1 - The making of a philosophical naturalist

Summary

“The law of the succession of types, although subject to some remarkable exceptions, must possess the highest interest to every philosophical naturalist.” / When Charles Darwin penned these lines in 1837, he was twenty-eight years old, fresh from the Beagle voyage, and a self-described 'philosophical naturalist'. As such, he was engaged neither in natural history nor in natural philosophy. Natural history, in the tradition of the Swedish botanist Linné (Linnaeus), concerned the systematic ordering of animals and plants and the discovery of new species. Natural philosophy, in the tradition of Descartes and Newton, concerned the search for general physical laws. Darwin was aligning himself with investigators whose work fell outside these traditions. Some were interested in a comparative anatomy based on ideal forms - the so-called 'transcendental' anatomists, such as the French zoologist Etienne Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire and his Scottish disciple Robert Knox. Others, such as the geologist Charles Lyell, were interested in building comprehensive theories about the earth and its inhabitants. Philosophical naturalists spoke of various 'laws of life'. They debated the existence of laws, for example, said to relate taxonomic groupings in regular circular arrangements, as in the so-called quinarian system, or to govern organic functions such as the development of the embryo. Another law under discussion was the law of the succession of types.