Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T18:24:36.310Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

New Light on the Historia Augusta

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 October 2020

Justin Stover
Justin Stover*
Affiliation:
University of Edinburgh
*
justin.stover@ed.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper presents a new manuscript of part of the Historia Augusta from Erlangen, which vindicates a more than century-old hypothesis by E. Patzig: that the 1489 Venice edition of the work is textually valuable. On this basis, and building on the recent work of R. Modonutti, I present five new passages that are not printed in modern editions of the HA, six lacunose passages restored, and propose that the lost Murbach manuscript is the source. Armed with this new evidence, I re-examine the question of the great lacuna between the Lives of Maximus and Balbinus and the Lives of the Two Valerians, showing that it is a codicological — and not authorial — feature.

Keywords

Historia Augustamanuscriptstextual criticismeditingLate Antiquity
Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Roman Studies , Volume 110 , November 2020 , pp. 167 - 198
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2020. Published by The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

I would like to thank George Woudhuysen and Gavin Kelly for many hours of conversation on the HA and insights at many points. In addition, participants in the Historia Augusta colloquium at Edinburgh in May 2019 — especially, besides the above, Rino Modonutti, Michael Allen and Michael Kulikowski — provided very helpful discussion and critique, as did the participants in the transmissions panel at the 11th Celtic Conference in Classics in St Andrews in 2018. It was a suggestion of Michael Reeve that first put me on the track of Colonna and the Mare historiarum. I am also very grateful to Lukas Dorfbauer, who provided insightful critique and generously provided an advance copy of his forthcoming publication. The Editor and JRS readers also offered substantial assistance. This is not to imply any of them endorse the views advanced here.

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Baker, R. 2014: ‘A study of a late antique corpus of biographies (Historia Augusta)’, unpublished D.Phil. thesis, University of Oxford.Google Scholar
Ballou, S. H. 1914: The Manuscript Tradition of the Historia Augusta, Leipzig.Google Scholar
Barnes, T. D. 1978: The Sources of the Historia Augusta, Collection Latomus 155, Brussels.Google Scholar
Barrett, G. and Woudhuysen, G. 2016a: ‘Assembling the Austrasian letters at Trier and Lorsch’, Early Medieval Europe 24, 3–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barrett, G. and Woudhuysen, G. 2016b: ‘Remigius and the “important news” of Clovis rewritten’, Antiquité tardive 24, 471–500.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bergman, J. 1898: De P. Herennio Dexippo et Gothorum illa in Atticam incursione quid scriptores et inscriptiones doceant, Stockholm.Google Scholar
Bernhardy, G. 1847: De Scriptoribus Historiae Augustae, Halle.Google Scholar
Bertrand, C., Desbordes, O. and Callu, J.-P. 1984–1985: ‘L’Histoire Auguste et l'historiographie médiévale’, Revue d'Histoire des Textes 14–15, 97–130.Google Scholar
Birley, A. R. 1967: ‘The Augustan History’ in Dorey, T. A. (ed.), Latin Biography, London, 113–28.Google Scholar
Birley, A. R. 1978: ‘The lacuna in the Historia Augusta,’ in Straub, J. (ed.), Bonner Historia-Augusta-Colloquium 1975/1976 , Bonn, 55–62.Google Scholar
Bischoff, B. 2004: Katalog der festländischen Handschriften des neunten Jahrhunderts (mit Ausnahme der wisigotischen). Teil 2: Laon–Paderborn, Wiesbaden.Google Scholar
Bleckmann, B. and Brandt, H. (eds) 2017: Historiae Augustae Colloquium Dusseldorpiense, Bari.Google Scholar
Boyer, B. B. 1948: ‘Insular contribution to medieval literary tradition on the Continent (concluded)’, Classical Philology 43, 31–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burgersdijk, D. 2010: ‘Style and structure of the Historia Augusta’, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Amsterdam.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Callu, J.-P. and Desbordes, O. 1989: ‘Le “Quattrocento” de l’Histoire Auguste’, Revue d'Histoire des Textes 19, 253–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Callu, J.-P. (ed.) 1992: Histoire Auguste, Vol. 1, Part I. Introduction générale, vies d'Hadrien, Aelius, Antonin, Paris.Google Scholar
Cameron, A. 2011: ‘Antiquus Error/novus error: the HA, Nicomachus Flavianus and the “pagan resistance”’, Journal of Roman Archaeology 24, 835–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Casaubon, I. 1603: Historiae Avgvstae Scriptores Sex. Aelius Spartianus, Iulius Capitolinus, Aelius Lampridius, Vulcatius Gallicanus, Trebellius Pollio, & Flauius Vopiscus. Isaacvs Casavbonvs ex vett. libris recensuit: idemque librum adiecit emendationvm ac notarvm, Paris.Google Scholar
Chastagnol, A. 1964: ‘Le problème de l'histoire Auguste. État de la question’, in Straub, J. (ed.), Bonner Historia-Augusta-Colloquium 1963, Bonn, 43–71.Google Scholar
Cornell, T. J. (ed.) 2013: The Fragments of the Roman Historians, 3 vols, Oxford.Google Scholar
Cortesi, M. 1984: ‘Una pagina di umanesimo in Eichstätt’, Quellen und Forschungen aus italienischen Archiven und Bibliotheken 64, 227–60.Google Scholar
Cortesi, M. 1986: ‘Scritti di Lorenzo Valla tra Veneto e Germania’, in Besoni, O. and Regoliosi, M. (eds), Lorenzo Valla e l'Umanesimo italiano. Atti del convegno internazionale di studi umanistici (Parma, 18–19 ottobre, 1984), 1986, 365–98.Google Scholar
Cortesi, M. 1994: ‘Un nuovo testimone delle Declamationes minores pseudoquintilianee’, in Bruni, S. (ed.), Immagini del Medioevo. Saggi di cultura mediolatina, Spoleto, 81–95.Google Scholar
de Beer, S. T. M. 2007: ‘Poetry and patronage: literary strategies in the poems of Giannantonio Campano’, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Amsterdam.Google Scholar
de Ste Croix, G. E. M. 1981: The Class Struggle in the Ancient Greek World: From the Archaic Age to the Arab Conquests, London.Google Scholar
Den Boeft, J., Drijvers, J. W., den Hengst, D. and Teitler, H. C. 2013: Philological and Historical Commentary on Ammianus Marcellinus XXIX, Leiden.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
den Hengst, D. 1981: The Prefaces in the Historia Augusta, Amsterdam.Google Scholar
Dendorfer, J. (ed.) 2015: Reform und früher Humanismus in Eichstätt. Bischof Johann von Eych (1445–1464), Regensburg.Google Scholar
Dessau, H. 1889: ‘Über Zeit und Persönlichkeit der Scriptores Historiae Augustae’, Hermes 24, 337–92.Google Scholar
Di Bernardo, F. 1975: Un vescovo umanista alla Corte Pontificia. Giannantonio Campano (1429–1477), Rome.Google Scholar
Dorfbauer, L. 2020: ‘Das Nürnberger Fragment und die karolingische Überlieferung der “Historia Augusta”’, Hermes 148, 345–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fischer, H. 1936: Die lateinischen Papierhandschriften der Universitätsbibliothek Erlangen, Erlangen (repr. Wiesbaden, 1971).Google Scholar
Fowden, G. 1998: ‘City and mountain in late Roman Attica’, Journal of Hellenic Studies 108, 48–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hohl, E. 1913: ‘Beitrage zur Textgeschichte der Historia Augusta’, Klio 13, 258–88, 387–423.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hirstein, J. 1998: ‘L'histoire du texte de l'Histoire auguste. Egnazio et la Vita Marci’, in Bonamente, G., Heim, F. and Callu, J.-P. (eds), Historia Augusta Colloquium Argentoratense, Bari, 167–89.Google Scholar
Kelly, G. 2015: Review of J. den Boeft, J. W. Drijvers. D. den Hengst and H. C. Teitler, Philological and Historical Commentary on Ammianus Marcellinus XXIX, Leiden, 2014 in Journal of Roman Studies 105, 457–8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kelly, G. and Stover, J. 2016: ‘The Hersfeldensis and the Fuldensis of Ammianus Marcellinus: a reconsideration’, Cambridge Classical Journal 62: 108–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Klein, I. 1882: ‘Kritische Bemerkungen zu den Script. Hist. Aug.’, Rheinisches Museum für Philologie 37, 274–91.Google Scholar
Krebs, C. B. 2011: A Most Dangerous Book: Tacitus’ Germania from the Roman Empire to the Third Reich, New York.Google Scholar
Leyser, H. 1841: ‘Ein Handschriftenkatalog aus dem Ende des 12. Jahrhunderts’, Serapeum 2, 331–4.Google Scholar
Luck, G. 1972: ‘The textual history of Juvenal and the Oxford lines’, Harvard Studies in Classical Philology 76, 217–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mallan, C. and Davenport, C. 2015: ‘Dexippus and the Gothic invasions: interpreting the new Vienna fragment (Codex Vindobonensis Hist. gr. 73, ff. 192v–193r)’, Journal of Roman Studies 105, 203–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marshall, P. K. 1983: ‘Scriptores Historiae Augustae’, in Reynolds 1983, 354–6.Google Scholar
Martin, G. 2017: ‘Die Struktur von Dexipps Skythika und die Historia Augusta’, in Bleckmann and Brandt 2017, 97–114.Google Scholar
Martin, G. and Grusková, J. 2014a: ‘“Scythica Vindobonensia” by Dexippus (?): new fragments on Decius’ Gothic Wars’, Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies 54, 728–54.Google Scholar
Martin, G. and Grusková, J. 2014b: ‘“Dexippus Vindobonensis (?)”. Ein neues Handschriftenfragment zum sog. Herulereinfall der Jahre 267/268’, Wiener Studien 127, 101–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Martin, G. and Grusková, J. 2014c: ‘Ein neues Textstück aus den “Scythica Vindobonensia” zu den Ereignissen nach der Eroberung von Philippopolis’, Tyche 29, 29–43.Google Scholar
Märtl, C. 2015: ‘Bischof Johann von Eych und Eneas Silvius Piccolomini’, in Dendorfer 2015, 93–113.Google Scholar
Mayer, M. 2016: ‘Génesis y evolución del texto de la Historia Augusta. Consideraciones a propósito de la Vita Pescenii Nigri’, in Velaza, J. (ed.), From the Protohistory to the History of the Text, Frankfurt am Main, 313–32.Google Scholar
Mecella, L. 2006: ‘Le città dell'Oriente romano e le invasioni barbariche del III secolo d.C.’, Mediterraneo antico 9, 241–66.Google Scholar
Mencken, J. B. (ed.) 1707: Jo. Antonii Campani, Episcopi Aprutini, Epistolae et Poemata, una cum Vita Auctoris, Leipzig.Google Scholar
Migliorati, G. 2013: Problemi di storia militare del secolo III d.C., Milan.Google Scholar
Millar, F. 1969: ‘P. Herennius Dexippus: the Greek world and the third-century invasions’, Journal of Roman Studies 59, 12–29 (= F. Millar, Rome, the Greek World and the East, Vol. 2: Government, Society and Culture in the Roman Empire, eds Cotton, H. M. and Rogers, G. M., Chapel Hill, NC, 265–97).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Modonutti, R. 2013: Fra Giovanni Colonna e la storia antica da Adriano ai Severi, Padua.Google Scholar
Modonutti, R. 2016: ‘I consiliarii di Severo Alessandro e la tradizione dell'Historia Augusta nel Trecento’, Segno e testo 14, 381–410.Google Scholar
Mommsen, Th. 1890: ‘Die Scriptores Historiae Augustae’, Hermes 25, 228–92.Google Scholar
Nobili, M. 2014: ‘Due note critiche alla Vita Commodi nella Historia Augusta’, in Piras, G. (ed.), Labor in studiis. Scritti di filologia in onore di Piergiorgio Parroni, Rome, 193–9.Google Scholar
Patzig, E. 1904: ‘Die römischen Quellen des salmasischen Johannes Antiochenus I. Eutrop und Ammian. Mit einem Anhange zur Textkritik der Scriptores Hist. Aug.’, Byzantinische Zeitschrift 13, 13–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Peachin, M. 1990: Roman Imperial Titulature and Chronology, A.D. 235–284, Amsterdam.Google Scholar
Pecere, O. 1995: ‘Il codice palatino dell’Historia Augusta come “edizione” continua’, in Pecere, O. and Reeve, M. D. (eds), Formative Stages of Classical Traditions: Latin Texts from Antiquity to the Renaissance. Proceedings of a Conference held at Erice, 11–22 October 1993, Spoleto, 323–69.Google Scholar
Peter, H. 1908: ‘Zur Textesgeschichte der Scriptores historiae Augustae’, Archiv für lateinische Lexikographie und Grammatik 15, 23–9.Google Scholar
Reynolds, L. D. (ed.) 1983: Texts and Transmission: A Survey of the Latin Classics, Oxford.Google Scholar
Rohrbacher, D. 2016: The Play of Allusion in the Historia Augusta, Madison, WI.Google Scholar
Savino, E. 2017: Richerche sull'Historia Augusta, Naples.Google Scholar
Sheffler, D. L. 2008: Schools and Schooling in Late Medieval Germany: Regensburg, 1250–1500, Leiden.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sosin, J. 2000: ‘Ausonius’ Juvenal and the Winstedt fragment’, Classical Philology 95, 199–206.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stover, J. 2017a: ‘Space as paratext: scribal practice in the medieval edition of Ammianus Marcellinus’, in Teeuwen, M. and van Renswoude, I. (eds), The Annotated Book in the Early Middle Ages: Practices of Reading and Writing, Turnhout, 305–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stover, J. 2017b: ‘Epitome de Caesaribus 1.24 and Ovid's exile’, Classical Philology 112, 267–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stover, J., 2020: ‘The Murbach manuscript of the Historia Augusta’, Exemplaria Classica (forthcoming).Google Scholar
Stover, J. and Woudhuysen, G. 2017: ‘Giovanni de Matociis and the Codex Oratorianus of the De uiris illustribus urbis Romae’, Exemplaria Classica 21, 125–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stover, J. and Woudhuysen, G., 2020: ‘Aurelius Victor and the ending of Sallust's Jugurtha’, Hermathena 199, 93–134.Google Scholar
Stover, J. and Woudhuysen, G., forthcoming: The Lost Historia of Sextus Aurelius Victor, Edinburgh (forthcoming 2021).Google Scholar
Suckale-Redlefsen, G. 2004: Die Handschriften des 8. bis 11. Jahrhunderts der Staatsbibliothek Bamberg. T. 1. Texte, Wiesbaden.Google Scholar
Syme, R. 1970: ‘Three jurists’, in Straub, J. (ed.), Bonner Historia-Augusta-Colloquium 1968–1969, Bonn, 309–323 (= R. Syme, Roman Papers, Vol. 2, ed. E. Badian, Oxford, 1979, 790–804).Google Scholar
Thomson, M. 2012: Studies in the Historia Augusta, Collection Latomus 337, Brussels.Google Scholar
Wagendorfer, M. 2015: ‘Johann von Eych und sein Umfeld an der Universität Wien nebst einigen Bemerkungen zur Biographie des Johannes Mendel aus Amberg’, in Dendorfer 2015: 47–64.Google Scholar
Winterbottom, M., Rouse, R. H. and Reeve, M. D. 1983: ‘Cicero, rhetorical works’, in Reynolds 1983: 98–112.Google Scholar
Zahn, P. 1973: ‘Hrabanus Maurus, Super Matthaeum. Zu einem neuen Fragmentfund in der Stadtbibliothek Nürnberg’, Bibliotheksforum Bayern 1, 120–5.Google Scholar
Zecchini, G. 2017: ‘Il nuovo Dexippo e l'Historia Augusta’, in Bleckmann and Brandt 2017, 189–96.Google Scholar