Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T12:52:01.906Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Cemetery or sacrifice? Infant burials at the Carthage Tophet

Age estimations attest to infant sacrifice at the Carthage Tophet

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 November 2013

Patricia Smith ,
Lawrence E. Stager ,
Joseph A. Greene  and
Gal Avishai
Patricia Smith*
Affiliation:
1Laboratory of Bio-anthropology and Ancient DNA, Faculties of Medicine and Dentistry, Hadassah-Ein Karem, The Hebrew University, Jerusalem 91120, Israel (Email: pat@cc.huji.ac.il; gal.avishai@mail.huji.ac.il)
Lawrence E. Stager
Affiliation:
2Semitic Museum, FAS Near Eastern Languages, 6 Divinity Avenue, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA (Email: stager@fas.harvard.edu; greene5@fas.harvard.edu)
Joseph A. Greene
Affiliation:
2Semitic Museum, FAS Near Eastern Languages, 6 Divinity Avenue, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA (Email: stager@fas.harvard.edu; greene5@fas.harvard.edu)
Gal Avishai
Affiliation:
1Laboratory of Bio-anthropology and Ancient DNA, Faculties of Medicine and Dentistry, Hadassah-Ein Karem, The Hebrew University, Jerusalem 91120, Israel (Email: pat@cc.huji.ac.il; gal.avishai@mail.huji.ac.il)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The recent article on the Carthage Tophet infants by Schwartz et al. (2012) takes issue with our paper (Smith et al. 2011) that claims the Carthaginians practiced infant sacrifice. Both studies were carried out on the same sample of cremated infant remains excavated by the ASOR Punic project between 1975 and 1980 (Stager 1982). We examined the contents of 334 urns while Schwartz et al. (2012) examined the same sample plus an additional fourteen urns (N = 348). We differed, however, in our conclusions regarding the age distribution of the infants and the extent to which it supported or refuted claims that Tophet infants were sacrificed. This note explains why we think that Schwartz et al. (2012) erred in their age assessments and introduces additional evidence to show that the age distribution of the Tophet infants supports our contention of infant sacrifice.

Type
Debate
Information
Antiquity , Volume 87 , Issue 338 , December 2013 , pp. 1191 - 1199
Copyright
Copyright © Antiquity Publications Ltd 2013

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Antoine, D., Hillson, S. & Dean, M.C.. 2009. The development clock of dental enamel: a test for the periodicity of prism cross-striations in modern humans and an evaluation of the most likely sources of error in histological studies of this kind. Journal of Anatomy 241:45–55.Google Scholar
Bonucci, E. & Graziani, G.. 1975. Comparative thermogravimetric, X-ray diffraction and electron microscope investigation of burnt bones from recent, ancient and prehistoric age. Atti Della Accademia dei Cincei, Scienze Fisiche, Matematiche e Naturali Series 8, 9:517-34.Google Scholar
Cardoso, H.F. 2007. Accuracy of developing tooth length as an estimate of age in human skeletal remains: the deciduous dentition. Forensic Science International 172:17–22.Google Scholar
Chadwick, D.J. & Cardew, G. (ed.). 2007. Ciba Foundation Symposium 205—dental enamel (Novartis Foundation Symposia). Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. doi:10.1002/9780470515303Google Scholar
Deutsch, D. & Pe'er, E.. 1982. Development of enamel in human fetal teeth. Journal of Dental Research 61:1543-51.Google Scholar
Deutsch, D., Tam, O. & Stack, M.V.. 1985. Postnatal changes in size, morphology and weight of developing postnatal deciduous anterior teeth. Growth 49:202-17.Google Scholar
Fazekas, I.G. & Kosa, F.. 1978. Forensic fetal osteology. Budapest: Akademiai Kiado.Google Scholar
Galley, C. & Wood, R.. 1998. On the distribution of deaths during the first year of life. Population: an English selection 11:35–59.Google Scholar
Gejvall, N.-G. 1949. Determination of cremated bones in urns from Carthage. Report prepared for the Ashmolean Museum, Oxford.Google Scholar
Gilchrist, R. & Mytum, H.C.. 1986. Experimental archaeology and burnt animal bone from archaeological sites. Circaea 4(1):29–38.Google Scholar
Gittings, C. 1984. Death, burial and the individual in early modern England. London: Croom Helm.Google Scholar
Gras, M., Rouillard, P. & Teixidor, P.. 1991. The Phoenicians and death. Berytus 39:127-76.Google Scholar
Holck, P. 1995. Why are small children so seldom found in cremations?, in Smits, E., Irigren, E. & Drusini, A.G. (ed.) Cremation studies in archaeology:33–38. Amsterdam: Logos.Google Scholar
Lebon, M., Reiche, F., Frohlich, J. & Bahein, J.. 2008. Characterization of archaeological burnt bones: contribution of a new analytical protocol based on derivative FTIR spectroscopy and curve fitting of the v1 v3 PO4 domain. Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry 392:1479-88.Google Scholar
Liversidge, H.M., Dean, M.C. & Molleson, T.L.. 1993. Increasing human tooth length between birth and 5.4 years. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 90:307-13.Google Scholar
Lovell, A. 1997. Death at the beginning of life, in Field, D., Hockey, J. & Small, N. (ed.) Death, gender and ethnicity:29–51. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Mahoney, P. 2012. Incremental enamel development in modern human deciduous anterior teeth. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 147:637-51.Google Scholar
Mayer, I., Schneider, S., Sydney-Zax, S. & Deutsch, D.. 1990. Thermal decomposition of developing enamel. Calcified Tissue International 46:254-57.Google Scholar
Mays, S. & Eyers, J.. 2011. Perinatal infant death at the Roman villa site at Hambleden, Buckinghamshire, England. Journal of Archaeological Science 38:1931-38.Google Scholar
Norman, N.J. 2002. Death and burial of Roman children: the case of the Yasmina cemetery at Carthage, part I: setting the stage. Mortality 7:302-23.Google Scholar
Norman, N.J. 2003. Death and burial of Roman children: the case of the Yasmina cemetery at Carthage, part II: the archaeological evidence. Mortality 8:36–47.Google Scholar
Olive, C. 1982. Étude anthropologique des restes osseux provenant de la nécropole archaïque du versant sud de la colline de Byrsa, in Lancel, S. (ed.) Byrsa II:391-96. Rome: École Française de Rome.Google Scholar
Person, A., Bocherons, H., Mariotti, A. & Renard, U.. 1997. Diagenetic evolution and experimental heating of bone phosphate. Paleogeography, Paleoclimatology, Paleoecology 126:135-49.Google Scholar
Richard, J. 1961. Étude médico-légale des urnes sacrificielles puniques et de leur contenu. Unpublished PhD dissertation, Université de Lille.Google Scholar
Robinson, C., Kirkham, J., Brookes, S.J., Bonass, W.A. & Shore, R.C.. 1995. The chemistry of enamel development. International Developmental Biology 39:145-52.Google Scholar
Robinson, C., Brookes, S.J., Shore, R.C. & Kirkham, J.. 1998. The developing enamel matrix: nature and function. European Journal of Oral Science 106:282-91.Google Scholar
Schmidt, C.W. 2008. The recovery and study of burned human teeth, in Schmidt, C.W. & Symes, S.A. (ed.) The analysis of burned human remains:55–74. London: Elsevier.Google Scholar
Schwartz, J., Houghton, F., Macchiarelli, R. & Bondioli, L.. 2010. Skeletal remains from Punic Carthage do not support systematic sacrifice of infants. PloS ONE 5(2): e9177.Google Scholar
Schwartz, J. 2012. Bones, teeth and estimating age of perinates: Carthaginian infant sacrifice revisited. Antiquity 86:738-45.Google Scholar
Scott, E. 1999. The archaeology of infancy and infant death (British Archaeological Reports international series 819). Oxford: Archaeopress.Google Scholar
Shipman, P., Foster, G. & Schoeninger, M.. 1984. Burnt bones and teeth: an experimental study of the color, morphology, crystal structure and shrinkage. Journal of Archaeological Science 11:307-25.Google Scholar
Smith, C.E., Pompura, J.R., Borenstein, S., Fazel, A. & Nanci, A.. 1989. Degradation and loss of matrix proteins from developing enamel. Anatomical Record 224:292–316.Google Scholar
Smith, P., Horwitz, L. & Zias, J.. 1990. Human remains from the Iron Age cemeteries at Akhziv. Part 1: the built tomb from the southern cemetery. Revista di Studi Fenici 18(2):137-50.Google Scholar
Smith, P., Mazar, E., Sabari, P., Selah, M. & Ganchrow, R.. 1993. The early Phoenicians excavated from Achziv, northern Israel. National Geographic Research and Exploration 9(1):54–69.Google Scholar
Smith, P., Avishai, G., Greene, J.A. & Stager, L.E.. 2011. Aging cremated infants: the problem of sacrifice at the Tophet of Carthage. Antiquity 85:859-75.Google Scholar
Soleil, M.M., Muller, P. & Richard, J.. 1958. Contribution à la détermination de l'age des enfants sacrifices à Carthage. Annales de Medicine Legale et de Criminologie 38(1):17–23.Google Scholar
Stager, L.E. 1982. Carthage, a view from the Tophet, in Niemeyer, H.G. (ed.) Phönizier im Westen: die Beiträge des Internationalen Symposiums über “Die phönizische Expansion im westlichen Mittelmeerraum” in Köln vom 24 bis 27 April 1979 (Madrider Beitrage 8):155-66. Mainz am Rhein: von Zabern.Google Scholar
Trelliso, L. 2004. The anthropological study on the human skeletal remains of Tyre-Al-Bass 1997, in Aubet, M.-E. (ed.) The Phoenician cemetery of Tyre-Al Bass: excavations 1997-99 (Bulletin d'archéologies et d'architecture libanaises Hors-Série 1):247-78. Beirut: Ministere de la Culture, Direction Générale des Antiquités.Google Scholar
Who World Health Organization. 2011. WHO mortality data and statistics. Available at: http://www.who.int/whosis/mort/ (accessed 18 April 2013).Google Scholar