Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-lj6df Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T12:39:17.713Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Photovoice method with older persons: a review

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 March 2019

Yuliya Mysyuk*
Affiliation:
Department of Epidemiology & Biostatistics, Amsterdam UMC, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Martijn Huisman
Affiliation:
Department of Epidemiology & Biostatistics, Amsterdam UMC, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands Department of Sociology, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
*
*Corresponding author. Email: y.mysyuk@vumc.nl

Abstract

For a long time researchers have used photography for different purposes, in different ways and with different focus. Photovoice is a qualitative visual research method that refers to photographs taken by the participants themselves. It has been used with different age groups and populations. The use of photovoice in older populations requires its own study of approaches, techniques and challenges. In this article, we review existing studies using photovoice with older participants specifically, to consider its potential as a qualitative research method in the field of gerontology. We discuss advantages and limitations of the method in gerontological research and provide guidelines for future studies. Our results show that photovoice has been used to study a wide range of topics in older people, from health issues and the impact of environment on health and wellbeing, to leisure experiences of groups living with HIV/AIDS. Using photovoice helps researchers to capture live experiences and perceptions of older persons and conduct engaging, involving and empowering research facilitating interaction, reflection and connection of participants. However, conducting photovoice studies can be practically challenging, such as when addressing special needs of the participants, or ethical and other feasibility issues. To conclude, photovoice has great potential for being used in gerontological research, it can be altered to fit specific goals, divergent issues studied and different research contexts.

Type
Review Article
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Adams, S, Savahl, S and Fattore, T (2017) Children's representations of nature using photovoice and community mapping: perspectives from South Africa. International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Well-being 12, 122.10.1080/17482631.2017.1333900CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Adekeye, O, Kimbrough, J, Obafemi, B and Strack, RW (2014) Health literacy from the perspective of African immigrant youth and elderly: a PhotoVoice project. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved 25, 17301747.10.1353/hpu.2014.0183CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Akkerman, A, Janssen, CG, Kef, S and Meininger, HP (2014) Perspectives of employees with intellectual disabilities on themes relevant to their job satisfaction. An explorative study using photovoice. Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities 27, 542554.10.1111/jar.12092CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Alexander, SA, Frohlich, KL and Fusco, C (2014) Problematizing “play-for-health” discourses through children's photo-elicited narratives. Qualitative Health Research 24, 13291341.10.1177/1049732314546753CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Allotey, P, Reidpath, D, Kouame, A and Cummins, R (2003) The DALY, context and the determinants of the severity of disease: an exploratory comparison of paraplegia in Australia and Cameroon. Social Science & Medicine 57, 949958.10.1016/S0277-9536(02)00463-XCrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Andonian, L and MacRae, A (2011) Well older adults within an urban context: strategies to create and maintain social participation. British Journal of Occupational Therapy 74, 211.10.4276/030802211X12947686093486CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Andress, L, Hallie, SS and Lee, A (2017) Co-constructing food access issues: older adults in a rural food environment in West Virginia develop a photonarrative. Cogent Medicine 4, 1309804.10.1080/2331205X.2017.1309804CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Angelo, J and Egan, R (2015) Family caregivers voice their needs: a photovoice study. Palliative & Supportive Care 13, 70–12.10.1017/S1478951514000522CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Annear, MJ, Cushman, G, Gidlow, B, Keeling, S, Wilkinson, T and Hopkins, H (2014) A place for visual research methods in the field of leisure studies? Evidence from two studies of older adults’ active leisure. Leisure Studies 33, 618643.10.1080/02614367.2013.841743CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baker, T and Wang, C (2006) Photovoice: use of a participatory action research method to explore the chronic pain experience in older adults. Qualitative Health Research 16, 14051413.10.1177/1049732306294118CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Balbale, SN, Schwingel, A, Chodzko-Zajko, W and Huhman, M (2014) Visual and participatory research methods for the development of health messages for underserved populations. Health Communication 29, 728740.10.1080/10410236.2013.800442CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Balmer, C, Griffiths, F and Dunn, J (2015) A review of the issues and challenges involved in using participant-produced photographs in nursing research. Journal of Advanced Nursing 71, 17261737.10.1111/jan.12627CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Banks, M (2001) Visual Methods in Social Research. London: Sage.10.4135/9780857020284CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bell, S and Menec, V (2015) ‘You don't want to ask for the help.’ The imperative of independence: is it related to social exclusion? Journal of Applied Gerontology 34, 121.10.1177/0733464812469292CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Blair, T and Minkler, M (2009) Participatory action research with older adults: key principles in practice can be used in general. Gerontologist 49, 651662.10.1093/geront/gnp049CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Breeden, LE (2016) Occupational therapy home safety intervention via telehealth. International Journal of Telerehabilitation 8, 2940.10.5195/IJT.2016.6183CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Cabassa, LJ, Nicasio, A and Whitley, R (2013 a) Picturing recovery: a photovoice exploration of recovery dimensions among people with serious mental illness. Psychiatric Services 64, 837842.10.1176/appi.ps.201200503CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Cabassa, LJ, Parcesepe, A, Nicasio, A, Baxter, E, Tsemberis, S and Lewis-Fernandez, R (2013 b) Health and wellness photovoice project: engaging consumers with serious mental illness in health care interventions. Qualitative Health Research 23, 618630.10.1177/1049732312470872CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Castleden, H, Garvin, T and Huu-ay-aht First Nation (2008) Modifying Photovoice for community-based participatory Indigenous research. Social Science & Medicine 66, 13931405.10.1016/j.socscimed.2007.11.030CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Catalani, C and Minkler, M (2010) Photovoice: a review of the literature in health and public health. Health Education & Behavior 37, 424451.10.1177/1090198109342084CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Chalfen, R (2011) Differentiating practices of participatory visual media production. In Margolis, E and Pauwels, L (eds), The Sage Handbook of Visual Research Methods. London: Sage, pp. 186200.10.4135/9781446268278.n10CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chan, AW, Chan, HY, Chan, IK, Cheung, BY and Lee, DT (2016) An age-friendly living environment as seen by Chinese older adults: a ‘photovoice’ study. International Journal of Environmental Research in Public Health 13, 19.10.3390/ijerph13090913CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Chaudhury, H, Mahmood, A, Michael, YL, Campo, M and Hay, K (2012) The influence of neighborhood residential density, physical and social environments on older adults’ physical activity: an exploratory study in two metropolitan areas. Journal of Aging Studies 26, 3543.10.1016/j.jaging.2011.07.001CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Collier, J (1957) Photography in anthropology: a report on two experiments. American Anthropologist 59, 843859.Google Scholar
Collier, J and Collier, M (1986) Visual Anthropology: Photography as a Research Method, revised and expanded edition. Albuquerque, NM: University of New Mexico Press.Google Scholar
Collins, ML, Baiardi, JM, Tate, NH and Rouen, PA (2015) Exploration of social, environmental, and familial influences on the sexual health practices of urban African American adolescents. Western Journal of Nursing Research 37, 14411457.10.1177/0193945914539794CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Epstein, I, Aligato, A, Krimmel, T and Mihailidis, A (2016) Older adults’ and caregivers’ perspectives on in-home monitoring technology. Journal of Gerontological Nursing 42, 4350.10.3928/00989134-20160308-02CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Fisher-McLean, KL (2017) Images of Community Crime in Ferguson, Missouri: Older Adults’ Perspectives Prior to July 2014. ProQuest Information & Learning. Available at https://mospace.umsystem.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/10355/49090/research.pdf?sequence=2&isAllowed=y/.Google Scholar
Fitzgerald, E, Bunde-Birouste, A and Webster, E (2009) Through the eyes of children: engaging primary school-aged children in creating supportive school environments for physical activity and nutrition. Health Promotion Journal of Australia 20, 127132.10.1071/HE09127CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Flum, MR, Siqueira, CE, DeCaro, A and Redway, S (2010) Photovoice in the workplace: A participatory method to give voice to workers to identify health and safety hazards and promote workplace change-a study of university custodians. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 53, 11501158.10.1002/ajim.20873CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Fitzpatrick, AL, Steinman, LE, Tu, SP, Ly, KA, Ton, TG, Yip, MP and Sin, MK (2012) Using photovoice to understand cardiovascular health awareness in Asian elders. Health Promotion Practice 13, 4854.10.1177/1524839910364381CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Frith, H and Harcourt, D (2007) Using photographs to capture women's experiences of chemotherapy: reflecting on the method. Qualitative Health Research 17, 13401350.10.1177/1049732307308949CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Fritz, H and Cutchin, MP (2017) Changing neighborhoods and occupations: experiences of older African-Americans in Detroit. Journal of Occupational Science 24, 140151.10.1080/14427591.2016.1269296CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Garner, SL and Faucher, MA (2014) Perceived challenges and supports experienced by the family caregiver of the older adult: a photovoice study. Journal of Community Health Nursing 31, 6374.10.1080/07370016.2014.901070CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Genoe, MR and Dupuis, SL (2014) The role of leisure within the dementia context. Dementia (London) 13, 3358.10.1177/1471301212447028CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Gosselink, CA and Myllykangas, SA (2007) The leisure experiences of older US women living with HIV/AIDS. Health Care Women International 28, 320.10.1080/07399330601001402CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Graziano, KJ (2004) Oppression and resiliency in a post-apartheid South Africa: unheard voices of Black gay men and lesbians. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology 10, 302316.10.1037/1099-9809.10.3.302CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Han, CS and Oliffe, JL (2016) Photovoice in mental illness research: a review and recommendations. Health (London) 20, 110126.10.1177/1363459314567790CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Harper, D (2002) Talking about pictures: a case for photo elicitation. Visual Studies 17, 1326.10.1080/14725860220137345CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hergenrather, K (2009) Photovoice as community-based participatory research: a qualitative review. American Journal of Behaviour 33, 686699.Google ScholarPubMed
Heslop, CW, Burns, S, Lobo, R and McConigley, R (2017) Developing a framework for community-based sexual health interventions for youth in the rural setting: protocol for a participatory action research study. BMJ Open 7, e013368.10.1136/bmjopen-2016-013368CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hopkins, H (2010) Nature Rich Settings and Healthy Ageing: Older Women in Urban Parks (Thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy), New Zealand: Lincoln University. New Zealand Available at http://hdl.handle.net/10182/2735.Google Scholar
Jones, B, Ingham, TR, Cram, F, Dean, S and Davies, C (2013) An indigenous approach to explore health-related experiences among Maori parents: the Pukapuka Hauora asthma study. BMC Public Health 13, 228.10.1186/1471-2458-13-228CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Jurkowski, JM (2008) Photovoice as participatory action research tool for engaging people with intellectual disabilities in research and program development. Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disability 46, 111.10.1352/0047-6765(2008)46[1:PAPART]2.0.CO;2CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Jurkowski, JM, Rivera, Y. and Hammel, J (2009) Health perceptions of Latinos with intellectual disabilities: the results of a qualitative pilot study. Health Promotion Practice 10, 144155.10.1177/1524839907309045CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kantrowitz-Gordon, I and Vandermause, R (2015) Metaphors of distress: photoelicitation enhances a discourse analysis of parents' accounts. Qualitative Health Research, 26, 10311043.10.1177/1049732315575729CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Killion, CM and Wang, CC (2000) Linking African American mothers across life stage and station through photovoice. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved 11, 310325.10.1353/hpu.2010.0816CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kingery, FP, Naanyu, V, Allen, W and Patel, P (2016) Photovoice in Kenya: sing a community-based participatory research method to identify health needs. Qualitative Health Research 26, 92104.10.1177/1049732315617738CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kohon, J and Carder, P (2014) Exploring identity and aging: auto-photography and narratives of low income older adults. Journal of Aging Studies 30, 4755.10.1016/j.jaging.2014.02.006CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lal, S, Jarus, T and Suto, MJ (2012) A scoping review of the Photovoice method: implications for occupational therapy research. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy 79, 181190.10.2182/cjot.2012.79.3.8CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
LeClerc, CM, Wells, DL, Craig, D and Wilson, JL (2002) Falling short of the mark: tales of life after hospital discharge. Clinical Nursing Research 11, 242263.10.1177/10573802011003002CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Leibing, A, Guberman, N and Wiles, J (2016) Liminal homes: older people, loss of capacities, and the present future of living spaces. Journal of Aging Studies 37, 1019.10.1016/j.jaging.2015.12.002CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Leipert, BD, McWilliam, C, Kelley, M, Forbes, D, Wakewich, P and George, J (2012) Rural women's health promotion needs and resources: a photovoice perspective. In Kulig, J and Williams, E (eds), Health in Rural Canada. Vancouver: University of British Colombia, pp. 481501.10.3138/9781442662513CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leipert, BD and Smith, J (2008) Using photovoice to explore rural older women's health promotion needs and resources. In Armstrong, P and Deadman, J (eds), Women's Health: Intersections of Policy, Research, and Practice. Toronto: Women's Press, pp. 135150.Google Scholar
Levin, T, Scott, BM, Borders, B, Hart, K, Lee, J and Decanini, A (2007) Aphasia talks: photography as a means of communication, self-expression, and empowerment in persons with aphasia. Topics in Stroke Rehabilitation 14, 7284.10.1310/tsr1401-72CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lewinson, T and Esnard, A-M (2015) Resource accessibility and walkability among older adults in extended-stay hotels. Journal of Housing for the Elderly 29, 396418.10.1080/02763893.2015.1055030CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lewinson, T, Robinson-Dooley, V and Grant, KW (2012) Exploring ‘home’ through residents’ lenses: assisted living facility residents identify homelike characteristics using photovoice. Journal for Gerontological Social Work 55, 745756.10.1080/01634372.2012.684758CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lockett, D, Willis, A and Edwards, N (2005) Through seniors’ eyes: an exploratory qualitative study to identify environmental barriers to and facilitators of walking. Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 37, 4865.Google ScholarPubMed
Lykes, MB, Blanche, MT and Hamber, B (2003) Narrating survival and change in Guatemala and South Africa: the politics of representation and a liberatory community psychology. American Journal of Community Psychology 31, 7990.10.1023/A:1023074620506CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mahmood, A, Chaudhury, H, Michael, YL, Campo, M, Hay, K and Sarte, A (2012) A photovoice documentation of the role of neighborhood physical and social environments in older adults’ physical activity in two metropolitan areas in North America. Social Science & Medicine 74, 11801192.10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.12.039CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Martin, N, Garcia, A and Leipert, B (2010) Photovoice and its potential use in nutrition and dietetic research. Canadian Journal of Dietetic Practice and Research 71, 9397.10.3148/71.2.2010.93CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Mitra, R, Siva, H and Kehler, M (2015) Walk-friendly suburbs for older adults? Exploring the enablers and barriers to walking in a large suburban municipality in Canada. Journal of Aging Studies 35, 1019.10.1016/j.jaging.2015.07.002CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morrison, T and Thomas, R (2014) Survivors’ experiences of return to work following cancer: a photovoice study. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy 81, 163172.10.1177/0008417414534398CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Morrison, T and Thomas, R (2015 a) Comparing men's and women's experiences of work after cancer: a photovoice study. Supportive Care in Cancer 23, 30153023.10.1007/s00520-015-2670-4CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Morrison, T and Thomas, R (2015 b) Cancer survivors’ concealment or disclosure of diagnosis: implications for return to work. Work 52, 643655.Google ScholarPubMed
Neill, C, Leipert, BD, Garcia, AC and Kloseck, M (2011) Using photovoice methodology to investigate facilitators and barriers to food acquisition and preparation by rural older women. Journal of Nutrition in Gerontology and Geriatrics 30, 225247.10.1080/21551197.2011.591268CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Novek, S and Menec, VH (2014) Older adults’ perceptions of age-friendly communities in Canada: a photovoice study. Ageing & Society 34, 10521072.10.1017/S0144686X1200150XCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Novek, S, Morris-Oswald, T and Menec, V (2012) Using photovoice with older adults: some methodological strengths and issues. Ageing & Society 32, 451470.10.1017/S0144686X11000377CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oliffe, JL and Bottorff, JL (2007) Further than the eye can see? Photo elicitation and research with men. Qualitative Health Research 17, 850858.10.1177/1049732306298756CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oliffe, JL, Bottorff, JL, Kelly, M and Halpin, M (2008) Analyzing participant produced photographs from an ethnographic study of fatherhood and smoking. Research in Nursing & Health 31, 529539.10.1002/nur.20269CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Outcalt, L (2013) Paid companions: a private care option for older adults. Canadian Journal on Ageing 32, 87102.10.1017/S0714980813000093CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Panazzola, P and Leipert, B (2013) Exploring mental health issues of rural senior women residing in southwestern Ontario, Canada: a secondary analysis photovoice study. Rural and Remote Health 13, 2320.Google ScholarPubMed
Prosser, J and Schwartz, D (1998) Photographs within the sociological research process. In Prosser, J (ed.), Image Based Research. London: Palmer Press, pp. 115130.Google Scholar
Rodriguez, PI, Dean, J, Kirkpatrick, S, Berbary, L and Scott, S (2016) Exploring experiences of the food environment among immigrants living in the Region of Waterloo, Ontario. Canadian Journal of Public Health 107, 5310.10.17269/CJPH.107.5310CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Ronzi, S, Pope, D, Orton, L and Bruce, N (2016) Using photovoice methods to explore older people's perceptions of respect and social inclusion in cities: opportunities, challenges and solutions. SSM-Population Health 2, 732–45.10.1016/j.ssmph.2016.09.004CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rosen, D, Goodkind, S and Smith, ML (2011) Using Photovoice to identify service needs of older African American methadone clients. Journal of Social Service Research 37, 526538.10.1080/01488376.2011.607369CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rush, KL, Murphy, MA and Kozak, JF (2012) A photovoice study of older adults’ conceptualizations of risk. Journal of Aging Studies 26, 448458.10.1016/j.jaging.2012.06.004CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Sanon, MA, Evans-Agnew, RA and Boutain, DM (2014) An exploration of social justice intent in photovoice research studies from 2008 to 2013. Nursing Inquiry 21, 212226.10.1111/nin.12064CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Schwingel, A, Linares, DE, Galvez, P, Adamson, B, Aguayo, L, Bobitt, J, Castañeda, Y, Sebastião, E and Marquez, DX (2015) Developing a culturally sensitive lifestyle behavior change program for older Latinas. Qualitative Health Research 25, 17331746.10.1177/1049732314568323CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Sims-Gould, J, Hurd Clarke, L, Ashe, MC, Naslund, J and Liu-Ambrose, T (2010) Renewal, strength and commitment to self and others: older women's reflections of the benefits of exercise using Photovoice. Qualitative Research in Sport and Exercise 2, 250266.10.1080/19398441.2010.488032CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stinson, DL (2010) This ain't something you can pray away: grandparents raising grandchildren, a photovoice project. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved 21, 125.10.1353/hpu.0.0262CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Strauss, A and Corbin, J (1990) Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques. Sage, CA: Newbury Park.Google Scholar
Thomas, M (2009) Auto-photography. Columbus, OH: The Ohio State University.10.1016/B978-008044910-4.00406-5CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thornton, MJ (2015) Exploring home in the context of health for the oldest old (Thesis submitted in partial fulfillment for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy), University of Colorado, US.Google Scholar
Tishelman, C, Lindqvist, O, Hajdarevic, S, Rasmussen, BH and Goliath, I (2016) Beyond the visual and verbal: using participant-produced photographs in research on the surroundings for care at the end-of-life. Social Science & Medicine 168, 120129.10.1016/j.socscimed.2016.09.012Google ScholarPubMed
van Hees, S, Horstman, K, Jansena, M and Ruwaard, D (2017) Photovoicing the neighbourhood: understanding the situated meaning of intangible places for ageing-in-place. Health & Place 48, 1119.10.1016/j.healthplace.2017.08.007CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wang, C and Burris, M (1994) Empowerment through Photo novella: portraits of participation. Health Education Quarterly 21, 171186.10.1177/109019819402100204CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wang, C and Burris, MA (1997) Photovoice: concept, methodology, and use for participatory needs assessment. Health Education and Behaviour 24, 369387.10.1177/109019819702400309Google ScholarPubMed
Wang, CC, Morrel-Samuels, S, Hutchison, PM, Bell, L and Pestronk, RM (2004) Flint Photovoice: community building among youths, adults, and policymakers. American Journal of Public Health 94, 911913.10.2105/AJPH.94.6.911CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wang, C and Redwood-Jones, Y (2001) Photovoice ethics: perspectives from Flint Photovoice. Health Education & Behavior 28, 560572.10.1177/109019810102800504CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wang, C, Yi, W, Tao, Z and Carovano, K (1998) Photovoice as a participatory health promotion strategy. Health Promotion International 13, 7586.10.1093/heapro/13.1.75CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yankeelov, PA, Faul, AC, D'Ambrosio, JG, Collins, WL and Gordon, B (2015) Another day in paradise: a photovoice journey of rural older adults living with diabetes. Journal of Applied Gerontology 34, 199218.10.1177/0733464813493136CrossRefGoogle Scholar