Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-p9bg8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T09:39:16.141Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The invention of history in the later Roman world. The conversion of Isauria in The Life of Conon

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 February 2012

Philip Wood
Philip Wood
Affiliation:
Corpus Christi College, Oxford
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The historiography of the later Roman Empire has emphasised the centripetal results of Christianisation, in which the new religion completed the earlier Hellenisation and destroyed independent languages, histories and notions of identity in Anatolia and much of Syria. However, the discourse of ethnic origins, drawn from Christian stories as well as the Classical past, allowed different kinds of cultural independence to survive this process on the edges of the Empire. While more famous cases are provided by the Armenians, Suryoye and Goths, here I examine an ultimately unsuccessful attempt at historical invention and cultural independence, that of the Isaurians from the end of the fifth century. I begin by discussing the stereotypes employed by a Roman élite to distinguish themselves from ‘barbarians’, both within and outside the empire, before examining the attempts of Isaurians to contest this in history and hagiography.

Özet

Geç Roma dönemi yazılı tarihi Hıristiyanlaşmanın merkezcil sonuçlarına ısrarla dikkat çekmekte ve bu yeni dinin erken Helenistleşmeyi bitirdiği ve Anadolu'da ve Suriye'nin büyük bir bölümünde bağımsız dilleri, tarihçeleri ve özdeşlik kavramını tahrip ettiğini söylemektedir. Buna rağmen, hem Hıristiyan'lar tarafından anlatılan hikayelere, hem de Klasik geçmişe dayanılarak etnik kökenler hakında devam eden konuşmalara dayanılarak İmparatorluğun sınır bölgelerinde kültürel bağımsızlık pek çok biçimde devam etmiştir. Her ne kadar Ermeniler, Süryaniler ve Gotlar bu konuda daha iyi örnek oluşturmaktalarsa da, ben bu çalışmada 5. yüzyıl sonlarından itibaren çok başarısız bir tarihi kültürel bağımsızlık hareketini incleyeceğim. İncelemeye Isaura'lıların bu başarısız tarihsel girişiminden önce, Romalı elitlerin kendilerini ‘barbar’lardan ayırt etmek için benimsedikleri klişeleşmiş davranış biçimlerini inceleyerek başlayacağım.

Type
Research Article
Information
Anatolian Studies , Volume 59 , December 2009 , pp. 129 - 138
Copyright
Copyright © The British Institute at Ankara 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Ammianus Marcellinus, Res Gestae: Rolfe, J. (ed.). London 1940Google Scholar
Amory, P. 2003: People and Identity in Ostrogothic Italy, 489–554. CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Ando, C. 2000: Imperial Ideology and Provincial Loyalty in the Roman Empire. BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
Bourdieu, P. 1977: Outline of a Theory of Practice. Tr. Nice, R.. CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burgess, W. 1992: ‘Isaurian factions in the reign of Zeno the Isaurian’ Latomus 51: 874–80Google Scholar
Cameron, A. 2000: ‘The Vandal conquest and Vandal rule’ in Cameron, A., Ward-Perkins, B., Whitby, M. (eds), The Cambridge Ancient History: Volume XIV. Cambridge: 552–69Google Scholar
Cameron, A. 2003: ‘Jews and heretics: a category error?’ in Becker, A., Reed, A. (eds), The Ways that Never Parted. Jews and Christians in Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages. Princeton: 345–60Google Scholar
Candidus: Blockley, R. (ed. and tr.), The Fragmentary Clacissizing Historians of the Later Roman Empire. Liverpool 1983: II, 455–65Google Scholar
Cartledge, P. 2002: The Greeks: A Portrait of Self and Others. OxfordGoogle Scholar
Croke, B. 2005: ‘Dynasty and ethnicity in the reign of Leo I and the eclipse of Aspar’ Chiron 36: 147–203Google Scholar
Dauge, Y. 1981: Le barbare: récherches sur le conception romaine de la barbarie et la civilisation. BrusselsGoogle Scholar
Doran, S. 1992: The Lives of Symeon the Stylite. KalamazooGoogle Scholar
Elton, H.W. 2000a: ‘The nature of the sixth-century Isaurians’ in Mitchell, S., Greatrex, G. (eds), Ethnicity and Culture in Late Antiquity. Swansea: 293–307CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Elton, H.W. 2000b: ‘Ilus and the imperial aristocracy under Zeno’ Byzantion 20: 394–407Google Scholar
Elton, H.W. 2002a: ‘Economic fringe – the reach of the Roman Empire in rough Cilicia’ in De Blois, L., Rich, J. (eds), Transformation of Economic Life under the Roman Empire. Amsterdam: 172–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Elton, H.W. 2002b: ‘Zeno and Alahan’ Anatolian Studies 52: 153–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Elton, H.W. 2003: ‘The economy of Cilicia in late antiquity’ Olba 8: 173–79Google Scholar
Elton, H.W. 2006: ‘A new late Roman urban centre in Isauria’ Journal of Roman Archaeology 19: 300–11CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Elton, H.W. 2007: ‘Ecclesiastical politics in fifth- and sixth-century Isauria’ in Drinkwater, J., Salway, B. (eds), Reflections on Wolf Liebeschuetz. London: 77–85Google Scholar
Garnsey, P. 1996: Ideas of Slavery from Aristotle to Augustine. CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Garnsey, P. 2002: ‘Roman citizenship and Roman law in the late empire’ in Swain, S. and Edwards, M. (eds), Approaching Late Antiquity. Oxford: 133–55Google Scholar
Gero, S. 1974: ‘Notes on Byzantine iconoclasm in the eighth century’ Byzantion 44: 1–24Google Scholar
Gough, M. 1972: ‘The emperor Zeno and some Cilician churches’ Anatolian Studies 22: 199–212CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greatrex, G. 2000: ‘Roman identity in the sixth century’ in Greatrex, G., Mitchell, S., (eds), Ethnicity and Culture in Late Antiquity. London: 267–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Heather, P. 1996: The Goths. OxfordGoogle Scholar
Heather, P. 2005: The Fall of the Roman Empire. OxfordGoogle Scholar
Hill, S. 1996: The Early Byzantine Churches of Cilicia and Isauria. AldershotGoogle Scholar
Holum, K. 1982: Theodosian Empresses: Women and Imperial Dominion in Late Antiquity. BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
Houwink ten Cate, P.H.J. 1965: The Luwian Population Group of Lycia and Cilicia Aspera During the Hellenistic Period. LeidenGoogle Scholar
Isaacs, B. 2004: The Invention of Racism in Classical Antiquity. PrincetonCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Joshua the Stylite: Watt, J., Trombley, F. (eds and trs), The Chronicle of Pseudo-Joshua the Stylite. Liverpool 2000Google Scholar
Kaster, R. 1988: Guardians of Language, the Grammarian and Society in Late Antiquity. BerkeleyCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lenski, N. 1999: ‘Assimilation and revolt in the territory of Isauria, from the 1st century BC to the 6th century AD’ Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient 42: 431–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Liebeschuetz, W. 1991: Barbarians and Bishops. Army, Church and State in the Age of Arcadius and Chrysostom. OxfordGoogle Scholar
Life and Miracles of Thecla: Dagron, G. (ed.). Brussels 1977Google Scholar
Life of Conon: Halkin, F. (ed.), Analecta Bollandiana 103: 1–34Google Scholar
Life of Daniel the Stylite: Delehaye, H. (ed.), Les saints stylites. Brussels 1923Google Scholar
Life of Marcellus: Dagron, G. (ed.), Analecta Bollandiana 86: 302–22Google Scholar
Life of Porphyrius of Gaza: Gregoire, H., Kugener, M. (eds). Paris 1930Google Scholar
John of Ephesus, Ecclesiastical History: Brooks, E.W. (ed.). Louvain 1936Google Scholar
Maas, M. 2003: ‘Delivered from their ancient customs: Christianity and the question of cultural change in early Byzantine ethnography’ in Grafton, A., Mills, K. (eds), Conversion in Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages. Rochester NY: 152–88Google Scholar
Malalas: Dindorf, L. (ed.). Bonn 1831Google Scholar
Malchus: Blockley, R. (ed. and tr.), The Fragmentary Clacissizing Historians of the Later Roman Empire. Liverpool 1983: II, 376–416Google Scholar
Mango, C. 1966: ‘Isaurian builders’ in Wirth, P. (ed.), Polychronion: Festschrift for P. Dölger. Heidelberg: 358–65Google Scholar
Millar, F. 2006: A Greek Roman Empire: Power and Belief under Theodosius II (408–450). OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Priscus: Blockley, R. (ed. and tr.), The Fragmentary Clacissizing Historians of the Later Roman Empire. Liverpool 1983: II, 222–376Google Scholar
Rapp, C. 2005: Holy Bishops in Late Antiquity: The Nature of Christian Leadership in an Age of Transition. BerkeleyCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schlaifer, R. 1936: ‘Greek theories of slavery from Homer to Aristotle’ Harvard Studies in Classical Philology 47: 165–204CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shaw, B. 1990: ‘Bandit highlands and lowland peace: the mountains of Isauria-Cilicia’ Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient 23: 199–233CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Socrates, , Ecclesiastical History: Hussey, R. (ed.). Oxford 1888Google Scholar
Stein, E. 1949: Histoire du Bas Empire. ParisGoogle Scholar
Sterk, A. 2004: Renouncing the World Yet Leading the Church: The Monk-Bishop in Late Antiquity. Cambridge MACrossRefGoogle Scholar
Teall, J. 1965: ‘The barbarians in Justinian's armies’ Speculum 40: 294–322CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Theodoret, , Cure of Hellenic Maladies: Canivet, P. (ed. and tr.), Thérapeutique des maladies helléniques. Paris 1958Google Scholar
Theodoret, , Historia Religiosa: Canivet, P., Leroy-Molinghen, A. (eds and trs), L'histoire des moines de Syrie: Histoire Philotheé. Paris 1979Google Scholar
Trombley, F. 1994: Hellenic Religion and Christianisation, c.370–529. LeidenGoogle Scholar
Wickham, C. 2005: Framing the Early Middle Ages. OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wood, P. forthcoming: ‘The circus factions and the monopoly of violence in fifth-century Constantinople’Google Scholar