Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dzt6s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T05:24:41.518Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Roman Military Deployment in North England*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 November 2011

David J. Breeze  and
Brian Dobson
David J. Breeze
Affiliation:
Historic Buildings and Monuments, 3–11, Melville Street, Edinburgh
Brian Dobson
Affiliation:
Department of Adult and Continuing Education Studies, Durham
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In 1963 Michael Jarrett published a short paper on ‘The Military Occupation of Roman Wales.’ It discussed the documentary evidence relating to the Roman conquest of the Welsh tribes and the differing attitudes of these tribes to Rome, but its main importance lay in the six distribution maps illustrating the forts occupied in a.d. 80, 100, 130, 150, 220 and 330. Subsequently Dr J. L. Davies has published a series of nine maps covering the first and second centuries. Two papers have recently extended the same treatment to Scotland. The north of England has never been afforded the same discussion. The most detailed distribution maps published to date are the five which appear in Professor Frere's Britannia. However, there have been maps and discussions of certain areas such as north-west England, or particular periods. It seems appropriate that a portrayal of the changing face of military deployment in north England over nearly 350 years should appear in a volume dedicated to John Gillam, who has done so much to illuminate the history of the area, not least through his work on that basic dating material, coarse pottery.

Type
Articles
Information
Britannia , Volume 16 , November 1985 , pp. 1 - 19
Copyright
Copyright © David J. Breeze and Brian Dobson 1985. Exclusive Licence to Publish: The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Jarrett, M. G., Bull. Board. Celtic Stud. xx Pt. 2 (May 1963), 206–20.Google Scholar

2 Davies, J. L. in Hanson, W. S. and Keppie, L. J. F. (eds.), Roman Frontier Studies 1979, Papers presented to the 12th International Congress of Roman Frontier Studies, BAR Int. Ser. 71 (Oxford, 1980), 255–77.Google Scholar

3 Breeze, D. J. and Dobson, B., Glasgow Archaeol. Journ. iv (1976), 124–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hanson, W. S. in Hanson, W. S. and Keppie, L. J. F. (eds), op. cit (note 2), 15–43.Google Scholar

4 Frere, S. S., Britannia, A History of Roman Britain, (2nd edn.London, 1974), figs. 3, 5, 6, 7 and 11.Google Scholar

5 e.g., Edwards, B. J. N. in Jarrett, M. G. and Dobson, B. (eds.), Britain and Rome, Essays presented to Eric Birley on his sixtieth birthday (Kendal, 1966), 95–105Google Scholar; Jones, G. D. B., Northern Hist. iii (1968), 1–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Potter, T. W., Romans in North-west England (Kendal, 1979), 356–66.Google Scholar

6 e.g., Hartley, B. R., Northern Hist. i (1966), 7–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hartley, B. R. in Butler, R. M. (ed.), Soldier and civilian in Roman Yorkshire (Leicester, 1971), 55–69Google Scholar; Jones, R. F. J. in King, A. and Henig, M. (eds.), The Roman West in the Third Century, Contributions from Archaeology and History, BAR Int. Ser. 109 (Oxford, 1981), 393–414.Google Scholar

7 Parisi, see Ptolemy, , Geography, II, 3, 10Google Scholar, conveniently accessible with discussion in Rivet, A. L. F. and Smith, Colin, The Place-Names of Roman Britain (London, 1979), 142Google Scholar; Carvetii, , JRS lv (1965), 224Google Scholar (Brougham, milestone dated 260–268), RIB 933 (Old Penrith); Brigantes, Ptolemy, loc. cit., Rivet, and Smith, , op. cit., 141–2Google Scholar and Tacitus, Agricola, 17; Setantii, Ptolemy, , op. cit., II, 3, 2Google Scholar, Rivet, and Smith, , op. cit., 134; Gabrantovices, Ptolemy, op. cit., II, 3, 4Google Scholar. Rivet, and Smith, , op. cit., 137–8; Textoverdi, RIB 1695.Google Scholar

8 Tacitus, , Annals XII, 32; 39Google Scholar. Rivet, and Smith, , op. cit., 137–8; Textoverdi, RIB 1695.Google Scholar

8 Tacitus, , Annals XII, 32; 39Google Scholar; Histories, 3, 45; Agricola, 17.Google Scholar

9 Tacitus, , Agricola, 17.Google Scholar

10 Tacitus, , Agricola, 17; 18.Google Scholar

11 Tacitus, , Agricola, 22.Google Scholar

12 Tacitus, , Agricola, 20.Google Scholar

13 Birley, A. R. in Levick, B. (ed.), The Ancient Historian and his Materials (Farnborough, 1975), 143Google Scholar; Dobson, B., Scot. Arch. Forum xii (1981), 6.Google Scholar

14 Juvenal, , Satires XIV, 196Google Scholar; Pausanius, , VIII, 43.Google Scholar

15 Statius, , Sihae, 5, 2, 142–9.Google Scholar

16 Tacitus, , Histories, 3, 45.Google Scholar

17 Res Gestae Divi Augusti 27. Tacitus, Annals, 12, 45 records a Roman garrison in the client state of Armenia.

18 Wenham, L. P. in Butler, R. M. (ed.), Soldier and Civilian in Roman Yorkshire (Leicester, 1971), 45–53Google Scholar. For the possibility of earlier occupation see Birley, A. R., Britannia iv (1973), 188 and n. 45.Google Scholar

19 Johnson, S., Britannia ix (1978), 77–80.Google Scholar

20 For the possibility and references see Birley, A. R., op. cit. (note 18), 189Google Scholar. The notion of a storming of Stanwick by Cerialis has recently been challenged: to the doubts expressed by Dobson, B., Trans. Architect. Archaeol. Soc. Durham Northumberland ii (1970), 39–40Google Scholar, add now Turnbull, P., Durham Archaeol. Journ. i (1984), 41–9Google Scholar; Haselgrove, C. C. and Turnbull, P., Stanwick, excavation and field-work, interim report 1981–83, Occasional Paper 4 of the Department of Archaeology, Durham University (Durham, 1983)Google Scholar; Chadburn, A., Northern Archaeology iv pt. 1 (1983), 2–20.Google Scholar

21 Johnson, S., op. cit. (note 19), 80.Google Scholar

22 Tacitus, , Agricola 20.Google Scholar

23 Jones, M. J., Roman fort defences to a.d. 117, BAR 21 (Oxford, 1975), 126.Google Scholar

24 We are grateful to Mr Peter Scott for advice on Piercebridge.

25 Hartley, B. R., op. cit. (note 6, Soldier and civilian), 58.Google Scholar

26 B. R. Hartley, ibid.

27 Wilderspool: Britannia vi (1975), 240Google Scholar. Walton-le-dale: Britannia xiii (1982), 352; xiv (1983), 296–7.Google Scholar

28 Castleshaw: Thompson, F. H., Trans. Lanes, and Cheshire Antiq. Soc. lxxvii (1967), 3. Hayton: S. Johnson, op. cit. (note 19).Google Scholar

29 Hartley, B. R., op. cit. (note 6, Northern Hist.), 12Google Scholar; Potter, T. W., op. cit. (note 5), 356.Google Scholar

30 Hartley, B. R. in Spratt, D. A., Prehistoric and Roman Archaeology of North-East Yorkshire, BAR 104 (Oxford, 1982), 211–2.Google Scholar

31 Breeze, D. J., The Northern Frontiers of Roman Britain (London, 1982), 60–72.Google Scholar

32 Birley, E., Roman Britain and the Roman Army (Kendal, 1953), 21.Google Scholar

33 Birley, E., Research on Hadrian's Wall (Kendal, 1961), 132–50Google Scholar; Breeze, D. J. and Dobson, B., Hadrian's Wall (Harmondsworth, 1978), 20–7Google Scholar; Daniels, C., Scot. Arch. Forum, Glasgow 1970 (1970), 94–5.Google Scholar

34 RIB 1826. Birley, E., op. cit. (note 33), 194.Google Scholar

35 Simpson, F. G. and Richmond, I. A., Trans. Cumb. West. Ant. Arch. Soc. xxxvi (1936), 176–7.Google Scholar

36 Birley, E., op. cit. (note 33), 148.Google Scholar

37 McCord, N. and Jobey, G., Arch. Ael.4 xlix (1971), 120.Google Scholar

38 Birley, E., op. cit. (note 33), 135, 143–6Google Scholar. Also on the Stanegate: Daniels, C. M. (ed.), Handbook to the Roman Wall (Newcastle upon Tyne, 13th edition, 1978), passim, but particularly 176–8 and 206–11.Google Scholar

39 Gillam, J. P., Arch. Ael5 v (1977), 56 and 60.Google Scholar

40 Jones, G. D. B., Britannia xiii (1982), 285. Professor Jones has kindly informed the first author that he no longer believes that the site at Finglandrigg is a Roman fort.Google Scholar

41 Ramm, H. in Branigan, K. (ed.), Rome and the Brigantes (Sheffield, 1980), 33Google Scholar; Sumpter, A. in Wilson, P. R., Jones, R. F. J. and Evans, D. M. (eds.), Settlement and Society in the Roman North (Bradford and Leeds, 1984), 84.Google Scholar

42 Gillam, J. P., op. cit. (note 39), 53–4Google Scholar; Birley, R., Vindolanda (London, 1977), 108–9.Google Scholar

43 For a report on the latest work on Carlisle, indicating military occupation continuing through the second century with modifications to the buildings, see McCarthy, M. R., in Wilson, P. R., Jones, R. F. J. and Evans, D. M. (eds), op. cit. (note 41), 65–70.Google Scholar

44 Breeze, D. J. and Dobson, B., op. cit. (note 33), 43–51.Google Scholar

45 Hartley, B. R., op. cit. (note 6, Northern Hist), fig. 1; Davies, J. L., op. cit. (note 2), 264–70.Google Scholar

46 Hartley, B. R., op. cit. (note 6, Northern Hist.), 17.Google Scholar

47 Breeze, D. J. in Miket, R. and Burgess, C. (eds.), Between and Beyond the Walls, Essays on the Prehistory and History of North Britain in Honour of George Jobey (Edinburgh, 1984), 264–6.Google Scholar

48 Hartley, B. R., Britannia iii (1974), 25Google Scholar; Davies, J. L., op. cit. (note 2), 269–71.Google Scholar

49 The Chesters diploma of 146 may indicate the presence of a unit in the fort at that time, recalling the possibility of this fort having a role related to the Stanegate before Hadrian's Wall was built: cf. Birley, E., op. cit. (note 33), 173.Google Scholar

50 Dobson, B., Trans. Architect. Archaeol. Soc. Durham Northumberland ii (1970), 34Google Scholar; Maxfield, V. A. and Reed, A. H., Arch. Ael.5 iii (1975), 56 and 64Google Scholar. Hartley, op. cit. (note 6, Northern Hist.), 8 and 16, suggests that Binchester was evacuated under Hadrian.Google Scholar

51 Ambleside: the recently discovered Antonine samian is from the civil settlement and thus may not be relevant to the occupation of the fort: Burkett, Mary E., Trans. Cumb. West. Ant. Arch. Soc. lxv (1965), 93–7Google Scholar; Trans. Cumb. West. Ant. Arch. Soc. lxxvii (1977), 179–80Google Scholar. This is implicitly accepted by Hartley, op. cit. (note 48). Templeborough: May, T., The Roman Forts of Templeborough near Rotherham (Rotherham, 1922), 11.Google Scholar

52 The authors have already expressed their reservations about the authenticity of the ‘Brigantian Revolt’: Breeze, D. J. and Dobson, B., op. cit. (note 33), 105–8. However, whether this ‘event’ happened or not, it has no relevance for these maps as whatever changes occurred in the 150s were subsumed in the greater troop movements of the 160s.Google Scholar

53 Chester, Little (off the bottom of this map): Britannia iv (1973), 285Google Scholar; xii (1981), 335. Wales: Davies, J. L., op. cit. (note 2), 269.Google Scholar

54 Gillam, J. P., Trans. Architect. Archaeol. Soc. Durham Northumberland, pt. 4 (1953), 262–3.Google Scholar

55 Gillam, J. P. and Tait, J., Arch. Ael.4 xlvi (1968), 85Google Scholar. Daniels, C. M. and Harbottle, Barbara, Arch. Ael.5 viii (1980), 65.Google Scholar

56 Bryant, S., Roman Manchester (Manchester, 1982), 15.Google Scholar

57 Dobson, B., op. cit. (note 50), 34.Google Scholar

58 ibid.

59 Mining: Simpson, G., Britons and the Roman Army (Farnborough, 1964), 139Google Scholar. Templeborough: May, T., op. cit. (note 51), 11.Google Scholar

60 McCarthy, M. R., op. cit. (note 43), 68Google Scholar; Birley, E. and Richmond, I. A., Arch. Ael.4 xv (1938), 260–4.Google Scholar

61 Dio 71, 16.

62 Potter, T. W., op. cit. (note 5), 363.Google Scholar

63 Watercrook, : loc. cit. 179Google Scholar; Templeborough: May, T., op. cit. (note 51), 11.Google Scholar

64 Mann, J. C., Glasgow Arch. Journ. iii (1974), 38Google Scholar. Hassall, M. in Johnston, D. E. (ed.), The Saxon Shore (London, 1977) 8–9.Google Scholar

65 Gillam, J. P., Arch. Ael.5 ii (1974), 12–5Google Scholar; Breeze, D. J. and Dobson, B., op. cit. (note 33), 243 for the garrison.Google Scholar

66 Dore, J. N. and Gillam, J. P., The Roman Fort at South Shields (Newcastle upon Tyne, 1979), 68–70.Google Scholar

67 Potter, T. W., op. cit. (note 5), 363.Google Scholar

68 RIB 1912. Wilkes, J. J. in Jarrett, M. G. and Dobson, B. (eds.), op. cit. (note 5), 215Google Scholar; Breeze, D. J. and Dobson, B., op. cit. (note 33), 245 for the garrison.Google Scholar

69 Wilkes, J. J., ibid. 130Google Scholar; Daniels, C. M. in Hanson, W. S. and Keppie, L. J. F. (eds.), op. cit. (note 2), 173–93.Google Scholar

70 Jones, R. P. Duncan, Chiron viii (1978), 541–60Google Scholar. See also: Birley, A. R. in King, A. and Henig, M. (eds.), op. cit. (note 6), 39–44Google Scholar; Breeze, D. J. in Miket, R. and Burgess, C. (eds.), op. cit. (note 47), 264–8.Google Scholar

71 Mann, J. C. in Casey, P. J., The End of Roman Britain, BAR 71 (Oxford, 1979), 146.Google Scholar

72 Casey, P. J. and Savage, M., Arch. Ael5 viii (1980), 79–80.Google Scholar

73 Notitia Dignitatum, Occ., 40.Google Scholar

74 Breeze, D. J. and Dobson, B., op. cit. (note 33), 274–5Google Scholar; Rivet, A. L. F. and Smith, Colin, op. cit. (note 7), 220–1.Google Scholar

75 Breeze, D. J. and Dobson, B., op. cit. (note 33), 221–7Google Scholar; Johnson, S., The Roman Forts of the Saxon Shore (London, 1976), 133–6, 149Google Scholar. Casey, P. J. (ed.), The End of Roman Britain, BAR 71 (Oxford, 1979), 75–6, suggests that ‘the Yorkshire coast signal stations could have been built by Maximus rather than Count Theodosius.’Google Scholar

76 We accept a date of about 400 for the Notitia Dignitatum: Mann, J. C. in Goodburn, R. and Bartholomew, P. (eds.), Aspects of the Notitia Dignitatum, BAR Suppl. Ser. 15 (Oxford, 1976), 8Google Scholar; Rivet, A. L. F. and Smith, Colin, op. cit. (note 7), 216–25.Google Scholar

77 Britannia xii (1981), 335.Google Scholar

78 Higham, N. J. in Clack, P. and Haselgrove, S. (eds.), Rural Settlement in the Roman North (Durham, 1982), 108.Google Scholar

79 Professor Mann sees the defence of the province falling into a series of layers – a zone of surveillance, the outpost forts, the Wall, the units in the hinterland forts and finally the legion at York: Mann, J. C. in Casey, P. J. (ed.), op. cit. (note 75), 145–6.Google Scholar

80 Pace Jones, G. D. B., ‘Concept and Development in Roman Frontiers’, Bulletin of the John Rylands University Library of Manchester 61, 1 (Autumn 1978), 138–42Google Scholar, following Luttwak, E. N., The Grand Strategy of the Roman Empire From the First Century a.d. to the Third (Baltimore and London 1976), 130–90.Google Scholar

81 Pace Rivet, A. L. F. in Rivet, A. L. F. (ed.), The Roman Villa in Britain (London, 1969), 192.Google Scholar

82 Mattingly, H., Tacitus on Britain and Germany (Harmondsworth, 1948), 67.Google Scholar