholar.

98 Priestley, J., Remarks on some paragraphs in the fourth volume of Dr. Blackstone's commentaries on the laws of England, relating to dissenters (London, 1769), Works, IV, 302–3Google Scholar. See also Works, XXII, 349–57.

99 An abstract…, p. iii.

100 Enfield, W., Principles and duty, p. 8Google Scholar.

101 Priestley, J., An essay on the first principles of government, and on the nature of political, civil and religious liberty (2nd edn, London, 1771), Works, XXII, 137Google Scholar. See also Kippis, A., A vindication of the protestant dissenting ministers with regard to their late application to parliament (London, 1773), p. 63Google Scholar. The preface to the first volume of the Theological repository, edited by Priestley, declared that its pages were open not just to Christians of all denominations but also to ‘persons who disbelieve Christianity, and revelation in general’. The Theological Repository, 1 (1769), 10Google Scholar.

102 Priestley, J., The proper constitution…, p. 79Google Scholar.

103 Brewer, J., ‘The Wilkites and the law: a study of radical notions of governance’ Brewer, J. and Styles, J. (eds) An ungovernable people: the English and their law in the 17th and 18th centuries (London, 1980), pp. 141fGoogle Scholar; Brewer, J., ‘English radicalism…’, in Pocock, Three British Revolutions, pp. 345–50Google Scholar.

104 Brewer, J., ‘English radicalism.…’, pp. 334–42Google Scholar.

105 Seaver, P., The Puritan lectureships: the politics of religious dissent (Stanford, 1970)Google Scholar.

106 See for example: Toulmin, J.The American War lamented… (London, 1776)Google Scholar; Turner, W., The whole service as performed in the congregation of protestant dissenters at Wakefield on Friday 13th December 1776, being the day appointed for a general fast (Wakefield, 1777)Google Scholar; Walker, G., A sermon preached to a congregation of protestant dissenters at Notthingham Dec. 13th 1776, being the day appointed for a general fast (London, 1777)Google Scholar; Cappe, N., Sermon preached on the 13th December 1776, the late day of national humiliation (London, 1777)Google Scholar.

107 Memoir of Cappe in Discourses…, XXXIV.

108 Ibid. pp. I–Ii.

109 [Priestley, J.], The present state of liberty in Great Britain and her colonies by an Englishman (London, 1769), Works, XXII, 380–98Google Scholar.

110 [Priestley, J.], An address to protestant dissenters of all denominations, on the approaching election of members of parliament, with respect to the state of public liberty in general, and of American affairs in particular (London, 1774), Works, XXII, 483–98Google Scholar; Priestley, to editor of Monthly Magazine, 1 02 1804, Appendix XXIV, Works, XXV, 396Google Scholar.

111 Priestley, , Memoirs, 1, 289nGoogle Scholar; Brown, P., The Chathamites, p. 148Google Scholar.

112 Plumb, , England in the 18th century, pp. 138, 187Google Scholar.

113 Brown, , Chathamites, 142Google Scholar; Thomas, D. O., The honest mind: the thought and work of Richard Price (Oxford, 1977), pp. 145–8Google Scholar etc.

114 For a sketch of Jervis see Schroeder, W. L., Mill Hill chapel 1674–1924 (Leeds, 1924), pp. 52–4Google Scholar. See also The correspondence of Jeremy Bentham, III (1971), ed. Christie, I. R., pp. 50, 67–8Google Scholar. (Here, on p. 50n Jervis is mistakenly identified.)

115 Priestley, , Memoirs, I, 175, 177–9, 180–8Google Scholar.

116 McLachlan, H., The letters of Theophilus Lindsey (Manchester, 1920), p. 85Google Scholar.

117 Ibid. p. 84; Lindsey to William Turner, 30 Jan. 1777, Turner correspondence, Literary and Philosophical Society Library, Newcastle-upon-Tyne.

118 Holt, A., A life of Joseph Priestley (Oxford, 1931), pp. 75–6Google Scholar.

119 Howe, P. P., The Life of William Hazlitt (London, 1928), p. 3Google Scholar; Wardle, R. M., Hazlitt (Nebraska, 1971), pp. 5–7Google Scholar.

120 Burke, E., Reflections on the revolution in France and on the proceedings in certain societies in London relative to that event (11th edn, London, 1791)Google Scholar; Burke: Select Works, II, ed. Payne, E. J. (Oxford, 1898), 12–13Google Scholar.

121 Palmer, S. (ed.), Letters, II, 4Google Scholar.

122 A Dissenter, ‘A serious and seasonable address to protestant dissenters in the present state of public affairs’, Protestant Dissenters Magazine, I (1794), 281Google Scholar.

123 Thus Priestley's successor at Birmingham argued that he was ‘merely a public instructor’ with no greater sanctity than any other man or woman: ‘Priests of all religions have been the bane of the world, the enemies of its peace and the embodied adversaries of truth and liberty. Religious instructors should have no exclusive privileges; their vocation, like others, should be estimated by its utility and importance. They should leave to those who love such things, fictitious sacredness, artificial consequence, priestly reverence and ecclesiastical privileges.’ Jones, D., The nature and duties of the office of a minister of religion (Birmingham, 1792), pp. v–viGoogle Scholar.

124 Walker, G., Essays on various subjects…to which is prefixed a life of the author (London, 1809), I, lxxvi–vii, CXXV, cxxxix–cxl, clviii–ixGoogle Scholar.

125 Cartwright, F. D., The life and correspondence of Major Cartwright (London, 1826), II, 19Google Scholar.

126 Walker, G., ‘The Duty and Character of a National Soldier’, Sermons (London, 1790), II, 437Google Scholar. The subscribers to these two volumes of sermons, incidentally, included half a dozen M.P.s.

127 Quoted in Tayler, J. J., A retrospect of the religious life of England (2nd edn, London, 1876), p. 296nGoogle Scholar.

128 For an account of Unitarian activism in local culture-building in the late 18th and early 19th century see Seed, J., ‘Unitarianism, political economy and the antinomies of liberal culture in Manchester 1830–50’, Social History, VII, I (1982) 4–6Google Scholar.

129 Brewer, J., ‘Commercialization and politics’ in McKendrick, N., Brewer, J. and Plumb, J. H. (eds.) The birth of a consumer society: the commercialization of eighteenth-century England (London, 1982), p. 200Google Scholar and passim. Similarly John Money has stressed the importance of canal and road schemes in bringing together scattered individuals in concerted cooperative action, thus helping to solidify class identities. See also Eley, G., ‘Re-thinking the political: social history and political culture in 18th and 19th century Britain’, Archiv fur Sozialgeschichte, XXI (1981), esp. 430–2Google Scholar; Money, J., Experience and identity, Birmingham and the West Midlands 1760–1800 (Manchester, 1977)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

130 For an excellent account of the processes of secularization in late Victorian nonconformity in South London see Cox, J.The English churches in a secular society: Lambeth 1870–1930 (Oxford, 1982)Google Scholar.

131 Brewer, John has remarked on this in a review of Money's book in Social History, IV, I (1979), 137Google Scholar.

132 See the critical comments on the particularism of 19th century urban history in Proctor, I., ‘Urbanization in the framework of the spatial structuring of social institutions: a discussion of concepts with reference to British material’, Pons, V. and Francis, R. (eds), Urban social research: problems and prospects (London, 1983), pp. 88–9Google Scholar.

133 Thus Priestley in 1771: ‘Dissenters, as such, have nothing in common but a Dissent from the Established Church, and it by no means follows that they, therefore, agree in anything else’. A free address to protestant dissenters as such, by a dissenter (London, 1771), Works, XXII, 249Google Scholar.

134 Phillips, N. C., Yorkshire and English national politics 1783–4 (Christchurch, New Zealand, 1961)Google Scholar.

135 See Priestley, , A free address…, loc. cit., p. 263Google Scholar.

136 Mary Nicholson to Mrs J. Nicholson, 7 April 1791, Nicholson Letters, loc. cit.