Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T18:49:21.643Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Politics of Public Education, Health and Welfare in the USA and Western Europe: How Growth and Reform Potentials Have Differed

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 January 2009

Arnold J. Heidenheimer
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Comparativists interested in the political dynamics of policy development, and students of public policy desirous of studying national programs in crossnational contexts, face similar dilemmas at present. There is a literature focusing on decision-making processes which often pays little regard to policy substance. There are statistical analyses of expenditure levels, but these are difficult to relate to the ample literature bearing on how particular substantive problems have been handled in specific national and local situations. As a result, political scientists interested in the cross-national study of broad policy areas - such as those studying social policy development in Western Europe and America - are now engaged in the creation of historically based frameworks which will permit more fruitful analyses of differences in the patterns of development.

Type
Articles
Information
British Journal of Political Science , Volume 3 , Issue 3 , July 1973 , pp. 315 - 340
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1973

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Marshall, T. H., Class, Citizenship and Social Development (Garden City, N.Y.: Anchor, 1965), p. 131.Google Scholar

2 Groth, Alexander L., Comparative Politics: A Distributive Approach (New York: Macmillan, 1971).Google Scholar

3 One might also mention the forthcoming studies by Heclo, Hugh, From Relief to Income Maintenance: Modern Social Policy-Making in Britain and Sweden (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1974)Google Scholar and Martin, Andrew, The Politics of Economic Policy in the United States from a Comparative Perspective (Beverly Hills: Sage, 1972).Google Scholar

4 Zöllner, Detiev, Oeffentliche Sozialleistungen und wirtschaftliche Entwicklung (Berlin: Duncker and Humblot, 1963), p. 54.Google Scholar

5 Theodore Marmor, R., The Politics of Medicare (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1970)Google Scholar, Chap. 2.

6 Pryor, Frederic L., Public Expenditures in Communist and Capitalist Nations (Homewood, III.: Irwin, 1968), p. 475.Google Scholar

7 Greenstone, J. David, Labor in American Politics (New York: Knopf, 1969), p. 365.Google Scholar

8 Rimlinger, Gaston V., Welfare Policy and Industrialization in Europe, America and Russia (New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1971), p. 83.Google Scholar

9 Mcconnell, Grant, Private Power and American Democracy (New York: Knopf, 1966), p. 83.Google Scholar

10 Greenstone, , Labor in American Politics, p. 363.Google Scholar

11 Rimlinger, , Welfare Policy, p. 80.Google Scholar

12 Marshall, , Class, Citizenship and Social Development, p. 122.Google Scholar

13 Aaron, Henry, ‘Social Security: International Comparisons’, in Eckstein, Otto, ed., Studies in the Economics of Income Maintenance (Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution, 1967), pp. 15–17.Google Scholar

14 Paukert, Felix, ‘Social Security and Income Redistribution: a Comparative Study’, International Labor Review, 98 (11, 1968), 425–50.Google Scholar

15 Taira, Koji and Kilby, Peter, ‘Differences in Social Security Development in Selected Countries’, International Social Security Review, XXII (1969), 139–53, PP. 145–6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

16 Katz, Michael B., ‘Secondary Education to 1870’, Encyclopedia of Education, VII (New York: Macmillan, 1971), pp. 163–4.Google Scholar

17 Kandel, Isaac Leon, ed., Twenty-Five Years of American Education (New York: Macmillan, 1924), p. 267.Google Scholar

18 The percentages of 14–18 year olds attending school full time in 1928–30 were 33 per cent in the US, 14 per cent in Sweden, 16 per cent in Germany, and 16 per cent in England. In the US four-fifths of secondary pupils were in general secondary schools; in Europe two-thirds or more were attending vocational-type schools. Hans, N., ‘Comparative Educational Statistics’, The Yearbook of Education: 1934 (London: Evans, 1935), pp. 172–3, 180–3.Google Scholar

19 The enrolment in all secondary schools per 10,000 of population was, according to the sources utilized by Banks, as follows: Banks, Arthur S., ed., Cross-Polity Times-Series Data (Cambridge: MIT Press, 1971)Google Scholar, Segment Six.

20 Berthoff, Rowland T., An Unsettled People (New York: Harper and Row, 1971), pp. 438, 440.Google Scholar

21 Fabricant, Solomon, The Trend of Government Activity in the United States Since 1900 (New York: National Bureau of Economic Research, 1952), pp. 39, 60.Google Scholar Salary data calculated by author on the basis of data in above source.

22 Hans, , ‘Comparative Educational Statistics’, p. 171.Google Scholar The US, in increasing its secondary teaching force tenfold between 1890 and the 1920s, added more teachers at this level than Germany had teaching at all levels in 1895. US education's share of all public social welfare expenditures climbed steadily to a peak of 56.8 per cent in 1929. Its share of GNP first climbed slowly (1913 – 1.3 per cent), more quickly in the 1920s (1929 – 2.4 per cent), and then quickly again from 1947 (1966 – 4.7 per cent).

23 A possibly suggestive interview was with a Chicago teamster in 1900, ‘who had encouraged his daughter's ambitions to become a school teacher only to find his own self-respect jeopardized: he was forced first to rent a new flat and buy new furniture; he was then expected to entertain his daughter's status-conscious, white-collar friends; what is more, as a result of his added expenses, the father was forced to send out his younger children to supplement his now inadequate wages; finally, his teacher-daughter threatened, at every sign of opposition from her father, to leave her home for more congenial surroundings.’ White, Dana F., ‘Education in the Turn-of-the-Century City: the Search for Control’, Urban Education, IV (1969), p. 178Google Scholar; Havighurst, Robert J. and Neugarten, Bernice L., Society and Education (Boston: Allyn and Bacon, 1957), pp. 358–60.Google Scholar

24 Pryor, , Public Expenditures, pp. 424, 428.Google Scholar Utilizing data from the 1950s, Pryor classifies the US as ‘high’, or more than 31/2 times average industrial wages for physicians’ incomes, whereas countries like West Germany and Soviet Russia, are classified as ‘low’, less than 21/2 times indusrial wages. For teachers, ratios of wages to average industrial wages for 1958 were 105 per cent for the US, 188 per cent for West Germany, 185 per cent for Austria, etc. See also Safilios-rotschild, Constantina, ‘A Cross-Cultural Examination of Women's Marital, Educational and Occupational Options,’ Acta Sociologica, XIV (1971), 96–113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

25 Kandel, I. L. acknowledged that Europe would be slow to follow the American movement for universal secondary education because it was based more on equality than educational principles: ‘Education’, Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, V (New York: Macmillan, 1935), p. 421.Google Scholar

26 Welter, Rush, Popular Education and Democratic Thought in America (New York: Columbia University Press, 1962), pp. 189, 241.Google Scholar

27 Veiller, Lawrence, Housing Reform (New York: Sage Foundation, 1910), p. 189.Google Scholar

28 Reports of the Mosely Commission to the United States of America (London: Co-operative Printing Society, 1904), p. 398.Google Scholar

29 Comstock, Alzada, ‘Expenditures, Public’, Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, VI, p. 7.Google Scholar

30 Rimlinger, , Welfare Policy, p. 232.Google Scholar

31 Merriam, Ida C. and Skolnik, Alfred M., Social Welfare Expenditures under Public Programs in the United States, 1929–1966 (Washington: US Social Security Administration, 1968), p. 253.Google Scholar

32 Merriam, and Skolnik, , Social Welfare Expenditures, pp. 192, 214.Google Scholar

33 International Labor Office, The Cost of Social Security: Sixth International Inquiry (Geneva: International Labor Office, 1967), p. 322.Google Scholar

34 Even the official document (Merriam, and Skolnik, , Social Welfare Expenditures, p. 161)Google Scholar ascertains that ‘the amounts expended remained relatively modest’.

35 Merriam, and Skolnik, , Social Welfare Expenditures, p. 193.Google Scholar

36 Gilb, Corinne, Hidden Hierarchies: the Professions and the Government (New York: Harper and Row, 1966), pp. 34–40Google Scholar; Stevens, Rosemary, American Medicine and the Public Interest (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1971), Chap. 3Google Scholar; Truman, David, The Governmental Process (New York: Knopf, 1951)Google Scholar; Berthoff, , Unsettled People, p. 450.Google Scholar

37 Naschold, Frieder, Kassenärzte and Krankenversicherungsreform (Freiburg: Rombach, 1967), p. 152.Google Scholar

38 Stevens, American Medicine, Chap. 7; Schlabach, Theodore F., Edwin E. Witte, Cautious Reformer (Madison: Wisconsin State Historical Society, 1969), pp. 112–15.Google Scholar

39 Mosher, Frederick, Democracy and the Public Service (New York: Oxford University Press, 1968), p. 109.Google Scholar

40 Friedman, Lawrence, Government and Slum Housing: a Century of Frustration (Chicago: Rand McNally, 1968), pp. 105, 109.Google Scholar

41 Bruno, Frank J., Trends in Social Work 1874–1956 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1957), pp. 227, 351.Google Scholar

42 Charles Abrams, ‘Housing Policy – 1937 to 1967’, in Frieden, B. and Nash, William, eds., Shaping an Urban Future (Cambridge: MIT Press, 1969), p. 36.Google Scholar

43 Rimlinger, , Welfare Policy, p. 232.Google Scholar

44 Bendix, Reinhard, Nation-Building and Citizenship: Studies of our Changing Social Order (New York: Wiley, 1964), pp. 81–3.Google Scholar

45 Eugene, N. and Anderson, Pauline, ‘Bureaucratic Institutionalization in Nineteenth Century Europe’, in Hiedenheimer, Arnold J., ed., Political Corruption: Readings in Comparative Analysi (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1970), pp. 91–105.Google Scholar

46 Finer, Samuel E., ‘Patronage and the Public Service: Jeffersonian Democracy and the Public Service’, in Heidenheimer, , ed., Political Corruption, pp. 106–28.Google Scholar

47 The judgement of Moses, Robert in English Civil Service Reform (New York: Columbia, 1903)Google Scholar that ‘the conditions in the services of England and the United States at the beginning of reform were astonishingly similar’ may be too strong. See also, Van Riper, Paul W., ‘Adapting a British Political Convention to American Needs’, Public Administration, XXXI (1953), 317–30;CrossRefGoogle ScholarCallard, Keith, ‘On the Ethics of Civil Servants in Great Britain and North America’, Public Policy, VII (1959). 134–56.Google Scholar

48 Bruno, , Trends in Social Work, p. 259.Google Scholar

49 Veiller, , Housing Reform, pp. 79–83.Google Scholar

50 Lindeman, E. C., ‘Public Welfare’, Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, XI, p. 688.Google Scholar

51 Rakoff, Stuart H. and Schaefer, Guenther F., ‘Politics, Policy and Political Science: Theoretical Alternatives’, Politics and Society,I (1970), 51–77, p. 66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

52 Humes, Samuel and Martin, Eileen, The Structure of Local Government (The Hague: International Union of Local Authorities, 1969), p. 75.Google Scholar

53 Lockard, Duane, ‘Local Government’, International Encyclopedia of Social Science, IX (New York: Collier and Macmillan, 1968), p. 453.Google Scholar

54 Herman, Harold, New York State and the Metropolitan Problem (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1963), p. 118.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

55 Fabricant, , Government Activity in the U.S., p. 252.Google Scholar

56 Salisbury, Robert H., ‘Schools and Politics in the Big City’, Harvard Education Review, XXXVII (1967), 408–24, p. 424.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

57 Coons, John E. et al. , Private Wealth and Public Education (Cambridge, Mass: Belknap Press, 1970), p. 45.Google Scholar

58 In the 1960s one-third of Hesse's small communes had not produced a single Gymnasium graduate in the preceding decade. Van De Graaff, John H., “West Germany's Abitur Quota and School Reform’, Comparative Education Review, XI (1967), 75–86, p. 81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

59 Kandel, , Twenty-five Years of American Education, p. 214.Google Scholar

60 Safran, William, Veto Group-Politics: the Case of Health Insurance Reform in West Germany (San Francisco: Chandler, 1967), pp. 128, 145.Google Scholar

61 Committee for Economic Development, Modernizing Local Government (New York: CED, 1966), pp. 32–3, 37–8.Google Scholar

62 Murphy, Jerome T., ‘Title I of ESEA: The Politics of Implementing Federal Education Reform’, Harvard Education Review, XLI (1971), 52–63, p. 53.Google Scholar

63 National Advisory Council on the Education of Disadvantaged Children, Title 1 ESEA: 1971 Annual Report (Washington, D.C.: 1971), p. 6.Google Scholar

64 Pryor, , Public Expenditures, p. 489.Google Scholar

65 International Studies of Values in Politics, Values and the Active Community (New York: Free Press, 1971), p. 208.Google Scholar

66 Bertram, Juergen, Staatspolitik und Kommunalpolitik (Stuttgart: Kohlhammer, 1967), p. 53.Google Scholar

67 Elazar, Daniel J., American Federalism: A View from the States (New York: Crowell, 1966), p. 195.Google Scholar

68 Crozier, Michel, The Bureaucratic Phenomenon (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1964), p. 236.Google Scholar

69 Montgomery, John D., ‘Programs and Poverty: Federal Aid in the Domestic and International Systems’, Public Policy, XVIII (1970), 517–38.Google Scholar

70 Pension and family allowance initiation dates are: Sweden –1913, 1947; Britain –1908, 1945; Germany –1889, 1954; US –1935, none.

71 According to OECD data Germany and Austria were the only countries in which secondary school enrolment increased by less than 50 per cent in the 1955–65 period. Growth indices for 1955–65 were Germany – 1 per cent, France 107 per cent, Sweden 34 per cent, UK 48 per cent. Development in Secondary Education (Paris: OECD, 1969), pp. 26–30.Google Scholar

72 Beatrice, and Webb, Sidney, ‘Special Supplement on Professional Associations’, New Statesman, IX (28 04 1917), p. 47.Google Scholar

73 Kariel, Henry S., The Decline of American Pluralism (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1961), p. 104.Google Scholar

74 Lieberman, Myron, Education as a Profession (Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1958), pp. 93–4.Google Scholar

75 Fuhrig, Wolf, ‘West Germany’ in Blum, Albert, ed., Teachers Unions and Associations (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1969), p. 113Google Scholar; Naschold, , Kassenärzte, pp. 120 ff.Google Scholar

76 Glaser, William A., ‘Doctors and Politics,’ American Journal of Sociology, LXVI (1960), 230–45, p. 237.CrossRefGoogle Scholar Thus the editor of a leading medical journal wrote in 1951: ‘The doctor's dilemma today emerges from the fact that politics is a dirty-hands business, and medicine has always been a clean-hands profession. Healing and heeling don't go together.’

77 Thus compulsory school attendance laws were introduced in Massachusetts in 1854, but not until 1920 in Mississippi.

78 Freymann, John G., ‘A Doctor Prescribes for the AMA’, Harper's, 231 (1965), 76–80, p. 78.Google Scholar

79 Fuhrig, , ‘West Germany’, p. 106.Google Scholar

80 Eckstein, , Pressure Group Politics (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1960), p. 29.Google Scholar

81 Between 1929 and 1959 the incomes of US specialists and GPs became less disparate. Incomes of the former increased by about two and a half, those of the latter five-fold. The American specialist colleges operated ‘largely without the strong social and regulatory overtones of the British models’, and the GP-specialist relationship has been marked by no ‘clear demarcation of function’. Stevens, , American Medicine, pp. 95Google Scholar, 185. In the US about 75 per cent of physicians engage in some specialty practice, but in the more demarcated British profession only 22 per cent, and in Germany 43 per cent, do so. Schicke, Romuald K., Arzt und Gesundheitsversorgung im gesellschaftlichen Sicherungssystem (Freiburg: Rombach, 1971), pp. 88, 164.Google Scholar

82 Eckstein, , Pressure Group Politics, pp. 68, 107;Google ScholarGilbert, Bentley B., The Evolution of National Insurance in Great Britain (London: Michael Joseph, 1966), pp. 413 ff.Google Scholar

83 Kariel, , Decline of American Pluralism, pp. 110–11.Google Scholar

84 Fesler, James W., The Independence of State Regulatory Agencies (Chicago: Public Administration Service, 1942), pp. 49, 60, 70.Google Scholar

85 Lowi, Theodore J., The End of Liberalism (New York: Norton, 1969), p. 86.Google Scholar

86 Witte, Edwin E., Social Security Perspectives (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1962), p. 317.Google Scholar

87 Mcconnell, Grant, ‘The Public Values of the Private Association’, in Pennock, J. Roland and Chapman, John W., ed., Voluntary Associations (New York: Atherton Press, 1969), p. 160.Google Scholar

88 Robinsohn, Saul B. and Kuhlmann, J. C., ‘Two Decades of Non-Reform in West German Education’, Comparative Education Review, XI (1967), 311–30, p. 326.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

89 De Graaff, Van, ‘West Germany's Abitur Quota’, p. 81.Google Scholar

90 Anderson, Odin W., Health Care: Can There be Equity? The United States, Sweden and England (New York: Wiley, 1972), p. 114.Google Scholar

91 Katona, George, Strumpel, Burkhard and Zahn, Ernest, Aspirations and Affluence (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1971), p. 162.Google Scholar

92 Verba, Sidney and Nie, Norman, Participation in America (New York: Harper and Row, 1972). pp. 280–4.Google Scholar

93 Infant mortality rates per 1,000 live births in 1960 were: US, 26; England, 21.8; Sweden, 16.6. Decline in infant morality rates was slower throughout the 1960s in the US. Anderson, , Health Care, pp. 148, 243.Google Scholar

94 Anderson, describing another subsidy program that Congress set up in an attempt to affect disease incidence, noted that ‘it must appear frightfully messy to British and Swedish observers … but given the federal system and the private ownership of the means of delivering health services, there was little alternative.’ Health Care, p. 177.

95 Nixdorff, Peter, ‘The Pace of West German Educational Reform as Affected by Land Politics’ (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Florida, 1970), p. 135.Google Scholar

96 Between 1906 and 1930 the number of medical schools was reduced from 162 to 76, and the doctor ratio from 157 to 126 per 100,000 population. The number of medical graduates was smaller in 1950 than it had been in 1904.

97 Marmor, Theodore R. and Thomas, D., ‘The Politics of Paying Physicians’, International Journal of Health Sciences, I (1972), 71–8, p. 74.Google Scholar

98 Greenstone, , Labor in American Politics, p. 369.Google Scholar

99 Paulston, Rolland G., Educational Change in Sweden (New York: Teachers College Press, 1968), p. 122.Google Scholar

100 Hancock, M. Donald, Sweden: The Politics of Postindustrial Change (Hinsdale, Illinois: Dryden, 1972)Google Scholar, Chap. 4.

101 Marshall, T. H., Social Policy, 3rd ed. (London: Hutchinson University Library, 1970), p. 116Google Scholar; Anderson, , Health Care, p. 93.Google Scholar

102 Lohmann, Joachim, ‘Entwicklung und Stand der Gesamtschulplanung in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland’, International Review of Education, XVII (1971), 50–7, p. 55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

103 Iglehart, John K., ‘Health Report’, National Journal, 10 07 1971, pp. 1444–5, 1449.Google Scholar

104 Eckstein, Harry, The English Health Service (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1958), p. 113Google Scholar; Gilbert, Evolution of National Insurance in Great Britain.

103 Forsythe, Gordon, Doctors and State Medicine (Philadelphia: J. B. Lippicott, 1966), p. 4.Google Scholar

106 Husen, Torsten, ‘Responsiveness and Resistance in the Educational System to Changing Needs of Society’, International Review of Education, XV (1969), 476–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

107 Gahlings, Ilse, Die Volksschullehrer and Ihre Berufsverbaende (Neuwied: Luchterhand, 1967)Google Scholar; Hight, Boyd, ‘Teachers, Bargaining and Strikes: Perspectives from the Swedish Experience’, UCLA Law Review, XV (1968), 842–76.Google Scholar

108 In a 1956 survey of medical students only 4 per cent said they would be ‘very interested’ in work with the Public Health Service or Veteran's Administration, 60 per cent said they were ‘not at all interested’; Glaser, , ‘Doctors and Polities’, p. 239.Google Scholar The proportion of doctors’ incomes deriving from public and private health insurance sources in 1963 was about 38 per cent in the US, some 63–80 per cent in West Germany and 90 per cent in Britain; Schicke, , Arzt, p. 166.Google Scholar

109 Anderson, , Health Care, p. 66.Google Scholar

110 Kuhlmann, Casper, ‘Schulreform und Gesellschaft in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland: 1946–1966’, in Robinsohn, S. B., ed., Schulreform im gesellschaftlichen Prozess, (Stuttgart: Klett, 1970), p. 170.Google Scholar

111 Husen, Torsten, Problems of Differentiation in Swedish Compulsory Schooling (Stockholm; Scandinavian University Books, 1962), p. 54.Google Scholar

112 Nixdorff, , ‘The Pace of West German Educational Reform’, p. 154.Google Scholar

113 Kuhlmann, , ‘Schulreform’, p. 185.Google Scholar

114 Fuhrig, , ‘West Germany’, p. 106.Google Scholar

115 Anthony King, ‘Ideas, Institutions and the Policies of Governments: a Comparative Analysis: Part III’, British Journal of Political Science (forthcoming).