Zeaxanthin and its structural isomer lutein are the most prevalent xanthophylls found in the human body. They are highly concentrated in the retina of human eyes. Zeaxanthin is the major component in the central macula, while lutein is predominant in the peripheral area(Reference Whitehead, Mares and Danis1, Reference Landrum and Bone2). It is believed that zeaxanthin and lutein function as blue-light filters and reactive oxygen species scavengers in the retina to protect the cells from oxidative damage(Reference Ahmed, Lott and Marcus3, Reference Junghans, Sies and Stahl4).
Numerous studies have suggested that zeaxanthin and lutein are crucial for visual health. In animal models (in monkeys), zeaxanthin and lutein have been found to be important for the development and maintenance of normal distribution of the retinal pigment epithelium(Reference Malinow, Feeney-Burns and Peterson5, Reference Leung, Sandstrom and Zucker6); retinal zeaxanthin has also been shown to protect the photoreceptors from light-induced damage in quail eyes(Reference Thomson, Toyoda and Langner7, Reference Thomson, Toyoda and Delori8). In human subjects, some epidemiological and clinical researchers have demonstrated that high levels of zeaxanthin and lutein intake are associated with significantly decreased risks of cataract and age-related macular degeneration(Reference Johnson9–Reference Seddon, Ajani and Sperduto11).
Because humans cannot synthesise xanthophylls, dietary intake of xanthophyll-containing foods is critical to provide these phytonutrients to our bodies. In the US population, the average intake of lutein and zeaxanthin together is about 2 mg/d(Reference Mares-Perlman, Fisher and Klein12), which is three times less than the dose of lutein and zeaxanthin that has been linked with a decreased risk of age-related macular degeneration and cataracts (6 mg/d)(Reference Seddon, Ajani and Sperduto11). Therefore, lutein and zeaxanthin supplements have been suggested for visual health in people with low dietary intake, especially for older adults.
However, although lutein is abundant in many green leafy vegetables such as kale and spinach, only a few kinds of food contain high concentrations of zeaxanthin(Reference Perry, Rasmussen and Johnson13, Reference Maiani, Caston and Catasta14). In cooked egg-yolk, maize and orange pepper, zeaxanthin concentrations are about 587, 202 and 1665 μg/100 g fresh weight, respectively(Reference Perry, Rasmussen and Johnson13). Spirulina is an alga that is rich in carotenoids, including zeaxanthin(Reference Miranda, Cintra and Barros15–Reference Annapurna, Deosthale and Bamji18). In the strain of spirulina studied in the present investigation, the concentration of zeaxanthin as a dried powder can reach 74 000 μg/100 g(Reference Wang, Wang and Wang19). Previous studies in animal models as well as in human subjects have demonstrated that β-carotene from spirulina has a high bioavailability and a high bioconversion to vitamin A factor(Reference Wang, Wang and Wang19); however, no studies on spirulina zeaxanthin have been reported.
In the present report, the enrichment of spirulina zeaxanthin in serum and its bioavailability in humans have been determined. A single serving of intrinsically 2H-labelled spirulina was consumed by American and Chinese healthy males. Their plasma samples were collected up to 45 d post- spirulina supplementation. The concentration and isotopic enrichment of spirulina zeaxanthin were analysed using C30 column-based HPLC and LC-atmospheric pressure chemical ionisation-MS (LC-APCI-MS). The results were used to calculate a relative bioavailability (the change in plasma concentration in response to a test meal)(Reference Traber20), which demonstrated that spirulina is a rich source of dietary zeaxanthin in both American and Chinese volunteers.
Materials and methods
Subjects and study design
The present study was conducted according to the guidelines laid down in the Declaration of Helsinki and all procedures involving human subjects were approved by the Institutional Review Board of Tufts Medical Center and the Institute of Nutrition and Food Hygiene Ethical Review Committee of the Chinese Academy of Preventative Medicine. Informed consent was obtained from all subjects under the guidelines established.
The human studies were conducted in China and the USA in 2006 and 2008, respectively. For this study, four American males (two African Americans and two Caucasians) and ten Chinese males were recruited separately. The volunteers were healthy, non-smoking adults and were not taking vitamin supplements at the time of the study. All subjects were instructed to eat a low-carotenoid diet for 2 weeks before taking the study dose. On day 1, each subject was given a spirulina supplement of 4 g (for American volunteers) or 5 g (for Chinese volunteers) with a carotene-free liquid formulated breakfast. The ingredients of this liquid breakfast contained banana, coconut milk, whey protein, glucose polymer, white sugar and water, which provided 12 g fat (26 % of total energy), 4 g protein (4 % of total energy) and 74 g carbohydrate (70 % of total energy), with a total energy content of 1668 kJ (399 kcal).
Fasting blood samples (10 ml) were collected from all subjects before supplementation as the baseline. Blood samples (10 ml) were collected from all subjects at 0 (fasting blood, just before breakfast), and 6, 8, 11 and 13 h after intake of the supplement on day 1. Blood was drawn at 0, 5 and 11 h on day 2, and at 0 and 11 h on day 3. Fasting blood samples (10 ml) were obtained on days 4, 5, 6, 7, 11, 13, 15, 19, 23, 27, 32, 39 and 45. Due to the schedules of the volunteers, time points varied slightly ( ± 1 d) for some subjects and two subjects had a shorter period of intervention (a minimum of 23 d).
Chemicals and materials
Most of the solvents used in this study including chloroform, methanol (MeOH), hexane, ethanol, tert-butyl methyl diethyl ether (MTBE), tetrahydrofurane were HPLC-grade and purchased from Sigma (St Louis, MO, USA). Diethyl ether was from Fisher Scientific (Fair Lawn, NJ, USA). NH2 cartridge columns were from Phenomenex (Torrance, CA, USA).
Preparation of 2H labelled spirulina
2H labelled spirulina (Spirulina platensis) was grown in liquid culture at the US Department of Agriculture Agricultural Research Service, Children's Nutrition Research Center in Houston, TX, USA as previously described(Reference Wang, Wang and Wang19). Briefly, a liquid stock culture of spirulina cells was obtained from the University of Texas Culture Collection of Algae (UTEX no. LB2340; University of Texas, Austin, TX, USA), inoculated into 20-litre glass carboys, and grown in a sterilised artificial seawater medium enriched with 23 atom % 2H2O. After 10–12 d of growth, the spirulina cultures were harvested, freeze-dried and shipped to the Carotenoids and Health Laboratory of the US Department of Agriculture Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging at Tufts University (Boston, MA, USA), where the freeze-dried spirulina was powdered, packed into capsules and stored at − 80°C immediately. Spirulina capsules for the China study were shipped by air, on dry ice, to the National Institute for Nutrition and Food Safety, Beijing, China. All spirulina capsules were stored at − 80°C until being analysed or consumed by the study subjects.
Sample preparation
Whole blood samples were protected from light using aluminium foil, incubated at 37°C for 30 min, and centrifuged at 4°C, 800 g for 15 min to separate the serum. Serum samples collected from Chinese subjects were stored at − 20°C first (less than 2 months) and then shipped by air, on dry ice, to the Carotenoids and Health Laboratory of HNRCA in Boston, MA, USA, where the samples were stored at − 80°C until analysis. Due to the light sensitivity of carotenoids, the extractions and analyses of carotenoids were performed under red light.
To extract carotenoids from spirulina, 1·0 mg of dried spirulina powder was mixed with 10 ml MeOH for 1 h in a shaking incubator at 120 rpm. The mixture was centrifuged at 3000 rpm for 5 min, and the MeOH extract was transferred into a 50 ml volumetric flask. The residue was further extracted with 10 ml of tetrahydrofurane, vortexed and centrifuged at 3000 rpm for 5 min. Extraction of tetrahydrofurane was repeated three or four times, and all tetrahydrofurane extracts were combined with the MeOH extract in the same flask. The final volume of the spirulina extract was adjusted to exactly 50 ml in the volumetric flask, and 1 ml of the extract was transferred to a 10 ml glass tube, dried under N2 and resuspended with 1 ml of ethanol for HPLC and LC-APCI-MS analyses.
To extract carotenoids from human serum, 500 μl serum samples, 500 μl of 0·85 % saline, 60 μl internal standard (echinenone in ethanol with absorbance of 0·1–0·2 measured at 460 nm), and 5 ml CHCl3–MeOH (2:1, v/v) were added into 15 ml disposable glass tubes. The mixture was vortexed, centrifuged at 3000 rpm for 5 min, and the lower layer was removed to another 15 ml tube. After removal of the chloroform layer, 3 ml hexane and 1 ml ethanol were added to the remaining aqueous phase, vortexed and centrifuged again. The upper layer was combined with the CHCl3–MeOH extract. All samples were extracted in duplicates, and their chloroform and hexane layers were combined together, dried under N2 and finally resuspended in 120 μl ethanol to make ready for HPLC analysis.
For LC-APCI-MS analysis, serum was extracted as done previously, but the final dried residue was resuspended with 100 μl of CHCl3. The CHCl3 solution was added to the centre of an aminopropyl column (500 mg/3 ml) in the Vac Elut apparatus, which was conditioned with 2 ml of hexane. An additional 100 μl of CHCl3 was used to wash the glass tube, and also transferred to the column. Under a gentle vacuum, the column containing the serum extracts was washed with 3 ml of hexane once, and eluted with 3 ml of diethyl ether with 3 % acetic acid. The elution was collected in a 5 ml glass tube, dried under N2 and resuspended with 120 μl of ethanol to make ready for LC-APCI-MS analysis.
HPLC analysis
The concentrations of xanthophylls in spirulina and human serum were analysed using a Waters HPLC coupled with a Waters 994 Programmable Photodiode Array Detector (Waters Corporation, Milford, MA, USA) and a semi-micro bore C30 column (3 μm, 150 mm × 3·0 mm; YMC, Wilmington, NC, USA). The HPLC mobile phase A contained MeOH, MTBE and 1·5 % ammonium acetate in water (85:12:3, by vol.); and phase B contained methanol, MTBE and 1·0 % ammonium acetate in water (8:90:2, by vol.). The gradient procedure, at a flow rate of 0·4 ml/min, was as follows: 0 % B isocratic (0–3 min), 0 % B – 20 % B linear gradient (3–10 min), 20 % B – 55 % B linear gradient (10–18 min), 55 % B – 95 % B linear gradient (18–33 min), 95 % B – 0 % B linear gradient (33–37 min), 0 % B isocratic (37–40 min). The total run time was 40 min and the injection volume was 20 μl. The UV–Vis spectra of all carotenoids were recorded in the range of 250–600 nm, and peak identification was based on comparisons with the retention times and absorption spectra of known carotenoid standards in our laboratory. Data acquisition and processing were performed using Empower Pro software (version 2.0; Waters Corporation).
LC-atmospheric pressure chemical ionisation-MS analysis
Analysis of zeaxanthin enrichment was performed with an Agilent LC-MS (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA) equipped with an Agilent HPLC, autosampler, UV detector, HP1100MSD with APCI interface and a C30 column (3 μm, 150 mm × 4·6 mm, Bischoff Chromatography, Leonberg, Germany). The HPLC mobile phase A contained MeOH, MTBE and 1·5 % ammonium acetate in water (83:15:2, by vol.); and phase B contained MeOH, MTBE and 1·0 % ammonium acetate in water (8:90:2, by vol.). Gradient procedures (flow rate 1 ml/min) were changed as follows: 0 % B isocratic (0–2 min), 0 % B – 5 % B linear gradient (2–10 min), 5 % B – 55 % B linear gradient (10–18 min), 55 % B – 95 % B linear gradient (18–20 min), 95 % B – 0 % B linear gradient (20–21 min), 0 % B isocratic (21–40 min). The total run time was 40 min and the injection volume was 60 μl. The UV–Vis spectra of peaks were recorded in the range of 250–600 nm and the mass spectra were recorded using the following parameters: polarity, positive; mass range, m/z 550–590; fragmentor, 90; gain, 20·00; threshold, 150; and stepsize, 0·1. Data acquisition and process were performed using ChemStations software (Agilent Technologies).
Data process and statistical analysis
The enrichment of labelled zeaxanthin was calculated by integrating the areas of labelled and unlabelled zeaxanthin in extracted ion chromatographs and by using the following equations (1–3):
The serum response of labelled zeaxanthin was calculated using equation 4, in which 0·0435 is the serum volume in litres/kg of body weight:
The area under the curve (AUC) of labelled zeaxanthin was calculated by using the curve of serum response of labelled zeaxanthin (nmol, as y axis) v. time (day, as x axis) via Integral-curve of Kaleidagraph software (version 3.5; Synergy Software, Reading, PA, USA). For all subjects, the AUC up to 15 d (AUC0–15 d) was calculated directly or calculated proportionally between the two nearest time points.
The average response to labelled spirulina zeaxanthin in the circulation was calculated using equation 5:
All statistical analyses were performed using Graphpad Prism for Windows software (version 4.0; GraphPad Software, San Diego, CA, USA). An unpaired t test was used to assess the significance of differences of age, body weight, BMI values, baseline concentrations of xanthophylls and serum responses to labelled spirulina zeaxanthin between American and Chinese subjects.
Results
Characteristics of American and Chinese subjects
As previously mentioned, two groups of middle-aged, healthy, non-smoking males were recruited in the USA (n 4) and China (n 10), respectively. The age range of American subjects is 46–52 (49·3 (sd 2·8)) years; weight range is 68·9–83·5 (76·3 (sd 6·1) kg); and BMI range is 23·1–26·5 (25·5 (sd 1·6)) kg/m2. The age range of Chinese subjects is 41–57 (48·1 (sd 5·7)) years; weight range is 52·2–78·4 (66·7 (sd 8·1)) kg; and BMI range is 17·9–27·4 (23·4 (sd 3·1)) kg/m2. Although the mean values of age, body weight and BMI of American subjects were higher than those of Chinese subjects, there were no statistically significant differences between them for these characteristics.
The carotenoid concentrations of all subjects in the two groups were in the reported ranges(Reference Ford and Giles21) (data not shown). The range of lutein concentrations was 0·12–0·18 μmol/l in the American group and 0·27–0·52 μmol/l in the Chinese group, while the range of zeaxanthin concentrations was 0·04–0·07 and 0·05–0·09 μmol/l in the American and Chinese groups, respectively.
Quantification of 2H-labelled zeaxanthin in spirulina
HPLC analyses showed that in the spirulina produced for this study, trans-zeaxanthin and trans-β-carotene were the two major carotenoids and cryptoxanthin, 13-cis-β-carotene and 9-cis-β-carotene were also present in low concentrations (Fig. 1). There was no lutein contained in the spirulina that we studied, and echinenone was too small to affect the experiment (Fig. 1).
Due to the different times at which the human studies were conducted in the USA (2008) and China (2006), the 2H-labelled spirulina was harvested in different batches. The concentration of spirulina zeaxanthin was 0·66 mg/g in the batch for American volunteers and 0·74 mg/g for Chinese volunteers; therefore, the dose of labelled spirulina zeaxanthin was 2·63 mg (4·61 μmol) for American volunteers and 3·68 mg (6·46 μmol) for Chinese volunteers (Table 1).
AUC, area under the curve.
* Baseline concentration was measured 4 d before the supplementation of spirulina.
† AUC was measured over 15 d for all subjects.
‡ Average serum response is the 15 d area under the labelled zeaxanthin response curve per μmol of consumed spirulina zeaxanthin.
Using LC-APCI-MS, the most abundant protonated molecules of unlabelled zeaxanthin were identified at m/z 569 (zeaxanthin+H+), and ions of anhydrozeaxanthin at m/z 551 (zeaxanthin+H+ − H2O) with an abundance of 12·6 % (Fig. 2(a)). About 99 % of zeaxanthin in the labelled spirulina was enriched with 2H, and Gaussian distribution of isotopomers of zeaxanthin had the most abundant enrichment of 8 2H at m/z 577 (zeaxanthin+2H8+H+; Fig. 2(b)). Similar isotopomer distribution of anhydrozeaxanthin ions (zeaxanthin+2H8+H+ − H2O, zeaxanthin +2H8+H+ − 2H2O) at m/z 559 and m/z 541 were also observed, with the abundance of 15·1 and 7·5 %, respectively (Fig. 2(b)).
Enrichment of labelled spirulina zeaxanthin in circulation in human subjects
The representative HPLC chromatographs and mass spectra of human serum zeaxanthin (from American subject 2) before and 48 h after supplementation with spirulina are shown in Fig. 3. The HPLC chromatographs demonstrate that serum extracts before and after supplementation shared similar carotenoid profiles (Fig. 3). All trans-lutein eluted at 6·9 min, and all trans-zeaxanthin eluted at 8·5 min. The amount of lutein decreased slightly 48 h post-supplementation (Fig. 3(a), before supplementation), but the amount of zeaxanthin greatly increased 48 h post-supplementation (Fig. 3(a), after supplementation).
According to the distribution of zeaxanthin mass (Fig. 2), the peaks of m/z 569–571 were assigned as endogenous unlabelled zeaxanthin, while those of m/z 573–583 were assigned as the 2H-labelled zeaxanthin from spirulina. Extracted ion chromatographs of unlabelled and labelled zeaxanthin showed that, before the supplementation, no labelled zeaxanthin was detectable at 8·5 min (Fig. 3(b), before supplementation); however, 48 h after supplementation, both labelled and unlabelled zeaxanthin were present (Fig. 3(b), after supplementation). The Gaussian isotopomer distribution of 2H-labelled zeaxanthin was clearly visible after supplementation (Fig. 3(c), after supplementation), but not before supplementation (Fig. 3(c), before supplementation), in the mass spectrum of the zeaxanthin peak maximum.
Serum responses to labelled spirulina zeaxanthin in American and Chinese volunteers
Although we followed the labelled zeaxanthin trace in the circulation up to 45 d, only data over 21 d are presented in the graphs. The concentrations of serum zeaxanthin increased dramatically about 1–2 d post-supplementation in all subjects (data not shown). The mean value of serum zeaxanthin concentration 1 d after supplementation increased from baseline of 0·06 to 0·11 μmol/l in American subjects and from baseline of 0·07 to 0·15 μmol/l in Chinese subjects (Table 1). Over the 21 d of this study, the serum concentrations of total zeaxanthin fluctuated in some subjects (e.g. American subject 1 and Chinese subject 7), but were relatively stable in others (e.g. American subject 2 and Chinese subject 10; Fig. 4). In all subjects, the enrichment of labelled zeaxanthin in the circulation reached a maximum between 1 and 3 d post-supplementation, and then decreased with little variation (Fig. 5 and data not shown). The amount of serum labelled zeaxanthin followed a similar pattern (Fig. 5). The mean highest value of labelled zeaxanthin as percentage of total zeaxanthin in American subjects was 62 % (range 59–65 %), and was 49 % in Chinese subjects (range 43–56 %; Table 1).
Area under the curve of labelled spirulina zeaxanthin responses in American and Chinese subjects
The AUC of labelled zeaxanthin was integrated using amounts of labelled zeaxanthin v. time over 15 d due to the detectability of the zeaxanthin. American subjects had a mean value of 1346 nmol × d and Chinese subjects had a mean value of 1279 nmol × d (Table 1). The mean value of the average serum response, which is the 15 d area under the serum labelled zeaxanthin response curve (in nmol × d) divided by the consumed zeaxanthin dose (in μmol), was 293 nmol × d/μmol in American subjects (range 254–335), and was 197 nmol × d/μmol in Chinese subjects (range 154–285).
Discussion
In the present study, we utilised 2H labelling and LC-APCI-MS to determine the bioavailability of spirulina zeaxanthin in human subjects. The peaks of enrichment of (M+2H8) and measurable isotopomers from (M+2H1) through (M+2H14) of labelled zeaxanthin were easily discernible from unlabelled zeaxanthin in human serum extracts (Fig. 3). After the study, subjects took a single dose of spirulina, and the labelled zeaxanthin was detected as early as 1 d post-supplementation (Fig. 5), and enrichments could be measured in circulation up to 45 d post-feeding (data not shown). Therefore, the serum response to labelled zeaxanthin from spirulina was sensitively detected with minimal influences by their daily dietary intake of zeaxanthin.
Our present study showed that spirulina is a good dietary source of zeaxanthin which can effectively increase serum zeaxanthin concentration in humans. There are several studies reporting the influence of dietary zeaxanthin on subject plasma zeaxanthin concentrations(Reference Wenzel, Gerweck and Barbato22–Reference Handelman, Nightingale and Lichtenstein26). In one study with older adults, egg-yolk supplementation of a beef tallow diet or a maize oil diet increased plasma zeaxanthin concentrations by 142 or 114 %, respectively(Reference Handelman, Nightingale and Lichtenstein26). A similar study of a 12-week egg intervention also showed that egg intake significantly increased serum zeaxanthin concentrations in women(Reference Wenzel, Gerweck and Barbato22). In a recently reported study, consumption of four egg-yolks/d for 5 weeks in older adults increased serum zeaxanthin concentrations from 0·03 to 0·06 μmol/l(Reference Vishwanathan, Goodrow-Kotyla and Wooten23). In our study, a single dose of 4·0 or 5·0 g spirulina significantly increased the zeaxanthin concentrations in the circulation of both American and Chinese subjects. One day after supplementation, the mean concentration of total serum zeaxanthin increased from 0·06 to 0·11 μmol/l in American subjects (2·63 mg zeaxanthin dose) and from 0·07 to 0·15 μmol/l in Chinese subjects (3·68 mg zeaxanthin dose; Table 1). Because egg-yolks contain a substantial amount of cholesterol, spirulina could be a good, alternative source of zeaxanthin for those individuals seeking to limit their dietary cholesterol intake. Consumption of vegetables such as spinach and maize at dietary levels have been reported to result in no increases in plasma zeaxanthin concentrations(Reference Hammond, Johnson and Russell25).
There are several factors that might be contributing to the high bioavailability of spirulina zeaxanthin in humans. First, dried spirulina powder contains an extremely high concentration of zeaxanthin, about 50–300 times higher than that in cooked egg-yolk, maize or pepper(Reference Perry, Rasmussen and Johnson13). In the present study, a single dose of 2·6 or 3·7 mg zeaxanthin was administrated to subjects, which might be difficult to achieve if other diets are chosen. Second, the spirulina cell wall is composed of proteins and peptidoglycans that can be digested easily, which helps zeaxanthin to be released from the food matrix(Reference Maiani, Caston and Catasta14, Reference Ciferri16). In addition, spirulina contains high concentrations of NEFA that can reach 9–14 % of the dry weight of spirulina(Reference Ciferri16, Reference Yeum and Russell27–Reference Hudson and Karis29). Since fat can increase the bioavailability of carotenoid absorption(Reference Wenzel, Gerweck and Barbato22, Reference Vishwanathan, Goodrow-Kotyla and Wooten23), the lipid matrix contained in spirulina may facilitate the absorption of zeaxanthin.
We observed a significant difference of average serum response to a single dose of spirulina zeaxanthin in middle-aged American and Chinese males (Table 1). However, it should be noted that the difference we observed was from two small groups (four American subjects, ten Chinese subjects), and no conclusion on racial differences of zeaxanthin absorption could be made at this point. Since it is known that both age and sex may affect the serum response to carotenoids(Reference Schweigert, Klingner and Hurtienne30–Reference Castenmiller and West32), the substantial response to spirulina zeaxanthin should be further investigated in other populations. With the present study, our data strongly suggested that spirulina is a rich dietary zeaxanthin source, which might benefit the general population for visual health.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank David A. Dworak and Chee-Ming Li for their assistance with producing the 2H-labelled spirulina. This work was supported by the Nestlé Foundation, Lausanne, Switzerland and by the US Department of Agriculture, under Cooperative Agreements 58-1950-7-707, 58-1950-9-001 and 58-6250-6-001. The authors' contributions were as follows: B. Y. conducted the sample and data analyses, and wrote the manuscript; R. M. R. and G. T. designed the study, conducted the US study and revised the manuscript; J. W., Y. W. and Z. W. conducted the human study and collected samples in China; P. M. S. was affiliated with the University Hospital and Nestlé Foundation (Lausanne, Switzerland) and revised the manuscript; S. Y. supervised the human study in China; M. A. G. produced the labelled spirulina, provided the spirulina diets and revised the manuscript. None of the authors had any personal or financial conflicts of interest.