The canopy light extinction coefficient (k) is defined as the exponential decline in the amount of light passing through the leaf layers as a function of leaf area index (LAI). This definition is standard in oil palm breeding trials and models of canopy photosynthesis, where k is sometimes assumed to have a fixed value. The present experiment aims to validate the alleged constancy of k. Therefore, k was inferred from the fractional transmission of photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) and LAI, as obtained from dura x pisifera test crosses of Nigeria and Ghana pisifera origins. The palms were planted at two densities (135 and 160 palms ha−1) in North Sumatra in 2010. At the age of 7.5 years after planting, the area of newly opened leaves approached a maximum. Transmission of PAR remained very low and was only weakly related to k. By contrast, LAI exerted a strong negative effect on k, which generated, under both densities, considerable differences in k between both origins and among pisifera within an origin. The assumption of applying a fixed k value for a certain genotype or palm density, as obtained during leaf expansion at closed canopy, may therefore not be realistic. The present study suggests that the relationship of k with LAI over time merits further investigation, starting just before canopy closure.