Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T15:15:11.880Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The Euromaidan and the crisis of Russian nationalism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 November 2018

Robert Horvath*
Affiliation:
Department of Politics and Philosophy, La Trobe University, Melbourne, Australia

Extract

This article examines the reverberations in Russia of the Euromaidan protests and the fall of the Yanukovych regime in Ukraine. It shows how the events in Kyiv provoked a major crisis in the Russian nationalist movement, which was riven by vituperative denunciations, the ostracism of prominent activists, the breakdown of friendships, the rupture of alliances, and schisms within organizations. Focusing on pro-Kremlin nationalists and several tendencies of opposition nationalists, it argues that this turmoil was shaped by three factors. First, the Euromaidan provoked clashes between pro-Kremlin nationalists, who became standard-bearers of official anti-Euromaidan propaganda, and anti-Putin nationalists, who extolled the Euromaidan as a model for a revolution in Russia itself. Second, the events in Ukraine provoked ideological contention around issues of particular sensitivity to Russian nationalists, such as the competing claims of imperialism and ethnic homogeneity, and of Soviet nationalism and Russian traditionalism. And third, many nationalists were unprepared for the pace of events, which shifted rapidly from an anti-oligarchic uprising in Kyiv to a push for the self-determination of ethnic Russians in Crimean and southeast Ukraine. As a result, they were left in the uncomfortable position of appearing to collaborate with the oppressors of their compatriots.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © 2015 Association for the Study of Nationalities 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alekseeva, Anna. 2014. “Delo davno minuvshikh dnei.” Novye izvestiia, March 18: 5.Google Scholar
Artemov, Igor. 2014a. “Pozitsiia RONS po sobytiiam na Ukraine.” January 31. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r7IRFrsgJbM.Google Scholar
Artemov, Igor. 2014b. “Igor’ Artemov (RONS) o situatsii na Ukraine.” February 26. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bBMhvEBSn8.Google Scholar
Averin, Aleksandr. 2014. “Titushka, khule.” February 21. http://alaverin.livejournal.com/595594.html#comments.Google Scholar
Baranovskii, Aleksei. 2014. “‘Dushu i tilo mi polozhim za nashu svobodu': Vozmozhen li Maidan v Rossii?” Delo, February 25. http://delo.ua/opinions/dushu-j-tilo-mi-polozhim-za-nashu-svobodu-vozmozhen-li-majdan-v-228270/.Google Scholar
Basmanov, Vladimir. 2014a. “Russkie natsionalisty posetili Maidan. Reportazh.” May 14. http://basmanov.livejournal.com/2466378.html.Google Scholar
Basmanov, Vladimir. 2014b. “Izmenilos’ li moe otnoshenie k Maidanu?” March 6. http://basmanov.livejournal.com/2486400.html.Google Scholar
Basmanov, Vladimir. 2014c. “O roste territorii kontslageria.” March 3. http://basmanov.livejournal.com/2485600.html.Google Scholar
Basmanov, Vladimir. 2014d. “Esli zavtra voina. Est’ veshchi, kotorye nado oboznachit’ iasno i chetko.” March 13. http://basmanov.livejournal.com/2490068.html.Google Scholar
Beness, Aijo. 2014c. “Voz'mem Krym, a zatem vostok i poidem na Kyiv.” March 14. http://ura.ru/content/svrd/14–03-2014/articles/1036261563.html.Google Scholar
Beness, Aijo. 2014d. “Untitled Facebook Entry.” March 22. https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=10202729880121568&stream_ref=10.Google Scholar
Bobrov, Dmitrii. 2014. “Pobeda i traur.” March 31. http://ns-dima-schultz.livejournal.com/140825.html.Google Scholar
Borodianskii, Georgii. 2014. “Zdes’ vam ne Donbass.” Novaia gazeta, August 6: 5. http://www.novayagazeta.ru/society/64731.html.Google Scholar
Demushkin, Dmitrii. 2014a. “Demushkin mysli pro Ukrainu, revoliutsiiu i russkikh.” February 26. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rPCTiM-HInk#t=30.Google Scholar
Demushkin, Dmitrii. 2014b. “26 iiunia 2014 FSB provelo operatsiiu v otnoshenii EPO Russkie v regionakh.” June 26. http://vk.com/wall20667769_113981.Google Scholar
Diatlovskaia, Ekaterina. 2014. “‘Strategiia-31’ vpervye oboshlas’ bez zaderzhanii.” Novye izvestiia, June 2: 2.Google Scholar
Rossiia, Drugaia. 2014a. “'Drugaia Rossiia’ ob”iavliaet o sozdanii Obshchestva liubitelei krymskogo turizma.” February 25. http://drugros.ru/news/3968.html.Google Scholar
Rossiia, Drugaia. 2014b. “My za russkikh i protiv ‘nemtsev'.” February 21. http://drugros.ru/statements/3963.html.Google Scholar
Dugin, Aleksandr. 2014a. “Natsizm made in USA.” Argumenty i fakty, February 12: 15.Google Scholar
Dugin, Aleksandr. 2014b. “Segodnia my uvideli nastoiashchego Putina, kotoryi prishel k russkoi istine.” April 17. http://www.nakanune.ru/articles/18908/.Google Scholar
Evstifeev, Dmitrii. 2014. “Nationalist mog stat’ zhertvoi mesti.” Izvestiia, December 18: 8.Google Scholar
Frolov, Petr. 2014. “Chto predlozhil Rogozin natsionalistam, chto prosil u nikh, i pochemu natsionalizma na segodnia bol'she net.” March 18. http://petrfrolov1.livejournal.com/4744.html.Google Scholar
Garina, Marina. 2005. “Natsionalistov ostavili bez futbola.” Izvestiia, December 12: 3.Google Scholar
Grishin, Aleksandr. 2014. “Politology, filosof Aleksandr DUGIN: Eto velikaia voina kontinentov.” Komsomol'skaia Pravda, February 21: 6.Google Scholar
Horvath, Robert. 2012. Putin's “Preventive Counter-Revolution”: Post-Soviet Authoritarianism and the Spectre of Velvet Revolution. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Klub, Izborskii. 2014. “Spasti Ukrainu! Memorandum ekspertov Izborskogo kluba.” February 13. http://ruskline.ru/opp/2014/02/18/spasti_ukrainu_memorandum_ekspertov_izborskogo_kluba/.Google Scholar
Katorzhnov, Dmitrii. 2014. “Liberaly ne khotiat idti na soglasovannuiu aktsiiu.” Moskovskii komsomolets. May 22: 2.Google Scholar
Kholmogorov, Egor. 2012. “Razbiraia Putina.” February 7. http://holmogor.livejournal.com/2012/02/07/.Google Scholar
Kholmogorov, Egor. 2013a. “Poliaki i litovtsy razmechtalis’ o novykh kholopakh – ukraintsakh.” Komsomol'skaia Pravda. December 2. http://www.kp.ru/daily/26166.5/3053364.Google Scholar
Kholmogorov, Egor. 2013b. “Untitled Blog Entry.” December 2. http://holmogor.livejournal.com/6022219.html.Google Scholar
Egor, Kholmogorov. 2013c. “Besprimesnaia ‘natsional-demokratiia'.” December 9. http://holmogor.livejournal.com/6036686.html.Google Scholar
Kholmogorov, Egor. 2014a. “Avatary russkogo natsionalizma.” Izvestiia, February 27. http://izvestia.ru/news/566689.Google Scholar
Kholmogorov, Egor. 2014b. “Slovo o pogibeli grada Kyiva.” February 20. http://vz.ru/columns/2014/2/20/673584.html.Google Scholar
Kholmogorov, Egor. 2014c. “Bitva orkov s goblinami.” Komsomol'skaia pravda. January 23. http://www.kp.ru/daily/26182.4/3073668/.Google Scholar
Kholmogorov, Egor. 2014d. “Sobiranie zemel’ russkikh.” Izvestiia, March 7: 1.Google Scholar
Kholmogorov, Egor. 2014e. “Novosti tak nazyvaemogo ‘natsionalizma.'” January 26. http://holmogor.livejournal.com/6120066.html.Google Scholar
Kholmogorov, Egor. 2014f. “Krymskie tezisy.” Vzgliad, March 2. http://www.vz.ru/columns/2014/3/2/675131.html.Google Scholar
Kholmogorov, Egor. 2014g. “O ZhZh Naval'nogo.” March 14. http://holmogor.livejournal.com/6200896.html.Google Scholar
Kholmogorova, Natal'ia. 2014a. “Pro Ukrainu.” February 24. http://nataly-hill.livejournal.com/2034222.html.Google Scholar
Kholmogorova, Natal'ia. 2014b. “O ‘banderovkskoi kartinke'.” February 24. http://nataly-hill.livejournal.com/2035631.html.Google Scholar
Kholmogorova, Natal'ia. 2014c. “Na maidane pobedil natsionalizm.” February 25. http://www.rus-obr.ru/blog/29716.Google Scholar
Kholmogorova, Natal'ia. 2014d. “Bezumnyi den'.” March 1. http://nataly-hill.livejournal.com/2040226.html.Google Scholar
Kholmogorova, Natal'ia. 2014e. “Untitled Blog Entry.” February 25. http://nataly-hill.livejournal.com/2036577.html.Google Scholar
Fedor, Klimenko. 2014. “Natsionalizm posle Kryma.” April 16. http://www.apn.ru/publications/article31433.htm.Google Scholar
Kolsto, Pal. 2014. “Russian Nationalists Flirt with Democracy.” Journal of Democracy 25 (3): 120134.Google Scholar
Krylov, Konstantin. 2013. “Konstantin Krylov o pozitsii NDP po situatsii v Ukraine.” December 8. http://ruspartia.livejournal.com/618084.html.Google Scholar
Krylov, Konstantin. 2014a. “O pozitsii po ukrainskomu voprosu.” Russkii obozrevatel, March 4. http://www.rus-obr.ru/blog/29883.Google Scholar
Krylov, Konstantin. 2014b. “Post.” March 20. http://krylov.livejournal.com/3245834.html.Google Scholar
Lapshin, Aleksei. 2014a. “Untitled Blog Entry.” February 19. http://alexey-lapshyn.livejournal.com/206455.html.Google Scholar
Lapshin, Aleksei. 2014b. “Paru prostykh voprosov k chestnomu russkomu muzhiku Eduardu Veniaminovichu Limonovu (Savenko).” March 20. http://alexey-lapshyn.livejournal.com/210116.html.Google Scholar
Lapshin, Aleksei. 2014c. “Vernulsia iz Ukrainy v Moskvu.” February 16. http://alexey-lapshyn.livejournal.com/206086.html.Google Scholar
Laruelle, Marlène. 2014. “Alexei Navalny and Challenges in Reconciling ‘Nationalism’ and ‘Liberalism.'Post-Soviet Affairs 30 (4): 276297.Google Scholar
Lavrova, Liudmila. 2014. “Igra v iashchik.” Zavtra, February 5: 8.Google Scholar
Limonov, Eduard. 2002. “Vtoraia Rossiia i Moskoviia.” Limonka, no. 194. http://limonka.nbp-info.ru/194/194_12_05.htm.Google Scholar
Limonov, Eduard. 2013a. “Marazm krepchaet.” Izvestiia, November 14: 9.Google Scholar
Limonov, Eduard. 2013b. “Pust Ukraina razlomitsia kak nesorazmernyi baton khleba.” November 30. http://limonov-eduard.livejournal.com/400038.html.Google Scholar
Limonov, Eduard. 2013c. “Tiagnibok, iz spiska Vizentalia.” Izvestiia, December 4: 9.Google Scholar
Liss, Artem. 2014. “Blog redaktora: Artem Loskutov i ‘federalizatsiia Sibiri'.” August 3. http://www.bbc.co.uk/russian/blogs/2014/08/140802_blog_editor_restricting_access.shtml.Google Scholar
Luk'ianenko, Sergei. 2014. “Ia vse skazal uzhe davno.” February 22. http://dr-piliulkin.livejournal.com/501944.html.Google Scholar
Navalny, Aleksei. 2014. “K ‘antimaidanovtsam’ (ili ne pytaites’ byt’ sviatee Papy Rimskogo).” February 23. http://navalny.livejournal.com/.Google Scholar
NDP. 2013. “Zaiavlenie TsK NDP.” December 22. http://tor85.livejournal.com/2550040.html.Google Scholar
NDP. 2014a. “NDP zaregistrirovali.” July 31. http://rosndp.org/ndp-zaregestrirovali.htm.Google Scholar
NDP. 2014b. “Otkaz v registratsii.” August 1. http://rosndp.org/otkaz-v-registracii.htm.Google Scholar
Popkov, Roman. 2014. “Untitled Comment.” March 8. http://vk.com/wall-5595894_9395.Google Scholar
Prokhanov, Aleksandr. 2014a. “Ukraina: plakha dlia russkikh.” Zavtra, January 29:1.Google Scholar
Prokhanov, Aleksandr. 2014b. “Neuzheli russkie podstaviat sheiu pod banderovskii nozh?” Komsomol'skaia Pravda, January 30: 5.Google Scholar
Prosvirnin, Egor. 2014a. “Ukraina dolzhna stat’ nastoiashchei Rossiei bez Kadyrova.” February 20. http://www.apn.ru/publications/article31097.htm.Google Scholar
Prosvirnin, Egor. 2014b. “Obrashchenie ko vsem russkim Ukrainy.” February 22. http://sputnikipogrom.com/russia/ua/9420/to-the-all-russian-people/.Google Scholar
Pulin, Mikhail. 2014. “Politika kremlevskoi vlasti – primer samogo otvratitel'nogo litsemeriia.” August 8. http://www.sensusnovus.ru/opinion/2014/08/08/19250.html.Google Scholar
Radchenko, Vsevolod. 2014. “O prave Kryma na samoopredelenie.” March 3. http://rosndp.org/o-prave-krima-na-samoopredelenie.htm.Google Scholar
Rodina. 2014. “Deklaratsiia o sozdanii russkogo internatsionala.” February 19. http://rodina.ru/novosti/slovo-i-delo/Deklaraciya-o-sozdanii-Russkogo-internacionala.Google Scholar
Runkevich, Dmitrii and Elena, Malai. 2013. “Rodina perekhvatit u LDPR natsionalisticheskii elektorat.” Izvestiia, November 1. http://izvestia.ru/news/559909.Google Scholar
Samarina, Aleksandra. 2012. “Apostoly konservativnogo patriotizma.” Nezavisimaia gazeta, September 10: 1.Google Scholar
Shagimulina, Dina. 2014. “V Novosibirske vystupili protiv voennoi interventsii na Ukraine.” March 2. http://sibkray.ru/news/1/860147/.Google Scholar
Simakin, Dmitrii. 2003. “Nev'ezdnoi.” Nezavisimaia gazeta, July 28: 7.Google Scholar
Skliarov, Andrei. 2013a. “Obrashchenie k rukovodstvu NDP.” December 8. http://nagletssklyarov.livejournal.com/72368.html.Google Scholar
Skliarov, Andrei. 2013b. “Finita la comedia! Rostovskoe regional'noe otdelenie NDP ofitsial'no samoraspustilos.” December 11. http://nagletssklyarov.livejournal.com/73331.html.Google Scholar
Sokovnin, Aleksei. 2011. “K ubiistvu advokata podkliuchili boevuiu organizatsiiu.” Kommersant, April 12: 5.Google Scholar
Tor, Vladimir. 2013a. “Real'no pozitnivnyi istoricheskii rezul'tat Maidana.” December 9. http://tor85.livejournal.com/2533838.html.Google Scholar
Tor, Vladimir. 2013b. “Pokhval'noe slovo Maidana.” December 10. http://tor85.livejournal.com/2535915.html.Google Scholar
Tor, Vladimir. 2014. “Duma o Putine.” February 24. http://tor85.livejournal.com/2641260.html.Google Scholar
Umland, Andreas. 2007. “Post-Soviet “Uncivil Society” and the Rise of Aleksandr Dugin. A Case Study of the Extraparliamentary Radical Right in Contemporary Russia.” PhD diss., University of Cambridge.Google Scholar
Umland, Andreas. 2010. “Aleksandr Dugin's Transformation from a Lunatic Fringe Figure into a Mainstream Political Publicist, 1980–1998: A Case Study in the Rise of Late and Post-Soviet Russian Fascism.” Journal of Eurasian Studies 1: 144152.Google Scholar
Vorob'ev, Stanislav. 2014. “Kyiv. Uroki revoliutsii i russkie interesy.” February 17. http://www.rusimperia.info/catalog/3942.html.Google Scholar