Overuse of the Criminal Justice System in Taiwan

Summary

INTRODUCTION

In Taiwan, some actions may have been unnecessarily criminalized at the legislative level, and extremely heavy punishments have been imposed on some offences. Furthermore, prosecutors do not have much power to decide whether or not to prosecute certain cases. Therefore, over-prosecution exists in Taiwan's criminal justice system. According to statistical data, overcrowding in prisons has been an issue for a long time. However, the Taiwanese government is aware of the problem and is taking measures to solve it by revising and enacting related statutes. This paper aims to address the problem concerning the overuse of the criminal justice system in Taiwan. In addition, the paper discusses how Taiwan is showing improvements in its attempt to resolve the problem at hand.

OVERUSE OF CRIMINALIZATION

THE ANNUAL NUMBER OF CRIMES

A total of 297,676 crimes occurred in 2015, which involved 270,817 offenders. In the same year, Taiwan's population was 23,492,074, indicating that 1,268.71 cases and 1,154.23 offenders existed per 100,000 people in Taiwan in 2015. From a long-term perspective (2000 to 2015), on average, a total of 423,302 cases (including 231,167 offenders) occurred annually. During that period, the average population was about 22,953,810. Thus, about 1,857.56 cases and 1,006.74 offenders existed per 100,000 Taiwanese annually, on average. The number of cases is greater than that of the offenders because one case means that an offender commits a crime. Therefore, when an offender commits two crimes, it adds up to two cases. The aforementioned data are further presented in Table 1.

One noteworthy observation from Table 1 is that the numbers of offenders have not evidently changed since 2007. In contrast, the number of cases show a consistent decreasing pattern. This means that the law and order situation in Taiwan has shown consistent improvement over the years.

TOP FIVE CRIMES IN TAIWAN

In the past few years, the top five crimes in Taiwan have been quite consistent. In 2014, among all cases sent by the police to the district prosecutor's offices, the most frequently occurring crimes were offences against public safety (10.7%), offences related to narcotics (6.3%), injury (5.0%), larceny (3.9%), and fraud (3.9%).