28 - Suffer the Rebellious Children: The Politics of Remaking Singapore and the Remaking of Singapore Politics

Summary

POLITICS OF REMAKING SINGAPORE

When analyzing the Singapore socialpolitical-cultural landscape of their times, contributors to the 1989 volume of Management of Success intimated at “clearly audible murmurs of discontent” and how “de-politicization of the recent past has been replaced by a re-politicization of the citizenry”. Acknowledging the People's Action Party (PAP) government's awareness of these challenges, the book told its readers to expect a policy mix of containment and compromise to deal with a more contentious citizenry. Through much of the 1990s, concerned that growing individualism could spawn a Western-inspired rights-based polity (something the PAP leadership wanted to avoid), official programmes promoted moral education a such as self-discipline, diligence, deference to authority, a readiness to sacrifice self-interest for the greater good of the community, and these were supposed to provide “cultural ballast” against “insidious elements of decadent Western culture”. To be sure, the PAP response also involved a new vision of a liberalized Singapore but the extent of any liberalization policy would be marked by a definition of political stability that must include itself at the helm. Nobody doubted that in the foreseeable future, the authoritarian grip of the PAP would be intact and the editors of the 1989 volume concluded with a cautionary remark that the public demand had not been made for the PAP to relinquish power which will be the true test of democracy. Reflecting the cautiousness, the index in that 1989 book did not have terms such as “civil disobedience”, “dissent”, or their approximation. No analyst then saw a possibility of that kind of restiveness on the horizon. Twenty years down the line, in this successor volume, that lacuna has to be plugged, not least because the starting point of this article is the return of civil disobedience after decades of its near total absence. Examples of such behaviour have picked up momentum in the last three years that the phenomenon cannot pass unnoticed.

If the contributors to the 1989 Management of Success volume did not envisage the kind of restiveness that twenty years would bring with a younger generation of citizens, it is partly because they did not foresee the details of a significant PAP project to remake Singapore.