Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-dh8gc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-15T14:52:57.889Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Entrepreneurial Typologies in the History of Industrial Italy: Reconsiderations

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 May 2011

Franco Amatori
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The market types that were the subject of an earlier essay in the Review are resurveyed in order to examine the changes that have occurred over the past fifty years. The entrepreneurial typologies identified then–one based on a market orientation, another that relies on state support, and a third, hybrid, approach–are still valid today. The liveliest components of the modern Italian economy, which operate as a fourth type of capitalism (mainly based on industrial districts), share features of the market typology, while, in southern Italy, the state's failure to support business is linked to the rise of organized crime. The more recent hybrid type features a new kind of actor, exemplified by Silvio Berlusconi, the central figure on the Italian political scene for almost two decades.

Type
Research Article
Information
Business History Review , Volume 85 , Issue 1 , Spring 2011 , pp. 151 - 180
Copyright
Copyright © The President and Fellows of Harvard College 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Amatori, Franco, ’Entrepreneurial Typologies in the History of Industrial Italy (1880–1960): A Review Article,“ Business History Review 54 (Autumn 1980): 359–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

2 Castronovo, Valerio, Giovanni Agnelli (Turin, 1971)Google Scholar; Bonelli, Franco, Lo sviluppo di una grande impresa in Italia: La Terni dal 1884 al 1962 (Turin, 1975)Google Scholar; Mori, Giorgio, Studi di storia dell'industria (Rome, 1966)Google Scholar and Il capitalismo industriale in Italia (Rome, 1977)Google Scholar; Cianci, Ernesto, Nascita dello Stato imprenditore in Italia (Milan, 1977)Google Scholar; Avagliano, Lucio, Alessandro Rossi e le origini dell'Italia industriale (Naples, 1969)Google Scholar; and Romano, Roberto, ’Il cotonificio Cantoni dalle origini al 1900,“ Studi Storici 16 (1975): 461–94.Google Scholar

3 Mortara, Alberto, ed., I protagonisti dell'intervento pubblico in Italia (Milan, 1984)Google Scholar; Carocci, Giampiero, Storia d'Italia dall'Unità a oggi (Milan, 1975).Google Scholar

4 Amatori, ’Entrepreneurial Typologies,“ 376–79.

5 On the importance of contextualization see Jones, Geoffrey and Wadhwani, R. Daniel, ’Entrepreneurship,“ in The Oxford Handbook of Business History, ed. Jones, Geoffrey and Zeitlin, Jonathan (Oxford, 2008), 501–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar. I more extensively developed this outline of Italian economic history in ’Big and Small Business in Italy's Industrial History,“ Rivista di Storia economica 2 (2008): 207–24Google Scholar, while the most complete survey is Ciocca, Pierluigi, Ricchi per sempre? Una storia economica dell'Italia (1796–2005) (Rome, 2007).Google Scholar

6 See Amatori, Franco, ’Entrepreneurship,“ Imprese e Storia 34 (2006): 233–67.Google Scholar

7 See Amatori, Franco and Bigatti, Giorgio, ’Business History in Italy at the Turn of the Century,“ in Business History around the World, ed. Amatori, Franco and Jones, Geoffrey (Cambridge, U.K., 2003), 215–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Giannetti, Renato and Vasta, Michelangelo, Storia dell'impresa industriale italiana (Bologna, 2005)Google Scholar; and Colli, Andrea and Vasta, Michelangelo, eds., Forms of Enterprise in Twentieth Century Italy: Boundaries, Structures, and Strategies (Cheltenham, 2010).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

8 Though neither completed nor published, scholars can consult a pre-print version available in the library at Bocconi University.

9 Toninelli, Pierangelo and Vasta, Michelangelo, ’Italian Entrepreneurship: Conjectures and Evidence from a Historical Perspective,“ in The Determinants of Entrepreneurship: Leadership, Culture, Institutions, ed. José García-Ruiz, L. and Toninelli, Pier Angelo (London, 2010), 49–79.Google Scholar

10 Polese, Francesca, ’In Search of a New Industry: Giovanni Battista Pirelli and his Educational Journey through Europe (1870–1871),“ Business History 48 (July 2006): 354–75CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Barbone, Donato, ’L'internazionalizzazione come condizione di sopravvivenza: Il caso Pirelli,“ in L'industria italiana nel mercato mondiale: Dalla fine dell'800 alla metà del '900, ed. Fiat, Archivio Storico (Turin, 1993), 87–116.Google Scholar

11 On these topics see the essays in Fiat, Archivio Storico, ed., L'industria italiana nel mercato mondiale: Dalla fine dell'800 alla metà del '900 (Turin, 1993).Google Scholar

12 Chiapparino, Francesco, ’Gualino, Riccardo,“ Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 60 (Rome, 2003), 172–78.Google Scholar

13 In 1927, with the ’Quota 90“ policy, it took 90 lira to buy one British pound sterling while the previous year the exchange rate had been 150 lira for one pound. This was the result of the ’lira battle“ proclaimed by Mussolini in August 1926.

14 Spadoni, Marcella, ’Marinotti, Franco,“ Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 70 (Rome, 2008), 550–54Google Scholar; Castronovo, Valerio and Falchero, Anna Maria, L'avventura di Franco Marinotti: Impresa, finanza e politica nella vita di un capitano di industria (Milan, 2008).Google Scholar

15 After Marinotti's death in 1966, SNIA started declining, due also to the difficulties of the artificial fibers industries caused by overproduction. In 2010 the company ceased operations.

16 Quoted by Cafagna, Luciano, Dualismo e sviluppo nella storia d'Italia (Venezia, 1989), 284. A good example is that of the Falck family, see Amatori, ’Entrepreneurial Typologies,“ 383–84.Google Scholar

17 Oswald, Anne von, ’L'industria tedesca in Italia dall'età giolittiana alla seconda guerra mondiale,“ Archivi e Imprese 10 (1994): 34–72Google Scholar; and Hertner, Peter, Il capitale tedesco in Italia dall'unità alla prima guerra mondiale (Bologna, 1983).Google Scholar

18 See Jesurum, A. Scolari Sellerio, ’Besso, Marco,“ Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 9 (Rome, 1967), 696–98Google Scholar; and Millo, Anna, Trieste, le assicurazioni, l'Europa: Arnoldo Frigessi di Rattalma e la Ras (Milan, 2004).Google Scholar

19 Amatori, ’Entrepreneurial Typologies,“ 366–70.

20 Coppini, Paolo Romano, ’Bastogi, Pietro,“ Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 7 (Rome, 1970), 176–80, updated in Dizionario Biografico degli Imprenditori Italiani (BDIE), mimeo (pre-print version).Google Scholar

21 Amatori, ’Entrepreneurial Typologies,“ 376–83.

22 Amatori, Franco, ’Donegani, Guido,“ in Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 41 (Rome, 1992), 134–42.Google Scholar

23 Bigazzi, Duccio, ’Esportazioni e investimenti esteri: La Fiat sul mercato mondiale fino al 1940,“ in Fiat 1899–1930: Storia e documenti, ed. Fiat, Progetto Archivio Storico (Milan, 1991), 77–168.Google Scholar

24 See note 13.

25 Perugini, Mario, ’Grande impresa e Italia autarchica: La Montecatini, 1929–1943,“ PhD diss., Universitá Bocconi, Milan, 2009.Google Scholar

26 Toninelli, Pier Angelo, ’Between Agnelli and Mussolini: Ford's Unsuccessful Attempt to Penetrate the Italian Automobile Market in the Interwar Period,“ Enterprise and Society 10 (June 2009): 335–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

27 Falchero, Anna Maria, ’Foto di gruppo: Gli elettrici dopo la marcia su Roma,“ in Annali di Storia dell'Impresa, vol. 9 (Bologna, 1993), 95–153.Google Scholar

28 Amatori, Franco and Brioschi, Francesco, ’Le grandi imprese private: Famiglie e coalizioni,“ in Storia del capitalismo italiano dal dopoguerra a oggi, ed. Barca, Fabrizio (Rome, 1997), 117–53.Google Scholar

29 Segreto, Luciano, Giacinto Motta: Un ingegnere alla testa del capitalismo industriale italiano (Rome-Bari, 2004), 284, 319.Google Scholar

30 Petrini, Francesco, Il liberismo a una dimensione: La Confinudstria e l'integrazione europea, 1947–1957 (Milan, 2005).Google Scholar

31 Balconi, Margherita, La siderurgia italiana (1945–1990): Tra controllo pubblico e incentivi di mercato (Bologna, 1991), 103.Google Scholar

32 Bairati, Piero, Vittorio Valletta (Turin, 1983).Google Scholar

33 See Colitti, Marcello, Energia e sviluppo in Italia: La vicenda di Enrico Mattei (De Donato, Bari, 1979Google Scholar) as well as the more recent Pozzi, Daniele, Dai gatti selvatici al cane a sei zampe: Tecnologia, conoscenza e organizzazione nell'AGIP e nell'ENI di Enrico Mattei (Venice, 2009).Google Scholar

34 Romano, Roberto, ’Borghi, Giovanni,“ Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 34 (Rome, 1988), 498–500Google Scholar; and Colli, Andrea, ’Fumagalli, Eden,“ Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 50 (Rome, 1998), 720–22.Google Scholar

35 Castellano, Carlo, L'industria degli elettrodomestici in Italia: Fattori e caratteri (Turin, 1965)Google Scholar; and Sori, Ercole, Merloni: Da Fabriano al mondo (Milan, 2005).Google Scholar

36 Berta, Giuseppe, Le idee al potere: Adriano Olivetti tra la fabbrica e la Comunitá (Milan, 1980)Google Scholar; and Bricco, Paolo, Olivetti prima e dopo Adriano: Industria, cultura, estetica (Naples, 2005).Google Scholar

37 Pirani, Mario, ’I tre appuntamenti mancati dell'industria italiana,“ Il Mulino 6 (1991): 1045–51.Google Scholar

38 McCraw, Thomas K., ’From Partners to Competitors: An Overview of the Period since World War II,“ in America versus Japan, ed. McCraw, Thomas K. (Boston, 1986), 1–33.Google Scholar

39 Amatori, ’Big and Small Business in Italy's Industrial History.“

40 Amatori, Franco, ’Beyond State and Market: Italy's Futile Search for a Third Way,“ in The Rise and Fall of State-Owned Enterprise in the Western World, ed. Toninelli, Pier Angelo (Cambridge, U.K., 2000), 128–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

41 On Mario Marchesi, see Roberto Tolaini, ’Marchesi, Mario,“ Dizionario Biografico degli Imprenditori Italiani (BDIE), mimeo (pre-print version). On Alberto Capanna see Ilaria Mandolesi, ’Capanna, Alberto,“ Dizionario Biografico degli Imprenditori Italiani (BDIE), mimeo (pre-print version).

42 See Arlacchi, Pino, La mafia imprenditrice: L'etica mafiosa e lo spirito del capitalismo (Bologna, 1983)Google Scholar; and Catanzaro, Raimondo, Il delitto come impresa: Storia sociale della mafia (Padua, 1988)Google Scholar. See also Barbagallo, Francesco, Il potere della camorra, 1973–1998 (Turin, 1999).Google Scholar

43 Hughes, Jonathan, ’Entrepreneurship,“ in Encyclopedia of American Economic History, vol. 1, ed. Porter, Glenn (New York, 1980), 229–46.Google Scholar

44 Baumol, William J., ’Entrepreneurship: Productive, Unproductive, and Destructive,“ Journal of Political Economy 5 (1998): 893–929.Google Scholar

45 Following the bombing of Tripoli in 1986, the Reagan Administration ordered Fiat to rid itself of the Libyan government as a shareholder if it wanted to continue participation in the ’Star Wars“ program. Lafico, a financial holding of the Libyan government, had bought 15 percent of the company's shares for a value of 300 billion lire in 1976. Given Fiat's good financial results, a decade later these shares had become worth ten times as much. Fiat (with the help of some banks and with a strong public relations campaign) went on to mislead new shareholders. For more on this incident, see Castronovo, Valerio, Fiat: 1899–1999, Un secolo di storia (Milan, 1999), 1572–77.Google Scholar

46 Amatori, Franco, ’Gardini, Raul,“ Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, vol. 52 (Rome, 1998), 271–77. Montedison was formed in 1966 as the merger of Montecatini with Edison. Edison was the biggest Italian electric company and was bloated with cash after the nationalization of the electric industry in 1962.Google Scholar

47 Borsa, Marco (with Luca De Biase), Capitani di sventura (Milano, 1992).Google Scholar

48 Robert Putnam with Leonardi, Robert and Nanetti, Raffaella, Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy (Princeton, 1993).Google Scholar

49 Fuà, Giorgio and Zacchia, Carlo, eds., Industrializzazione senza fratture (Bologna, 1983)Google Scholar. See also Becattini, Giacomo, Dal distretto industriale allo sviluppo locale: Svolgimento e difesa di un'idea (Turin, 2000)Google Scholar; and Colli, Andrea, I volti di Proteo: Storia della piccola impresa in Italia nel Novecento (Turin, 2002).Google Scholar

50 Colli, Andrea, Il quarto capitalismo: Un profilo italiano (Venice, 2002)Google Scholar. Colli utilizes the concept of ’Fourth Capitalism“ based on an idea first expressed by Turani, Giuseppe in I sogni del grande Nord (Bologna, 1996).Google Scholar

51 On Berlusconi, see Fiori, Giuseppe, Il venditore: Storia di Silvio Berlusconi e della Fininvest (Milano, 2006)Google Scholar; and Molteni, Mario, Il gruppo Fininvest (Turin, 1998).Google Scholar

52 For a detailed overview of the privatization process see IRI, Le privatizzazioni in Italia: 1992–2000 (Rome, 2001).Google Scholar

53 Zamagni, Vera, Finmeccanica: Competenze che vengono da lontano (Bologna, 2009).Google Scholar

54 Amatori, Franco and Licini, Stefania, eds., Dalmine, 1906–2006: Un secolo di industria (Dalmine, 2006).Google Scholar

55 Gallino, Luciano, La scomparsa dell'Italia industriale (Turin, 2003).Google Scholar

56 Berta, Giuseppe, Metamorfosi: L'industria italiana fra declino e trasformazione (Milan, 2004).Google Scholar

57 Porter, Michael E., The Competitive Advantage of Nations (New York, 1998; 1st ed. 1990), 421–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar