Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-94fs2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-15T10:49:35.453Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

KAMINALJUYU CHRONOLOGY AND CERAMIC ANALYSIS: AN ALTERNATIVE VIEW

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 December 2017

Michael Love
Michael Love*
Affiliation:
Department of Anthropology, California State University, Northridge, Northridge, CA 91330–8244, USA (michael.love@csun.edu)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Recently, Inomata and colleagues (2014) proposed a revision to Shook and Popenoe de Hatch's (1999) chronology of Kaminaljuyu, recommending a new chronology based on detailed Bayesian analysis of the calibrated dates. In this article, I present data suggesting that Inomata and colleagues' proposed chronology should be viewed with caution, especially with regard to the apogee of Kaminaljuyu, the Verbena and Arenal phases. Furthermore, the impact of their revised chronology is overstated because the model of highland-to-lowland diffusion that they attack has long been moribund.

Recientemente, Inomata y sus colegas (2014) plantean una revisión de la cronología de Kaminaljuyu, Guatemala publicada por Shook y Popenoe de Hatch (1999). Ellos proponen una nueva cronología basada en el análisis Bayesiano de fechas calibradas. Los datos aquí presentados sugieren que la cronología de Inomata y colaboradores debe ser considerada con cautela, especialmente en lo que respecta al apogeo de Kaminaljuyu (fases Verbena y Arenal). Asimismo, los impactos que se derivan de dicha cronología revisada son sobreestimados, porque el modelo de difusión de tierras altas a tierras bajas que los autores discuten ha estado en decadencia desde hace muchos años.

Type
Article
Information
Latin American Antiquity , Volume 29 , Issue 2 , June 2018 , pp. 260 - 278
Copyright
Copyright © 2017 by the Society for American Archaeology 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References cited

Arroyo, Bárbara (editor) 2010 Entre cerros, cafetales, y urbanismo en el valle de Guatemala: Proyecto de Rescate Naranjo. Academía de Geografía e Historia de Guatemala, Guatemala.Google Scholar
Arroyo, Bárbara 2010 Cronología. In Entre cerros, cafetales y urbanismo en el valle de Guatemala: Proyecto de Rescate Naranjo, edited by Arroyo, Bárbara, pp. 185–194. Academia de Geografía e Historia de Guatemala, Guatemala.Google Scholar
Arroyo, Bárbara, and Paiz, Lorena 2010 Cerámica. In Entre cerros, cafetales y urbanismo en el valle de Guatemala: Proyecto de Rescate Naranjo, edited by Arroyo, Bárbara, pp. 103–183. Academia de Geografía e Historia de Guatemala, Guatemala.Google Scholar
Arroyo, Barbara, Ajú Alvarez, Gloria, Rojas, Andrea, Máh, Patricia, Estrada, Javier, Serech, Emanuel, Méndez, Jorge, Reneé Jerez, Maria, and Juárez, Daniel 2014 Kaminaljuyú: Nuevas perspectivas sobre el uso de los espacios. In XXVII Simposio de investigaciones arqueológicos en Guatemala 2013, Vol. 2, edited by Arroyo, Bárbara, Méndez Salinas, Luís, and Rojas, Andrea, pp. 695–706. Ministerio de Cultura y Deportes, Instituto de Antropología e Historia, Asociación Tikal, Guatemala City.Google Scholar
Bayliss, Alex 2015 Quality in Bayesian Chronological Models in Archaeology. World Archaeology 47:677–700.Google Scholar
Bove, Frederick J., Sonia Medrano, B., Brenda Lou, P., and Bárbara Arroyo, L. (editors) 1993 The Balberta Project: The Terminal Formative-Early Classic Transition on the Pacific Coast of Guatemala. No. 6. University of Pittsburgh Department of Anthropology/Tikal Association, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.Google Scholar
Brady, James E., Ball, Joseph W., Bishop, Ronald L., Pring, Duncan C., Hammond, Norman, and Housley, Rupert A. 1998 The Lowland Maya “Protoclassic”: A Reconsideration of its Nature and Significance. Ancient Mesoamerica 9:17–38.Google Scholar
Braswell, Geoffrey 2015 Discussion. Paper presented at the 80th Annual Meeting of the Society for American Archaeology, San Francisco, California.Google Scholar
Braswell, Geoffrey E., and Robinson, Eugenia J. 2011 The Eastern Cakchiquel Highlands During the Preclassic Period: Interaction, Growth, and Depopulation. In The Southern Maya in the Late Preclassic: The Rise and Fall of an Early Mesoamerican Civilization, edited by Love, Michael and Kaplan, Jonathan, pp. 287–315. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Bronk Ramsey, Christopher 2001 Development of the Radiocarbon Calibration Program OxCal. Radiocarbon 43:355–363.Google Scholar
Bronk Ramsey, Christopher 2009 Bayesian Analysis of Radiocarbon Dates. Radiocarbon 51:337–360.Google Scholar
Buck, Caitlin E. 2004 Bayesian Chronological Data Interpretation: Where Now? In Tools for Constructing Chronologies: Crossing Disciplinary Boundaries, edited by Buck, Caitlin E. and Millard, Andrew R., pp. 25–42. Springer, London.Google Scholar
Chinchilla Mazariegos, Oswaldo, Bove, Frederick J., and Vicente Genovez, José 2009 La cronología del período clásico en la Costa Sur de Guatemala y el fechamiento del estilo escultórico Cotzumalguapa. Proceedings of the V Coloquio Pedro Bosch Gimpera. Instituto de Investigaciones Antropológicas.Google Scholar
Clark, John E., and Cheetham, David 2005 Cerámica formativa de Chiapas. In La producción alfarera en el México Antiguo, Vol. I, edited by Merino Carrión, Beatriz Leonor and Cook, Ángel García, pp. 285–433. Colección cientíca, no. 484. Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, México, D.F.Google Scholar
Clark, John E. and Pye, Mary E. 2011 Re-Visiting the Mixe-Zoque: A Brief History of the Preclassic Peoples of Chiapas. In The Southern Maya in the Late Preclassic, edited by Love, Michael and Kaplan, Jonathan, pp. 25–45. Colorado University Press, Boulder.Google Scholar
Coe, Michael D. 1962 Mexico. Praeger, New York.Google Scholar
Cowgill, George L. 2015 We Need Better Chronologies: Progress in Getting Them. Latin American Antiquity 26:26–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Demarest, Arthur A. 1986 The Archaeology of Santa Leticia and the Rise of Maya Civilization. Middle American Research Institute. Tulane University, New Orleans, Louisiana.Google Scholar
Demarest, Arthur A. 1989 The Olmec and the Rise of Civilization in Eastern Mesoamerica. In Regional Perspectives on the Olmec, edited by Sharer, Robert J. and Grove, David C., pp. 303–344. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Demarest, Arthur A. 2011 The Political, Economic, and Cultural Correlates of Late Preclassic Southern Highland Material Culture. In The Southern Maya in the Late Preclassic: The Rise and Fall of an Early Mesoamerican Civilization, edited by Love, Michael and Kaplan, Jonathan, pp. 345–386. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Demarest, Arthur A. 2015 El debate sobre las cronologías preclásicas del mundo Maya: Evidencia, interpretaciones y controversias (comentario). In XXVIII Simposio de investigaciones arqueológicos en Guatemala 2014, Vol. 2, edited by Arroyo, Bárbara, Méndez Salinas, Luís, and Paiz, Lorena, pp. 1201–1207. Ministerio de Cultura y Deportes, Instituto de Antropología e Historia, Asociación Tikal, Guatemala City.Google Scholar
Demarest, Arthur A., and Sharer, Robert J. 1986 Late Preclassic Ceramic Spheres, Cultural Areas, and Cultural Evolution in the Southeastern Highlands of Mesoamerica. In The Southeast Maya Periphery, edited by Urban, Patricia A. and Schortman, Edward M., pp. 194–223. University of Texas Press, Austin.Google Scholar
Efron, Bradley 2013 Bayes' Theory in the 21st Century. Science 340:1177–1178.Google Scholar
Gifford, James C. 1976 Prehistoric Pottery Analysis and the Ceramics of Barton Ramie in the Belize Valley. Memoirs of the Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology 18. Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts.Google Scholar
Guernsey, Julia 2006 Ritual and Power in Stone: The Performance of Rulership in Mesoamerican Izapan Style Art. University of Texas Press, Austin.Google Scholar
Guernsey, Julia 2012 Sculpture and Social Dynamics in Preclassic Mesoamerica. Cambridge University Press, New York.Google Scholar
Guernsey, Julia, and Michael Love 2005 Late Preclassic Expressions of Authority on the Pacific Slope. In Lords of Creation: The Origins of Sacred Maya Kingship, edited by Fields, Virginia M. and Reents-Budet, Dorie, pp. 37–43. Los Angeles County Museum of Art, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Henderson, Lucia R. 2013 Bodies Politic, Bodies in Stone: The Imagery of the Human and the Divine in the Sculpture of Late Preclassic Kaminaljuyú, Guatemala. PhD dissertation, Department of Art and Art History, University of Texas, Austin.Google Scholar
Inomata, Takeshi, Ortiz, Raúl, Arroyo, Bárbara, and Robinson, Eugenia J. 2014 Chronological Revision of Preclassic Kaminaljuyú, Guatemala: Implications for Social Process in the Southern Maya Area. Latin American Antiquity 25:377–408.Google Scholar
Inomata, Takeshi, and Henderson, Lucia R. 2015 Time Tested: Re-thinking Chronology and Sculptural Traditions in Preclassic Southern Mesoamerica. Antiquity 90:456–471.Google Scholar
Kidder, Alfred V. 1961 Archaeological Investigations at Kaminaljuyú, Guatemala. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 105:559–570.Google Scholar
Love, Michael 1993 Ceramic Chronology and Chronometric Dating: Stratigraphy and Seriation at La Blanca, Guatemala. Ancient Mesoamerica 4:17–29.Google Scholar
Love, Michael 2002a Early Complex Society in Pacific Guatemala: Settlements and Chronology of the Río Naranjo, Guatemala. Papers of the New World Archaeological Foundation 66. Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah.Google Scholar
Love, Michael 2002b Ceramic Chronology of Formative Period Western Pacific Guatemala and Its Relationship to Other Regions. In Incidents of Archaeology in Central America and Yucatan: Studies in Honor of Edwin M. Shook, edited by Love, Michael, Hatch, Marion P., and Escobedo, Héctor L., pp. 51–73. University Press of America, Lanham, Maryland.Google Scholar
Love, Michael 2002c Domination, Resistance, and Political Cycling in Formative Pacific Guatemala. In The Dynamics of Power, edited by O'Donovan, Maria, pp. 141–158. Center for Archaeological Investigations Occasional Paper Number 29. University of Southern Illinois, Carbondale.Google Scholar
Love, Michael 2004 Etnicidad, identidad, y poder en la costa del Pacifico en el Preclásico Tardío. In XVI Simposio de la arqueología Guatemalteca, edited by Pedro Laporte, Juan, and Escobedo, Héctor L.. Nacional, Museo. Guatemala, Guatemala.Google Scholar
Love, Michael 2007 Recent Research in the Southern Highlands and Pacific Coast of Mesoamerica. Journal of Archaeological Research 15:275–328.Google Scholar
Love, Michael 2011a Critical Issues in the Southern Maya Region and the Late Preclassic Period. In The Southern Maya in the Late Preclassic: The Rise and Fall of an Early Mesoamerican Civilization, edited by Love, Michael, and Kaplan, Jonathan, pp. 3–23. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Love, Michael 2011b Cities, States and City-State Culture in the Late Preclassic Southern Maya Region. In The Southern Maya in the Late Preclassic: The Rise and Fall of an Early Mesoamerican Civilization, edited by Love, Michael and Kaplan, Jonathan, pp. 47–75. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Love, Michael 2016 Early States in the Southern Maya Region. In The Origins of Maya States, edited by Traxler, Loa P. and Sharer, Robert J., pp. 271–327. University Museum, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Love, Michael, and Castillo, Donaldo 2016 The Pottery of El Ujuxte, Retalhuleu. Manuscript on file, Department of Anthropology, California State University, Northridge.Google Scholar
Lowe, Gareth W. 1977 The Mixe-Zoque as Competing Neighbors of the Early Lowland Maya. In The Origins of Maya Civilization, edited by Adams, Richard E. W., pp. 197–248. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Lowe, Gareth W., Lee, Thomas A. Jr., and Martínez Espinosa, Eduardo 1982 Izapa: An Introduction to the Ruins and Monuments. Papers of the New World Archaeological Foundation Vol. 31. Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah.Google Scholar
Lowe, Gareth W., Ekholm, Susanna M., and Clark, John E. 2013 Middle and Late Preclassic Izapa: Ceramic Complexes and History. Papers of the New World Archaeological Foundation Vol. 73. New World Archaeological Foundation, Provo, Utah.Google Scholar
Mendelsohn, Rebecca R. 2015 Izapa y sus vecinos: Formativo Medio al Clásico Temprano. Paper presented at the Mesa Redonda Kaminaljuyú, Antigua Guatemala, Guatemala.Google Scholar
Mendelsohn, Rebecca R. 2017a Resilience and Interregional Interaction at the Early Mesoamerican City of Izapa: The Formative to Classic Period Transition. PhD dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University at Albany, State University of New York, Albany.Google Scholar
Mendelsohn, Rebecca R. 2017b The Chronology of the Formative to Classic Period Transition at Izapa: A Reevaluation. Latin American Antiquity, https://doi.org/10.1017/laq.2017.56.Google Scholar
Michels, Joseph W., and Wetherington, Ronald K. 1978 The Kaminaljuyu Test Trenches: Component Assemblage and Phasing. In Settlement Pattern Excavations at Kaminaljuyu, Guatemala, edited by Michels, Joseph W., pp. 619–720. The Pennsylvania State University Monograph Series on Kaminaljuyu. University Park, Pennsylvania.Google Scholar
Ohi, Kuniaki (editor) 1994 Kaminaljuyú, Vol. 2. Tobacco and Salt Museum, Tokyo.Google Scholar
Ohi, Kuniaki, Nimani, Hiroshi, Ito, Nobuyuki, Shibata, Shione, and Nakamori, Sho 1994 La cerámica de Kaminaljuyu: Tipología y cronología. In Kaminaljuyu, edited by Kuniaki, Ohi, Vol. 2, pp. 505–523. Tobacco and Salt Museum, Tokyo.Google Scholar
Parsons, Lee A. 1986 The Origins of Maya Art: A Study of the Monumental Sculpture of Kaminaljuyu, Guatemala and the Southern Pacific Coast. Studies in Pre-Columbian Art and Archaeology Publication No. 28. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Pettitt, Paul B., Davies, William, Gamble, Clive S., and Richards, Martin B. 2003 Palaeolithic Radiocarbon Chronology: Quantifying Our Confidence Beyond Two Half-Lives. Journal of Archaeological Science 30:1685–1693.Google Scholar
Popenoe de Hatch, Marion 1987 La importancia de la ceramica utilitaria en arqueología, con observaciones sobre la prehistoria de Guatemala. Anales de geografía e historia de Guatemala Tomo LXI:151–183.Google Scholar
Popenoe de Hatch, Marion 1991 El Protoclásico: Nueva evidencia de Kaminaljuyú. In II Simposio de investigaciones arqueológicas en Guatemala, 1988, edited by Pedro Laporte, Juan, Villagrán de Brady, S., Escobedo, Héctor L., Guerra de González, Dora, and Valdés, Juan A., pp. 82–86. Ministerio de Cultura y Deportes, Instituto de Antropología e Historia, Asociación Tikal, Guatemala.Google Scholar
Popenoe de Hatch, Marion 1993 Análisis de la cerámica: Metodología “Vajilla”. In III Simposio de arqueología Guatemalteca, edited by Pedro Laporte, Juan, Escobedo, Héctor L., and Villagrán de Brady, Sandra, pp. 339–356. Ministerio de Cultura y Deportes, Instituto de Antropología e Historia, Asociación Tikal, Guatemala.Google Scholar
Popenoe de Hatch, Marion 1997 Kaminaljuyú/San Jorge: Evidencia arqueológica de la actividad económica en el Valle de Guatemala 300 a.C. a 300 d.C. Universidad del Valle de Guatemala, Guatemala.Google Scholar
Popenoe de Hatch, Marion 2002 New Perspectives on Kaminaljuyú, Guatemala: Regional Interaction During the Preclassic and Classic Periods. In Incidents of Archaeology in Central America and Yucatán: Studies in Honor of Edwin M. Shook, edited by Love, Michael W., Popenoe de Hatch, Marion, and Escobedo, Héctor L., pp. 277–296. University Press of America, Lanham, Maryland.Google Scholar
Popenoe de Hatch, Marion, Schieber de Lavarreda, Christa, and Orrego Corzo, Miguel 2011 Late Preclassic Developments at Takalik Abaj. In The Southern Maya in the Late Preclassic: The Rise and Fall of an Early Mesoamerican Civilization, edited by Love, Michael, and Kaplan, Jonathan, pp. 203–236. University Press of Colorado, Boulder.Google Scholar
Reimer, Paula J., Bard, Edouard, Bayliss, Alex, Warren Beck, J., Blackwell, Paul G., Bronk Ramsey, Christopher, Buck, Caitlin E., Cheng, Hai, Lawrence Edwards, R., Friedrich, Michael, Grootes, Pieter M., Guilderson, Thomas P., Haflidason, Haflidi, Hajdas, Irka, Hatté, Christine, Heaton, Timothy J., Hoffmann, Dirk L., Hogg, Alan G., Hughen, Konrad A., Felix Kaiser, K., Kromer, Bernd, Manning, Stuart W., Niu, Mu, Reimer, Ron W., Richards, David A., Marian Scott, E., Southon, John R., Staff, Richard A., Turney, Christian S. M., and van der Plicht, Johannes 2013 Intcal13 and Marine13 Radiocarbon Age Calibration Curves 0–50,000 Years Cal BP. Radiocarbon 55:1869–1887.Google Scholar
Robinson, Eugenia J. 2015 El periodo Preclásico Medio del valle de antigua: Cronología y contexto. In XXVIII Simposio de investigaciones arqueológicos en Guatemala 2014, Vol. 2, edited by Arroyo, Bárbara, Méndez Salinas, Luís, and Paiz, L., pp. 1193–2000. Ministerio de Cultura y Deportes, Instituto de Antropología e Historia, Asociación Tikal, Guatemala City.Google Scholar
Robinson, Eugenia, Garnica, Marlen and Braswell, Geoffrey E. 2006 El final del Preclásico: Kaminaljuyu y su periferia oeste. In XIX Simposio de investigaciones arqueológicas en Guatemala, 2005, edited by Pedro Laporte, Juan, Arroyo, Bárbara, and Mejía, Héctor E., pp. 145–155. Ministerio de Cultura y Deportes, Instituto de Antropología e Historia, Asociación Tikal, Fundación Arqueológica del Nuevo Mundo, Guatemala.Google Scholar
Rosenswig, Robert M., López-Torrijos, Ricardo, Antonelli, Caroline E., and Mendelsohn, Rebecca R. 2013 Lidar Mapping and Surface Survey of the Izapa State on the Tropical Piedmont of Chiapas, Mexico. Journal of Archaeological Science 40:1493–1507.Google Scholar
Rosenswig, Robert M., López-Torrijos, Ricardo, and Antonelli, Caroline E. 2015 Lidar Data and the Izapa Polity: New Results and Methodological Issues from Tropical Mesoamerica. Anthropological and Archaeological Sciences 7:487–504.Google Scholar
Rosenswig, Robert M., and Mendelsohn, Rebecca R. 2016 Izapa and the Soconusco Region, Mexico, in the First Millennium A.D. Latin American Antiquity 27:357–377.Google Scholar
Rosenswig, Robert M., Culleton, Brendan, Kennett, Douglas, Lieske, Rosemary, Mendelsohn, Rebecca, and Nunez-Cortez, Yahaira 2017 The Early Occupation of Izapa: Recent Excavations, New Middle Formative Dating and Ceramic Analyses. Ancient Mesoamerica. In press.Google Scholar
Shibata, Shione 1994 Recopilación de la historia de los estudios cronológicos de Kaminaljuyu. In Kaminaljuyu, Vol. 2, edited by Ohi, Kuniaki, pp 73–89. Tobacco and Salt Museum, Tokyo.Google Scholar
Shook, Edwin M., and Kidder, Alfred V. 1952 Mound E-III-3, Kaminaljuyú, Guatemala. Contributions to American Anthropology and History No. 53:33–127. Carnegie Institution of Washington, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Shook, Edwin M., and Popenoe de Hatch, Marion 1999 Las tierras altas centrales: Períodos Preclásico y Clásico. In Epoca Precolombina, Tomo I, Historia General de Guatemala, edited by Popenoe de Hatch, Marion, pp. 289–318. Asociación de Amigos del País, Fundación para la Cultura y el Desarrollo, Guatemala City.Google Scholar
Taché, Karine, and Hart, John P. 2013 Chronometric Hygiene of Radiocarbon Databases for Early Durable Cooking Vessel Technologies in Northeastern North America. American Antiquity 78:359–372.Google Scholar
Taylor, Royal Ervin, and Bar-Yosef, Ofer 2014 Radiocarbon Dating: An Archaeological Perspective. Second ed. Left Coast Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Wetherington, Ronald K. 1978a The Ceramic Chronology of Kaminaljuyú. In The Ceramics of Kaminaljuyú, Guatemala, edited by Wetherington, Ronald K., pp. 115–150. Pennsylvania State University Press, University Park.Google Scholar
Wetherington, Ronald K. 1978b Ceramic Figurines at Kaminaljuyú. In The Ceramics of Kaminaljuyú, Guatemala, edited by Wetherington, Ronald K., pp. 299–400. Pennsylvania State University Press, University Park.Google Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Love supplementary material 1

Supplementary Table

Download Love supplementary material 1(File)
File 41.4 KB
Supplementary material: File

Love supplementary material 2

Supplementary Table

Download Love supplementary material 2(File)
File 24.8 KB
Supplementary material: File

Love supplementary material 3

Supplementary Table

Download Love supplementary material 3(File)
File 39.6 KB
Supplementary material: File

Love supplementary material 4

Supplementary Table

Download Love supplementary material 4(File)
File 41.2 KB