APPENDIX. NOTE ON DYNAMICAL PRINCIPLES

Summary

Although the day is long past when there could be any serious difference of opinion as to whether a particular solution of a dynamical question is or is not correct, the proper formulation of the principles of Dynamics has been much debated, and especially in recent times.

To a student still at the threshold of the subject the most important thing is that he should acquire as rapidly as possible a system of rules which he can apply without hesitation, and, so far as his mathematical powers will allow, with success, to any dynamical question in which he may be interested. From this point of view it is legitimate, in expounding the subject, to take advantage of such prepossessions which he may have as are serviceable, whilst warning him against others which may be misleading. This is the course which has been attempted in the present work, as in most elementary accounts of the subject.

But if at a later stage the student, casting his glance backwards, proceeds to analyse more closely the fundamental principles as they have been delivered to him, he may become aware that there is something unsatisfactory about them from a formal, and even from a logical standpoint. For instance, it is asserted, as an induction from experience, that the velocity of a body not acted on by any force will be constant in magnitude and direction, whereas the only means of ascertaining whether a body is, or is not, free from the action of force is by observing whether its velocity is constant.