Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gxg78 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T04:31:27.785Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

William McIlwaine and the 1859 Revival in Ulster: A Study of Anglican and Evangelical Identities

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 September 2014

DANIEL RITCHIE
DANIEL RITCHIE*
Affiliation:
School of History and Anthropology, Queen's University Belfast, Belfast BT7 1NN; e-mail: dritchie05@qub.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The Evangelical awakening which took place in the province of Ulster during 1859 was one of the most important events in the religious history of the north of Ireland. Although it has received virtually uncritical acceptance by modern Evangelicals in Northern Ireland, few are aware that there was a significant minority of Evangelicals who dissented from offering the movement their wholehearted support. This article examines why one of nineteenth-century Belfast's most controversial Anglican clerics, the Revd William McIlwaine, was very critical of the movement. Not all critics were outright opponents of the revival, however. McIlwaine was one of the revival's moderate critics, who believed that it was partially good. Nevertheless, the awakening's physical manifestations and its impact on theology and church order deeply disturbed him. The article also explains why 1859 was a turning point in McIlwaine's ecclesiastical career, which saw him move from Evangelicalism to a moderate High Church position.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 65 , Issue 4 , October 2014 , pp. 803 - 826
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Hempton, David and Hill, Myrtle, Evangelical Protestantism and Ulster society, 1790–1840, London 1992, 146Google Scholar.

2 Finlay Holmes, ‘The 1859 revival reconsidered’, new introduction to J. T. Carson, God's river in spate: the story of the religious awakening in Ulster 1859, 2nd edn, Belfast 1994, p. xii.

3 Hodge, Charles, The constitutional history of the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America, II: 1741–1788, Philadelphia 1840, 13–122Google Scholar; Act of the Associate Presbytery, for renewing the National Covenant of Scotland, and the Solemn League and Covenant, Glasgow 1763, 34–5.

4 Holmes, A. R., ‘The experience and understanding of religious revival in Ulster Presbyterianism, c. 1800–1930’, Irish Historical Studies xxxiv (2005), 361–85 at p. 369Google Scholar; Sprague, W. B., Lectures on revival of religion, New York 1833Google Scholar.

5 Dickson, J. N. I., Beyond religious discourse: sermons, preaching and Evangelical Protestants in nineteenth-century Irish society, Milton Keynes 2007, 155Google Scholar.

6 Livingstone, D. N., ‘Darwin in Belfast: the evolution debate’, in Foster, J. W. (ed.), Nature in Ireland: a scientific and cultural history, Belfast 1999, 387–408 at p. 389Google Scholar.

7 Doyle, Mark, Fighting like the devil for the sake of God: Protestants, Catholics and the origins of violence in Victorian Belfast, Manchester 2009, 33Google Scholar.

8 McIlwaine, William, ‘The religious aspect of Ulster revivalism’, JMS vii (Oct. 1860), 59–77Google Scholar.

9 BNL, 14 Aug. 1885.

10 Certificate presented to Jane Wilson, 25 Dec. 1836, McIlwaine papers, PRONI, Belfast, ms D2877/5/1.

11 Leslie, J. B., Clergy of Connor: from patrician times to the present day, 2nd edn, Belfast 1993, 469Google Scholar.

12 BNL, 14 Aug. 1885.

13 BU, 19 Nov. 1863; cf. Witness, 16 Apr. 1880.

14 BNL, 14 Aug. 1885.

15 S. P. Kerr, ‘The Church of Ireland in Belfast, 1800–1870’, unpubl. MPhil diss. Edinburgh 1978, 37.

16 Ibid. 57–62; BNL, 30 July 1833.

17 IEG, 22 Aug. 1885, 712.

18 Carson, God's river in spate (Belfast 1958 edn), 101–2.

19 NW, 18 July 1859.

20 Alexander McCann, The revival movement in Lisburn, Lisburn 1859, 6, 60; cf. BU, 21 July 1859.

21 Evangelical Alliance: report of the proceedings of the conference, held at Freemason's hall, London, from August 19th to September 2nd inclusive, 1846, London 1847, 76; Ballymena Observer, 10 Sept. 1859.

22 BU, 24 Sept. 1859; NW, 23 Sept. 1859.

23 Cf. Livingstone, David and Wells, R. A., Ulster-American religion: episodes in the history of a cultural connection, Notre Dame 1999, 23Google Scholar.

24 Londonderry Standard, 29 Sept. 1859; cf. [John Johnston], The revival movement in Ireland:an impartial history of the revival movement from its commencement to the present time; with portraits of some of the most distinguished labourers in the work, Belfast 1859, p. xvii.

25 William McIlwaine, Revivalism reviewed, Belfast 1859, 7.

26 Idem, ‘Ulster revivalism: a retrospect’, JMS vi (Jan. 1860), 178–98 at p. 184Google Scholar; BNL, 5 July 1865; BU, 6 July 1865.

27 NW, 23 Sept. 1859; BDM, 23 Sept. 1859.

28 BDM, 24 Sept. 1859.

29 BNL, 18 Oct. 1875.

30 D. W. Miller, ‘Ulster Evangelicalism and American culture wars’, Radharc v (2004–6), 197–215 at p. 200.

31 A recent survey of Evangelicalism has highlighted some minor problems with Bebbington's definition, yet basically recognises that it is the best available: Mark Hutchinson and John Wolffe, A short history of global Evangelicalism, Cambridge 2012, 16–17.

32 Bebbington, D. W., Evangelicalism in modern Britain: a history from the 1730s to the 1980s, London 1989, 3Google Scholar.

33 Livingstone, ‘Darwin in Belfast’, 387; Sean Farrell, Rituals and riots: sectarian violence and political culture in Ulster, 1784–1886, Lexington 2000, 145.

34 BDM, 19 July 1859.

35 McIlwaine, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 180–1.

36 Porter, J. S., Lectures on the doctrine of atonement, London 1860Google Scholar; Montgomery, Henry, The creed of an Arian, Belfast 1841Google Scholar.

37 William MacIlwaine, The atonement considered in eight lectures, London 1861, pp. v, 1.

38 Idem, Revivalism reviewed, 15.

39 Idem, ‘Religious aspect’, 76; cf. J. V. Fesko, Diversity within the Reformed tradition: supra-Evangelicalism and infralapsarianism in Calvin, Dort, and Westminster, Jackson 2001, 189, 192.

40 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 76.

41 Idem, ‘Atonement considered’, 3; sermon on Revelation xxii.14, 18 Mar. 1860, McIlwaine sermon books, RCBL, ms 342/6.

42 Sermon on 2 Corinthians v.14, 29 Jan. 1860: ibid.

43 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 76.

44 Letham, Robert, The Westminster Assembly: reading its theology in historical context, Phillipsburg 2009, 69–83Google Scholar.

45 Fesko, Reformed tradition, 296. An interesting case has been made that the language of the Westminster Confession best fits within a supralapsarian scheme, but does not go so far as to exclude infralapsarians: Richard, G. M., ‘Samuel Rutherford's supralapsarianism revealed: a key to the lapsarian position of the Westminster Confession of Faith’, Confessional Presbyterian iv (2008), 162–70Google Scholar.

46 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 70.

47 A. R. Acheson, ‘The Evangelicals in the Church of Ireland, 1784–1859’, unpubl. PhD diss. Queen's University, Belfast 1967, 316.

48 BU, 16 July 1859; 31 Jan. 1860.

49 Hamilton, William, An inquiry into the scriptural character of the revival of 1859, Belfast 1866, 295Google Scholar; cf. NW, 20 Aug. 1859.

50 McIlwaine, Revivalism reviewed, 3; Stopford, E. A., The work and the counterwork, Dublin 1859Google Scholar; Hincks, Edward, God's work & Satan's counter-works, 2nd edn, Belfast 1859Google Scholar.

51 McIlwaine, Revivalism reviewed, 4, and ‘Ulster revivalism’, 182.

52 BDM, 19 July 1859.

53 Ibid.

54 McIlwaine, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 182.

55 BDM, 19 July 1859.

56 McIlwaine, Revivalism reviewed, 4.

57 Ibid. 13.

58 Nelson, Isaac, An answer to the Rev John Macnaughtan's defence of revivalism, assurance, and the witness of the Spirit, Belfast 1867, 10Google Scholar.

59 BNL, 25 Nov. 1863.

60 BNL, 18 Oct. 1875.

61 Thompson, E. P., The making of the English working class, Penguin edn, Harmondsworth 1968, 418Google Scholar.

62 McIlwaine, Revivalism reviewed, 10.

63 Idem, ‘On physical affections in connection with religion, as illustrated by “Ulster revivalism”’, JMS vi (July 1860), 439–60 at p. 444Google Scholar.

64 Ibid; cf. Revivalism reviewed, 7–8; NW, 18 July 1859.

65 McIlwaine, Revivalism reviewed, 8–9, and ‘Ulster revivalism’, 181; cf. BDM, 6 June 1859. Revivalists denied this: BU, 30 June 1859.

66 McIlwaine, Revivalism reviewed, 8–9.

67 BDM, 19 July 1859.

68 Cf. Carwardine, Richard, Transatlantic revivalism: popular Evangelicalism in Britain and America, 1790–1865, 2nd edn, Milton Keynes 2006, 172Google Scholar; Orr, J. E., The second Evangelical awakening in Britain, London 1949, 173Google Scholar.

69 Morgan, James, Thoughts on the revival of 1859, Belfast 1859, 5Google Scholar.

70 McIlwaine, ‘Physical affections’, 441.

71 Idem, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 181–2, and ‘Religious aspect’, 68–70.

72 McCosh, James, The Ulster revival and its physiological accidents, Belfast 1859, 15Google Scholar.

73 ‘Report on the state of religion’, Missionary Herald (Sept. 1859), 401–3 at p. 402, quoted in McIlwaine, ‘Physical affections’, 441–2; BNL, 8 July 1859.

74 McIlwaine, ‘Physical affections’, 442.

75 Idem, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 190, 193; cf. Hempton and Hill, Evangelical Protestantism, 108–12. Other sources suggest that there were more prostrations in rural areas: Portadown Weekly News, 6 Aug. 1859.

76 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 62.

77 Idem, ‘Physical affections’, 442–3.

78 Idem, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 190; cf. Moore, S. J., The history & prominent characteristics of the present revival in Ballymena and its neighbourhood, [Ballymena 1859], 10–12Google Scholar.

79 Nelson, Year of delusion, 51.

80 McIlwaine, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 185.

81 Idem, Revivalism reviewed, 8.

82 Ibid. 12–13, and ‘Ulster revivalism’, 180–1.

83 BNL, 18 Aug. 1859.

84 McIlwaine, Revivalism reviewed, 15.

85 Holmes, Janice, Religious revivals in Britain and Ireland, 1859–1905, Dublin 2000, 45Google Scholar.

86 Londonderry Standard, 4 Aug. 1859.

87 McIlwaine, ‘Physical affections’, 444–6, and ‘Religious aspect’, 60; cf. BU, 4 June 1859, and Reid, J. S., History of the Presbyterian Church in Ireland, ed. Killen, W. D., 2nd edn, London 1863, i. 103Google Scholar.

88 McIlwaine, ‘Physical affections’, 458.

89 Idem, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 189, and ‘Physical affections’, 446–7; cf. Baillie, W. D., The Sixmilewater revival of 1625, Belfast 1976, 18Google Scholar.

90 McIlwaine, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 189, 196.

91 See Holmes, A. R., ‘The Ulster revival of 1859: causes, controversies and consequences’, this Journal lxiii (2012), 488–515 at p. 505Google Scholar.

92 BU, 31 Jan. 1860.

93 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 61.

94 Idem, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 195.

95 Idem, Revivalism reviewed, 15. For revivalist counter-claims see BU, 21 June 1859.

96 McIlwaine, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 197; cf. Rosaline Delargy, ‘The history of the Belfast District Lunatic Asylum, 1829–1921’, unpubl. PhD diss. University of Ulster 2002, 87.

97 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 65.

98 Gibson, William, The year of grace: a history of the Ulster revival of 1859, Edinburgh 1860, 393–6Google Scholar.

99 Cf. Donat, J. G., ‘Medicine and religion: on the physical and mental disorders that accompanied the Ulster revival of 1859’, in Brynum, W. F. and others (eds), The anatomy of madness: essays in the history of psychiatary, London 1998, iii. 125–50Google Scholar at pp. 137–44.

100 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 65–6.

101 Donat, ‘Medicine and religion’, 132–3.

102 McIlwaine, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 191–5.

103 BU, 31 May 1859.

104 BU, 30 June 1859.

105 McIlwaine, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 198.

106 Holmes, Religious revivals, 40.

107 See Bebbington, David, Victorian religious revivals: culture and piety in local and global contexts, Oxford 2012, 48, 179Google Scholar, 191, 222–3, 270–1.

108 See p. 824 below.

109 McIlwaine, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 178–9; cf. BU, 2 June 1859.

110 McIlwaine, Revivalism reviewed, 5.

111 Ibid. 10.

112 Carson, God's river (Belfast 1958 edn), 101; BNL, 30 May 1859; Toye, Jane, Brief memorials of the late Rev. Thomas Toye, Belfast, Belfast 1873, 56Google Scholar; BDM, 3 June 1859; J. B. Armour to John Megaw, 14 Sept. 1859, Armour papers, PRONI, ms D1792/A2/1.

113 BDM, 19 July 1859.

114 Kerr, ‘Church of Ireland’, 138.

115 McIlwaine, ‘Physical affections’, 454; cf. Hempton and Hill, Evangelical Protestantism, 153.

116 McIlwaine, ‘Physical affections’, 447.

117 Idem, Revivalism reviewed, 5.

118 Ibid. 11; cf. BU, 31 May, 4 June 1859.

119 Myrtle Hill, ‘Ulster awakened: the ’59 revival reconsidered’, this Journal xli (1990), 443–62 at p. 459.

120 McIlwaine, Revivalism reviewed, 5.

121 Idem, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 183–4.

122 Ibid. 180, 197.

123 Hill, ‘Ulster awakened’, 456–60.

124 Hobsbawm, Eric, The age of revolution, Europe, 1789–1848, Abacus edn, London 2008, 277Google Scholar.

125 McIlwaine, Revivalism reviewed, 15–16.

126 Idem, ‘Physical affections’, 456; cf. Coad, Roy, A history of the Brethren movement, 2nd edn, Exeter 1976, 171Google Scholar.

127 Acheson, ‘Evangelicals’, 129.

128 Gribben, Crawford, ‘“The worst sect that a Christian man can meet”: opposition to the Plymouth Brethren in Ireland and Scotland, 1859–1900’, Scottish Studies Review iii (2002), 34–53Google Scholar at p. 35; Holmes, ‘Experience and understanding’, 382.

129 Nelson, Year of delusion, 67–88; Gibson, Year of grace, 16.

130 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 67.

131 Long, K. T., The revival of 1857–58: interpreting an American religious awakening, New York 1998, 50–5Google Scholar.

132 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 67.

133 Ibid. 68.

134 Wolffe, John, The expansion of Evangelicalism: the age of Wilberforce, More, Chalmers and Finney, Leicester 2006, 31, 185Google Scholar.

135 McIlwaine, ‘Physical affections’, 444.

136 Carwardine, Transatlantic revivalism, 173, 199.

137 Kent, John, Holding the fort: studies in Victorian revivalism, London 1978, 72Google Scholar; anon., ‘Revival of religion in the Church’, Covenanter ii (Apr. 1858), 85–90 at p. 88.

138 McIlwaine, ‘Physical affections’, 460.

139 BDM, 19 July 1859.

140 McIlwaine, ‘Physical affections’, 460.

141 Idem, ‘Religious aspect’, 64.

142 Nelson, Year of delusion, 161–82.

143 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 64.

144 Ibid.

145 Ibid. 68.

146 Cf. anon., Revivalism: is it of God, or of the devil?, new edn, Belfast 1859.

147 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 69.

148 Ibid. 70–1.

149 Wolffe, Expansion, 94–5.

150 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 72–3.

151 Baillie, John, The revival: or, what I saw in Ireland, London 1860, 36Google Scholar.

152 McIlwaine, ‘Religious aspect’, 74.

153 Ibid. 75–6.

154 Livingstone, ‘Darwin in Belfast’, 389; BNL, 2 Mar. 1864; 14 Aug. 1885; IEG, 22 Aug. 1885, 712.

155 BU, 14 Nov. 1863.

156 BNL, 2 Mar. 1864.

157 Ibid; cf. 18 Oct. 1875.

158 BNL, 2 Mar. 1864; 22 Nov. 1870.

159 McIlwaine, ‘Physical affections’, 453.

160 Dorrian, Patrick, Correspondence between Rev. William McIlwaine, incumbent of St George's Protestant Church, Belfast and Most Rev. Dr Dorrian, lord bishop of Down and Connor, Belfast 1865, 14–20Google Scholar.

161 Ibid. 25.

162 Ibid. 45.

163 BNL, 2 Mar. 1868.

164 Porter, J. S., The Athanasian Creed examined, Belfast 1872Google Scholar; BNL, 20, 22, 24, 25, 26, 27, 29 Apr., 1, 8 May 1872.

165 MacIlwaine, William, The Athanasian Creed defended, Belfast 1872, 23Google Scholar.

166 Ibid; cf. Van Dixhoorn, Chad, ‘New taxonomies of the Westminster Assembly (1643–52): the creedal controversy as case study’, Reformation & Renaissance Review vi (Apr. 2004), 82–106Google Scholar.

167 McIlwaine expressed his gladness at the advance of the Gospel in Rome, and his desire to see the formation of a Reformed Church of Italy: BNL, 9 Nov. 1871; 2 Nov. 1872; 30 Oct. 1873; 26 Feb. 1874; 9 Jan. 1875.

168 McIlwaine, William, Sermons in explanation and defence of church doctrine, VII: The Reformation, Dublin 1873Google Scholar; BNL, 22 Nov. 1870.

169 Yates, Nigel, Buildings, faith and worship: the liturgical arrangement of Anglican churches, 1600–1900, rev. edn, Oxford 2000, 129Google Scholar.

170 IEG, 22 Aug. 1885, 712; cf. BNL, 2 Mar. 1864; 18 May 1871; 14 Aug. 1885; Yates, Nigel, The religious condition of Ireland, 1770–1850, Oxford 2006, 286CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Livingstone, ‘Darwin in Belfast’, 389; Hempton and Hill, Evangelical Protestantism, 121–2.

171 BNL, 1 Aug. 1874.

172 Report of the resident magistrate, 26 July 1857, Chief Secretary's Office, Registered papers, National Archives of Ireland, Dublin, ms 1857/6324.

173 BNL, 14 Aug. 1885; IEG, 22 Aug. 1885, 712; cf. Witness, 17, 24 Jan. 1879; 16 Apr. 1880.

174 F. F. Moore, In Belfast by the sea, ed. Patrick Maume, UCD Press edn, Dublin 2007, 72. However, a Presbyterian critic accused McIlwaine of being ‘the Ritualistic parson of St George's’: Witness, 16 Apr. 1880.

175 S. R. McBride, ‘Bishop Mant and the Down and Connor and Dromore Church Architecture Society’, unpubl. PhD diss. Queen's University, Belfast 1996, 26.

176 Cf. Ibid. 92.

177 BNL, 2 Nov. 1872.

178 IEG, 22 Aug. 1885, 712.

179 BNL, 18 Oct. 1875.

180 William McIlwaine to Lord Dufferin, 14 Mar. 1860, PRONI, Dufferin papers, ms MIC22/9; McIlwaine, ‘Ulster revivalism’, 179.

181 For a defence of the view that revival and revivalism can be sharply distinguished see Murray, I. H., Revival and revivalism: the making and marring of American Evangelicalism, Edinburgh 1994, pp. xvii–xxiiGoogle Scholar.

182 BNL, 9 Jan. 1875.

183 Witness, 15 Jan. 1875.

184 BNL, 9 Jan. 1875.