Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T10:25:29.307Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Mobilization of Labour and the Production of Knowledge: The Antiquarian Tradition in Rhodesia*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Terence Ranger
Terence Ranger
Affiliation:
University of Manchester
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

One of the advantages of looking at white society in Southern Rhodesia is that it was a very simple society by contrast to South Africa and that its essential structures show up very clearly. This was certainly true of the business of producing models of African societies, customs and conduct. In South Africa there grew up a cluster of intellectual ‘experts’ on Africans – including a distinguished group of anthropologists. In South Africa, therefore, the connexion between the requirements of the white economy and the most influential models of African societies was complex and indirect. In Rhodesia there was no such tradition of indigenous social science. As a contributor to the Native Affairs Department Annual admitted in 1956, ‘of all areas in Africa Southern Rhodesia was the most backward in anthropological knowledge of its own indigenous peoples’. In Southern Rhodesia the men who administered Africans, mobilized them for employment and kept them working were also the men who produced the authorized versions of the African past, of African customs and of African ‘personality’.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 20 , Issue 4 , October 1979 , pp. 507 - 524
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1979

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Hannan, Father M., reviewing Gelfand, M., Medicine and magic of the Mashona, NADA, xxxiii (1956), 101.Google Scholar

2 Work by Chief Native Commissioners and Native Commissioners includes: Bullock, C., The Mashona, The Indigenous Natives of Southern Rhodesia (Cape Town, 1928)Google Scholar; idem, The Mashona and the Matabele (Cape Town, 1950); Nielsen, P., The Matabele at Home (Bulawayo, 1913)Google Scholar; Posselt, F. W. T., A Survey of the Native Tribes of Southern Rhodesia (Salisbury, 1929Google Scholar); idem, Fact and Fiction (Bulawayo, 1935).

3 Howman, Roger, ‘The native labourer and his food’, NADA, xix (1942), 3–24.Google Scholar

4 Tracy, Hugh, ‘Native dancing – a wasted asset’, NADA, xvii (1940), 29–32.Google Scholar

5 Sauer's, address is reported in the Bulawayo Chronicle, 24 Dec. 1898.Google Scholar

6 Patterson, K. D. and Hartwig, G., ‘The disease factor: an introductory overview’, in Patterson, and Hartwig, (eds.), Disease in African History: An Introductory Survey and Case Studies (Durham, N.C., 1978).Google Scholar

7 Nyambo, Simon S., ‘The Shire Highlands: a socio-economic history of the plantation system of production in Malawi, 1891–1938’, M.A. thesis, University of Malawi, 05 1973.Google Scholar

8 Gelfand, Michael, A Service to the Sick: A History of the Health Services for Africans in Southern Rhodesia, 1890–1953. Zambeziana, no. 1 (Gwelo, 1976), 18.Google Scholar

9 Jones, Gareth Stedman, Outcast London (London, 1971), 192 n.Google Scholar

10 Janzen, John, The Quest for Therapy in Lower Zaire (Berkeley, 1978), 42–3.Google Scholar

11 Thornton, Stephen, ‘Changing patterns of coercive control: The consolidation of white dominance’, unpublished MS, 7–8.Google Scholar

12 Ibid., 8, 9, 31–6.

13 Ibid., 36.

14 M. Hannan, ‘Foreword’, in Gelfand, M., Shona Religion (Cape Town, 1962Google Scholar); idem, ‘Foreword’, in M. Gelfand, African Crucible (Wynberg, n.d.).

15 Craig, Robert, ‘Foreword’Google Scholar, in Gelfand, M., A Non-Racial Island of Learning: A History of the University College of Rhodesia (Gwelo, 1978), 6.Google Scholar

16 Gelfand, M., Shona Ritual (Cape Town, 1959), vii.Google Scholar

17 I do not wish here to pursue the more general controversy about the origins and nature of the Mwari cult, to which I hope to return in a subsequent article.

18 Blake-Thompson, J., ‘Some notes on African ritual sacrifice’, NADA, xxxiv (1957), 124.Google Scholar

19 Gelfand, , A Service to the Sick, 31–3.Google Scholar

20 Wright, Allan, Valley of the Ironwoods (Capetown, 1972), 86.Google Scholar

21 This account of Blake-Thompson's career is based on Wright, on references in Blake-Thompson's, own work, and on the obituary published in NADA, xi, 1 (1964), 73.Google Scholar

22 I confess that I have not been able to obtain a copy of this work and know of its existence only through footnote references by authors who drew on Blake-Thompson as an expert.

23 Howman, Roger, ‘The native labourer and his food’, NADA, xvii (1940), 18, 21.Google Scholar

24 ‘Our contributors’, NADA, xxxiii (1956), 104.Google Scholar

25 Blake-Thompson, J., ‘Some notes on African ritual sacrifice’, NADA, xxxiv (1957), 124–5.Google Scholar

26 Blake-Thompson, J., ‘The Bantu: notes on their origins and history. Part 1: Non-African elements in Bantu culture’, International African Institute Collection, Manchester University Library, P. 3Google Scholar. The manuscript in the collection is now 122 pages long but constitutes a mere fragment of the original total. There is no trace of a second part and it is clear from the list of contents to Part I that this copy is lacking a good deal, most crucially for my purpose here an appendix on ‘ Sources and collection of information’. It is clear that other Rhodesian scholars – most particularly von Sicard and Roger Summers – had access to the completed manuscript. The section of the manuscript which I have seen is in a packet addressed to Daryll Forde and date-stamped 11 May 1958.

27 ‘The Bantu’, 4.Google Scholar

28 Ibid., 11.

29 In fairness to Blake-Thompson and Lino, ‘savagery’ was not seen entirely or even mainly as a Bantu characteristic. ‘The early Bantu might arrive as savages but they soon learned the rules and would abide by them.’ Those who ignored and ultimately destroyed the rules were ‘the Arabs, the Portuguese, the Azimba, the Anguru, and the savages who wore skins from the south’.

30 ‘The Bantu’, especially pp. 5Google Scholar, 7, 8, 23, 79, 80, 83, 114, 122.

31 For an account of the way in which particular occupations were allocated on an ethnic basis in early Bulawayo see Thornton, Stephen, ‘Municipal employment in Bulawayo: An assessment of differing forms of proletarianisation’, unpublished MS, 1978Google Scholar. Briefly, the argument is that people from further away, whose home economy offered no option but the sale of labour, were obliged to take the least well rewarded jobs that then came to be regarded as in some sense ‘natural’ to them. Other African workers had a vested interest in maintaining these job classifications.

32 Blake-Thompson, , ‘The Bantu’, 55–7.Google Scholar

33 Ibid., 58–9.

34 Wright, , Valley of the Ironwoods, 27.Google Scholar

35 Ibid., 27 35. 48, 86.

36 von Sicard, Harald, ‘The Ancient Sabi-Zimbabwe route’, NADA, xl (1963).Google Scholar

37 Obituary, NADA, xli (1964), 70.Google Scholar

38 Summers, Roger, ‘Carl Mauch on Zimbabwe ruins’ and ‘Imbahuru Hill’, NADA, xxix (1952), 15, 82.Google Scholar

39 Summers, Roger and Blake-Thompson, J., ‘Mlimo and Mwari: Notes on a native religion in Southern Rhodesia’, NADA, xxxiii (1956Google Scholar); Summers, Roger, Zimbabwe: A Rhodesian Mystery (Cape Town, 1963), 99.Google Scholar

40 Introduction; editorial; review of Religion, Shona, NADA, xl (1963), 2, 123.Google Scholar

41 Beach, David, ‘Great Zimbabwe as a Mwari-cult Centre’, Rhodesian Prehistory, ii (1973), 11–12.Google Scholar

42 Summers and Blake-Thompson, ‘Mlimo and Mwari’; Summers, Zimbabwe: A Rhodesian Mystery.

43 Werbner, Richard P., ‘Introduction’ and ‘Continuity and policy in Southern Africa's High God cult’, in Werbner, R. P. (ed.), Regional Cults (London, 1977).Google Scholar

44 Ranger, Terence, ‘The historiography of the Mwari cult of Rhodesia: origins and early history’, Conference of the Association of Social Anthropologists, Manchester, 1976.Google Scholar

45 Gelfand, , African Crucible, vii.Google Scholar

46 Ransford, Oliver, Rulers of Rhodesia from Earliest Times to the Referendum (London, 1968), 4.Google Scholar

47 Ita, J. M., ‘Frobenius, Senghor and the image of Africa’, in Horton, Robin and Finnegan, Ruth (eds.), Modes of Thought (London, 1973).Google Scholar