Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-lj6df Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T06:12:10.334Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

ICONOCLASM AND PROFIT: SALES OF DESPOILED MONUMENTAL BRASSES AND TOMBS IN LONDON, 1547–53

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 September 2022

Robert Hutchinson Open the ORCID record for Robert Hutchinson [Opens in a new window]
Robert Hutchinson*
Affiliation:
Wood Myst, Wantley Lane, Storrington, West Sussex RH20 4HA, UK Email: rh1972@btinternet.com
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This analysis of the despoilation of monumental brasses and tombs in London during Edward vi’s reign is based on evidence provided by contemporary inventories of church goods and churchwardens’ accounts, supported by fieldwork and discoveries of recycled brasses during conservation. It reveals how the Reformation impacted the fortunes of the London marblers producing brasses, describes how plundered memorials were sold and provides evidence on their fate. Estimates, based on volumes of metal sold, create a potential range of 700–812 brasses lost from possibly forty-three London churches over 1548–53. After c 1550, marblers engraved 2mm thick hammered plate (cast from despoiled latten church goods, such as candlesticks and crucifixes) to sustain production when supplies of looted brasses diminished. The trade in plundered brasses ended after the accession of Edward’s Catholic half-sister, Mary, in August 1553.

Keywords

archaeology of reformationiconoclasmmonumental brassestombsLondon
Type
Research paper
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 102 , September 2022 , pp. 316 - 341
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of The Society of Antiquaries of London

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Manuscript sources

Bodleian, Add ms D 43, fol 16. ‘Charges of the Kinges warres and Fortifications’, 30 September 1538–July 1552Google Scholar
BL, Add ms 5697, fol 256v. Drawing of tomb of Edward Shurley and wife, 1558, Isfield, SussexGoogle Scholar
BL, Add ms 25343, fol 23v. Accompts of Henry Tooley’s foundation, Ipswich, 1566–95. ‘Chardges of Mr Tolie’s tombe.’Google Scholar
BL, Statutes of the Realm, 1819Google Scholar
ERO, D/DP F236. Papers of executors of William Pownsett, 1554–9Google Scholar
TNA, E122/88/20. Exchequer customs accounts of London collector of tunnage and poundage, London coastal trade, October 1566Google Scholar
TNA, PROB 11 36/277. Will of John Owen, gun founder, 12 August 1549Google Scholar
TNA, PROB 11 42A/143. Will of Thomas Salter, chantry priest, 31 August 1558Google Scholar
TNA, PROB 11 49/31. Will of John White, 20 May 1567Google Scholar

Published primary sources

Dasent, J 1891. Acts of the Privy Council 1550–52, new ser, 3, HMSO, London Google Scholar
Gairdner, J and Brodie, R H (eds) 1905. Letters & Papers, Foreign & Domestic, in the Reign of Henry VIII, 20, pt 1, HMSO, London Google Scholar
Garry, F and Garry, A 1893. Churchwardens’ Accounts of the Parish of St Mary’s Reading 1550–1662, Edward Blackwell, ReadingGoogle Scholar
Griffith, E 1831. Cases of Supposed Exemption from Poor Rates Claimed on the Ground of Extra-parochiality, with a Preliminary Sketch of the Ancient History of St Andrew Holborn, Henry Butterworth, London Google Scholar
Jenks, S (ed) 2019a. ‘Petty customs particulars of accounts (exports) and controlment roll (import & exports) of Robert Hennage; controlment roll of Richard Breame, (London, 29 September 1534–29 September 1535)’, Quellen und Darstallungen Zur Hansischen Geschichte, 74, pt 4, no 17, LubeckGoogle Scholar
Jenks, S 2019b. ‘Petty customs particulars of accounts (imports) of Richard Warner, (London 29 September 1536–29 September 1537)’, Quellen und Darstallungen Zur Hansischen Geschichte, 74, pt 4, no 18, LubeckGoogle Scholar
King, H 1869. ‘Inventories of church goods, Edward VI’, Trans Essex Archaeol Soc, old ser, 4, 197–234Google Scholar
King, H 1878. ‘Inventories of church goods, Edward VI’, Trans Essex Archaeol Soc, new ser, 1, 5–32Google Scholar
Kingsford, C H (ed) 1908. A Survey of London by John Stow, 2 vols, Clarendon Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Littlehales, H 1905. Medieval Records of a London City Church: St Mary at Hill, 1420–1559, Early English Text Society, London Google Scholar
Nichols, J G (ed) 1857. Literary Remains of King Edward VI, 2 vols, Roxburghe Club, London Google Scholar
Overall, W H (ed) 1871. Accounts of the Churchwardens of the Parish of St Michael Cornhill in the City of London 1456–1608, Alfred Waterlow, London Google Scholar
Roberts, R 1910. ‘Further inventories of church goods & ornaments in … Surrey in the reign of Edward VI’, Surrey Archaeol Colls, 23, 30–70 Google Scholar
Turnbull, W B (ed) 1861. Calendar of State Papers Foreign 1547–55, HMSO, London Google Scholar
Tyssen, D J 1869a. ‘Survey of the church of the College of Malling, near Lewes’, Sussex Archaeol Colls, 21, 159–90Google Scholar
Tyssen, D J 1869b. ‘Inventories of church goods of the churches of … Surrey in the reign of Edward VI’, Surrey Archaeol Colls, 4, 1–149 Google Scholar
Walters, H B 1939. London Churches at the Reformation, SPCK, London Google Scholar

Secondary sources

Bayliss, J 2014. ‘The export of brass from England during the Reformation’, Bull Monumental Brass Soc, 126, 515–6Google Scholar
Bayliss, J 2020. ‘New thoughts on a sixteenth century workshop’, in Steer 2020b, 234–54Google Scholar
Bertram, J (ed) 2006. The Catesby Family & their Brasses at Ashby St Legers, Monumental Brass Society, London Google Scholar
Cameron, K 1974. ‘Technical aspects of monumental brasses’, Archaeol J, 131, 215–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Craddock, P 2000–1. ‘Some analyses of medieval monumental brasses’, Trans Monumental Brass Soc, 16, 315–26Google Scholar
Egan, B 1976. ‘A palimpsest discovery at Ashby St Legers’, Trans Monumental Brass Soc, 12, 101–4Google Scholar
Egan, B and Hutchinson, R 1974. ‘A palimpsest find at Blewbury, Berks’, Trans Monumental Brass Soc, 11, 413–26Google Scholar
Hutchinson, R 2003. ‘Tombs of brass are spent: Reformation reuse of monumental brasses’, in Gaimster, D and Gilchrist, R (eds), The Archaeology of Reformation 1480–1580, 450–68, Maney, Leeds Google Scholar
Hutchinson, R and Egan, B 1993. ‘History writ in brass: the Fermer workshop 1546–55: the design’, Trans Monumental Brass Soc, 15, 142–83Google Scholar
Hutton, R 1987. ‘Local impact of the Tudor Reformations’, in Haigh, C (ed), The English Reformation Revised, 114–38, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Llewellyn, N 2011. East Sussex Church Monuments 1530–1830, Sussex Record Society, Lewes Google Scholar
Macklin, H 1905. Monumental Brasses, Swan Sonnenschein, London Google Scholar
Norris, M 1977. Monumental Brasses: the memorials, 2 vols, Philips & Page, London Google Scholar
Norris, M 1978. Monumental Brasses: the craft, Faber & Faber, London Google Scholar
Page-Phillips, J 1963. ‘A palimpsest at Milton, near Cambridge’, Trans Monumental Brass Soc, 10, 16–18 Google Scholar
Page-Phillips, J 1980. Palimpsests: the backs of monumental brasses, 2 vols, Monumental Brass Society, London Google Scholar
Ramsey, N 1981. ‘Makers of sixteenth century church monuments Ipswich [and] Bisham Abbey’, Bull Monumental Brass Soc, 27, 9–10 Google Scholar
Rawlins, M and Egan, B 1976. ‘A non-figure ‘Fermour’ brass at Chilton, Bucks’, Trans Monumental Brass Soc, 12, 1051–8Google Scholar
Scarisbrick, J 1997. Henry VIII, Yale University Press, New Haven and London Google Scholar
Schofield, J 1997. ‘Excavations on the site of St Nicholas Shambles, Newgate Street, City of London 1975–79’, London and Middlesex Archaeol Soc, 48, 77–136 Google Scholar
Steer, C 2020a. ‘The parishioners of St Nicholas Shambles’, in Steer 2020b, 459–81Google Scholar
Steer, C (ed) 2020b. The Monuments Man: essays in honour of Jerome Bertram, Shaun Tyas, Donnington Google Scholar
Waterhouse, R 2013. ‘Tudor bronze guns of the Channel Islands’, Societe Jersiaise Bull, 13, 86–114 Google Scholar
Weever, J 1631. Ancient Funerall Monuments, Thomas Harper, LondonGoogle Scholar
Welch, C 1894. History of Tower Bridge and of Other Bridges over the Thames Built by the Corporation of London, Smith, Elder & Co, London Google Scholar
Whittemore, P 2017. ‘No Cause to Mourne Though Here He Lye’: funerary monuments in London c 1000–1666, Wynchmore Books, London Google Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Hutchinson supplementary material

Hutchinson supplementary material

Download Hutchinson supplementary material(File)
File 183 KB