Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T00:41:13.673Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The Ice Slide on the Glacier Du Tour

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 January 2017

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © International Glaciological Society 1951

On the afternoon of Sunday, 14 August 1949, we had climbed up the slopes of the Tête de la Jorette (1700 m.) from the hamlet of Le Tour in the Chamonix valley (Haute Savoie, France) and had a full view of the Glacier du Tour opposite. All the afternoon small blocks of ice had been falling from the lowest portion of the glacier snout. At 14.00 hr. we noticed a narrow semicircular crack running from the right-hand bank of the glacier to the centre. This is just visible in Fig. 1 (p. 492) and is shown in the sketch map in Fig. 2 below. The crack was at a point where the slope of the glacier bed increased considerably, at a height of 2200 m. and lay well in front of the more level firn basin at a height of about.2700 m. A little below the point at which we saw the crack the ice passes into an ice fall over a cliff the steepest angle of which is about 50–60°. Each time we looked at it for the next two hours the crack appeared a little wider and stood out a deep blue against the white ice. At 16.45 hr. the crack widened appreciably, and, as we watched, the whole lower mass of the glacier moved forward and gathered speed. As it passed down the increasingly steep slope to the ice fall the ice broke into colossal blocks and poured down the precipitous slope with a noise like heavy, continuous thunder (Fig. 3, p. 492). A few seconds later, as the ice reached the terminal moraine a cloud of ice particles rose and completely obscured the view for some thirty seconds during which a blast of cold air reached us from across the valley (Fig. 4, p. 493).

Fig. 1 The glacier just before the slide

Fig. 2 Sketch-plan of the Glacier du Tour after the slide. (By courtesy of the Editors of “Géographie Alpine,” Grenoble)

Fig. 3 The commencement of the slide

The Glacier du Tour ice slide (see text, p. 508 et seq.)

Fig. 4 The ice cloud a few seconds later

At the north side (left-hand side in the photographs) a true rainbow of about 45° of arc appeared. This is interesting as it shows that the ice particles, presumably of irregular shapes, must have melted, forming spherical drops, the latent heat being supplied by the warm air of the valley. This is what would be expected since small particles have a large surface to volume ratio.

Fig. 5 (p. 493) shows the glacier when movement had ceased and the cloud had dispersed. The weight of ice that fell was estimated at half a million tons,Footnote * equivalent to some forty years’ accumulation. The ice from the slide engulfed nine people who were picnicking on the moraine. This was the most disastrous slide that had occurred in the French Alps since that of the Glacier de Tête-Rousse in July 1892 which claimed 125 victims.

Photographs by R. M. Glaister, reproduced by courtesy of the Editors of “Weather”

Fig. 5 The glacier at the end of the slide

Since glacier slides on this scale must necessarily be rare occurrences it is interesting to see whether any meteorological explanation can be found in this case. I am indebted to Professor P. Veyret of the Institut de Géographie Alpine of Grenoble for the information in the following tables.

Table I shows that although the summer of 1949 was hotter than that of 1948 it was actually cooler than those of the preceding years. However, from the minimum and maximum daily temperatures of the month (Table II) it is seen that the slide occurred in the middle of a cold spell with a minimum of 1° C. at 1460 m. on the day of the slide. On the basis of the I.C.A.N. dry adiabatic lapse rate of 1.98° C./1000 ft. (6.5° C./km.) this means a minimum of −4° C. at the height of the breakaway, 2200 m. The cause of the slide is thus most probably to be found in the succession of warm days and cold nights which preceded the occurrence. This would cause repeated melting and freezing (expansion) of the ice in the glacial cracks thus driving the lower part of the glacier forward with a wedge or ratchet-like action into an unstable position.Footnote

Table I Mean temperatures (° C.) at Le Tour (1460 m.)

Table II Day temperatures (° C.) at Le Tour, August 1949

References

* Other accounts make this figure considerably higher.—Ed.

Mons. P. Guichonnet in an account of the slide in the Revue de Géographie Alpine, Grenoble (Tome 38, Fasc. 4, 1950, p. 198–201), reaches the same conclusion, but suggests that the very hot summer of 1947 may have loosened the adhesion of the glacier sole.

Another factor was suggested by Mons. Messines du Sourbier, President of the Glaciological Sub-section of the Société Hydrotechnique de France (Mémoires et Travaux, Vol. 1, 1950, p. 56–60). According to this the recent recession of the glacier had brought the snout out of a gully in which it lay firm thus damming the ice stream, on to a steep open-faced cliff above and so removing the dam.

The two accounts quoted in this note provide certain other details to which those interested are referred.—Ed.

Figure 0

Fig. 1 The glacier just before the slide

Figure 1

Fig. 2 Sketch-plan of the Glacier du Tour after the slide. (By courtesy of the Editors of “Géographie Alpine,” Grenoble)

Figure 2

Fig. 3 The commencement of the slideThe Glacier du Tour ice slide (see text, p. 508 et seq.)

Figure 3

Fig. 4 The ice cloud a few seconds later

Figure 4

Fig. 5 The glacier at the end of the slide

Photographs by R. M. Glaister, reproduced by courtesy of the Editors of “Weather”
Figure 5

Table I Mean temperatures (° C.) at Le Tour (1460 m.)

Figure 6

Table II Day temperatures (° C.) at Le Tour, August 1949