Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T11:14:58.216Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Outthinking and Outflanking the Owners of the World”: A Historiography of the African American Struggle for Education

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2017

Ronald E. Butchart
Ronald E. Butchart*
Affiliation:
College of Education, State University College at Cortland, New York
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

W. E. B. DuBois once argued that the proper education for oppressed groups such as African Americans had a special, critical purpose. He knew, as have all serious educators since Socrates accepted his cup, that education was always and everywhere political. For the oppressed, the political role of schooling had to be aimed precisely at finding the means to end the oppression. In 1930, speaking before the graduating students at Howard University, he put the issue this way: “Let there be no misunderstanding about this, no easy going optimism. We are not going to share modern civilization just by deserving recognition. We are going to force ourselves in by organized far-seeing effort—by outthinking and outflanking the owners of the world today who are too drunk with their own arrogance and power successfully to oppose us, if we think and learn and do.” It is clear from his own life's work that to “think and learn and do”—the “outthinking and outflanking”—required schooling.

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 28 , Issue 3 , Fall 1988 , pp. 333 - 366
Copyright
Copyright © 1988 by the History of Education Society 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 DuBois, W. E. B., The Education of Black People: Ten Critiques, 1906–1960 ed. Aptheker, Herbert (New York, 1973), 77. The history of education is intimately related to all other areas of history and cannot be understood in isolation from political, social, economic, and institutional history. Nowhere is this clearer than in African American history, in which the social embeddedness of education is sharply illustrated. However, in order to keep this discussion within reasonable bounds, this essay and accompanying notes are limited to the scholarship specifically related to the history of black education, with a handful of exceptions.Google Scholar

2 For alternative periodization, see Franklin, Vincent P., “Introductory Essay: Changing Historical Perspectives on Afro-American Life and Education,” in New Perspectives on Black Educational History, ed. Franklin, Vincent P. and Anderson, James D. (Boston, 1978), 1–18; and Meier, August and Rudwick, Elliott, Black History and the Historical Profession, 1915–1980 (Urbana, Ill., 1986). Franklin relies on a traditional historiographic periodization; Meier and Rudwick are less concerned with changing interpretation than with the growth of black history. Both add important dimensions to the dialogue, much of which I have not sought to repeat in this essay.Google Scholar

3 Woodson, Carter G., The Education of the Negro Prior to 1861 … (1919; reprint, New York, 1968); DuBois, W. E. B., ed., The Negro Common School (Atlanta, Ga., 1901); Birnie, C. W., “Education of the Negro in Charleston, South Carolina, Prior to the Civil War,” Journal of Negro History 12 (Jan. 1927): 13–21; Jackson, Luther P., “Religious Instruction of Negroes, 1830–1860, with Special Reference to South Carolina,” Journal of Negro History 15 (Jan. 1930): 72–114; Vibert, Faith, “The Society for the Propagation of the Gospel in Foreign Parts: Its Work for the Negroes in North America before 1783,” Journal of Negro History 18 (Apr. 1933): 171–212; on postelementary education, see, e.g., Daniel, W. A., The Education of Negro Ministers (1925; reprint, New York, 1969); Clement, Rufus E., “The Church School as a Social Factor in Negro Life,” Journal of Negro History 12 (Jan. 1927): 5–12; Jackson, Reid E., “Rise of Teacher-Training for Negroes,” Journal of Negro Education 7 (Oct. 1938): 540–47; and DuBois, W. E. B. and Granville Dill, August, eds., The College-Bred Negro American (Atlanta, Ga., 1910); for informal agencies, see, e.g., Johnson, Charles S., “The Rise of the Negro Magazine,” Journal of Negro History 13 (Jan. 1928): 7–21; Porter, Dorothy B., “The Organized Educational Activities of Negro Literary Societies, 1828–1846,” Journal of Negro Education 5 (Oct. 1936): 555–76; Birnie, , “Education of the Negro in Charleston”; Edward Moorland, Jesse, “The Young Men's Christian Association among Negroes,” Journal of Negro History 9 (Apr. 1924): 127–38; Johnson, Campbell C., “Negro Youth and the Educational Program of the Y.M.C.A.,” Journal of Negro Education 9 (July 1940): 354–71; Cuthbert, Marion, “Negro Youth and the Educational Program of the Y.W.C. A.,” Journal of Negro Education 9 (July 1940): 363–71; few institutional biographies were written in this period, but see Francis Greenwood Peabody, Education for Life: The Story of Hampton Institution (Garden City, N.Y., 1918); and Jackson, Luther P., “The Origins of Hampton Institute,” Journal of Negro History 10 (Apr. 1925): 131–49; on education in the North, see also Carroll, J. C., “The Beginnings of Public Education for Negroes in Indiana,” Journal of Negro Education 8 (Oct. 1939): 649–58.Google Scholar

4 DuBois, W. E. B., The Souls of Black Folk (1903; reprint, New York, 1969), 64 (first quotation), 67, 71; idem, Negro Common School, 21–42, second quotation on 40; idem, Black Reconstruction in America, 1860–1880 (1935; reprint, Cleveland, 1964), 637–69. See also Jackson, Luther P., “The Educational Efforts of the Freedmen's Bureau and Freedmen's Aid Societies in South Carolina, 1862–1872,” Journal of Negro History 8 (Jan. 1923): 1–40; Kassel, Charles, “Educating the Slave—A Forgotten Chapter of Civil War History,” Open Court 41 (Apr. 1927): 239–56; Eggleston, G. K., “The Work of Relief Societies during the Civil War,” Journal of Negro History 14 (July 1929): 272–99.Google Scholar

5 Sullivan Williams, Henry, “The Development of the Negro Public School System in Missouri,” Journal of Negro History 5 (Apr. 1920): 137–65; Woodson, Carter G., Early Negro Education in West Virginia (Institute, W.Va., 1921); Ambush Taylor, Alrutheus, The Negro in South Carolina during the Reconstruction (1924; reprint, New York, 1969): 82–105; Ambush Taylor, Arutheus, “The Negro in the Reconstruction of Virginia,” Journal of Negro History 11 (Apr. 1926): 379–415; Sherman Savage, W., “Legal Provisions for Negro Schools in Missouri from 1865 to 1890,” Journal of Negro History 16 (July 1931): 309–21; Sherman Savage, W., “Legal Provisions for Negro Schools in Missouri from 1891 to 1935,” Journal of Negro History 22 (July 1937): 335–44; DuBois, , Negro Common School; Lance G. E. Jones, Negro Schools in the Southern States (Oxford, Eng., 1928).Google Scholar

6 DuBois, Woodson, Taylor, and others documented segregation and exclusion, of course. But separation remained a minor issue in these studies, not a theme of significance. Savage, “Legal Provisions for Negro Schools in Missouri, 1865–1890,” 309–21; idem, “Legal Provisions for Negro Schools in Missouri, 1891–1935,” 335–44; and idem, “Early Negro Education in the Pacific Coast States,” Journal of Negro Education 15 (Spring 1946): 134–39, focused more fully on legal and legislative issues than most contemporary African American education historians; hence, his studies are among the few that make racial segregation a theme.Google Scholar

7 Even the few studies whose theme appears to be industrial education frequently do not provide rigorous histories of the idea or its effects. Peabody's Education for Life, for instance, is an extended panegyric.Google Scholar

8 Jesse Jones, Thomas, ed., Negro Education: A Study of the Private and Higher Schools for Colored People in the U.S. (Washington, D.C., 1917); DuBois, , Negro Common School, 42; see also Washington, Booker T. and DuBois, W. E. B., The Negro in the South … ([1907?]; reprint, New York, 1970): 102–3, 114. Jones, however, wrote largely in support of continued segregation.Google Scholar

9 Wright, Richard R., A Brief Historical Sketch of Negro Education in Georgia (Savannah, Ga., 1894), 50, 52; see also, Peabody, Education for Life; Funke, Loretta, “The Negro in Education,” Journal of Negro History 5 (Jan. 1920): 1–21; Diggs, Margaret A., Catholic Negro Education in the United States (Washington, D.C., 1936).Google Scholar

10 Porter, , “Organized Educational Activities of Negro Literary Societies,” 576. See also Taylor, “Negro in the Reconstruction of Virginia,” 414; Birnie, , “Education of the Negro in Charleston”; Woodson, , Early Negro Education in West Virginia DuBois, , Negro Common School, 21–42, 91; Johnson, Charles S., “Rise of the Negro Magazine”; Jackson, Reid E., “Rise of Teacher-Training for Negroes”; Clement, “Church School as a Social Factor”; Leidecker, Kurt F., “The Education of Negroes in St. Louis, Missouri, during William Torrey Harris’ Administration,” Journal of Negro Education 10 (Oct. 1941): 643–49.Google Scholar

11 DuBois, , Souls of Black Folk 127; Daniel, , The Education of Negro Ministers, 28 and passim; Clement, “Church School as a Social Factor.”Google Scholar

12 DuBois, , Negro Common School 118.Google Scholar

13 Horace Fitchett, E., “The Influence of Claflin College on Negro Family Life,” Journal of Negro History 29 (Oct. 1944): 459; see, among others, Preston, Emmett D. Jr., “Development of Negro Education in the District of Columbia,” Journal of Negro Education 9 (Oct. 1940): 595–603; Preston, , “The Development of Negro Education in the District of Columbia, 1800–1860,” Journal of Negro Education 12 (Spring 1943): 189–98.Google Scholar

14 Jackson, Luther P., “Religious Instruction of Negroes,” 72.Google Scholar

15 Knight, Edgar W., “The ‘Messianic’ Invasion of the South after 1865,” School and Society, 5 June 1943, 647, 645. See also idem, “Reconstruction and Education in South Carolina,” South Atlantic Quarterly 18 (Oct. 1919): 350–64 and 19 (Jan. 1920): 55–66; idem, Public School Education in North Carolina (1916; reprint, New York, 1969): esp. 265; deRoulhac Hamilton, J. G., “The Freedmen's Bureau in North Carolina,” South Atlantic Quarterly 8 (Jan. 1909): 53–67 and (Apr. 1909): 154–63.Google Scholar

16 Lee Swint, Henry, The Northern Teacher in the South, 1862–1870 (1941; reprint, New York, 1967).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

17 Grayson Noble, Stuart, Forty Years of the Public Schools in Mississippi, with Special Reference to the Education of the Negro (New York, 1918): 75–89, quotation on 82. See also Charles Dabney, Universal Education in the South, 2 vols. (Chapel Hill, N.C., 1936).Google Scholar

18 Mann Bond, Horace, The Education of the Negro in the American Social Order (1934; reprint with new preface and additional chapter, New York, 1966), 13.Google Scholar

19 Mann Bond, Horace, Negro Education in Alabama: A Study in Cotton and Steel (1939; reprint, New York, 1969), 141.Google Scholar

20 Harlan, Louis R., Separate and Unequal: Public School Campaigns and Racism in the Southern Seaboard States, 1901–1915 (1958; reprint, New York, 1968); Preston Vaughn, William, Schools for All: The Blacks and Public Education in the South, 1865–1877 (Lexington, Ky., 1974); Allen Bullock, Henry, A History of Negro Education in the South: From 1619 to the Present (1967; reprint, New York, 1970). On the history of northern black education written during this period, see, e.g., L. D. Reddick, “The Education of Negroes in States Where Separate Schools Are Not Legal,” Journal of Negro Education 16 (Summer 1947): 290–300; McGinnis, Frederick A., The Education of Negroes in Ohio (Wilberforce, Ohio, 1962); Manola Wright, Marion, The Education of Negroes in New Jersey (New York, 1941). Southern state studies include William R. Davis, The Development and Present Status of Negro Education in East Texas (New York, 1934); Whitener, Daniel J., “The Republican Party and Public Education in North Carolina, 1867–1900,” North Carolina Historical Review 37 (July 1960): 382–96; Bond, , Negro Education in Alabama; Hugh Victor Brown, History of the Education of Negroes in North Carolina (Raleigh, N.C., 1961). Cf. Hollis Moody Long, Public Secondary Education for Negroes in North Carolina (New York, 1932), a sociological approach.Google Scholar

21 See, among others, Alderson, William T. Jr., “The Freedmen's Bureau and Negro Education in Virginia “ North Carolina Historical Review 29 (Jan. 1952): 64–90; Lowe, W. A., “The Freedmen's Bureau and Education in Maryland,” Maryland Historical Magazine 47 (Mar. 1952): 29–39; Abbott, Martin, “The Freedmen's Bureau and Negro Schooling in South Carolina,” South Carolina Historical Magazine 57 (Apr. 1956): 65–81; Richardson, Joe M., “The Freedmen's Bureau and Negro Education in Florida,” Journal of Negro Education 31 (Fall 1962): 460–67.Google Scholar

22 Davis, William, Negro Education in East Texas 137; Harlan, , Separate and Unequal, 269; see also Knox, Ellis O., “The Origins and Development of the Negro Separate School,” Journal of Negro Education 16 (Summer 1947): 269–79; Wright, Marion, Education of Negroes in New Jersey. Google Scholar

23 Noble, Jeanne L., The Negro Woman's College Education (New York, 1956), 18; Johnson, Charles S., The Negro College Graduate (1938; reprint, College Park, Md., 1969), 339; see also Range, Willard, The Rise and Progress of Negro Colleges in Georgia, 1865–1949 (Athens, Ga., 1951); Gallagher, Buell G., American Caste and the Negro College (1938; reprint, New York, 1966); Vera Cuthbert, Marion, Education and Marginality: A Study of the Negro Woman College Graduate (New York, 1942); Oliver Wendell Holmes, Dwight, The Evolution of the Negro College (1934; reprint, New York, 1970); Mann Bond, Horace, “The Evolution and Present Status of Negro Higher and Professional Education in the United States,” Journal of Negro Education 17 (Summer 1948): 224–35; Mann Bond, Horace, “The Origin and Development of Negro Church Colleges,” Journal of Negro Education 29 (Summer 1960): 217–26. Among institutional biographies from the period, see Frederick A. McGinnis, A History and Interpretation of Wilberforce University (Wilberforce, Ohio, 1941); and Neyland, Leedell W. and Riley, John W., The History of Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University (Gainesville, Fla., 1963). Elisabeth S. Peck, Berea's First Century, 1855–1955 (Lexington, Ky., 1955), deals briefly with Berea while it was an integrated college.Google Scholar

24 Bond, , Negro Education in Alabama 215. Range, Negro Colleges in Georgia, 78; Meier, August, “The Beginning of Industrial Education in Negro Schools,” Midwest Journal 7 (Spring 1955): 21–44; Meier, August, “The Vogue of Industrial Education,” Midwest Journal 7 (Fall 1955): 241–66. Bullock, Negro Education in the South, addresses industrial education desultorily, but is less willing to dismiss industrial education altogether; see esp. 100–102, 159–60.Google Scholar

25 Whitney Leavell, Ullin, Philanthropy in Negro Education (1930; reprint, Westport, Conn., 1970), 57–58; Bond, , Education of the Negro, 148–50; see also, Bond, Negro Education in Alabama, 262–86; Jones, Lance G. E., The Jeanes Teacher in the United States, 1908–1933: An Account of Twenty-five Years’ Experience in the Supervision of Negro Rural Schools (Chapel Hill, N.C., 1937); Holmes, , Evolution of the Negro College, esp. 14, 69–71; Fosdick, Raymond B., Adventure in Giving: The Story of the General Education Board, a Foundation Established by John D. Rockefeller (New York, 1962).Google Scholar

26 Harlan, , Separate and Unequal 254; see also Bullock, , Negro Education in the South, 117–20; Meier, , “Vogue of Industrial Education,” 241–66; Preston Vaughn, William, “Partners in Segregation: Barnas Sears and the Peabody Fund,” Civil War History 10 (Sept. 1964): 260–74; cf. West, Earle H., “The Peabody Education Fund and Negro Education, 1867–1880,” History of Education Quarterly 6 (Summer 1966): 3–21.Google Scholar

27 Knox, , “Origins and Development of the Negro Separate School”; Dabney, Lillian G., The History of Schools for Negroes in the District of Columbia, 1807–1947 (Washington, D.C., 1949), esp. 252–53; Levy, Leonard W. and Phillips, Harlan B., “The Roberts Case: Source of the ‘Separate but Equal’ Doctrine,” American Historical Review 56 (Apr. 1951): 510–18; Groves, Harry E., “A Re-examination of the ‘Separate but Equal’ Doctrine in Public Education,” Journal of Negro Education 20 (Fall 1951): 520–34; “How Imminent is the Outlawing of Segregation?” Journal of Negro Education 20 (Fall 1951): 495–98; Graham, Howard J., “The Fourteenth Amendment and School Segregation,” Buffalo Law Review 3 (1953): 1–24. Post-Brown studies of the origins of segregation and the antecedents to desegregation include John Hope Franklin, “Jim Crow Goes to School: The Genesis of Legal Segregation in Southern Schools,” South Atlantic Quarterly 58 (Spring 1959): 225–35; Kelly, Alfred H., “The Congressional Controversy over School Desegregation, 1867–1875,” American Historical Review 64 (Apr. 1959): 537–63; Harlan, , Separate and Unequal; Louis R. Harlan, “Desegregation in New Orleans Public Schools during Reconstruction,” American Historical Review 67 (Apr. 1962): 663–75; Preston Vaughn, William, “Separate and Unequal: The Civil Rights Act of 1875 and Defeat of the School Integration Clause,” Southwest Social Science Quarterly 48 (Sept. 1967): 146–54; Vaughn, , Schools for All; Mabee, Carleton, “A Negro Boycott to Integrate Boston Schools,” New England Quarterly 41 (Sept. 1968): 341–61; Meier, August and Rudwick, Elliott M., “Early Boycotts of Segregated Schools: The East Orange, New Jersey, Experience, 1899–1906,” History of Education Quarterly 7 (Spring 1967): 22–35; Meier and Rudwick, “Early Boycotts of Segregated Schools: The Alton, Illinois Case, 1897–1908,” Journal of Negro Education 36 (Fall 1967): 394–402; Meier, August and Rudwick, Elliott M., “Early Boycotts of Segregated Schools: The Case of Springfield, Ohio, 1922–1923,” American Quarterly 20 (Winter 1968): 744–58; Jacobs, Donald M., “The Nineteenth-Century Struggle over Segregated Education in the Boston Schools,” Journal of Negro Education 39 (Winter 1970): 76–85. For histories of desegregation written in this period, see, e.g., Benjamin Muse, Ten Years of Prelude: The Story of Integration since the Supreme Court's 1954 Decision (New York, 1964); Blaustein, Albert P. and Ferguson, Clarence C. Jr., Desegregation and the Law: The Meaning and Effect of the School Segregation Cases (New Brunswick, N.J., 1957); Berman, Daniel M., It Is So Ordered: The Supreme Court Rules on School Segregation (New York, 1966); Orfield, Gary, Reconstruction of Southern Education: The Schools and the 1964 Civil Rights Act (New York, 1969); Bartley, Numan V., The Rise of Massive Resistance: Race and Politics in the South during the 1950s (Baton Rouge, La., 1969).Google Scholar

28 Jones, Lance, Jeanes Teacher xv–xvi. Among many reflecting the interracial theme, see Brown, History of Education of Negroes in North Carolina; Edward Jones, A Candle in the Dark: A History of Morehouse College (Valley Forge, Pa., 1967); Brawley, James P., Two Centuries of Methodist Concern: Bondage, Freedom, and Education of Black People (New York, 1974); and the sources cited in note 25 on philanthropy in black education. Not all who developed interracialism as a theme were integrationists. Early in this period, some writers lauded interracial cooperation as a means to ease the harsher aspects of educational discrimination and make separate truly equal. See, e.g., William Davis, Negro Education in East Texas; Lance Jones, Jeanes Teacher; Wilson, Charles H., Education for Negroes in Mississippi since 1910 (Boston, 1947).Google Scholar

29 Wright, Marion, Education of Negroes in New Jersey 194; Reddick, , “Education of Negroes Where Separate Schools Are Not Equal,” esp. 300; Davis, John W., “The Negro Land-Grant College,” Journal of Negro Education 2 (July 1933): 315; McGinnis, , Education of Negroes in Ohio, xii; Newby, Robert G. and Tyack, David B., “Victims without ‘Crimes': Some Historical Perspectives on Black Education,” Journal of Negro Education 40 (Summer 1971): 192–206; Myrdal, Gunnar, An American Dilemma: The Negro Problem and Modern Democracy (New York, 1944).Google Scholar

30 Caliver, Ambrose, “Certain Significant Developments in the Education of Negroes during the Past Generation,” Journal of Negro History 35 (Apr. 1950): 111–34; quotation on 120.Google Scholar

31 Gallagher, , American Caste and the Negro College xiii–xiv.Google Scholar

32 Harlan, , Separate and Unequal xvii; others in this dissenting tradition include Knox, “Origins and Development of the Negro Separate School”; and Aptheker, Herbert, “Literacy, the Negro, and World War II,” Journal of Negro Education 15 (Fall 1946): 595–602; Bond, , Negro Education in Alabama; Bond, , Education of the Negro. Bond moved closer to liberal integrationism by the 1960s, however. In 1934 he wrote that it was “highly possible that [the] day will never come” when blacks would become “full participants in the American social order” (Education of the Negro, 4). However, in the new preface and conclusion to this book, written in 1966, he expressed a cautious optimism toward assimilation, and embraced the “tangle of pathologies” explanation of black culture. Thus, he appears to have abandoned his focus on systemic bases for oppression and rooted his analysis in the family and culture of black America instead.Google Scholar

33 Bullock, , Negro Education in the South xiv–xi and passim.Google Scholar

34 Ibid., 34, 60–88.Google Scholar

35 Ibid., 188; Bond, , Negro Education in Alabama 289.Google Scholar

36 Webber, Thomas L., Deep like the Rivers: Education in the Slave Quarter Community, 1831–1865 (New York, 1978); Cornelius, Janet, “'We Slipped and Learned to Read': Slave Accounts of the Literacy Process, 1830–1865,” Phylon 44 (Sept. 1983): 171–86; Blassingame, John W., The Slave Community: Plantation Life in the Antebellum South (New York, 1972); Blassingame, , Black New Orleans, 1860–1880 (Chicago, 1973); Genovese, Eugene D., Roll, Jordan, Roll: The World the Slaves Made (New York, 1974). Cf. Peter Kolchin, “Reevaluating the Antebellum Slave Community: A Comparative Perspective,” Journal of American History 70 (Dec. 1983): 579–601.Google Scholar

37 Wilkerson, Doxie, “Ghetto School Struggles in Historical Perspective,” Science and Society 33 (Spring 1969): 130–49; Hurst, Marsha, “Integration, Freedom of Choice, and Community Control in Nineteenth-Century Brooklyn,” Journal of Ethnic Studies 3 (Fall 1975): 33–55; Mabee, Carleton, Black Education in New York State: From Colonial to Modern Times (Syracuse, N.Y., 1979); Marie Perkins, Linda, “Quaker Beneficence and Black Control: The Institute for Colored Youth, 1852–1903,” in New Perspectives, ed. Franklin, and Anderson, , 19–43; Jolley Mohraz, Judy, The Separate Problem: Case Studies of Black Education in the North, 1900–1930 (Westport, Conn., 1979); Franklin, Vincent P., The Education of Black Philadelphia: The Social and Educational History of a Minority Community, 1900–1950 (Philadelphia, 1979); Daniel, Phillip T. K., “A History of Discrimination against Black Students in Chicago Secondary Schools,” History of Education Quarterly 20 (Summer 1980): 147–62; Homel, Michael W., Down from Equality: Black Chicagoans and the Public Schools, 1920–1941 (Urbana, Ill., 1984); Pieroth, Doris, “With All Deliberate Caution: School Integration in Seattle, 1954–1968,” Pacific Northwest Quarterly 73 (Apr. 1982): 50–61; Rury, John L., “The New York African Free School, 1827–1836: Conflict over Community Control of Black Education,” Phylon 44 (Sept. 1983): 187–97; among others cited below.Google Scholar

38 Studies of black students include Aptheker, Herbert, “Negro College Students in the 1920s: Years of Preparation and Protest: An Introduction,” Science and Society 33 (Spring 1969): 150–67; Bigglestone, W. E., “Oberlin College and the Negro Student, 1865–1940, Journal of Negro History 56 (July 1971): 198–219; Wolters, Raymond, The New Negro on Campus: Black College Rebellions of the 1920s (Princeton, N.J., 1975); Griggs Fleming, Cynthia, “The Effect of Higher Education on Black Tennesseans after the Civil War,” Phylon 44 (Sept. 1983): 209–16; Spivey, Donald, “The Black Athlete in Big-Time Intercollegiate Sports, 1941–1968,” Phylon 44 (June 1983): 116–25; Perkins, Linda M., “The Impact of the ‘Cult of True Womanhood’ on the Education of Black Women,” Journal of Social Issues 39 (1983): 17–28; and Wyatt-Brown, Bertram, “Black Schooling during Reconstruction,” in Fraser, Walter J. Jr., et al., The Web of Southern Social Relations: Women, Family, and Education (Athens, Ga., 1985): 146–65. On white teachers in black education, see Jacqueline Jones, Soldiers of Light and Love: Northern Teachers and Georgia Blacks, 1865–1873 (Chapel Hill, N.C., 1980); Small, Sandra E., “The Yankee Schoolmarm in Freedmen's Schools: An Analysis of Attitudes,” Journal of Southern History 45 (Aug. 1979): 381–402; Foner, Philip S. and Pacheco, Josephine F., Three Who Dared: Prudence Crandall, Margaret Douglass, Myrtilla Miner: Champions of Antebellum Black Education (Westport, Conn., 1984). On black teachers, see Howard N. Rabinowitz, “Half a Loaf: The Shift from White to Black Teachers in the Negro Schools of the Urban South, 1865–1890,” Journal of Southern History 40 (Nov. 1974): 565–94; Griggs Fleming, Cynthia, “The Plight of Black Educators in Postwar Tennessee, 1865–1920,” Journal of Negro History 64 (Fall 1979): 355–64; Evans, Art and Evans, Annette M., “Black Educators before and after 1960,” Phylon 43 (Sept. 1982): 254–61; Morris, Robert C., Reading, ‘Riting, and Reconstruction: The Education of Freedmen in the South, 1861–1870 (Chicago, 1981): 85–130; Butchart, Ronald E., “We Best Can Instruct Our Own People': New York African Americans in the Freedmen's Schools, 1861–1875,” Afro-Americans in New York Life and History 12 (1988): 27–49; and biographies of black educators, such as Louis R. Harlan, Booker T. Washington, 2 vols. (New York, 1972, 1983); Manning, Kenneth R., Black Apollo of Science: The Life of Ernest Everett Just (New York, 1983); McMurry, Linda O., George Washington Carver: Scientist and Symbol (New York, 1981); Richardson, Joe M., “Francis L. Cardozo: Black Educator during Reconstruction,” Journal of Negro Education 48 (Winter 1979): 73–83; and Perkins, Linda M., “Heed Life's Demands: The Educational Philosophy of Fanny Jackson Coppin,” Journal of Negro Education 51 (Summer 1982): 181–90.Google Scholar

39 Smith, Timothy L., “Native Blacks and Foreign Whites: Varying Responses to Educational Opportunity in America, 1880–1950,” Perspectives in American History 6 (1972): 309–35; Troen, Selwyn K., The Public and the Schools: Shaping the St. Louis System, 1838–1920 (Columbia, Mo., 1975): 91–98; Portes, Alejandro and Wilson, Kenneth, “Black-White Differences in Educational Attainment,” American Sociological Review 41 (June 1976): 414–31.Google Scholar

40 Jay Gould, Stephen, The Mismeasure of Man (New York, 1981); Chase, Allan, Legacy of Malthus: The Social Costs of the New Scientific Racism, 2d ed. (Urbana, Ill., 1980).Google Scholar

41 Butchart, Ronald E., Northern Schools, Southern Blacks, and Reconstruction: Freedmen's Education, 1862–1875 (Westport, Conn., 1980); Richardson, Joe M., Christian Reconstruction: The American Missionary Association and Southern Blacks, 1861–1890 (Athens, Ga., 1986); Jones, Jacqueline, Soldiers of Light and Love; Morris, Reading, ‘Riting, and Reconstruction; Sue Alexander, Roberta, “Hostility and Hope: Black Education in North Carolina during Presidential Reconstruction, 1865–1867,” North Carolina Historical Review 53 (Apr. 1976): 113–32; Wilson, Keith, “Education as a Vehicle of Racial Control: Major General N. P. Banks in Louisiana, 1863–1864,” Journal of Negro Education 50 (Spring 1981): 156–70. Curiously, James M. McPherson, The Struggle for Equality: Abolitionists and the Negro in the Civil War and Reconstruction (Princeton, N.J., 1964), esp. 154–77, which anticipated many of the later revisionist arguments, was generally ignored by historians of black education.Google Scholar

42 Anderson, James D., “The Hampton Model of Normal School Industrial Education, 1868–1900,” in New Perspectives, ed. Franklin, and Anderson, , 61–96; see also Harlan, , Booker T. Washington. Robert G. Sherer, Subordination or Liberation? The Development and Conflicting Theories of Black Education in Nineteenth-Century Alabama (University, Ala., 1977), and James M. McPherson, The Abolitionist Legacy: From Reconstruction to the NAACP (Princeton, N.J., 1975): 203–33, contribute to Willard Range's assertion that the liberal arts remained as the core of most secondary and higher education curricula. Also on industrial education, see Allen W. Jones, “The Role of Tuskegee in the Education of Black Farmers,” Journal of Negro History 60 (Apr. 1975): 252–67.Google Scholar

43 Anderson, James D., “Northern Foundations and the Shaping of Southern Black Rural Education, 1902–1935,” History of Education Quarterly 18 (Winter 1978): 371–96; idem, “The Southern Improvement Company: Northern Reformers’ Investment in Negro Cotton Tenancy, 1900–1920,” Agricultural History 52 (Jan. 1978): 111–31; idem, “Northern Philanthropy and the Training of the Black Leadership: Fisk University, A Case Study, 1915–1930,” in New Perspectives, ed. Franklin and Anderson, 97–112; idem, “Education as a Vehicle for the Manipulation of Black Workers,” in Work, Technology, and Education: Dissenting Essays in the Intellectual Foundations of American Education, ed. Walter Feinberg and Henry Rosemont, Jr. (Urbana, 1975): 15–40; Quinn Kelley, Don, “Ideology and Education: Uplifting the Masses in Nineteenth-Century Alabama,” Phylon 40 (June 1979): 147–58; Stephen Peeps, J. M., “Northern Philanthropy and the Emergence of Black Higher Education—Do-Gooders, Compromisers, or Co-conspirators?” Journal of Negro Education 50 (Summer 1981): 251–69; Spivey, Donald, Schooling for the New Slavery: Black Industrial Education, 1868–1915 (Westport, Conn., 1978).Google Scholar

44 Institutional biographies include Jones, Edward A., Candle in the Dark Logan, Rayford W., Howard University: The First Hundred Years, 1867–1967 (New York, 1969); Bacote, Clarence A., The Story of Atlanta University: A Century of Service, 1865–1965 (Atlanta, Ga., 1969); Mann Bond, Horace, Education for Freedom: A History of Lincoln University, Pennsylvania (Lincoln University, Pa., 1976); Stanford Cozart, Leland, A Venture of Faith: Barber-Scotia College, 1867–1967 (Charlotte, N.C., 1976); Campbell, Clarence T. and Allan Rogers, Oscar Jr., Mississippi: The View from Tougaloo (Jackson, Miss., 1979); Zella, J. Patterson, Black, Langston University: A History (Norman, Okla., 1979); and Richardson, Joe M., A History of Fisk University, 1865–1946 (University, Ala., 1980). On other issues in higher education, see, e.g., John E. Fleming, The Lengthening Shadow of Slavery: A Historical Justification for Affirmative Action for Blacks in Higher Education (Washington, D.C., 1976); Shannon, Samuel H., “Land-Grant College Legislation and Black Tennesseans: A Case Study in the Politics of Education,” History of Education Quarterly 22 (Summer 1982): 139–57; Pearson, Ralph L., “Reflections on Black Colleges: The Historical Perspective of Charles S. Johnson,” History of Education Quarterly 23 (Spring 1983): 55–68. On black professional training and organizations, see Alfred A. Moss, Jr., The American Negro Academy: Voice of the Talented Tenth (Baton Rouge, La., 1981): 304; see also Summerville, James, Educating Black Doctors: A History of Me harry Medical College (University, Ala., 1983); Clark Hine, Darlene, “The Pursuit of Professional Equality: Meharry Medical College, 1921–1938, A Case Study,” in New Perspectives, ed. Franklin, and Anderson, , 173–92; Parker, Kellis E. and Stebman, Betty J., “Legal Education for Blacks,” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 407 (May 1973): 144–55; Rae McNeil, Genna, “To Meet the Group Needs: The Transformation of Howard University School of Law, 1920–1935,” in New Perspectives, ed. Franklin, and Anderson, , 149–71; Perry, Thelma D., The History of the American Teachers Association (Washington, D.C., 1975); Middleton, Ernest J., “The Louisiana Education Association, 1901–1970,” Journal of Negro Education 47 (Fall 1978): 363–78.Google Scholar

45 Homel, , Down from Equality Schwartz, Bernard, Swann's Way: The Second Busing Case and the Supreme Court (New York, 1986); Pride, Richard A. and David Woodard, J., The Burden of Busing: The Politics of Desegregation in Nashville (Knoxville, Tenn., 1985); Metcalf, George R., From Little Rock to Boston: The History of School Desegregation (Westport, Conn., 1983); Weinberg, Meyer, A Chance to Learn: The History of Race and Education in the United States (Cambridge, Mass., 1977); Kluger, Richard, Simple Justice: The History of Brown v. Board of Education and Black America's Struggle for Equality (New York, 1976); Gerber, David A., “Education, Expediency, and Ideology: Race and Politics in the Desegregation of Ohio Public Schools in the Late Nineteenth Century,” Journal of Ethnic Studies 1 (Fall 1973): 1–31; Pieroth, , “With All Deliberate Caution,” 50–61; Morgan Kousser, J., “Making Separate Equal: Integration of Black and White School Funds in Kentucky,” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 10 (Winter 1980): 399–428; Caughey, John, To Kill a Child's Spirit: The Tragedy of School Segregation in Los Angeles (Itasca, Ill., 1973); Hornsby, Alton Jr., “The Freedmen's Bureau Schools in Texas, 1864–1870,” Southwestern Historical Quarterly 76 (Apr. 1973): 397–417. Raymond Wolters, The Burden of Brown: Thirty Years of School Desegregation (Knoxville, Tenn., 1984), deals with segregation, but fits better within one of the possible postrevisionist camps described later than in a discussion of revisionism.Google Scholar

46 Aickin Rothschild, Mary, “The Volunteers and the Freedom Schools: Education for Social Change in Mississippi,” History of Education Quarterly 22 (Winter 1982): 401–20; Abney, Everett E., “A Comparison of the Status of Florida's Black Public School Principals, 1965–66/1975–76,” Journal of Negro Education 49 (Fall 1980): 398–406; Howie, Donald L. W., “The Image of Black People in Brown v. Board of Education,” Journal of Black Studies 3 (Mar. 1973): 371–84; Franklin, Vincent P., “Persistence of School Segregation in the Urban North,” Journal of Ethnic Studies 1 (Winter 1974): 51–68.Google Scholar

47 State studies include Mabee, Black Education in New York State; Russell, Lester F., Black Baptist Secondary Schools in Virginia, 1887–1957: A Study in Black History (Metuchen, N.J., 1981); Scott, John I. E., The Education of Black People in Florida (Philadelphia, 1974); Carper, James C., “The Popular Ideology of Segregated Schooling: Attitudes toward the Education of Blacks in Kansas, 1854–1900,” Kansas History 1 (Winter 1978): 254–65. Among urban studies, see Homel, Down from Equality; Franklin, Education of Black Philadelphia; Mohraz, , Separate Problem; June O. Patton, “The Black Community of Augusta and the Struggle for Ware High School, 1880–1899,” in New Perspectives, ed. Franklin and Anderson, 45–59.Google Scholar

48 Interracialism is central to Jacqueline Jones, Soldiers of Light and Love; Richardson, , Christian Reconstruction; McPherson, , Abolitionist Legacy; Rothschild, , “The Volunteers and the Freedom Schools”; Howe, Florence, “Mississippi's Freedom Schools,” Harvard Educational Review 35 (Spring 1965): 141–60. More critical studies include Butchart, Northern Schools, Southern Blacks, and Reconstruction; Harlan, , Booker T. Washington; Wolters, , The New Negro on Campus; Perkins, , “Quaker Beneficence and Black Control.” See note 45 for studies of segregation and desegregation.Google Scholar

49 Homel, , Down from Equality Weinberg, A Chance to Learn; Spivey, , Schooling for the New Slavery; Troen, , The Public and the Schools, 91–98; Fuller, Edmund, Prudence Crandall: An Incident of Racism in Nineteenth-Century Connecticut (Middletown, Conn., 1971), among others.Google Scholar

50 Wilkerson, , “Ghetto School Struggles,” 145; see also Butchart, , Northern Schools, Southern Blacks, and Reconstruction Wilson, , “Education as a Vehicle of Racial Control”; Fleming, John E., The Lengthening Shadow of Slavery; and citations to Anderson in notes 42 and 43.Google Scholar

51 Mohraz, , Separate Problem and studies cited in note 36.Google Scholar

52 Moss, , The American Negro Academy Franklin, , Education of Black Philadelphia; Webber, , Deep like the Rivers; Mabee, , Black Education in New York State; Sherer, , Subordination or Liberation?; Cozart, , A Venture of Faith. Google Scholar

53 Mabee, , Black Education in New York State.Google Scholar

54 Butchart, Ronald E., “Understanding the Retreat from Integration and Affirmative Action: Implications of Some Historical Parallels,” Peabody Journal of Education 57 (Oct. 1979), 1–9, sketches, tentatively, an interpretation of this period.Google Scholar

55 Wilkerson, , “Ghetto School Struggles,” 146.Google Scholar

56 Examples of the genre include Elizabeth Jacoway, Yankee Missionaries in the South: The Penn School Experiment (Baton Rouge, La., 1980): Jacqueline Jones, Soldiers of Light and Love; McPherson, , Struggle for Equality; McPherson, , Abolitionist Legacy; Foner and Pacheco, Three Who Dared; Homel, , Down from Equality; and Richardson, , Christian Reconstruction. Google Scholar

57 Authors loosely associated with this tendency include Franklin, Education of Black Philadelphia; Webber, , Deep like the Rivers; Blassingame, , The Slave Community; Blassingame, , Black New Orleans, 1860–1880; Mohraz, , Separate Problem; and Wolters, , New Man on Campus. Google Scholar

58 Among others, see Aptheker, “Negro College Students in the 1920s,” Science and Society 33 (Spring 1969): 150–67; Aptheker, , “Literacy, the Negro, and World War II,” Journal of Negro Education 15 (Fall 1946): 595–602; Anderson, all sources cited in notes 42 and 43; Butchart, , Northern Schools, Southern Blacks, and Reconstruction; Wilkerson, , “Ghetto School Struggles in Historical Perspective,” Science and Society, 33 (1969), 130–49; and, less successfully, Spivey, Schooling for the New Slavery. Google Scholar

59 This tendency is still embryonic, but can be detected in such general work as Nicholas Lemann, “The Origins of the Underclass,” Atlantic Monthly 257 (June 1986): 31–55, and 258 (July 1986): 54–68; and more specific studies such as Wolters, Burden of Brown; and Sowell, Thomas, Education: Assumptions versus History: Collected Papers (Stanford, Calif., 1986).Google Scholar