Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T08:22:31.076Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Is cognitive–behavioural therapy more effective than relaxation therapy in the treatment of anxiety disorders? A meta-analysis

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 October 2017

Jesus Montero-Marin ,
Javier Garcia-Campayo ,
Alba López-Montoyo ,
Edurne Zabaleta-del-Olmo  and
Pim Cuijpers
Jesus Montero-Marin*
Affiliation:
Faculty of Health and Sport Sciences, University of Zaragoza, Huesca, Spain Primary Care Prevention and Health Promotion Research Network (RedIAPP), Zaragoza, Spain
Javier Garcia-Campayo
Affiliation:
Primary Care Prevention and Health Promotion Research Network (RedIAPP), Zaragoza, Spain Miguel Servet University Hospital, University of Zaragoza, Zaragoza, Spain
Alba López-Montoyo
Affiliation:
Departamento de Psicología Básica, Clínica y Psicobiología, Universidad Jaume I, Castellón, Spain
Edurne Zabaleta-del-Olmo
Affiliation:
Institut Universitari d'Investigació en Atenció Primària (IDIAP) Jordi Gol, Barcelona, Spain
Pim Cuijpers
Affiliation:
Department of Psychology, VU University, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
*
Author for correspondence: J. Montero-Marin, E-mail: jmontero@unizar.es
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Background

It is not clear whether relaxation therapies are more or less effective than cognitive and behavioural therapies in the treatment of anxiety. The aims of the present study were to examine the effects of relaxation techniques compared to cognitive and behavioural therapies in reducing anxiety symptoms, and whether they have comparable efficacy across disorders.

Method

We conducted a meta-analysis of 50 studies (2801 patients) comparing relaxation training with cognitive and behavioural treatments of anxiety.

Results

The overall effect size (ES) across all anxiety outcomes, with only one combined ES in each study, was g = −0.27 [95% confidence interval (CI) = −0.41 to −0.13], favouring cognitive and behavioural therapies (number needed to treat = 6.61). However, no significant difference between relaxation and cognitive and behavioural therapies was found for generalized anxiety disorder, panic disorder, social anxiety disorder and specific phobias (considering social anxiety and specific phobias separately). Heterogeneity was moderate (I2 = 52; 95% CI = 33–65). The ES was significantly associated with age (p < 0.001), hours of cognitive and/or behavioural therapy (p = 0.015), quality of intervention (p = 0.007), relaxation treatment format (p < 0.001) and type of disorder (p = 0.008), explaining an 82% of variance.

Conclusions

Relaxation seems to be less effective than cognitive and behavioural therapies in the treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder, and obsessive–compulsive disorder and it might also be less effective at 1-year follow-up for panic, but there is no evidence that it is less effective for other anxiety disorders.

Keywords

Anxiety disorderscognitive–behavioural therapyrelaxation therapymeta-analysis
Type
Review Article
Information
Psychological Medicine , Volume 48 , Issue 9 , July 2018 , pp. 1427 - 1436
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alonso, J and Lepine, JP (2007) Overview of key data from the European Study of the Epidemiology of Mental Disorders (ESEMeD). Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 68, 3–9.Google Scholar
Bandelow, B and Michaelis, S (2015) Epidemiology of anxiety disorders in the 21st century. Dialogues in Clinical Neuroscience 17, 327–335.Google Scholar
Bandelow, B et al. (2015) Efficacy of treatments for anxiety disorders: a meta-analysis. International Clinical Psychopharmacology 30, 183–192.Google Scholar
Begg, CB and Mazumdar, M (1994) Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. Journal of the International Biometric Society 50, 1088–1101.Google Scholar
Bernstein, DA and Borkovec, TD (1973) Progressive Relaxation Training: A Manual for the Helping Professions. Research Press: Illinois.Google Scholar
Borenstein, M et al. (2009) Introduction to Meta-analysis, pp. 409–414. Wiley: UK.Google Scholar
Butler, G et al. (1991) Comparison of behavior therapy and cognitive behavior therapy in the treatment of generalized anxiety disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 59, 167–175.Google Scholar
Chambless, DL and Hollon, SD (1998) Defining empirically supported therapies. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 66, 7–18.Google Scholar
Cohen, J (1988) Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: NJ.Google Scholar
Cuijpers, P et al. (2016) Relative effects of cognitive and behavioral therapies on generalized anxiety disorder, social anxiety disorder and panic disorder: a meta-analysis. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 43, 79–89.Google Scholar
De Jonge, P et al. (2016) Cross-national epidemiology of panic disorder and panic attacks in the world mental health surveys. Journal of Depression and Anxiety 33, 1155–1177.Google Scholar
Duval, S and Tweedie, R (2000) Trim and fill: a simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Journal of the International Biometric Society 56, 455–463.Google ScholarPubMed
Egger, M et al. (1997) Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. British Medical Journal 315, 629–634.Google Scholar
Hayes-Skelton, SA et al. (2013) A contemporary view of applied relaxation for generalized anxiety disorder. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy 42, 292–302.Google Scholar
Hedges, LV (1981) Distribution theory for Glass's estimator of effect size and related estimators. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics 6, 107–128.Google Scholar
Higgins, JPT and Green, S (2011) Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0. (Updated March 2011). The Cochrane Collaboration: Oxford, UK.Google Scholar
Hirschtritt, ME, Bloch, MH and Mathews, CA (2017) Obsessive-compulsive disorder: advances in diagnosis and treatment. JAMA 317, 1358–1367.Google Scholar
Imai, H et al. (2016) Psychological therapies versus pharmacological interventions for panic disorder with or without agoraphobia in adults. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 10, CD011170.Google Scholar
Ioannidis, JPA, Patsopoulos, NA and Evangelou, E (2007) Uncertainty in heterogeneity estimates in meta-analyses. British Medical Journal 335, 914–916.Google Scholar
Kessler, RC et al. (2012) Twelve-month and lifetime prevalence and lifetime morbid risk of anxiety and mood disorders in the United States. International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research 21, 169–184.Google Scholar
Koenen, KC et al. (2017) Posttraumatic stress disorder in the Wold Mental Health Surveys. Psychological Medicine 47, 2260–2274.Google Scholar
Kraemer, HC and Kupfer, DJ (2006) Size of treatment effects and their importance to clinical research and practice. Biological Psychiatry 59, 990–996.Google Scholar
Laupacis, A, Sackett, DL and Roberts, RS (1988) An assessment of clinically useful measures of the consequences of treatment. The New England Journal of Medicine 318, 1728–1733.Google Scholar
Mayo-Wilson, E et al. (2014) Psychological and pharmacological interventions for social anxiety disorder in adults: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. Lancet Psychiatry 1, 368–376.Google Scholar
Moher, D et al. (2010) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. International Journal of Surgery 8, 336–341.Google Scholar
Öst, LG (1987) Applied relaxation: description of a coping technique and review of controlled studies. Behaviour Research and Therapy 25, 397–409.Google Scholar
Pompoli, A et al. (2016) Psychological therapies for panic disorder with or without agoraphobia in adults: a network meta-analysis. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 4, CD011004.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, R (1979) The ‘file-drawer problem’ and tolerance for null results. Psychological Bulletin 86, 638–641.Google Scholar
Ruscio, AM et al. (2008) Social fears and social phobia in the USA: results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Psychological Medicine 38, 15–28.Google Scholar
Ruscio, AM et al. (2017) Cross-sectional comparison of the epidemiology of DSM-5 generalized anxiety disorder across the globe. JAMA Psychiatry 74, 465–475.Google Scholar
Siev, J and Chambless, DL (2007) Specificity of treatment effects: cognitive therapy and relaxation for generalized anxiety and panic disorders. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 75, 513–522.Google Scholar
Skapinakis, P et al. (2016) Pharmacological and psychotherapeutic interventions for management of obsessive-compulsive disorder in adults: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. Lancet Psychiatry 3, 730–739.Google Scholar
Wardenaar, KJ et al. (2017) The cross-national epidemiology of specific phobia in the World Mental Health Surveys. Psychological Medicine 47, 1744–1760.Google Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Montero-Marin et al supplementary material

Montero-Marin et al supplementary material 1

Download Montero-Marin et al supplementary material(File)
File 122.4 KB