No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Were our critics right about the Stasi?
AIDS disinformation and “disinformation squared” after five years
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 16 May 2019
Abstract
Background. Disinformation, now best known generically as “fake news,” is an old and protean weapon. Prominent in the 1980s was AIDS disinformation, including the HIV-from-Fort-Detrick myth, for whose propagation some figures ultimately admitted blame while others shamelessly claimed credit. In 2013 we reported a comprehensive analysis of this myth, finding leading roles for the Soviet Union’s state security service, the KGB, and for biologist and independent conspiracy theorist Jakob Segal but not for East Germany’s state security service, the Stasi. We found Stasi involvement had been much less extensive and much less successful than two former Stasi officers had begun claiming following German reunification. In 2014 two historians crediting the two former Stasi officers coauthored a monograph challenging our analysis and portraying the Stasi as having directed Segal, or at least as having used him as a “conscious or unconscious multiplier,” and as having successfully assisted a Soviet bloc AIDS-disinformation conspiracy that they soon inherited and thenceforth led. In 2017 a German appellate court found our 2013 analysis persuasive in a defamation suit brought by a filmmaker whose work the 2014 monograph had depicted as co-funded by the Stasi.
Question and methods. Were our critics right about the Stasi? We asked and answered ten subsidiary questions bearing upon our critics’ arguments, reassessing our own prior work and probing additional sources including archives of East Germany’s Partei- und Staatsführung [party-and-state leadership] and the recollections of living witnesses.
Findings. Jakob Segal transformed and transmitted the myth without direction from the KGB or the Stasi or any element of East Germany’s party-and-state leadership. The Stasi had trouble even tracking Segal’s activities, which some officers feared would disadvantage East Germany scientifically, economically, and politically. Three officers in one Stasi section did show interest in myth propagation, but their efforts were late, limited, inept, and inconsequential.
Conclusion. The HIV-from-Fort-Detrick myth, most effectively promoted by Jakob Segal acting independently of any state’s security service, was not, contrary to claims, a Stasi success.
Keywords
- Type
- Article
- Information
- Copyright
- © Association for Politics and the Life Sciences 2019
References
Gottlieb, M. S., Schroff, R., and Schanker, H. M.
et al. , “Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia and mucosal candidiasis in previously healthy homosexual men: evidence of a new acquired cellular immunodeficiency,”
New England Journal of Medicine
, 10 December 1981, 305(24): 1425–1431.Google Scholar
Masur, H., Michelis, M. A., and Greene, J. B.
et al. , “An outbreak of community-acquired Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia: initial manifestation of cellular immune dysfunction,”
New England Journal of Medicine
, 10 December 1981, 305(24): 1431–1438.Google Scholar
Siegal, F. P., Lopez, C., and Hammer, G. S.
et al. , “Severe acquired immunodeficiency in male homosexuals, manifested by chronic perianal ulcerative Herpes simplex lesions,”
New England Journal of Medicine
, 10 December 1981, 305(24): 1439–1444.Google Scholar
Gallo, R. C., Sarin, P. S., and Gelmann, E. P.
et al. , “Isolation of human T-cell leukemia virus in acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS),”
Science
, 20 May 1983, 220 (4599): 865–867; doi:10.1126/science.6601823.Google Scholar
Barre-Sinoussi, F., Chermann, J. C., and Rey, F., “…L. Montagnier, Isolation of a T-lymphotropic retrovirus from a patient at risk for acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS),”
Science
, 20 May 1983, 220 (599); 868–871; doi:10.1126/science.6189183.Google Scholar
Anonymous, “AIDS may invade India: Mystery disease caused by US experiments,” Patriot [New Delhi, India], 16 July 1983, pp. 2, 7. [Date and pagination handwritten on copied original. Copy kindly provided by Todd Leventhal, U.S. Department of State.].Google Scholar
United States Department of State, Soviet Influence Activities: A Report on Active Measures and Propaganda, 1986–87 (Washington: Department of State Publications, August 1987 [released October 1987]), Appendix A, p. 44.Google Scholar
Valentin Sapewalow [Zapevalov], “Panic in the west or what is hiding behind the sensation surrounding AIDS,” Literaturnaya Gazeta, 30 October 1985.Google Scholar
Drozdov, Sergey G., interview in Russian), “AIDS: Panic continues,” Literaturnaya Gazeta, 11 December 1985.Google Scholar
Geissler, Erhard and Sprinkle, Robert Hunt, “Disinformation squared: Was the HIV-from-Fort-Detrick myth a Stasi success?,”
Politics and the Life Sciences
, Fall 2013, 32:2, pp. 2–99; http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=10.2990%2F32_2_2; https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/politics-and-the-life-sciences/article/disinformation-squared-was-the-hivfromfortdetrick-myth-a-stasi-success/8CFEA2F6B8FA780208DFAC39DC57A03E; doi: 10.2990/32_2_2.Google Scholar
Qiu, Linda, “Fingerprints of Russian Disinformation: From AIDS to Fake News,”
New York Times
, 12 December 2017.Google Scholar
Tous, Adam en, Nakashima, Ellen, and Jaffe, Greg, “Kremlin’s trolls beset Web as U.S. dithered: Russian disinformation threat went uncontested as it metastasized,” Washington Post, 26 December 2017, pp. A1, A6-7.Google Scholar
EU vs DISINFORMATION | DON’T BE DECEIVED, QUESTION EVEN MORE, https://euvsdisinfo.eu; last accessed 26 December 2017.Google Scholar
Geissler, Erhard, “Falsches über Fake News: Wie die ‘New York Times’ auf der Jagd nach Desinformationen zum Thema Aids selbst welche reproduziert [False about Fake News: How the New York Times in the hunt for disinformation on the subject of AIDS itself reproduced some],” Neues Deutschland [New Germany], 6–7 January 2018.Google Scholar
Rosenberg, Matthew, Savage, Charlie, and Wines, Michael, “Russia Sees Midterm Elections as Chance to Sow Fresh Discord, Intelligence Chiefs Warn,”
New York Times
, 13 February 2018.Google Scholar
Nakashima, Ellen, “Russian spies hacked the Olympics and tried to make it look like North Korea did it, U.S. officials say,”
Washington Post
, 24 February 2018; https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/russian-spies-hacked-the-olympics-and-tried-to-make-it-look-like-north-korea-did-it-us-officials-say/2018/02/24/44b5468e-18f2-11e8-92c9-376b4fe57ff7_ story.html?utm_ term=.5f87d6a5c14a.Google Scholar
Bohnsack, Günter and Brehmer, Herbert, Auftrag Irreführung. Wie die Stasi Politik im Westen machte. [Mission Misleading: How the Stasi Made Politics in the West] (Hamburg: Carlsen, 1992), pp. 219–20.Google Scholar
Boghardt, Thomas, “Operation INFEKTION. Soviet bloc intelligence and its AIDS disinformation campaign,”
Studies in Intelligence
, December 2009, 53(4):1–24.Google Scholar
Müller-Enbergs, Helmut, e-mail communication with EG, 15 March 2011.Google Scholar
Selvage, Douglas and Nehring, Christopher, Die AIDS-Verschwörung: Das Ministerium für Staatssicherheit und die AIDS-Desinformationskampagne des KGB [The AIDS Conspiracy: The Ministry for State Security and the AIDS Disinformation Campaign of the KGB] (Berlin: Der Bundesbeauftragte für die Unterlagen des Staatssicherheitsdienstes der ehemaligen Deutschen Demokratischen Republik Abteilung Bildung unf Forschung [The Federal Commissioner for the Records of the State Security Service of the former German Democratic Republic Department of Education and Research], the BStU, 2014), p. 19.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 20.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 35.Google Scholar
https://www.deutsches-spionagemuseum.de/en/museum/history/; last accessed 30 December 2017.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 78–80.Google Scholar
KGB, Information No. 2955 (russ.), 7 September 1985. COMDOS-Arch, Fond (F.) 9, opis (op.) 4, a.e. 663, 208. Translated by Daria Karetnikov. Archiv der Berlin-Brandenburgischen Akademie der Wissenschaften (ABBAW) Bu A 1600/10.Google Scholar
Sims, Nicholas, The Evolution of Biological Disarmament
(SIPRI Chemical & Biological Warfare Studies 19)
, (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001).Google Scholar
KGB, Information No. 2742 (russ.), Undated, written not before 26 October 1986. In: “Cooperation with the KGB 1987”. COMDOS-Arch-R, F. 9, op. 4, a.e. 675, Bl. 156–159. Translated by Daria Karetnikov. ABBAW, Bu A 1600/10.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 69.Google Scholar
Boghardt, pp. 11–2.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 45–51.Google Scholar
Segal, Jakob, letter to Harry Mehner, SED-Kreisleitung [leadership of the Communist Party], East German Television, Berlin, 3 October 1985. Stiftung Archiv der Parteien und Massenorganisationen der DDR im Bundesarchiv [Foundation Archives of the Parties and Mass Organizations of the GDR in the Federal Archives] (SAPMO-BArch), NY 4516, vorl. K. 12. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 14.Google Scholar
Segal, Jakob, interviewed by Alfred Lee, “Aids [sic] sensation,” Sunday Express, 26 October 1986; BStU MfS – HA II, Nr. 22082: 22–23.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 41.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 6.Google Scholar
United Nations, Background Document on new Scientific and Technological Developments …, BWC/CONF.II/4/Add.1, 29 August 1986. Quoted in Erhard Geissler (ed.), Strengthening the Biological Weapons Convention by Confidence-Building Measures. SIPRI. Oxford University Press 1990, p. 24, note 50.Google Scholar
Leitenberg, Milton, Zilinskas, Raymond, and Kuhn, Jens, The Soviet Biological Weapons Program: A History. (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2012); http://www.hup.harvard.edu/results-list.php?author=11131.Google Scholar
Milton Leitenberg, e-mail response to RHS, 31 December 2017.Google Scholar
Judyth Twigg, HIV/AIDS in Russia and Eurasia, Volume 1 (Gordonsville: Palgrave Macmillan, 2006).Google Scholar
dpa, “Drei Aids-Tote in der Sowjetunion – 130 Kranke [Three AIDS deaths in the USSR – 130 sick],” August 1987. BArch DQ 1 / 12725/2. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
United States Department of State, Soviet Influence Activities.Google Scholar
Shultz, George P., Turmoil and Triumph: My Years as Secretary of State (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1993), pp. 997–998.Google Scholar
Oberdorfer, Don, “State Dept. hails Moscow for ‘disavowal’ on AIDS; propaganda had blamed disease on U.S.,”
Washington Post
, 3 November 1987, p. A27.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 27.Google Scholar
Romerstein, Herbert, “Disinformation as a KGB Weapon in the Cold War,”
The Journal of Intelligence History
, 1, Summer 2001, pp. 54–67, at p. 61.Google Scholar
Bureau of International Information Programs, U.S. Department of State, “Definitions,” 2005 (14 January).http://www.america.gov/st/webchat-english/2005/January/20050114144833atlahtnevel0.1894342.html.Google Scholar
Milstein, M. A. and Semeyko, L. S., “U.S. military ‘R&D’ through Soviet eyes,”
Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists
, 1977, 33(2): 33–38.Google Scholar
Geissler, Erhard, “Implications of genetic engineering for chemical and biological warfare,” in: World Armaments and Disarmament: Stockholm International Peace Research Institute Yearbook (SIPRI Yearbook [1984]) (London and Philadelphia: Taylor & Francis, 1984), pp. 421–54.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 48.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 23.Google Scholar
United States Department of State, Soviet Influence Activities, p. 33.Google Scholar
Segal, Jakob and Lilli, Segal, “AIDS: USA-home made evil; NOT imported from AFRICA,” distributed at the margin of the Harare summit, 1986.Google Scholar
United Nations General Assembly, “Prevention and Control of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS),” Forty-second session, Resolution A/42/8 26, October 1987, PAAA Bestand MfAA, ZR 6037/93.Google Scholar
Anonymous, [Memo] “Professor Segal – Stand – Darlegung [Professor Segal – situation – explanation],” undated, presumably April 1988. Politisches Archiv des Auswärtigen Amts der Bundesrepublik Deutschland (PAAA) [Political Archive of the Federal Foreign Office of the Federal Republic of Germany], Bestand Ministerium für Auswärtige Angelegenheiten der DDR [Holdings of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the GDR] (MfAA), ZR 1.202/13. Akten-Nr. 608, AIDS-Bekämpfung USA-DDR [AIDS control USA East Germany], 1987–1989. Translation by EG.Google Scholar
Sprinkle, Geissler, Text Box “Origins of AIDS agents HIV-1 and HIV-2,” p. 6.Google Scholar
Selvage und Nehring, p. 35.Google Scholar
Segal, Lilli and Segal, und Jakob, “Über den Ursprung von AIDS [On the origin of AIDS],” type-written manuscript, 13 pages, incomplete, undated, presumably January 1986. BStU “Nils” folder, Blatt 35–47.Google Scholar
[Axel] Theisinger, “Bericht über ein weiteres Kontaktgespräch mit dem IM-Kandidaten ‘Nils’ [Report on another contact conversation with the IM candidate ‘Nils’],” 22 January 1986, BStU MfS AIM 4835/88, Bd. 1, 23. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 19.Google Scholar
Claasen, Heimo, “Das KRITISCHE TAGEBUCH. Das AIDS-Rätsel – die Suche nach dem Sündenbock [The Critical Diary: The Riddle of AIDS – looking for the scapegoat],” WDR Hörfunk [WDR Radio], 6 March 1987.Google Scholar
Jakob, Segal and Segal, Lilli, “Le SIDA – sa nature et son origine [AIDS – its nature and origin],” type-written manuscript, undated, presumably autumn 1986; BStU MfS HA VII/ZMA, Nr. 935, 89–139.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 37.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 19–22.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 82.Google Scholar
Claasen, Heimo, “Zur Geschichte des Films ‘AIDS – die Afrikalegende’ und der verfälschenden Darstellung von Selvage [Regarding the history of the movie “AIDS – die Afrikalegende” and the distorting interpretation by Selvage],” January 2015. Unpublished.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 41–2.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 52–61.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 33–4.Google Scholar
Anonymous, “10-Tagebericht vom 07.11.1986 [Ten-days report of 7 November 1986],” The Federal Commissioner for the Records of the State Security Service of the former German Democratic Republic (BStU) MfS XV 334/66 “Diversant” Beifügung Bd. 19 Aop 26320/91, Blatt 200.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 68.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 54–9.Google Scholar
Heym, Stefan and Segal, Jakob, [interview]. “AIDS: man-made in USA,” tageszeitung (taz) [West Berlin], 18 February 1987, 1097:11–13. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, pp. 77–8.Google Scholar
Feddersen, Jan and Gast, Wolfgang, “Wie das AIDS-Virus nach Fort Detrick kam [How the AIDS virus came to Fort Detrick],” taz, 9 January 2010.Google Scholar
Gast, Wolfgang, “Der Auftrag hieß Desinformation — Die taz im Visier des Staatssicherheitsdienstes, Teil 3: Wie die Stasi Falschmeldungen lancierte / Ob Barschel-Briefe, IWF oder Aids-Propaganda — die Stasi versuchte mitzumischen [The order was called disinformation — The taz in the sights of the Stasi, part 3: How the Stasi issued fake news / Whether Barschel-letters, IWF or AIDS propaganda — the Stasi tried to be on it], taz, 30 December 1992.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 68, note 254.Google Scholar
Widmann, Arno, personal communication with EG, 26 January 2017.Google Scholar
Koch, Meinrad, “HIV ist kein gentechnologisches Produkt [HIV is not a genetically engineered product],” interview in taz, 28 February 1987.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 76.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 20.Google Scholar
Sprinkle, R. H., e-mail to Douglas Selvage (copied to Erhard Geissler), 28 October 2014.Google Scholar
Selvage, Douglas, e-mail to R. H. Sprinkle and Erhard Geissler, 28 November 2014.Google Scholar
Funder, Anna, Stasiland: Stories From Behind the Berlin Wall (London: Granta Books, 2003).Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 17.Google Scholar
Münkel, Daniela, State Security: A Reader on the GDR Secret Police (Berlin: BStU 2016).Google Scholar
Grimmer, Reinhard, Irmler, Werner, Neiber, Gerhard, and Schwanitz, Wolfgang, “Sicherheitspolitik der SED, Staatliche Sicherheit der DDR und Abwehrarbeit des MfS [Security policy of the SED, State Security of the GDR and Counter-Intelligence Service of the MfS],” in Reinhard Grimmer, Werner Irmler, Willi Opitz, Wolfgang Schwanitz, eds., Die Sicherheit. Zur Abwehrarbeit des MfS. Vol. 1, Berlin, 2002, pp. 44–238. Translation by E.G.Google Scholar
Gieseke, Jens, The GDR State Security: Shield and Sword of the Party. second ed., Berlin: BStU, 2006, p. 5.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, pp. 48–54.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, pp. 48–54.Google Scholar
Münkel, p. 46.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 52.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, pp. 49, 54.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 146.Google Scholar
Prof. Dr. Jakob Segal, Dr. Lilli Segal, and Dr. Ronald Dehmlow, “AIDS – its nature and origin,” undated manuscript. Copy courtesy of Todd Leventhal, United States Department of State.Google Scholar
Segal, Jakob, Segal, Lilli, and Dehmlow, Ronald, “Das AIDS – seine Natur und sein Ursprung [AIDS – its nature and its origin],” in Stephan Eggedinger, ed, Streitbarer Materialismus[Militant Materialism], Nr. 11, July 1988, 7–65; at www.streitbarer-materialismus.de; accessed 5 March 2012.Google Scholar
Ronald Dehmlow, personal communication with EG, 18 June 2012.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 90.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 55.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 17–23.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 43–4.Google Scholar
Geissler, Erhard, “Es gab keine AIDS-Verschwörung des MfS mit den Segals [There was no AIDS conspiracy of the MfS with the Segals],” Zeitschrift des Forschungsverbundes SED-Staat, Nr. 37, 2015, pp. 94–120, at pp. 101–102.Google Scholar
Karl Seidel letter to Kurt Hager, 22 September 1986. SAPMO-BArch DY/30/26444. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Kurt Hager, letter to Karl Seidel, 25 September 1986, SAPMO-BArch DY 30 26444. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Sönnichsen, Niels, telephone conversation with EG, 17 January 2017.Google Scholar
Sönnichsen, Niels, letter to Minister Mecklinger, 24 November 1986. With attachment: “Bericht über ein Colloquium in der Hautklinik der Charité, am 21.11.1986 [Report on a seminar in the dermatological hospital on 21 November 1986],” BArch DQ 1/13082. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Lummitsch, letter to HA XX/AKG and BV [regional administration of the MfS], 19 December 1986, BStU MfS HA II/6 1271, p. 15. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 68–70.Google Scholar
Dewitz, “Bericht. Prof. Segal. Gen. Prof. Rosenthal gab heute folgende Einschätzung [Report. Prof. Segal. Comrade Prof. Rosenthal today provided the following assessment],” 17 March 1987, BStU MfS HA XX Nr. 7101, Teil 2, pp. 304–7, at p. 307. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Dewitz, “Bericht. Prof. Segal pp. 306–7. Translated by E.G.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, pp. 87–8.Google Scholar
Geissler, Erhard and Rosenthal, Hans-Alfred, AIDS und biologische Kriegführung [AIDS and biological warfare],” 5 March 1987. Unpublished ABBAW, A 1600/2. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, pp. 86–7.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 20.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 67.Google Scholar
Geissler, “Es gab keine AIDS-Verschwörung des MfS mit den Segals,” pp. 110–111.Google Scholar
Anonymous, “Information für leitende Kader [Information for leading cadre],” Sonderinformation Nr. 104/1983. Institut für Wissenschaftsinformation in der Medizin [Institute for Scientific Information in Medicine]. BArch DQ 1, 15401. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Sönnichsen, Niels, “Bericht über die Teilnahme am Kongress ‘AIDS in Afrika’ vom 22.-23.11.1985 in Brüssel [Report on the participation in the congress “AIDS in Africa” of 22 to 23 November 1985 in Brussells,” 25 November 1985. BArch DQ / 1/12718.Google Scholar
Chaitow, P. M., comment in “Portrait eines heimtückischen Feindes [Portrait of a malicious enemy],” Trud, 6 October 1985, attachment to Ludwig Mecklinger, 14 November 1985. BArch DQ 1/13082.Google Scholar
Theodor, Helmut, note. 29 November 1985. BArch DQ 1/13080. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 31.Google Scholar
[Horst] Schönfelder, [Niels] Sönnichsen and [Sieghart] Dittmann], “Bericht über die Arbeitstagung der Vertreter der Ministerien für Gesundheitswesen der RGW-Länder zum Problem AIDS [Report on a workshop of representatives of the Ministries of Health of the COMECON countries regarding AIDS],” Moskau, 21–22 April 1987. BArch DQ 1/13082.Google Scholar
Mecklinger, Ludwig, “Richtlinie zur Erkennung, Verhütung und Bekämpfung des Syndroms der erworbenen Immundefekts (AIDS). Entwurf [Guideline regarding the diagnosis, prophylaxis, and control of the syndrome of acquired immunodeficiency (AIDS). Draft],” 1987. BArch DQ 1/13083/1. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
[Helmut] Theodor, correspondence with I.K., H.P. and S.R., 12 March – 20 April 1987. BArch DQ 1/14462 Teil 2. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 42–3 and fig. 10.Google Scholar
Segal, Jakob, “Where does AIDS come from?” Moscow News, 26 April 1987. Translation of an English translation of a Russian translation of the German original. BArch DQ 117/20, part 2.Google Scholar
Mecklinger, Ludwig, letters to Kurt Hager and Willy Stoph, 22 April 1987. BArch DQ 1/12728.Google Scholar
Geissler, Erhard, “‘Lieber AIDS als gar nichts aus dem Westen!’ Wie Partei- und Staatsführung der DDR mit dem AIDS-Problem umgingen [‘Better AIDS than nothing from the West.’ How the Partei- und Staatsführung of the GDR dealt with the AIDS problem],” Zeitschrift des Forschungsverbundes SED-Staat [Journal of the research association SED-Staat], Nr. 22, 2007. pp. 91–116, at p. 96–98.Google Scholar
USA, FM AMEMBASSY EMB BERLIN TO SECSTATE WASHCD 4742. Confidential. Subject: official-informal. August 1987 . U.S. Department of State Case No. F-2014-23141 Doc No C05838563.Google Scholar
GDR non-paper, undated [July 1987] PAAA Bestand MfAA, ZR 1.202/13 Akten-Nr. 608, AIDS-Bekämpfung USA-DDR [AIDS control USA East Germany], 1987–1989. Translation by E.G.Google Scholar
Anonymous “Auszug aus einer Aufzeichnung des Konsultationsgespräches von Krolikowski mit Ridgway am 24. 7. 1987 [Extract from the notes of a meeting of Krolikowski with Ridgway on 24 September 1987],” p. 3. PAAA Bestand MfAA ZR 1.202/13 Akten-Nr. 608, AIDS-Bekämpfung USA-DDR [AIDS control USA East Germany], 1987-1989. Translation by E.G.Google Scholar
USA, FM AMEMBASSY EMB BERLIN TO SECSTATE WASHCD 4742. Confidential. Subject: official-informal. August 1987. U.S. Department of State Case No. F-2014-23141 Doc No C05838563.Google Scholar
United States Department of State, Soviet Influence Activities, pp. 33–5.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, pp. 103–4.Google Scholar
USA, FM AMEMBASSY EMB BERLIN TO SECSTATE WASHCD. Confidential. “Subject: Non-paper on bilateral relationship: Ambassador Nier meeting. December 1987. U.S. Department of State Case No. F-2014-23141 Doc No C05838555.Google Scholar
Barth, Herbert, “Notiz für Genossen Oskar Fischer [Note for comrade Oskar Fischer],” 5 January 1988. PAAA Bestand MfAA ZR 1.202/13 Akten-Nr. 608, AIDS-Bekämpfung USA-DDR [AIDS control USA East Germany], 1987–1989. Translation by E.G.Google Scholar
Siegler, letter to Herbert Barth, undated [8 January 1988 or earlier]. PAAA Bdstand MfAA ZR 1.202/13. Akten-Nr. 608, AIDS-Bekämpfung USA-DDR [AIDS control USA East Germany], 1987–1989. Translation by E.G.Google Scholar
Sönnichsen, Niels, letter to EG, with attachments. 20 October 1986. ABBAW, Bu A 1600/2.Google Scholar
Siegler, letter to Herbert Barth, undated [8 January 1988 or earlier]. PAAA Bestand MfAA ZR 1.202/13. Akten-Nr. 608, AIDS-Bekämpfung USA-DDR [AIDS control USA East Germany], 1987–1989. Translation by E.G.Google Scholar
Siegler, letter to [Herbert] Barth, “zur Kenntnisnahme und Entscheidung [for information and decision],” undated [early January 1988]. PAAA Bestand MfAA ZR 1.202/13. Akten-Nr. 608, AIDS-Bekämpfung USA-DDR [AIDS control USA East Germany], 1987–1989. Translation by E.G.Google Scholar
Greenwald, John, [Memo], 28 February 1989. PAAA Bestand MfAA ZR 1.202/13. Akten-Nr. 608, AIDS-Bekämpfung USA-DDR [AIDS control USA East Germany], 1987–1989. Translation by E.G.Google Scholar
Anonymous, “Der AIDS-Krimi [The AIDS thriller],” interview with J. Segal in BASTA (Wien), December 1988.Google Scholar
Segal, Jakob, Brief an den Chefredakteur [letter to the editor-in-chief]” from ARD or WDR, 31 March 1989, SAPMO-BArch, NY4516/vorl. K.7. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Siegler, “Vermerk über ein Gespräch von Genossen Dr. Norbert Reemer, Sektorleiter in der Abteilung USA, mit dem Rat der USA-Botschaft, John Greenwald, am 28. Februar 1989 im MfAA [Note on a meeting of comrade Dr. Norbert Reemer, section leader in the U.S. Department, with the US Embassy Council, John Greenwald, on 28 February 1989 in the MfAA],” 28 February. PAAA Bestand MfAA ZR 1.202/13. Akten-Nr. 608 “AIDS-Bekämpfung USA-DDR” 1987–1989. Translation by E.G.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 4–5.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 39 and Fig. 7.Google Scholar
United States Department of State, Soviet Influence Activities, p. 35.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 42.Google Scholar
Segal, Jakob, Lebenslauf [curriculum vitae], undated, presumably 1955. BStU MfS 14459/62: 11.Google Scholar
Boghardt, p. 12.Google Scholar
Segal, Lilli, Lebenslauf [curriculum vitae], undated, presumably 1967. SAPMO-BArch NY4516/vorl.K.13.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 44.Google Scholar
Segal, Lilli, Vom Widerspruch zum Widerstand: Erinnerungen einer Tochter aus gutem Hause [From Conflict to Resistance: Memories of a Daughter from a Good Home] (Berlin: Aufbau-Verlag, 1986), pp. 143–194, 252. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Anonymous, book review of “AIDS: U.S.A. – Home-Made Evil; Not Imported From Africa,” Social Change and Development (Zimbabwe), 1986, 14:34–37.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, pp. 19, 35.Google Scholar
Anonymous, “Plan der gemeinsamen und abgestimmten Massnahmen der Aufklärungsorgane des MdI der VR Bulgarien und des MfS der DDR für 1987 und 1988 [Plan of joint and agreed measures of the reconnaissance authorities of the Interior Ministry of the People’s Republic Bulgaria and of the MfS of the GDR for 1987 and 1988],” Berlin 3 September 1986. COMDOS-Arch-R, F.9, op.4, a.e.670, pp.108–119, at p. 112. Quoted by Selvage and Nehring, p. 36, note 113. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 36.Google Scholar
Nikolow, L., “Information on consultations with German comrades on 16 to 19 September 1986 in Sofia and on concrete agreements regarding several joint active measures,” COMDOS-Arch-R, F.9, Op. 2 a,e. 670, p. 104. Translated by C. Nehring into German and by EG into English. Quoted by Selvage and Nehring 36, note 116.Google Scholar
Stankow, D., “Information on talks with comrade Wolfgang Mutz, deputy head of department HV A/X of the MfS of the GDR during his stay in Bulgaria on 16 to 19 September 1986, 22 November 1986,” COMDOS-Arch–R, F.9, op. 4, a,e. 670, p. 123–127. Translated by C. Nehring into German and by EG into English. Quoted by Selvage and Nehring, p. 36.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 147.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 58.Google Scholar
Materialien der Ständige Arbeitsgruppe ‘AIDS’ der Zentralen Kommission des Ministerrates zur Verhütung und Bekämpfung von Epidemien [Documents of the Permanent Working Group ‘AIDS’ of the Central Commission of the Councils of Ministers on Prevention and Control of Epidemics], BArch DQ / 1 / 12727.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 36–37.Google Scholar
[Lilli Segal] “Bericht zur Kontaktaufnahme durch Mitarbeiter der USA-Botschaft in der DDR [Report on being contacted by representatives of the U.S. Embassy in the GDR],” undated [Sep or Oct 1986]. Attachment to Oldenburg to Häseler, 23 October 1986. BStU MfS HA II 22082, p. 39–40. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 45–7.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 64.Google Scholar
Kruse, Kuno, ed., AIDS – Erreger aus dem Genlabor? Die Diskussion der rätselhaften Herkunft einer Krankheit, die die Welt bedroht [AIDS – pathogens from the gene laboratory? The discussion of the mysterious origin of a disease that threatens the world]. (Berlin: Simon & Leutner, 1987).Google Scholar
Koch, Meinrad, HIV ist kein gentechnologisches Produkt [HIV is not a product of genetic engineering],” interview in taz, 28 February 1987, reprinted in Kruse 1987.Google Scholar
Anonymous, “Recherchen zum Thema, ‘AIDS – eine biologische Waffe?’ Streng vertraulich [Investigations on the theme ‘AIDS – a biological weapon?’ Highly confidential],” Information G/019624/12/05/87/02 XV 334/66 BStU “Diversant” Aop 26320/9 Bd 20, Bl. 49–50, 13 May 1987. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Anonymous, Aufzeichnung (Notes), 29 June 1987. COMDOS-Arch-R, F. 9, op. 4, a.e. 676, p. 46. Quoted by Selvage and Nehring, p. 83, note 329. [Sofia] Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, pp. 79–80.Google Scholar
Stankow, D., “Report on talks of officers of the Bulgarian Secret Service with German comrades, 26 to 29 September 1988 in Sofia,” COMDOS-Arch- R, F.9, op. 4, a,e. 691, pp. 86–98. Translated by C. Nehring into German and by EG into English. Quoted by Selvage and Nehring, p.109.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 71.Google Scholar
Klare, Hans-Hermann, “Virus aus dem CIA-Labor? Ein DDR-Biologe verwirrt die Öffentlichkeit mit der Behauptung, der AIDS-Erreger sei in den USA bei Experimenten für biologische Waffen gezüchtet worden [Virus from a CIA laboratory? A biologist from the GDR misleads the public by claiming the AIDS agent had been created in the USA in the course of biological weapons research],” Stern, 12 March 1987.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, p. 74.Google Scholar
Heimo Claasen, email communication with EG, 9 February 2017.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 112.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 73–4.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 73–4.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 115 and footnote 488.Google Scholar
Anonymous, “Report on talks with the German comrades on 26 to 29 September 1989 in Berlin,” 10 October 1989. COMDOS-Arch-R, F.9, op. 4, a.e. 691, Bl. pp. 184–196, at p. 189. Translated by C. Nehring into German and by EG into English. Quoted by Selvage and Nehring p. 109.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 149.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 72–5.Google Scholar
Landgericht Frankfurt am Main [Regional Court for Frankfurt am Main], Urteil In dem Rechtsstreit Malte Rauch …– Kläger – gegen die Bundesrepublik Deutschland, vertreten durch den Bundesbeauftragten für die Unterlagen des Staatssicherheitsdienstes der ehemaligen DDR, Herrn Roland Jahn …– Beklagte – …, [Judgment in the legal dispute Malte Rauch ... - Plaintiff - against the Federal Republic of Germany, represented by the Federal Commissioner for the documents of the State Security Service of the former GDR, Mr. Roland Jahn ... - Defendant - ...], 2 December 2016. 2-03 O 81/15.Google Scholar
Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main [Higher Regional Court for Frankfurt am Main], Beschluss in dem Rechtsstreit Rauch gegen Bundesrepublik Deutschland [Decision in the case of Rauch against the Federal Republic of Germany], 16 November 2017a. 16 U 2/17.Google Scholar
Oberlandesgericht 2017b, p. 16. Translated by EG.Google Scholar
Oberlandesgericht 2017, pp. 10, 14, 18–20. Translated by EG and RHS.Google Scholar
Oberlandesgericht 2017, p. 19. Translated by EG and RHS.Google Scholar
Selvage and Nehring, p. 109.Google Scholar
Grißmer, Julia, [attorney to Malte Rauch], letter to Landgericht Frankfurt am Main [Regional Court for Frankfurt am Main] re. the legal dispute Malte Rauch against the Federal Republic of Germany. 2–03 O 81/15. 29 October 2016, p. 7.Google Scholar
Oberlandesgericht 2017, p. 10.Google Scholar
Grass, Günter, personal communication with Kai Schlüter, 16 April 2009, in Kai Schlüter, Günter Grass im Visier. Die Stasi-Akte[Günter Grass in the sights. The Stasi file], Ch. Links Verlag Berlin 2010, p. 11. Translated by EG and RHS.Google Scholar
Vosoughi, Soroush, Roy, Deb, and Aral, Sinan, “The spread of true and false news online,”
Science
, 9 March 2018, 359:1146–1151.Google Scholar
McCoy, Terrence, “A professor in U.S. is telling Liberians that the Defense Department ‘manufactured’ Ebola,”
Washington Post
, 26 September 2014.Google Scholar
Sudakov, Dmitry, “USA created Ebola virus as biological weapon?” Pravda.ru, 11 August 2014; http://www.pravdareport.com/science/earth/11-08-2014/128247-ebola_biological_weapon-0/; last accessed 5 February 2018.Google Scholar
Geissler and Sprinkle, pp. 76–7.Google Scholar