Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T09:04:27.625Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Accountability in Population Biobanking: Comparative Approaches

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2021

Mylène Deschênes  and
Clémentine Sallée
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Biobanking activities for genetic research purposes have recently undergone nothing short of a small revolution. Many biobanks have left their traditional home of a small refrigerator in a laboratory to reach the unprecedented proportion of large, sophisticated storage centers containing DNA samples from whole populations. As we turn our attention to research on complex diseases and show great interest in human genetic variation and genetic epidemiology, we need to base our research not only on the DNA of small family cohorts, but on larger sample collections, coupled with geographic location, genealogical information, and environmental and medical data. Population genetic research projects are underway around the world. Setting up such large-scale population biobanks is a challenge for any researcher. Population genetic research projects raise legal, ethical, and social issues that need to be addressed properly in order to maintain the trust of the population, an absolute requirement for the success of such research endeavour.

Type
Symposium
Information
Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics , Volume 33 , Issue 1 , Spring 2005 , pp. 40 - 53
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 2005

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

For more information on the UK Biobank project, see UK Biobank, at <http://www.ukbiobank.ac.uk> (last visited June 1, 2004).+(last+visited+June+1,+2004).>Google Scholar
Estonian Parliament, Human Gene Research Act, Estonia, December 13, 2000, entered into force on January 8, 2003, available at <http://www.legaltext.ee/text/en/X50010.htm> (last visited May 5, 2004) [hereinafter HGRA].+(last+visited+May+5,+2004)+[hereinafter+HGRA].>Google Scholar
DeCode Genetics, at <http://www.decodegenetics.com> (last visited May 25, 2003).+(last+visited+May+25,+2003).>Google Scholar
Ministry of Health and Social Security, Act on a Health Sector Database no. 139/1998, Iceland, 1998–1999, available at <http://brunnur.stjr.is/interpro/htr/htr.nsf/pages/gagnagr-ensk#allt> (last visited May 25, 2004).+(last+visited+May+25,+2004).>Google Scholar
Icelandic Supreme Court, Ragnhildur Gumundsdóttir v. The State of Iceland, No. 151/2003, available through the official website of Mannvernd, at <http://www.mannvernd.is/english/> (last visited June 1, 2004). On November 27, 2003, the Icelandic Supreme Court held that some provisions of the Act on a Health Sector Database violated Paragraph 1 of Article 71 of the Constitution (right to privacy). The court therefore concluded that the appellant's request for her father's health information not to be included in the database should be granted.+(last+visited+June+1,+2004).+On+November+27,+2003,+the+Icelandic+Supreme+Court+held+that+some+provisions+of+the+Act+on+a+Health+Sector+Database+violated+Paragraph+1+of+Article+71+of+the+Constitution+(right+to+privacy).+The+court+therefore+concluded+that+the+appellant's+request+for+her+father's+health+information+not+to+be+included+in+the+database+should+be+granted.>Google Scholar
Ministry of Health and Social Security, Act on Biobanks no. 110/2000, Iceland, May 13, 2000, available at <http://brunnur.stjr.is/interpro/htr/htr.nsf/printview/Act-biobanks> (last visited May 25, 2004).+(last+visited+May+25,+2004).>Google Scholar
See “Partners” on the DeCode Genetics website, at <http://www.decodegenetics.com> (last visited June 19, 2004).+(last+visited+June+19,+2004).>Google Scholar
To whom do you confide the delicate task of approving and monitoring a population research project? To a designated local REB, a national REB, or multiple REBs?Google Scholar
See the information about public consultation of the website of the UK biobank, at <http://www.ukbiobank.ac.uk/consultation.htm> (last visited June 1, 2004).+(last+visited+June+1,+2004).>Google Scholar
See UK Biobank Ethics and Governance Framework, III B) “External Governance,” at 25, available at <http://www.ukbiobank.ac.uk/documents/egf-comment-version.doc> (last visited June 1, 2004).+(last+visited+June+1,+2004).>Google Scholar
Network of Applied Genetic Medicine, Statement of Principles on the Ethical Conduct of Human Genetic Research Involving Populations, Montreal (QC), 2003, at <http://www.rmga.qc.ca/en/index.htm> (last visited June 1, 2004).+(last+visited+June+1,+2004).>Google Scholar
Act on Biobank no. 110/2000h, Art. 4.Google Scholar
Id. at Art. 6.Google Scholar
Estonian Genome Project, at <http://www.geenivaramu.ee/index.php?lang=eng&sub=78> (last visited July 5, 2004).+(last+visited+July+5,+2004).>Google Scholar
HGRA, Para. 29; EGP Internet brochure, EGP, at <http://www.geenivaramu.ee/mp3/trykisENG.pdf.> (last visited June 14, 2003).+(last+visited+June+14,+2003).>Google Scholar
See the Act on Biobanks, e.g. mentioned under article 4 and 12.Google Scholar
HGRA, Para. 24(2) and 29(1).Google Scholar
Act on Biobanks, Art. 12 in fine.Google Scholar
HGRA, Para, 5 and 18(3).Google Scholar
HGRA, Para. 18(3).Google Scholar
The Estonian Genome Project, “Genome Project Ends Cooperation with Current Financier,” News and Articles (December 27, 2004), at <http://www.geenivaramu.ee/index.php?show=uudised&id=172&lang=eng> (last visited February 15, 2005).+(last+visited+February+15,+2005).>Google Scholar
See, e.g., The Estonian Genome Project, “The Estonian Genome Project Foundation and EGeen Agreed upon Year 2004 Financing,” News and Articles (April 5, 2004), at <http://www.geenivaramu.ee/index.php?show=uudised&id=156&lang=eng> (last visited February 15, 2005).+(last+visited+February+15,+2005).>Google Scholar
The Estonian Genome Project, “Data Collection for the Estonian Genome Project has Spread to Twelve Counties,” News and Articles (September 10, 2003), at <http://www.geenivaramu.ee/index.php?lang=eng&show=uudised&id=131> (last visited June 18, 2004).+(last+visited+June+18,+2004).>Google Scholar
It is worth mentioning that the Scottish Executive has agreed to invest £500,000 in the project and that the project will ultimately be self-financed. See, The UK Biobank, a Study of Genes, Environment and Health, at <http://www.ukbiobank.ac.uk/Documents/long%20briefing%20paper.pdf>, at 2 (last visited June 18, 2004).,+at+2+(last+visited+June+18,+2004).>Google Scholar
The United Kingdom Parliament, Select Committee on Science and Technology, Fourth Report, Human Genetic Databases: Challenges and Opportunities, (March 20, 2001), at <http://www.parliament.the-stationery-office.co.uk/pa/ld200001/ldselect/ldsctech/57/5703.htm> (last visited March 3, 2005), at Chapter 1: Summary and Recommendations.+(last+visited+March+3,+2005),+at+Chapter+1:+Summary+and+Recommendations.>Google Scholar
See, notably, the summary of comments on the UK Biobank Ethics and Governance Framework. Many respondents (individuals or organization) outlined that in order for the UK Biobank project to receive public support and trust, the powers of the Ethics and Governance Council should include the right to veto certain uses, and its decisions on profits and its redistribution should have some weight. UK Biobank, UK Biobank Ethics and Governance Framework: Summary of Comments on Version 1.0, (May 2004), at <http://www.ukbiobank.ac.uk/Documents/Biobank%20EGF%20Report%20Summary%20of%20Comments.pdf> (last visited February 15, 2005).+(last+visited+February+15,+2005).>Google Scholar
The Wellcome Trust, the Medical Research Council, the Department of Health, UK Biobank Ethics and Governance Framework, For Comment (September 24, 2003), at <http://www.ukbiobank.ac.uk/documents/egf-comment-version.doc> (last visited February 15, 2005) at 23.+(last+visited+February+15,+2005)+at+23.>Google Scholar
Act on a Health Sector Database, supra note 4.Google Scholar
Id. at Art.1.Google Scholar
Icelandic Supreme Court, Ragnhildur Gumundsdóttir v. The State of Iceland, No. 151/2003, available through the official website of Mannvernd, at <http://www.mannvernd.is/english/> (last visited June 1, 2004).+(last+visited+June+1,+2004).>Google Scholar
Act on Biobanks, supra note 6.Google Scholar
Id. at Art. 14.Google Scholar
DeCode Genetics, “DeCode Genetics, Inc. Code of Business Conduct and Ethics,” available through DeCode Genetics, at <http://www.decodegenetics.com> (last visited June 5, 2004).+(last+visited+June+5,+2004).>Google Scholar
For instance, the Tongan project, a South-Pacific population genetic research project developed by two private companies was mainly opposed and finally abandoned for privacy and confidentiality issues. See, e.g., Burton, B., “Opposition Stalls Genetic Profiling Plan for Tonga,” Inter Press Service (February 18, 2002), at <http://www.hi.si/∼elsagen/tonga.html> (last visited February 29, 2005); see also Barkham, P., “Faraway Tonga Cashes in on its Gene Pool Secrets,” Guardian, November 23, 2000; Griggs, K., “Tonga Sells its Old, New Genes” Wired, November 27, 2000 at <http://www.wired.com/news/medtech/0,1286,40354,00.htm> (last visited February 15, 2005).Google Scholar
Estonian Parliament, Personal Data Protection Act (February 12, 2003, entered into force on October 1, 2003), at <http://www.legaltext.ee/text/en/X70030.htm> (last visited February 15, 2005).+(last+visited+February+15,+2005).>Google Scholar
See Hgra, , Para. 7.Google Scholar
See Hgra, , Para. 31, which amends Para. 1281 of the Criminal Code.Google Scholar
See Estonian Parliament, Data Protection Act, February 12, 2003, (RT I, 2003, 26, 158), at <http://www.legaltext.ee/text/en/X70030.htm> (last visited February 15, 2005) chapters 8 and 9. Furthermore, in the event of wrongful disclosure of a subject's identification, the participant can, by virtue of paragraphs 10(2) and 21 of the HGRA, require that his or her biological material and data be destroyed.+(last+visited+February+15,+2005)+chapters+8+and+9.+Furthermore,+in+the+event+of+wrongful+disclosure+of+a+subject's+identification,+the+participant+can,+by+virtue+of+paragraphs+10(2)+and+21+of+the+HGRA,+require+that+his+or+her+biological+material+and+data+be+destroyed.>Google Scholar
Iceland Minister of Health and Social Security, Act on the Protection of Individuals with Regard to the Processing of Personal Data, No 77/2000, Iceland (May, 2000), at <http://www.mannvernd.is/english/laws/Act.DataProtection.html> (last visited February 15, 2005).+(last+visited+February+15,+2005).>Google Scholar
Id. at Art. 35, Para. 4, Art. 37, Para. 2 and 4, and Arts. 38 to 43.Google Scholar
Id. at Arts, 11 and 12.Google Scholar
Act on Biobanks, Arts. 14 and 15. See also Arts. 41 to 43 of the Act on the Protection of Individuals with regard to the Processing of Personal Data. According to these provisions, violation of the terms of the Act can lead to daily penalties, criminal sanctions or compensation of the individual subject.Google Scholar
Ministry of Health and Social Security, Operating Licence for the Creation and Operation of a Health Sector Database (January 2000), at <http://brunnur.stjr.is/interpro/htr/htr.nsf/pages/operat-lic> (last visited February 15, 2005), at Art. 6(6). Ministry of Health and Social Security, Government Regulation on a Health Sector Database no. 32/2000 (2000), at <http://personuvernd.is/tolvunefnd.nsf/pages/185B14872B3F7F19002569180037B462> (last visited February 15, 2005).+(last+visited+February+15,+2005),+at+Art.+6(6).+Ministry+of+Health+and+Social+Security,+Government+Regulation+on+a+Health+Sector+Database+no.+32/2000+(2000),+at++(last+visited+February+15,+2005).>Google Scholar
Id. at 6.7.Google Scholar
Quebec Government, An Act Respecting Access to Documents held by Public Bodies and the Protection of Personal Information, R.S.Q., Chapter A-2.1, at <http://www.canlii.org/qc/laws/sta/a-2.1/20040323/whole.html> (last visited June 19, 2004) art.125; Quebec Government, Health Insurance Act, R.S.Q., Chapter A-29, at <http://www.canlii.org/qc/laws/sta/a-29/20040323/whole.html> at Art. 63 (last visited June 19, 2004). The RAMQ keeps on file all the medical services that are paid for by the state for all Quebec citizens.+(last+visited+June+19,+2004)+art.125;+Quebec+Government,+Health+Insurance+Act,+R.S.Q.,+Chapter+A-29,+at++at+Art.+63+(last+visited+June+19,+2004).+The+RAMQ+keeps+on+file+all+the+medical+services+that+are+paid+for+by+the+state+for+all+Quebec+citizens.>Google Scholar
United Kingdom Parliament, Data Protection Act 1998 c.29, (1998), at <http://www.legislation.hmso.gov.uk/acts/acts1998/19980029.htm> (last visited February 15, 2005). Chapter 29, Part VI, Arts. 51 to 55.+(last+visited+February+15,+2005).+Chapter+29,+Part+VI,+Arts.+51+to+55.>Google Scholar
World Medical Association, Declaration on Ethical Considerations Regarding Health Databases (October 6, 2002), at <http://www.wma.net/e/policy/d1.htm> (last visited February 15, 2005) §§ 30–31.+(last+visited+February+15,+2005)+§§+30–31.>Google Scholar
It is to be noted that in the U.K., the Human Genetics Commission suggested that unlawful disclosure be criminalized. Human Genetics Commission, Inside Information: Balancing the Interests in the Use of Personal Genetic Data, May 2002, at 105.Google Scholar
The reproduction of this diagram was authorized by the UK Biobank Management Board, diagram available on UK Biobank website.Google Scholar
Available on UK Biobank website, at <http://www.biobank.ac.uk/documents/managements-structure.ppt> (last visited July 5, 2004).+(last+visited+July+5,+2004).>Google Scholar
The reproduction of this diagram was authorized by Doctor Claude Laberge, Diagram available on Cartagène website, at <http://www.cartagene.qc.ca/img/CaG.UPDATE.NOV.jpg> (last visited July 7, 2004).+(last+visited+July+7,+2004).>Google Scholar