The spread of English has created a rich array
of varieties, which are often grouped into a tripartite division:
the ENL, ESL, and EFL of Quirk, or the inner-circle, outer-circle,
and expanding-circle of Kachru. These varieties, especially
ESL, differ among themselves in both form and function. It is
often assumed in the literature that these varieties are autonomous
systems of communication. This article challenges this assumption
by showing that the innovative phonological features of one
ESL variety, the vernacular English spoken in Singapore, cannot
be analyzed without reference to native English. These
change-in-progress features fall into two types: those that
originate in phonemes, and those that originate in words. Social
stigma associated with them poses a formidable barrier to their
stabilization and diffusion, and consequently to their
autonomization. Nonnative English is grammatically dependent
on native English.