Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-7cvxr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T03:35:28.052Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

England, Britain and the Audit of War (The Prothero Lecture)

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 February 2009

Kenneth O. Morgan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

THE award of the Booker Prize for 1995 to Pat Barker's Ghost Road did more than pay tribute to the latest powerful novel in the author's ‘Regeneration Cycle’. It also emphasised once again how much the historical and cultural consciousness of twentieth-century Britain is dominated by images of war. With the obvious exception of Northern Ireland, Great Britain has been an unusually peaceful and stable country in a century marked by revolution and upheaval. Yet our national experience has been shaped, almost obsessed, by two world wars in a way true of few, if any, other countries. Memories of 1914 and 1939 tower over us like Lutyens's massive monument at Thiepval. The war leaders, David Lloyd George and Winston Churchill, are commonly thought of as our two greatest prime ministers in modern times (though another, more recent, prime minister, victorious in the Falklands, still has her champions). Armistice day, Remembrance Sunday and the wearing of poppies retain their potency as all-powerful national symbols of sacrifice. The British Legion remains an influential pressure group. The eightieth anniversary of the battle of the Somme in July 1996 emphasised anew the enduring impact of the tragedies of the first world war. More generally, the fiftieth anniversaries of VE Day and VJ Day the previous year were nationwide ceremonies of remembrance for the sacrifices of the second. Almost every episode in current history, especially where Europe is involved, is commonly linked with memories of earlier conflict. Even the 1996 crisis in Anglo-German relations, such as it was, arising from ‘mad cow disease’ evoked comparison with 1939.

Type
Research Article
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 7 , December 1997 , pp. 131 - 153
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 1997

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Barker, Pat, Regeneration (1991)Google Scholar; The Eye in the Door (1993); The Ghost Road (1995).

2 Independent, 23 May 1996; Kettle, Martin in Guardian, 23 05 1996Google Scholar.

3 Fussell, Paul, The Great War and Modern Memory 1975)Google Scholar; Winter, Jay, Sites of Memory, Sites of Mourning. The Great War in European Cultural History (Cambridge, 1995)Google Scholar.

4 e.g. Dyer, Geoff, The Missing of the Somme (1996 edn)Google Scholar.

5 Taylor, A. J. P., English History, 1914–1945 (Oxford, 1965), 600Google Scholar.

6 Barnett, C., The Audit of War: The Illusion and Reality of Britain as a Great Nation (new paperback edn, 1996)Google Scholar.

7 Greenberg, Allen, ‘Lutyens' Cenotaph’, Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians, 58, 1 (03 1989), 5–21Google Scholar; Hussey, Christopher, The Life Sir Edwin Lutyens (1984 edn), 391–5Google Scholar.

8 Priestley, J. B., Postscripts 1940), 42Google Scholar; cf. Nicholas, Sian, ‘“Sly Demagogues” and Wartime Radio: J. B. Priestley and the BBC’, 20th Century British History, 6, 3 (1995), esp. 254–61Google Scholar.

9 Cf.Thompson, John A., Reformers and War (Cambridge, 1987)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 See Morgan, Kenneth O., Consensus and Disunity. The Lloyd George Coalition Government, 1918–1922 (Oxford, 1979), 80ffGoogle Scholar.

11 For the Conference, see Lowe, Rodney, ‘The Failure of Consensus in Britain: The National Industrial Conference, 1919–21’, Historical Journal, 21, 3 (09 1978), 649ffGoogle Scholar. More generally, Middlemas, Keith, Politics in Industrial Society (London, 1979), 137ffGoogle Scholar.

12 Conversation between Lloyd George and Briand, London, 21 December 1921, Butler, Rohan and Butler, J. P. T., eds., Documents on British Foreign Policy, 1919‐1939, First Series, XV (London, HMSO, 1967), 786Google Scholar; conversation between Lloyd George and Briand, Cannes, 4 January 1922, W. N. Medlicott, Douglas Dakin and M. E. Lambert, eds., ibid, XIX (London, HMSO, 1974), 7.

13 Skidelsky, Robert, John Maynard Keynes: Hopes Betrayed, 1883–1920 (1983), 360–1Google Scholar. It is unfortunate that the author's analysis of The Economic Consequences of the Peace, particularly its financial arguments, is relatively brief. Keynes, added to the impact of his book with his Essays in Biography (1933)Google Scholar including a celebrated and inaccurate study of Lloyd George, withheld from the Economic Consequences.

14 Law, Bonar, letter in Times, 7 10 1922Google Scholar.

15 Irving, Robert Grant, Indian Summer. Lutyens, Baker and Imperial Delhi (New Haven and London, 1981), 355Google Scholar.

16 There is a vivid account of the departure from Glasgow station in Shinwell, Emanuel, Conflict without Malice 1955), 76–7Google Scholar. Shinwell, member for Linlithgow, was not a Glasgow member himself. For Maxton, see Brown, Gordon, Maxton (Edinburgh, 1986)Google Scholar, and Howell, David, A Lost Left (Manchester, 1986)Google Scholar, for John Maclean.

17 See Ellis, E. L., T.J.: The Life of Dr Thomas Jones C.H. (Cardiff, 1992)Google Scholar.

18 This is printed in George, David Lloyd, From Terror to Triumph (1915), 1–15Google Scholar.

19 On this, see Morgan, Kenneth O., Wales in British Politics, 1868–1922 (3rd edn, Cardiff, 1980)Google Scholar.

20 The only book on the College is Craik, W. W., The Central Labour College (London, 1964)Google Scholar.

21 Morgan, Kenneth O., Modern Wales: Politics, Places and People (Cardiff, 1995), 102ffGoogle Scholar.

22 See Morgan, Jane, Conflict and Order. The Police and Labour Disputes in England and Wales, 1900–1939 (Oxford, 1987)Google Scholar.

23 Professor Rees Davies's inaugural lecture, University of Oxford, delivered 29 February 1995.

24 Fussell, Paul, Wartime (Oxford, 1989), 209ffGoogle Scholar.

25 Kramnick, Isaac and Sheerman, Barry, Harold Laski. A Life on the Left (1993), 467ffGoogle Scholar.

26 Howard, Anthony, ‘We are the Masters Now’, in The Age of Austerity, ed. Sissons, Michael and French, Philip (new edn, Oxford, 1986), 19Google Scholar.

27 Jay, Douglas, The Socialist Case (2nd edn, 1947), 258Google Scholar. To be fair, the author was applying this dictum specifically to education and health.

28 On the other hand, Smith, Harold L., Smith, , ed., War and Social Change. British Society in the second World War (Manchester, 1988), 208ffGoogle Scholar, has argued Pcrsuasively that the status of women in general was not enhanced by the war years.

29 Data in Middleton, Roger, Government versus the Market (1996)Google Scholar.

30 For the neglect of safety regulations, see Supple, Barry, The History of the British Coal Industry, vol. IV, 1913–46 (Oxford, 1987), 426ffGoogle Scholar. In the Gresford, Wrexham, coal disaster in September 1934, 265 miners (including boys) were killed in an explosion. Despite clear evidence of flagrant negligence by the managers, the outcome was that in 1937 there were fines of £15 imposed on each of four charges, and £20 each on four other charges.

31 Tomlinson, Jim, ‘Mr Attlee's Supply-Side Socialism’, Economic History Review, 46, 1 (1993), 1–22Google Scholar. For a fuller treatment, see the same author's Democratic Socialism and Economic Policy. The Attlee years, 1945–1951 (Cambridge, 1996), 68ffGoogle Scholar.

32 Leventhal, Fred, ‘“A Tonic to the Nation”: The Festival of Britain, 1951’, Albion, 27, 3 (Fall 1995), 449–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

33 I cover this episode in some detail in my forthcoming official biography of Lord Callaghan (Oxford, 1997), pp. 560–2. I am indebted to Lord Callaghan, HE Helmut Schmidt, Lord Murray of Epping Forest and Mr Jack Jones for first-hand information.

34 See especially Turner, John, Lloyd George's Secretariat (Cambridge, 1980)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

35 An interesting work is MacKenzie, S. P., Politics and Military Morale (Oxford, 1992)Google Scholar. For the non-radicalizing effect of ABCA classes, see Crang, J. A., ‘Politics on Parade: Army Education and the 1945 General Election’, History, 81, 262 (04 1996), esp. 224–6Google Scholar. For some perceptive comments on the second world war and ideas of ‘heritage’, see Samuel, Raphael, Theatres of Memory (1994), 208Google Scholar.

36 This phrase appears in Franks to Attlee, 15 July 1950 (PRO, PREM 8/1405). See also Danchev, Alex, Oliver Franks, Founding Father (Oxford, 1993), 109ffGoogle Scholar.

37 Churchill to Eisenhower, 21 April 1953, Eisenhower to Churchill, 5 May 1953 (PRO, PREM 11/421).

38 See Barnett, Corelli, The Lost Victory. British Dreams, British Realities, 1945–1950 (1995), 70–102Google Scholar. Attlee's views appear in PRO, CAB 129/1, 1 September 1945, and CAB 131/2, 13 March 1946.

39 For a fuller analysis of the dispute between Gaitskell and Bevan, see Morgan, Kenneth O., Labour in Power, 1945–1951 (Oxford, 1984), 441ffGoogle Scholar.

40 Hennessy, Peter, Never Again (1992), 268Google Scholar.

41 Donoughue, Bernard and Jones, G. W., Herbert Morrison. Portrait of a Politician (1973), 481Google Scholar.

42 e.g. Sir Roger Makins (UK ambassador in Washington) to members of US State Department, 21–2 December 1955 (PRO, FO317/115999), M 1017/14, in the British government, Peter Thorneycroft applied the term ‘fool's paradise’ to the Messina conference and Macmillan spoke scornfully of ‘seismic eruptions’ in Sicily.

43 Evans, Elwyn, Alun Llywelyn-Williams (Cardiff, 1991), 37ffGoogle Scholar.

44 Davies, D. Hywel, The Welsh Nationalist Party, 1922–1945 (Cardiff, 1983), 237ffGoogle Scholar. Lewis was defeated by Professor W.J. Gruffydd, a former member of Plaid Cymru, standing as a Liberal.

45 Calder, Angus, The Myth of the Blitz (1991), 73–4Google Scholar.

46 Harvie, Christopher, ‘Labour in Scotland during the Second World War’, Historical Journal, 26, 4 (12 1983), especially 929–34Google Scholar; and Walker, Graham, Thomas Johnston (Manchester, 1988), 151ffGoogle Scholar.

47 See Harvie, Christopher, The Rise of Regional Europe (1993)Google Scholar.

48 Taylor, A. J. P., The Troublemakers (1957), 178Google Scholar, citing works by Bertrand Russell, Lowes Dickinson, G. P. Gooch and H. N. Brailsford, all members of the Union of Democratic Control during the war.

49 See Roberts, Andrew, ‘Patriotism: The Last Refuge of Sir Arthur Bryant’, in Eminent Churchillians (1993), 287ffGoogle Scholar.

50 See the excellent collective volume, Blake, Robert and Louis, Wm Roger, eds., Churchill (Oxford, 1993)Google Scholar.

51 Watt, D. C., How War Came (1989)Google Scholar; Parker, R. A. C., Chamberlain and Appeasement. British Policy and the Coming of the Second World War (1993)Google Scholar.