A number of items are arranged in a line. At each unit of time one of the items is requested, the i th being requested with probability Pi. We consider rules which reorder the items between successive requests in a fashion which depends only on the position in which the most recently requested item was found. It has been conjectured that the rule which always moves the requested item one closer to the front of the line minimizes the average position of the requested item. An example with six items shows that the conjecture is false.

Suppose that we are given a set of n elements which are to be arranged in some order. At each unit of time a request is made to retrieve one of these elements — the ith being requested with probability Pi. We show that the rule which always moves the requested element one closer to the front of the line minimizes the average position of the element requested among a wide class of rules for all probability vectors of the form P1 = p, P2= · ·· = Pn = (1 – p)/(n − 1). We also consider the above problem when the decision-maker is allowed to utilize such rules as ‘only make a change if the same element has been requested k times in a row', and show that as k approaches infinity we can do as well as if we knew the values of the Pi.