Pathways to Prohibition: Radicals, Moderates, and Social Movement
Outcomes. By Ann-Marie E. Szymanski. Durham, NC: Duke University
Press, 2003. 344p. $89.95 cloth, $24.95 paper.
In this book, Ann-Marie Szymanski achieves what may have been an
unintended goal: She demonstrates that the success of a social movement
that seeks transformative public policy depends on both the
development of flexible, highly adaptative strategies for local reforms
and the emergence of opportune conditions for the
consolidation of local successes into national—in this case,
constitutional—reform. Her study of Prohibition politics and
organizational strategies crafted over time brings together insights
from new institutionalists who explain how the unique interests of
governmental agencies and “states” shape policy outcomes,
as well as from political scientists whose studies on the relationships
between ideologies, political strategies, and small group dynamics have
generated varied pressures for policy reform. If the social movement
theorists pay attention to this study, they will enlarge their
perspectives, build more sophisticated models, do more comprehensive
research, and explain more fully and accurately how social movements
actually generate successful political reforms.