Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T21:00:39.067Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Oxford and the Origins of Liberal Catholicism in the Church of England

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

W. R. Ward
W. R. Ward*
Affiliation:
University of Manchester
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The publication of Lux Mundi in 1889 has long been regarded as an important moment in the development of Anglican thought. Equally familiar is the distress which the new turn gave to H. P. Liddon, who could only regard the effort made by the Lux Mundi group to set the Catholic faith in its right relation to modern knowledge as capitulation to the snares of liberalism, and as ultimately fatal to the close coherence of Christian truth. The book represented a new grafting upon the stock of the English Catholic party, and no satisfactory explanation has ever been offered of the reasons why such a theology was produced within the post-Tractarian circle at Oxford. The new outlook involved a wholesale change from the deductive theology of the Tractarians with its imperatives against the world and all those things which liberalism accepted in the world, to an inductive theology which appealed to men for Christ by showing how the best and truest things led up to Him and found fulfilment in Him. At the same time religion appeared now as an interpretation of the world as well as of the Church, and the intense conservatism of Pusey and Keble was replaced by the radicalism of Scott Holland and Gore. The question is first why these new attitudes grew up amongst men who more than any others were conditioned against them by intense religious training, and, secondly, a question regarded by Prestige as inexplicable, how it came about that Liddon was so shocked by a publication which embodied tendencies which had been notorious for twenty years and of which, in a letter to Scott Holland in 1884, he had seemed quite clearly aware.

Type
Research Article
Information
Studies in Church History , Volume 1: Papers read at the first winter and summer meetings of the Ecclesiastical History Society , 1964 , pp. 233 - 252
Copyright
Copyright © Ecclesiastical History Society 1964

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Page 233 of note 1 Henry Scott Holland, Memoir and letters, ed. Stephen, Paget, London 1921, 112 Google Scholar.

Page 234 of note 1 Ramsey, A. M., From Gore to Temple, London 1960, 2 Google Scholar.

Page 234 of note 2 Smith, B. A., Dean Church: the Anglican response to Newman, London 1958, 103 Google Scholar.

Page 235 of note 1 An address to members of the lower division of the house of Convocation on the proposed examination statute, Oxford 1830; Letters and Correspondence of John Henry Newman, ed. Anne, Mozley, London 1891, 1, 200-03, 220Google Scholar; Reply to an expostulatory letter, Oxford 1829; καλοίς κάγαθοἲς, Oxford 1829.

Page 235 of note 2 Quarterly Review, LIX, 474-5.

Page 235 of note 3 The duke’s programme from which he never swerved was set out shortly after he had been installed in office as chancellor; Apsley House MSS, duke of Wellington to vice-chancellor, 27 August 1834.

Page 238 of note 1 B.M. MS Add. 40470, ff. 305-08; printed in Lathbury, C. D., Correspondence on church and religion of W. E. Gladstone, London 1910, 1, 342-7Google Scholar.

Page 239 of note 1 Keble College MSS, Letters of J. Keble to T. Keble, 9 June 1847.

Page 240 of note 1 Apsley House MSS, F. C. Plumpere to duke of Wellington, 16 Aug. 1850; B.M. MS Add. 34578, ff. 123-5; Bodleian Library MS Top Oxon. e 80, ff. 15-19.

Page 240 of note 2 Guardian, 1852, 45.

Page 241 of note 1 Ibid., 1852, 384, 401, 424, 441, 489, 521, 569.

Page 241 of note 2 Ibid., 1852, 696;Christian Remembrancer, XXV, 192-212.

Page 242 of note 1 Ashwell, A. R. and Wilberforce, R. G., Life of Samuel Wilberforce, London 1880-2, 11, 150 Google Scholar; bishop of Oxford to lord Derby, 17 Sept. 1852. MS Knowsley Papers, 156/3.

Page 242 of note 2 Letters of J. B. Mozley, London 1885, 217.

Page 243 of note 1 Pages from the diary of an Oxford lady, ed. Gifford, M. J., Oxford 1932, 20 Google Scholar; Correspondence of Arthur Hugh Clough, ed. Mulhauser, F. L., Oxford 1957, 11, 373 Google Scholar. Cf. B.M. MS Add. 44183 f. 57.

Page 243 of note 2 B.M. MSS Add. 44376, f. 246; 44377, ff. 193, 199; 44230, ff. 278, 283-4, 288: Guardian, 1854, 136.

Page 244 of note 1 Bodleian Library, MS Acland d.68, ff. 8-11. Cf. MS Acland d.69, ff. 30-3.

Page 245 of note 1 Life and Letters of Dean Church, ed. Church, Mary C., London 1895, 171 Google Scholar.

Page 246 of note 1 Denison, G. A., Notes of my life, 1805-78, Oxford & London 1878, 334-7Google Scholar; Guardian, 1864, 684; Keble College MSS, Corr. of E. B. Pusey with J. Keble [1864, soon after 27 July].

Page 246 of note 2 E.g. Guardian, 1865, 460, 498, 716-7.

Page 247 of note 1 Quarterly Review, CXVIII, 193 ff. Cf. Is Mr. Gladstone the right man for Oxford? (n.pl. 1865).

Page 247 of note 2 Urquhart, E. W., The late Oxford University election, London 1865 Google Scholar.

Page 247 of note 3 Johnston, J. O., The life and letters of Henry Parry Liddon, 2nd ed. London 1904, 99 Google Scholar; Liddon House MSS, Liddon Diary, 18 July 1865.

Page 247 of note 4 Liddon, H. P., Life of E. B. Pusey, London 1893-7, IV, 199–200 Google Scholar.

Page 247 of note 5 Guardian, 1866, 1203: Autobiography of Montagu Burrows, ed. Burrows, S. M., London 1908, 209–227 Google Scholar.

Page 248 of note 1 Liddon House MSS, Liddon Diary, 4 Sept. 1866.

Page 249 of note 1 Liddon, , Life ofPusey, IV, 198 Google Scholar; B.M. MS Add. 44281, ff. 352-3.

Page 249 of note 2 Cf.Burrows, M., Pass and Class, Oxford 1860, 143 Google Scholar.

Page 249 of note 3 Talbot, E. S., Memories of my early life, London 1924, 45 Google Scholar.

Page 250 of note 1 Gwendolen, Stephenson, Edward Stuart Talbot 1844-1934, London 1936, 55 Google Scholar.

Page 251 of note 1 Liddon House MSS, Liddon Diary, 20 Dec. 1867; 11 Feb. 1868.

Page 251 of note 2 See e.g. Guardian, 1877, 156, 148; 1879, 1441, 1677; 1880, 713; The Times, 23 May 1879, 9, 10; 27 May, 9; 31 May, 7 (and following numbers); 3 June, 9; 28 April 1880, 7; 16 April 1881, 9.

Page 251 of note 3 Liddon House MSS, Liddon Diary, 6 March 1880; 1 Feb. 1881.