19 Consistency of self-reported sport-related concussion history

Abstract

Objective:

An accurate accounting of prior sport-related concussion (SRC) is critical to optimizing the clinical care of athletes with SRC. Yet, obtaining such a history via medical records or lifetime monitoring is often not feasible necessitating the use of self-report histories. The primary objective of the current project is to determine the degree to which athletes consistently report their SRC history on serial assessments throughout their collegiate athletic career.

Participants and Methods:

Data were obtained from the NCAA-DoD CARE Consortium and included 1621 athletes (914 male) from a single Division 1 university who participated in athletics during the 2014-2017 academic years. From this initial cohort, 752 athletes completed a second-year assessment and 332 completed a third-year assessment. Yearly assessments included a brief self-report survey that queried SRC history of the previous year. Consistency of self-reported SRC history was defined as reporting the same number of SRC on subsequent yearly evaluation as had been reported the previous year.

For every year of participation, the number of SRC reported on the baseline exam (Reported) and the number of SRC recorded by athletes and medical staff during the ensuing season (Recorded) were tabulated. In a subsequent year, the expected number of SRC (Expected) was computed as the sum of Reported and Recorded. For participation years in which Expected could be computed, the reporting deviation (RepDev) gives the difference between the number of SRCs which were expected to be reported at a baseline exam based on previous participation year data and the number of SRCs which was actually reported by the athlete or medical record during the baseline exam. The reporting deviation was computed only for those SRC that occurred while the participant was enrolled in the current study (RepDevSO). Oneway intraclass correlations (ICC) were computed between the expected and reported numbers of SRC.

Results:

341 athletes had a history of at least one SRC and 206 of those (60.4%) had a RepDev of 0. The overall ICC for RepDev was 0.761 (95% CI 0.73-0.79). The presence of depression (ICC 0.87, 95% CI 0.79-0.92) and loss of consciousness (ICC 0.80, 95% CI 0.720.86) were associated with higher ICCs compared to athletes without these variables. Female athletes demonstrated higher self-report consistency (ICC 0.82, 95% CI 0.79-0.85) compared to male athletes (ICC 0.72, 95% CI 0.68-0.76). Differences in the classification of RepDev according to sex and sport were found to be significant (x2=77.6, df=56, p=0.03). The sports with the highest consistency were Women’s Tennis, Men’s Diving, and Men’s Tennis with 100% consistency between academic years. Sports with the lowest consistency were Women’s Gymnastics (69%), Men’s Lacrosse (70%), and Football (72%). 96 athletes had at least one study-only SRC in the previous year and 69 of those (71.9%) had a RepDevSO of 0 (ICC 0.673, 95% CI 0.64-0.71).

Conclusions:

Approximately 40% of athletes do not consistently report their SRC history, potentially further complicating the clinical management of SRC. These findings encourage clinicians to be aware of factors which could influence the reliability of self-reported SRC history.