International Democracy and the West: The Role of Governments,
Civil Society, and Multinational Business. By Richard Youngs. New
York: Oxford University Press, 2004. 232p. $99.00.
In his seminal article published nearly 30 years ago, cleverly called
“Second Image Reversed,” Peter Gourevitch outlined a set of
arguments for why and how to study the international causes of domestic
outcomes. This framework had a profound effect on several literatures, but
only a minor ripple in the study of regime change. A handful of
international relations scholars, including John Owen and Mark Peceny,
have made important contributions to this field, and a smattering of
comparativists have added the international dimension to their list of
independent variables that influence regime type, but the subject could
not be considered a mainstream field. In fact, the third-wave
transitologists gave only passing attention to the international
dimensions of democratization. Laurence Whitehead did write an important
chapter on international dimensions of democratization in the four-volume
study on transitions from autocratic rule edited by Louillermo
O'Donnell, Philippe C. Schmitter, and Lawrence Whitehead. Yet, in one
of the introductory essays in this study, Schmitter wrote that one
“of the firmest conclusions that emerged … was that
transitions from authoritarian rule and immediate prospects for political
democracy were largely to be explained in terms of national forces and
calculations. External actors tended to play an indirect and usually
marginal role” (in O'Donnell, Schmitter, and Whitehead, eds.,
Transitions from Authoritarian Rule: Southern Europe, 1986, p.
5). Scholars and policy analysts writing about democratization after the
end of the Cold War have devoted more attention to international factors,
yet the subject is still grossly neglected. This absence of scholarship is
all the more surprising given the foreign policy debates in Washington,
Brussels, Moscow, and Tehran about the role the United States in fostering
“regime change.”