Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T06:59:28.343Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Diffusion of Early Franco-Italian All'Antica Ornament: The Renaissance Frieze in the Chapel of the Hospital of St Cross, Winchester, and the Gaillon Stalls, Now at St Denis, Paris

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2008

Nicholas Riall
Nicholas Riall
Affiliation:
Rock Cottage, High Street, Glynneath SA11 5AP, UK. E-mail: .
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In Volume 82 (2002) of the Antiquaries Journal, the canopied benches at St Cross were described, along with a discussion of their date and patronage. This paper takes the subject further by suggesting a reconstruction of the layout of these fittings. Conclusions reached in the earlier paper are further refined: the distinctive mouldings on the frieze, benches and desks clearly demonstrate that all three elements are integral to the same work and not added to preexisting benches, as previously argued. Further research suggests that the imagery and style of the frieze at St Cross had little impact on the aesthetic of the works patronized by Bishop Fox in Winchester Cathedral. Instead, parallels are drawn between the St Cross frieze and other modes of all'antica work in France, including the celebrated Renaissance stalls from the chapel of the archiepiscopal palace at the Château de Gaillon (Eure) and the cathedral stalls at Amiens (Somme). It has also become apparent that there is no other extant work in England that directly parallels the frieze at St Cross, and that the nearest analogue is the stallwork from Gaillon.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 88 , September 2008 , pp. 258 - 307
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 2008

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

ABBREVIATIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY

BL British Library, LondonGoogle Scholar
HRO Hampshire Record OfficeGoogle Scholar
BL, Additional 29928 (collection of sketches relating to antiquities, by John Carter)Google Scholar
HRO, 21M65/A1/21 (register of Bishop Fox)Google Scholar
HRO, 65M89/Z250 (Winchester photographs)Google Scholar
HRO, 111M94W/X2 (illustrations relating to St Cross Hospital)Google Scholar
HRO, TOP 343/2 (Winchester illustrations)Google Scholar
Abbott, S 2001. ‘William Butterfield and the Hospital of St Cross, Winchester’, Ecclesiol Today, 16, 2–7Google Scholar
Allen, P S and Allen, H M 1929. Letters of Richard Fox, 1486–1527, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Baggs, A P 1968. ‘Sixteenth-century terracotta tombs in East Anglia’, Archaeol J, 125, 295–301Google Scholar
Ball, C 1818. An Historical Account of Winchester with Descriptive Walks, WinchesterGoogle Scholar
Biddle, M 1993. ‘Early Renaissance at Winchester’, in Crook (ed) 1993, 257–304Google Scholar
Biddle, M 1993. King Arthur's Round Table, WoodbridgeGoogle Scholar
Blunt, A 1969. ‘L'influence française sur l'architecture et la sculpture décorative en Angleterre pendant la première moitié du XVIme siècle’, Revue de l'Art, 4, 17–29Google Scholar
Blunt, A 1973. Art and Architecture in France, 1500 to 1700, LondonGoogle Scholar
Bos, A and Dubois, J 2007. ‘Les boiseries de la chapelle du château de Gaillon’, in Huynh and Crépin-Leblond 2007, 83–98Google Scholar
Bottineau-Fuchs, Y 2005, Georges d'Amboise (1460–1510): un prélat normand de la Renaissance, RouenGoogle Scholar
The Builder 1865. [views of the chapel of St Cross Hospital], 28 10, 765Google Scholar
Carter, J 1790. Specimens of the Ancient Sculpture and Painting in England, LondonGoogle Scholar
Cave, C J P 1935. The Roof Bosses of Winchester Cathedral, WinchesterGoogle Scholar
Chirol, E 1952. Le Château de Gaillon, RouenGoogle Scholar
Chirol, E 1958. ‘Un dessin de stalles inédit du début du XVIe siècle’, Bulletin de la Société de l'Art français, 55–9Google Scholar
Crépin-Leblond, T 2007. ‘La décor et sculpté de la chapelle de Gaillon’, in Huynh and Crépin-Leblond 2007, 98–105Google Scholar
Crook, J (ed) 1993. Winchester Cathedral: nine hundred years, 1093–1993, ChichesterGoogle Scholar
Crook, J 2002. ‘New light on the history of St Mary's church, Old Basing, Hampshire: an incised design for a post-medieval window’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 154, 92–133Google Scholar
Davies, C S L 2004. ‘Fox, Richard (1447/8–1528)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography: online edition (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), <http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/100561> (9 04 2008)+(9+042008)>Google Scholar
Deville, A 1850. Comptes De Dépenses de la Construction du Château de Gaillon, ParisGoogle Scholar
Dollman, F T 1858. Ancient Domestic Architecture, LondonGoogle Scholar
Franklin, M J 1993. English Episcopal Acta, VIII: Winchester, 1070–1204, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Harper-Bill, C 2004. ‘Sherborn [Sherburne], Robert (c 1454–1536)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography: online edition (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), <http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/25357> (9 04 2008)+(9+042008)>Google Scholar
Humbert, LM 1868. Memorials of the Hospital of St Cross, LondonGoogle Scholar
Huynh, M and Crépin-Leblond, T 2007. L'Art des Frères d'Amboise, ParisGoogle Scholar
Illustrated London News 1865. [views of the chapel of St Cross Hospital], 18 11, 481Google Scholar
Kipling, G W 1892. Compotus Rolls of the Obedientiaries of St Swithun's Priory, Winchester, WinchesterGoogle Scholar
Levenson, J A, Oberhuber, K and Sheehan, J L 1973. Early Italian Engravings from the National Gallery of Art, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
Liou, E Y-L 1997. ‘Cardinal Georges d'Amboise and the Château de Gaillon at the dawn of the French Renaissance’, unpublished PhD thesis, Pennsylvania State University, USAGoogle Scholar
Milner, J 1798–1799. The History, Civil and Ecclesiastical, and Survey of the Antiquities of Winchester, 2 vols, 1st edn, WinchesterGoogle Scholar
Pagazini, X 2007. ‘La chapelle de Gaillon: architecture’, in Huynh and Crépin-Leblond 2007, 68–81Google Scholar
Riall, N 2003. ‘Thomas Silkstede's Renaissance-styled canopied woodwork in the south transept of Winchester Cathedral’, Proc Hampshire Fld Club Archaeol Soc, 58, 209–25Google Scholar
Riall, N 2005. ‘Bringing the Renaissance to Tudor England: the role of Richard Fox and his frieze at St Cross, Winchester’, unpublished PhD thesis, University of Wales SwanseaGoogle Scholar
Riall, N 2007a. ‘The early Tudor Renaissance in Hampshire: Anthony Blunt and “L'influence française sur l'architecture et la sculpture décorative en Angleterre pendant la première moitié du XVIme siècle” revisited’, Renaissance Stud, 21(2), 218–53Google Scholar
Riall, N 2007b. ‘A Winchester mason and the early Renaissance style in the 1520s: reconstructing the “lost” ambulatory chapel of Sir John and Mary Lisle at Thruxton church, Hampshire’, Architect Hist, 50, 31–58Google Scholar
Riall, N 2007c. ‘Thomas Bertie, bishop's mason, and the early Tudor Renaissance styled tomb of Ralph and Edith Pexall at Sherborne St John, Hampshire’, Proc Hampshire Fld Club Archaeol Soc, 62, 143–67Google Scholar
Riall, N 2007d. ‘An early Italianate tomb at East Tisted, Hampshire’, Alton Pap, 11, 25–37Google Scholar
Riall, N 2008. ‘All'antica ornament during the first Renaissance in England: the case of the Draper Chapel at Christchurch priory’, Proc Dorset Natur Hist Archaeol Soc, 129, 25–37Google Scholar
Rieder, W 1977. ‘French sixteenth-century boiserie and furniture’, Apollo, 106, 350–7Google Scholar
Smith, A 1988a. ‘The life and building activity of Richard Fox, c 1447–1528’, unpublished PhD thesis, University of LondonGoogle Scholar
Smith, A 1988b. ‘The chantry chapel of Bishop Fox’, Winchester Cathedral Rec, 57, 27–32Google Scholar
Smith, A 1996. Roof Bosses of Winchester Cathedral, WinchesterGoogle Scholar
Smith, A and Riall, N 2002. ‘Early Tudor canopywork at the hospital of St Cross, Winchester’, Antiq J, 82, 125–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thurley, S 1993. The Royal Palaces of Tudor England, New Haven and LondonGoogle Scholar
Tracy, C 1993. ‘The Lady Chapel stalls’, in Crook (ed) 1993, 231–46Google Scholar
Tracy, C 2003. ‘The Henry VII Chapel stalls and the eighteenth-century remodelling’, in Westminster Abbey: the Lady Chapel of Henry VII (eds Tatton-Brown, T and Mortimer, R), 227–52, WoodbridgeGoogle Scholar
Tracy, C 2005. ‘The bishop's palace at Mirepoix (Ariège) and French Renaissance oak panelling in a Scottish house’, Antiq J, 85, 176–249Google Scholar
Tracy, C and Harrison, H 2004. The Choir-stalls of Amiens Cathedral, ReadingGoogle Scholar
Vasselot, J J M de 1927. ‘Les boiseries de Gaillon au Musée de Cluny’, Bulletin Monumental, 86, 321–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar
VCH Hants 1903, Victoria County History of Hampshire, II, LondonGoogle Scholar
VCH Hants 1912, Victoria County History of Hampshire, v, LondonGoogle Scholar
Warner, R 1793. Topographical Remarks on South-western parts of Hampshire, WinchesterGoogle Scholar
Warren, F T 1902. Winchester Illustrated, WinchesterGoogle Scholar
Warton, T 1760. A Description of the City, College and Cathedral of Winchester, LondonGoogle Scholar
Wavell, J 1773. History of Winchester, WinchesterGoogle Scholar
Wells-Cole, A 1997. Art and Decoration in Elizabethan and Jacobean England, New Haven and LondonGoogle Scholar
Wilson, C 2003. Winchester cathedral, chantry chapel of Bishop Richard Fox', in Gothic: art for England 1400–1547 (eds Marks, R and Williamson, P), 244–5, LondonGoogle Scholar
Woodruff, C E 1914. Sede Vacante Wills: a calendar of wills proved before the commissary of the prior and chapter of Christ Church, Canterbury, during vacancies in the primacy, Kent Archaeol Soc Records Branch 3, CanterburyGoogle Scholar
Woolfson, J 1997. ‘John Claymond, Pliny the elder, and the early history of Corpus Christi College, Oxford’, Engl Hist Rev, 112, 882–903Google Scholar
Woolfson, J 2003. ‘Bishop Fox's bees and the early English Renaissance’, Reformation & Renaissance Review, 5(1), 7–26Google Scholar
Woolfson, J 2004. ‘Claymond, John (1467/8–1536)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography: online edition (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), <http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/5565> (10 04 2008)+(10+042008)>Google Scholar