Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-j824f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-15T15:38:55.677Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Interpreting Ancient Maya Civic Plans: Reply to Smith

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2017

Wendy Ashmore  and
Jeremy A. Sabloff
Wendy Ashmore
Affiliation:
Department of Anthropology, University of California, Riverside, CA 92521-0418 (wendy.ashmore@ucr.edu)
Jeremy A. Sabloff
Affiliation:
University of Pennsylvania Museum, 33rd & Spruce Streets, Philadelphia, PA 19104-6324 (jsabloff@ccat.sas.upenn.edu)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In response to Smith’s critique, we situate our work within the scientific method. We review how our hypotheses arose, how and by whom they have been tested, and with what results. Like Smith, we focus on whether Maya civic centers include emphatic expression of a north-south axis, and on the inference of a partially cosmological basis of Maya axial orders. We indicate sources of our inferences and review explicitly the criteria that Smith faults us for having omitted. We reaffirm that these ideas merit further testing, and welcome renewed and expanded collaboration as to the best methods for doing so. In the spirit of collaboration, we offer specific programmatic suggestions for how this inquiry might proceed.

Por responder a la crítica de Smith, situamos nuestras ideas dentro del método científico. Damos cuenta de los principios de nuestras hipótesis, las pruebas de las mismas, y los resultados de estas pruebas. Igual con Smith, examinamos la propuesta expresión enfática de un eje norte-sur, y la inferencia de una fundación cosmológica de los ordenes axiales mayas. Notamos las fuentes de ilación e indicamos los criterios que nos tacha Smith por haber omitido antes. Reafirmamos que vale hacer mas la prueba, y invitamos a colaborar en efectuarla. A este fin, sugremos unos medios iniciales.

Type
Comments
Information
Latin American Antiquity , Volume 14 , Issue 2 , June 2003 , pp. 229 - 236
Copyright
Copyright © 2003 by the Society for American Archaeology.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References Cited

Ashmore, Wendy 1986 Peten Cosmology in the Maya Southeast: An Analysis of Architecture and Settlement Patterns at Classic Quiriguá. In The Southeast Maya Periphery, edited by Patricia A. Urban and Edward M. Schortman, pp. 35‘49. University of Texas Press, Austin.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy 1987 Cobble Crossroads: Gualjoquito Architecture and External Elite Ties. In Interaction on the Southeast Mesoamerican Periphery: Prehistoric and Historic Honduras and El Salvador, edited by Eugenia J. Robinson, pp. 28–48. BAR International Series 327. British Archaeological Reports, Oxford.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy 1989 Construction and Cosmology: Politics and Ideology in Lowland Maya Settlement Patterns. In Word and Image in Maya Culture: Explorations in Language, Writing, and Representation, edited by William F. Hanks and Don S. Rice, pp. 272–286. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy 1991 Site-Planning Principles and Concepts of Directionality Among the Ancient Maya. Latin American Antiquity 2:199–226.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy 1992 Deciphering Maya Site Plans. In New Theories on the Ancient Maya, edited by Elin Danien and Robert J. Sharer, pp. 173–184. Museum Monographs, 77. University of Pennsylvania Museum, Philadelphia.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy 1998 Monumentos Políticos: Sitios, Asentamiento, y Paisaje por Xunantunich, Belice. In Anatomia de una Civilización: Aproximaciones Interdisciplinarias a la Cultura Maya, edited by Andres Ciudad Ruiz, Yolanda Fernández Marquinez, José Miguel García Campillo, Ma. Josefa Iglesias Ponce de León, Alfonso Lacadena García-Gallo, Luis T. Sanz Castro, pp. 161–183. Publ. No. 4. Sociedad Española de Estudios Mayas, Madrid.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy, and Bernard Knapp, A. (editors) 1999 Archaeologies of Landscape: Contemporary Perspectives. Blackwell, Oxford.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy, and Leventhal, Richard M. 1993 Xunantunich Revisited. Paper presented at the Conference on Belize, University of North Florida, Jack sonville.Google Scholar
Ashmore, Wendy, and Sabloff, Jeremy A. 2002 Spatial Orders in Maya Civic Plans. Latin American Antiquity 13:201–216.Google Scholar
Aveni, Anthony F. 1980 Skywatchers of Ancient Mexico. University of Texas Press, Austin.Google Scholar
Aveni, Anthony F. 2002 Skywatchers. University of Texas Press, Austin.Google Scholar
Aveni, Anthony F., Hartung, Horst, and Buckingham, Beth 1978 The Pecked-Cross Symbol in Ancient Mesoamerica. Science 202:267–279.Google Scholar
Bender, Barbara (editor) 1993 Landscape: Politics and Perspectives. Berg, Oxford.Google Scholar
Binford, Lewis R. 1962 Archaeology as Anthropology. American Antiquity 28:217–225.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blanton, Richard E. 1994 Houses and Households: A Comparative Study. Plenum, New York.Google Scholar
Bradley, Richard 1993 Altering the Earth: The Origins of Monuments in Britain and Continental Europe. Monograph Series Number 8. Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, Edinburgh.Google Scholar
Bricker, Victoria 1983 Directional Glyphs in Maya Inscriptions and Codices. American Antiquity 48:347–353.Google Scholar
Brotherston, Gordon 1976 Mesoamerican Description of Space II: Signs for Direction. Ibero-Amerikanisches Archiv N. F. 2 (1):39–42.Google Scholar
Carl, Peter, Kemp, Barry, Laurence, Ray, Coningham, Robin, Higham, Charles, and Cowgill, George L. 2000 Viewpoint: Were Cities Built as Images? Cambridge Archaeological Journal 10:327–365.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coe, Michael D. 1965 A Model of Ancient Community Structure in the Maya Lowlands. Southwestern Journal of Anthropology 21:97–114.Google Scholar
Coggins, Clemency Chase 1967 Palaces and the Planning of Ceremonial Centers in the Maya Lowlands. Unpublished manuscript, Tozzer Library, Peabody Museum, Harvard University.Google Scholar
Coggins, Clemency Chase 1980 The Shape of Time: Some Political Implications of a Four-part Figure. American Antiquity 45:727–739.Google Scholar
Culbert, T. Patrick (editor) 1991 Classic Maya Political History: Hieroglyphic and Archaeological Evidence. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
De Montmollin, Olivier 1989 The Archaeology of Political Structure: Settlement Analysis in a Classic Maya Polity. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Dunning, Nicholas P., Scarborough, Vernon, Valdez, Fred Jr., Luzzadder-Beach, Sheryl, Beach, Timothy, and Jones, John G. 1999 Temple Mountains, Sacred Lakes, and Fertile Fields: Ancient Maya Landscapes in Northwestern Belize. Antiquity 73:650–660.Google Scholar
Fialko, Vilma 1988 Mundo Perdido, Tikal: Un Ejemplo de Complejos de Conmemoración Astronómica. Mayab 4:13–21.Google Scholar
Freidel, David, Scheie, Linda, and Parker, Joy 1993 Maya Cosmos: Three Thousand Years on the Shaman’s Trail. William Morrow, New York.Google Scholar
Fritz, John M., Michell, George, and Nagaraja Rao, M. S. 1984 Where Kings and Gods Meet: The Royal Centre at Vijayanagara, India. University of Arizona Press, Tucson.Google Scholar
Gallareta Negrón, Tomas, Hernández, Lourdes Toscano, and Alvarez, Carlos Pérez 1995 Programa de Investigatión del Proyecto Labná: Temporada de Campo 1995. Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Consejo de Arqueología, Yucatán, Mexico.Google Scholar
Gossen, Gary 1974 Chamulas in the World of the Sun: Time and Space in a Maya Oral Tradition. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Guillemin, George 1968 Development and Function of the Tikal Ceremonial Center. Ethnos 33:1–35.Google Scholar
Hammond, Norman 1981 Settlement Patterns in Belize. In Lowland Maya Settlement Patterns, edited by Wendy Ashmore, pp. 157–186. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Hanks, William F. 1990 Referential Practice: Language and Lived Space Among the Maya. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
Houk, Brett A. 1996 The Archaeology of Site Planning: An Example from the Maya Site of Dos Hombres, Belize. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University of Texas, Austin. University Microfilms, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
Johnston, Kevin J., and Gonlin, Nancy 1998 What Do Houses Mean? Approaches to the Analysis of Classic Maya Commoner Residences. In Function and Meaning in Classic Maya Architecture, edited by Stephen D. Houston, pp. 141–185. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington D.C. Google Scholar
Jones, Christopher 1991 Cycles of Growth at Tikal. In Classic Maya Political History, edited by T. Patrick Culbert, pp. 102–127. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Jones, Christopher, Ashmore, Wendy, and Sharer, Robert J. 1983 The Quiriguá Project: The 1977 Season. In Quiriguá Reports, Volume II, edited by Edward M. Schortman and Patricia A. Urban, Paper No. 6, pp. 1–38. Museum Monograph, 49. The University of Pennsylvania Museum, Philadelphia.Google Scholar
Keller, Angela H. 1995 Testing and Excavation around Sache II and Group C. In Xunantunich Archaeological Project: 1997 Field Season, edited by Richard M. Leventhal, pp. 96–115. Cotsen Institute of Archaeology, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Kuper, Hilda 1972 The Language of Sites in the Politics of Space. American Anthropologist 74:411–425.Google Scholar
Laporte, Juan Pedro, and Fialko, Vilma 1995 Un Reencuentro con Mundo Perdido, Tikal, Guatemala. Ancient Mesoamerica 6:41–94.Google Scholar
Leach, Edmund 1983 The Gatekeepers of Heaven: Anthropological Aspects of Grandiose Architecture. Journal of Anthropological Research 39:243–264.Google Scholar
LeCount, Lisa J., Yaeger, Jason, Leventhal, Richard M., and Ashmore, Wendy 2002 Dating the Rise and Fall of Xunantunich, Belize: A Late and Terminal Classic Lowland Maya Regional Center. Ancient Mesoamerica 13:41–63.Google Scholar
Low, Setha M. 1995 Indigenous Architecture and the Spanish-American Plaza in Mesoamerica and the Caribbean. American Anthropologist 97:748–762.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maca, Allan L. 1999 The Urban Panorama of a Classic Maya Center: Site Planning at 8th Century Copán. Paper presented at the First Annual Graduate Symposium, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia.Google Scholar
Maca, Allan L. 2002 Spatio-temporal Boundaries in Classic Maya Settlement Systems: Copán’s Urban Foothills and the Excavations at Group 9J-5. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, Harvard University. University Microfilms, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
Marcus, Joyce 1983 On the Nature of the Mesoamerican City. In Prehistoric Settlement Patterns: Essays in Honor of Gordon R. Willey, edited by Evon Z. Vogt and Richard M. Leventhal, pp. 195–242. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque, and Peabody Museum, Harvard University, Cambridge MA.Google Scholar
Marcus, Joyce 1992 Mesoamerican Writing Systems: Propaganda, Myth, and History in Four Ancient Civilizations. Princeton University Press, Princeton.Google Scholar
Martin, Simon, and Grube, Nikolai 2000 Chronicle of the Maya Kings and Queens: Deciphering the Dynasties of the Ancient Maya. Thames and Hudson, London.Google Scholar
Moore, Jerry D. 1992 Pattern and Meaning in Prehistoric Peruvian Architecture: The Architecture of Social Control in the Chimu State. Latin American Antiquity 3:95–113.Google Scholar
O’Connor, David 1989 City and Palace in New Kingdom Egypt. Cahier de Recherches de l’Institut de Papyrologíe et d’Egyptologie de Lille. Societes urbaines en Egypte et au Soudan, 11:73–87.Google Scholar
Prem, Hanns 2000 ¿Detrás de qué Esquina Se Esconde la Ideología? In Arquitectura e Ideología de los Antiguos Mayas: Memoria de la Segunda Mesa Redonda de Palenque, edited by Silvia Trejo, pp. 55–70. CONACULTA/Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico.Google Scholar
Preucel, Robert W. 1991 The Philosophy of Archaeology. In Processual and Postprocessual Archaeologies: Multiple Ways of Knowing the Past, edited by Robert W. Preucel, pp. 17–29. Occasional Paper, 10. Center for Archaeological Investigations, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale.Google Scholar
Preucel, Robert W. 2000 Making Pueblo Communities: Architectural Discourse at Kotyiti, New Mexico. In The Archaeology of Communities: A New World Perspective, edited by Marcello A. Canuto and Jason Yaeger, pp. 58–77. Routledge, London.Google Scholar
Rapoport, Amos 1982 The Meaning of the Built Environment: A Nonverbal Communication Approach. Sage, Beverly Hills.Google Scholar
Robin, Cynthia 2002 Outside of Houses: the Practices of Everyday Life at Chan Nóohol, Belize. Journal of Social Archeology 2:245–268.Google Scholar
Sabloff, Jeremy A., and Ashmore, Wendy 2001 An Aspect of Archaeology’s Recent Past and its Relevance in the New Millennium. In Archaeology at the Millennium: A Sourcebook, edited by Gary M. Feinman and T. Douglas Price, pp. 11–32. Kluwer Academic/Plenum, New York.Google Scholar
Scheie, Linda, and Mathews, Peter 1998 The Code of Kings: The Language of Seven Sacred Maya Temples and Tombs. Scribner, New York.Google Scholar
Sharer, Robert J., Fash, William L., Sedat, David W., Traxler, Loa P., and Williamson, Richard 1999 Continuities and Contrasts in Early Classic Architecture of Central Copan. In Mesoamerican Architecture as a Cultural Symbol, edited by Jeff Karl Kowalski, pp. 220–249. Oxford University Press, Oxford.Google Scholar
Steinhardt, Nancy Shatzman 1986 Why Were Chang’an and Beijing so Different? Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 45:339–357.Google Scholar
Thompson, J. Eric S. 1960 Maya Hieroglyphic Writing: An Introduction. 2nd edition. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.Google Scholar
Tourtellot, Gair, Wolf, Marc, Smith, Scott, Gardella, Kristen, and Hammond, Norman 2002 Exploring Heaven on Earth: Testing the Cosmological Model at La Milpa, Belize. Antiquity 76:633–634.Google Scholar
Tozzer, Alfred M. (translator and editor) 1941 Landa’s Relación de las Cosasde Yucatan. Papers of the Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology, 18. Harvard University, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Webster, David 1999 The Archaeology of Copán, Honduras. Journal of Anthropological Research 7:1–53.Google Scholar