No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Goodness has nothing to do with it: Why problem orientation need not make for parochial theory
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 June 2004
Abstract:
Social-cognitive psychologists' problem orientation is, in itself, no threat to the generation of normatively neutral general theory. What would put general theory at risk is, rather, the reliance on a valence-balancing explanatory heuristic. Fortunately, social-cognitive research communities have resources to override this heuristic and utilize more epistemically effective cultural tools.
- Type
- Open Peer Commentary
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2004
References
Notes
1. They are also concerned that the phenomena in question are not as contranormative as claimed, a mistake in judgment that leads to unwarranted gloominess about human nature. This is an interesting but independent issue.
2. Not least because psychologists were typically unaware of the philosophical literature in which these claims appeared.
3. Sampson (1971) suggests that balance theory describes a tendency with substantial adaptive advantages, including provision of “noncontradictory guidelines to action” (p. 131).
4. Were this not the case, K&F themselves would have reason to be profoundly pessimistic about human capacities. It takes more than recognition of their historically adaptive function to make one less gloomy about human hankerings for fat and sugar. You need to know that there are ways to outwit one's craving for crullers.