People out of Place: Globalization, Human Rights, and the
Citizenship Gap. Edited by Alison Brysk and Gershon Shafir. New York:
Routledge, 2004. 272p. $75.00 cloth, $24.95 paper.
The original essays in this anthology make a significant contribution
to the ongoing debates about citizenship, human rights, and the future of
the nation-state by exploring the contradictory impacts of globalization
on the provision of individual rights. On the one hand, the transnational
flows of people, capital, and technology associated with globalization
have led to a deflation of citizenship rights, particularly for members of
vulnerable groups, and created large noncitizen populations with
significantly fewer rights than citizens. Yet on the other hand, the
cosmopolitan aspects of globalization, such as the evolution of human
rights and the expansion of liberal legal norms, create new levels of
membership and new venues in which to claim rights. The book has two
related goals. The first is to describe the complicated processes by which
globalization is altering the nature of nation-state citizenship and
creating a “citizenship gap” among global elites, legal
citizens, marginalized citizens, and migrants. The volume's second
goal is to determine whether the cosmopolitan aspects of globalization can
remedy the citizenship gap. Will existing nation-state citizenship and
emerging universal rights regimes be sufficient to protect the rights of
marginalized citizens and noncitizens? Or must human rights be embedded in
global governance in order to close the citizenship gap?