Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T06:23:02.251Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Climate of Change? The Oil Industry and Decarbonization in Historical Perspective

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 May 2019

Marten Boon
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Decarbonization has been identified as necessary to preventing catastrophic climate change, creating a dilemma for the global oil industry. This article examines the industry's reaction to this dilemma and focuses on its historical response to market and governmental regulatory pressure. The article argues that differing national climate policies provoked some oil companies to develop proactive decarbonization strategies. However, the continued growth of fossil fuel demand, the industry's vested interests, and the voluntary nature of climate governance have resulted in the industry taking very little meaningful action to achieve decarbonization.

Keywords

multinational oil companiesenvironmental historyclimate changeenergy transitiondecarbonization
Type
Research Article
Information
Business History Review , Volume 93 , Issue 1: Business and the Environment Revisited , Spring 2019 , pp. 101 - 125
Copyright
Copyright © The President and Fellows of Harvard College 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

Earlier versions of this article were presented at the University of Umeå and Harvard Business School. The author would like to thank Ann-Kristin Bergquist and Mattias Näsman and three anonymous reviewers for their invaluable comments and suggestions.

References

1 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), Global Warming of 1.5°C (Geneva, 2018)Google Scholar; Steffen, Will, Richardson, Katherine, Rockström, Johan, Cornell, Sarah E., Fetzer, Ingo, Bennett, Elena M., Biggs, Reinette, et al. , “Planetary Boundaries: Guiding Human Development on a Changing Planet,” Science 347, no. 6223 (2015): 1259855CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

2 United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), Emissions Gap Report 2018 (Nairobi, 2018)Google Scholar; Victor, David G., Akimoto, Keigo, Kaya, Yoichi, Yamaguchi, Mitsutsune, Cullenward, Danny, and Hepburn, Cameron, “Prove Paris Was More Than Paper Promises,” Nature 548, no. 7665 (2017): 25–27CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

3 International Energy Agency (IEA), Key World Energy Statistics 2018 (Paris, 2018), 2Google Scholar.

4 Unruh, Gregory, “Understanding Carbon Lock-In,” Energy Policy 28, no. 12 (2000): 817–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hughes, Thomas P., “The Seamless Web: Technology, Science, Etcetera, Etcetera,” Social Studies of Science 16, no. 2 (1986): 281–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Geels, Frank W., “Disruption and Low-Carbon System Transformation: Progress and New Challenges in Socio-Technical Transitions Research and the Multi-Level Perspective,” Energy Research & Social Science 37 (Mar. 2018): 224–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Van der Vleuten, E. and Högselius, P., “Resisting Change? The Transnational Dynamics of European Energy Regimes,” in Governing the Energy Transition: Reality, Illusion or Necessity?, ed. Verbong, Geert and Loorbach, Derk (Hoboken, NJ, 2012), 75–100Google Scholar.

6 See, for example, Mom, Gijs, “Roads without Rails: European Highway-Network Building and the Desire for Long-Range Motorized Mobility,” Technology and Culture 46, no. 4 (2005): 745–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Schipper, Frank, Driving Europe: Building Europe on Roads in the Twentieth Century (Amsterdam, 2008)Google Scholar; and Sabin, Paul, Crude Politics: The California Oil Market, 1900–1940 (Berkeley, 2005), 11Google Scholar.

7 Jones, Geoffrey, Profits and Sustainability: A History of Green Entrepreneurship (Oxford, 2017), 346–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Hockerts, Kai and Wüstenhagen, Rolf, “Greening Goliaths versus Emerging Davids: Theorizing about the Role of Incumbents and New Entrants in Sustainable Entrepreneurship,” Journal of Business Venturing 25, no. 5 (2010): 481–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 See, for example, “New York Sues Big Oil Companies over Climate Change,” Financial Times, 11 Jan. 2018; Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL), Smoke and Fumes: The Legal and Evidentiary Basis for Holding Big Oil Accountable for the Climate Crisis (Washington, DC, 2017), 8–19; and Brulle, Robert J., “Institutionalizing Delay: Foundation Funding and the Creation of U.S. Climate Change Counter-Movement Organizations,” Climatic Change 122, no. 4 (2014): 681–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar. On investor criticism and expectations, see, for instance, Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), Implementing the Recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (Geneva, 2017); and Institutional Investors Group on Climate Change (IIGCC), Investor Climate Compass: Oil and Gas: Navigating Investor Engagement (London, 2017).

10 Oil consumption in developed countries (OECD members) grew at an annual rate of 0.3 percent between 1990 and 2017; in non-OECD countries, at 2.5 percent. Author's own calculations, from BP, Statistical Review of World Energy (2018).

11 Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 358–59; Ehrenfeld, John R., “Beyond the Brave New World: Business for Sustainability,” in The Oxford Handbook of Business and the Natural Environment, ed. Bansal, Pratima and Hoffman, Andrew J. (Oxford, 2012), 611–19Google Scholar; Thomas N. Gladwin, “Capitalism Critique: Systemic Limits on Business Harmony with Nature,” in Bansal and Hoffman, Oxford Handbook, 657–74; Wright, Christopher and Nyberg, Daniel, Climate Change, Capitalism, and Corporations: Processes of Creative Self-Destruction (Cambridge, UK, 2015), 6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 360.

13 For example: Melosi, Martin V. and Pratt, Joseph A., eds., Energy Metropolis: An Environmental History of Houston and the Gulf Coast (Pittsburgh, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Sabin, Crude Politics; Santiago, Myrna I., The Ecology of Oil: Environment, Labor, and the Mexican Revolution, 1900–1938 (Cambridge, UK, 2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Gorman, Hugh S., Redefining Efficiency: Pollution Concerns, Regulatory Mechanisms, and Technological Change in the U.S. Petroleum Industry (Akron, OH, 2001)Google Scholar.

14 Rome, Adam, “The Ecology of Commerce: Environmental History and the Challenge of Building a Sustainable Economy,” in Green Capitalism? Business and the Environment in the Twentieth Century, ed. Berghoff, Hartmut and Rome, Adam (Philadelphia, 2017), 3–12Google Scholar.

15 Ekwurzel, B., Boneham, J., Dalton, M. W., Heede, R., Mera, R. J., Allen, M. R., and Frumhoff, P. C., “The Rise in Global Atmospheric CO2, Surface Temperature, and Sea Level from Emissions Traced to Major Carbon Producers,” Climatic Change 144, no. 4 (2017): 579–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Griffin, Paul, The Carbon Majors Database: CDP Carbon Majors Report 2017 (London, 2017)Google Scholar.

16 IEA, Key World Energy Statistics, 2.

17 IEA, 14, 19.

18 Jackson, R. B., Quéré, C. Le, Andrew, R. M., Canadell, J. G., Korsbakken, J. I., Liu, Z., Peters, G. P., and Zheng, B., “Global Energy Growth Is Outpacing Decarbonization,” Environmental Research Letters 13, no. 12 (2018): 120401CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 UNEP, Emissions Gap, xvii.

20 Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 399–400.

21 IPCC, Global Warming, 16–19.

22 Bill McKibben, “Why We Need to Keep 80 Percent of Fossil Fuels in the Ground,” Yes!, Spring 2016, 19; McGlade, Christophe and Ekins, Paul, “The Geographical Distribution of Fossil Fuels Unused When Limiting Global Warming to 2°C,” Nature 517 (8 Jan. 2015): 187–90CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

23 Lazarus, Michael and Asselt, Harro van, “Fossil Fuel Supply and Climate Policy: Exploring the Road Less Taken,” Climatic Change 150, no. 1–2 (2018): 1–13CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Green, Fergus and Denniss, Richard, “Cutting with Both Arms of the Scissors: The Economic and Political Case for Restrictive Supply-Side Climate Policies,” Climatic Change 150, no. 1–2 (2018): 73–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Lenferna, Georges Alexandre, “Can We Equitably Manage the End of the Fossil Fuel Era?,” Energy Research & Social Science 35 (2018): 217–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar;

25 Princen, Thomas, Manno, Jack, and Martin, Pamela, Ending the Fossil Fuel Era (Cambridge, MA, 2015)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 40; Ann-Kristin Bergquist, “Business and Sustainability: New Business History Perspectives” (Harvard Business School Working Paper No. 18-034, Boston, 2017), 9–10.

27 Pratt, Joseph A., “Growth or a Clean Environment? Responses to Petroleum-Related Pollution in the Gulf Coast Refining Region,” Business History Review 52, no. 1 (1978): 5–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gorman, Hugh, “Efficiency, Environmental Quality, and Oil Field Brines: The Success and Failure of Pollution Control by Self-Regulation,” Business History Review 73, no. 4 (1999): 601–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

28 Gorman, Redefining Efficiency, 358–59.

29 Gorman, 269–70.

30 Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 90–91.

31 Pratima Bansal and Andrew J. Hoffman, “Retrospective, Perspective, and Prospective: Introduction to the Oxford Handbook on Business and the Natural Environment,” in Bansal and Hoffman, Oxford Handbook, 6; Hoffman, Andrew J., “Trends in Corporate Environmentalism: The Chemical and Petroleum Industries, 1960–1993,” Society & Natural Resources 9 (1996): 56–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32 Bansal and Hoffman, “Retrospective,” 7.

33 Bergquist, “Business and Sustainability,” 16.

34 Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 174.

35 Jones, 360.

36 See, for example, Holliday, Charles O., Schmidheiny, Stephan, and Watts, Philip, Walking the Talk: The Business Case for Sustainable Development (Sheffield, 2002), 83–87Google Scholar; and Hoffman, Andrew J. and Georg, Susse, Business and the Natural Environment: A Research Overview (London, 2018), 21CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

37 Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 177–79; Mock, Theodore J., Strohm, Christiane, and Swartz, Kevin M., “An Examination of Worldwide Assured Sustainability Reporting,” Australian Accounting Review 17, no. 41 (2007): 67–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

38 Rome, “Ecology of Commerce,” 3–12; Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 290–94.

39 Hoffman, Andrew J., From Heresy to Dogma: An Institutional History of Corporate Environmentalism (Stanford, 2001), 107Google Scholar.

40 Sluyterman, Keetie, “Royal Dutch Shell: Company Strategies for Dealing with Environmental Issues,” Business History Review 84, no. 2 (2010): 214–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hoffman, “Trends in Corporate Environmentalism,” 61–63; From Heresy To Dogma, 109–15.

41 Dunlap, Riley E. and McCright, Aaron M., “Organized Climate Change Denial,” in The Oxford Handbook of Climate Change and Society, ed. Dryzek, John S., Norgaard, Richard B., and Schlosberg, David (Oxford, 2011), 104–28Google Scholar; Skjærseth, J. B., “Major Oil Companies in Climate Policy: Strategies and Compliance,” in Implementing the Climate Regime: International Compliance, ed. Hovi, Jon, Stokke, Olav Schram, and Ulfstein, Geir (London, 2005), 191–92Google Scholar.

42 Banerjee, Neela, Cushman, John H. Jr., Hasemyer, David, and Song, Lisa, Exxon: The Road Not Taken (New York, 2015)Google Scholar.

43 David Hasemyer, “Fossil Fuels on Trial: Where the Major Climate Change Lawsuits Stand Today,” InsideClimate News, 6 Jan. 2019, https://insideclimatenews.org/news/04042018/climate-change-fossil-fuel-company-lawsuits-timeline-exxon-children-california-cities-attorney-general.

44 Pratt, Joseph A. and Hale, William E., Exxon: Transforming Energy, 1973–2005 (Austin, 2013), 462Google Scholar.

45 Pinkse, Jonatan and Kolk, Ans, International Business and Global Climate Change (Abingdon, 2009), 51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

46 Lazyer, J. A., “Deep Freeze: How Business Has Shaped the Global Warming Debate in Congress,” in Business and Environmental Policy: Corporate Interests in the American Political System, ed. Kraft, Michael E. and Kamieniecki, Sheldon (Cambridge, MA, 2007), 99Google Scholar; Kamieniecki, Sheldon, Corporate America and Environmental Policy: How Often Does Business Get Its Way? (Palo Alto, CA, 2006), 182Google Scholar.

47 Oreskes, Naomi and Conway, Erik M., Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming (New York, 2010), 187–90Google Scholar; Brulle, “Institutionalizing Delay,” 681–94.

48 Falkner, Robert, “Business and Global Climate Governance: A Neo-pluralist Perspective,” in Business and Global Governance, ed. Ougaard, Morten and Leander, Anna (London, 2010), 99–117Google Scholar; Oreskes and Conway, Merchants of Doubt, 215; Gelbspan, Ross, Boiling Point: How Politicians, Big Oil and Coal, Journalists, and Activists Are Fueling the Climate Crisis – and What We Can Do to Avert Disaster (New York, 2004)Google Scholar.

49 Yergin, Daniel, The Quest: Energy, Security and the Remaking of the Modern World (New York, 2011)Google Scholar, e-book, 753–79.

50 Skjærseth, Jon Birger, ExxonMobil: Tiger or Turtle on Social Responsibility? (Lysaker, Norway, 2003), 9–10Google Scholar; Kolk, Ans and Levy, David, “Winds of Change: Corporate Strategy, Climate Change and Oil Multinationals,” European Management Journal 19, no. 5 (2001): 505Google Scholar; Elkington, John et al. , The Non-Reporting Report: Engaging Stakeholders (London, 1998), 11Google Scholar.

51 Royal Dutch Shell (RDS), The Shell Report 1998: Profits and Principles – Does There Have to Be a Choice?, 40–41; BP, Environmental and Social Report 2000, 5; BP, Sustainability Report 2004, 33–37.

52 Skjærseth, Jon Birger and Skodvin, Tora, Climate Change and the Oil Industry: Common Problem, Varying Strategies (Manchester, 2003), 202CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Levy, David and Newell, Peter, “Oceans Apart? Business Responses to the Environment in Europe and North America,” Environment 42, no. 9 (2000): 8–20Google Scholar.

53 Reid, Erin M. and Toffel, Michael W., “Responding to Public and Private Politics: Corporate Disclosure of Climate Change Strategies,” Strategic Management Journal 30, no. 11 (2009): 1157–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Moody-Stuart, Mark, Responsible Leadership: Lessons from the Front Line of Sustainability and Ethics (New York, 2014), 142Google Scholar; Yergin, The Quest, 776–78.

54 Moody-Stuart, Responsible Leadership; Browne, John, Beyond Business (London, 2010), 76–82Google Scholar; Sæverud, Ingvild Andreassen and Skjærseth, Jon Birger, “Oil Companies and Climate Change: Inconsistencies between Strategy Formulation and Implementation?,” Global Environmental Politics 7, no. 3 (2007): 59–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kolk and Levy, “Winds of Change.”

55 Gleckman, H., “Transnational Corporations’ Strategic Responses to ‘Sustainable Development,’” in Green Globe Yearbook of International Co-operation on Environment and Development, ed. Bergesen, H. O., Parmann, G., and Thommessen, Ø. B. (Oxford, 1995), 93–106Google Scholar.

56 Holliday, Schmidheiny, and Watts, Walking the Talk, 16–18.

57 RDS, The Shell Report 1998, 46–47; Sluyterman, “Royal Dutch Shell,” 213; Gendron, Corinne, Girard, Bernard, Ivanaj, Silvester, Ivanaj, Vera, and Friser, Alice, “Rôle et responsabilités des hauts dirigeants face aux changements climatiques: réflexions à partir du cas de BP,” Entreprises et Histoire 86, no. 1 (2017): 34–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Browne, Beyond Business, 76–82; Vogel, David, The Market for Virtue: The Potential and Limits of Corporate Social Responsibility (Washington, DC, 2005), 125–26Google Scholar; Lowe, Ernest A. and Harris, Robert J., “Taking Climate Change Seriously: British Petroleum's Business Strategy,” Corporate Environmental Strategy 5, no. 2 (1998): 22–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

58 BP Amoco, Environmental and Social Report 1998; RDS, Shell Report 1998; Statoil, The Future Is Now: Statoil and Sustainable Development (Stavanger, Norway, 2002); Elkington, John, The Oil Sector Report: A Review of Environmental Disclosure in the Oil Industry (London, 1999)Google Scholar; Elkingtong et al., Non-Reporting Report, 11.

59 Elkington, Oil Sector Report, 20.

60 Vogel, Market for Virtue, 125–26.

61 Balmer, John, Powell, Shaun, and Greyser, Stephen, “Explicating Ethical Corporate Marketing: Insights from the BP Deepwater Horizon Catastrophe: The Ethical Brand That Exploded and Then Imploded,” Journal of Business Ethics 102, no. 1 (2011): 1–14CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

62 Fletcher, Luke, Crocker, Tom, Smyth, James, and Marcell, Kane, Beyond the Cycle: Which Oil and Gas Companies Are Ready for the Low-Carbon Transition? Executive Summary (London, 2018)Google Scholar.

63 Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 377.

64 Jones, 366–67; Forbes, Linda C. and Jermier, John M., “The New Corporate Environmentalism and the Ecology of Commerce,” Organization & Environment 23, no. 4 (2010): 465–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hawken, Paul, The Ecology of Commerce: A Declaration of Sustainability (New York, 1994), 54–55Google Scholar.

65 King, Andrew A. and Lenox, Michael J., “Industry Self-Regulation without Sanctions: The Chemical Industry's Responsible Care Program,” Academy of Management Journal 43, no. 4 (2000): 698–716Google Scholar; Short, Jodi L. and Toffel, Michael W., “Making Self-Regulation More Than Merely Symbolic: The Critical Role of the Legal Environment,” Administrative Science Quarterly 55, no. 3 (2010): 361–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lyon, Thomas P. and Maxwell, John W., “Environmental Public Voluntary Programs Reconsidered,” Policy Studies Journal 35, no. 4 (2007): 723–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

66 Jones, Profits and Sustainability; Bergquist, “Business and Sustainability,” 23.

67 Bowen, Frances, After Greenwashing: Symbolic Corporate Environmentalism and Society (Cambridge, UK, 2014), 226CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

68 BP Amoco, 1998 Environmental and Social Report, 5; RDS, The Shell Report 1999: People, Planet and Profits – an Act of Commitment, 31–32.

69 Shell reported a reduction of 35 percent from 1990 levels in 2017. Author's own calculations based on RDS, The Shell Report 2000, 14; RDS, Sustainability Report 2017,” 57.

70 Kolk, Ans, Levy, David, and Pinkse, Jonatan, “Corporate Responses in an Emerging Climate Regime: The Institutionalization and Commensuration of Carbon Disclosure,” European Accounting Review 17, no. 4 (2008): 719–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

71 Thomas Hickmann, “Voluntary Global Business Initiatives and the International Climate Negotiations: A Case Study of the Greenhouse Gas Protocol,” Journal of Cleaner Production 169 (15 Dec. 2017): 94–104; Deborah Gordon and Stephen D. Ziman, “Petroleum Companies Need a Credible Climate Plan” (policy paper, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Nov. 2018), https://carnegieendowment.org/files/Gordon_Petro_Companies_Need_Climate_Plan_Nov2018.pdf.

72 John Ashton, “Open Letter to Shell's Ben van Beurden from John Ashton,” Guardian, 30 Mar. 2015, https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/mar/30/open-letter-shell-ben-van-beurden-john-ashton-climate-change.

73 This position is voiced both in individual corporate statements (annual and sustainability reports) and among industry advocacy groups such as the International Emissions Trading Association, the Carbon Pricing Leadership Coalition, and the WBCSD. See, for example, BP, Advancing the Energy Transition (London, 2018).

74 Faulkner, Hugh, “Some Comments on the INC Process,” in Negotiating Climate Change: The Inside Story of the Rio Convention, ed. Mintzer, Irving M. and Leonard, J. Amber (Cambridge, 1994), 229–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Levy, David L. and Kolk, Ans, “Strategic Responses to Global Climate Change: Conflicting Pressures on Multinationals in the Oil Industry,” Business and Politics 4, no. 3 (2002): 275–300CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Pinkse and Kolk, International Business, 23.

75 Nasiritousi, Naghmeh, “Fossil Fuel Emitters and Climate Change: Unpacking the Governance Activities of Large Oil and Gas Companies,” Environmental Politics 26, no. 4 (2017): 621–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 399.

76 Meckling, Jonas, “The Globalization of Carbon Trading: Transnational Business Coalitions in Climate Politics,” Global Environmental Politics 11, no. 2 (2011): 26–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Vormedal, Irja, “The Influence of Business and Industry NGOs in the Negotiation of the Kyoto Mechanisms: The Case of Carbon Capture and Storage in the CDM,” Global Environmental Politics 8, no. 4 (2008): 36–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

77 Pinkse and Kolk, International Business, 113, 121.

78 Stalkup, F. I., “Carbon Dioxide Miscible Flooding: Past, Present, and Outlook for the Future,” Journal of Petroleum Technology 30, no. 8 (1978): 1102–12CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

79 Ringrose, Philip S., “The CCS Hub in Norway: Some Insights from 22 Years of Saline Aquifer Storage,” Energy Procedia 146 (July 2018): 166–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

80 Dixon, Tim, Romanak, Katherine, Neades, Samantha, and Chadwick, Andy, “Getting Science and Technology into International Climate Policy: Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage in the UNFCCC,” Energy Procedia 37 (2013): 7590–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Vormedal, “Influence of Business,” 36–65.

81 IEA, World Energy Outlook 2017 (Paris, 2017), 111.

82 Lovell, Bryan, Challenged by Carbon: The Oil Industry and Climate Change (Cambridge, UK, 2010), 129Google Scholar.

83 Furre, Anne-Kari, Eiken, Ola, Alnes, Håvard, Vevatne, Jonas Nesland, and Kiær, Anders Fredrik, “20 Years of Monitoring CO2-Injection at Sleipner,” Energy Procedia 114 (2017): 3916–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

84 Lovell, Challenged by Carbon, 137.

85 Griffin, Carbon Majors Database, 14–15; IIGCC, Global Climate Disclosure Framework for Oil and Gas Companies (London, 2010), 1–3; RDS, Shell Report 1998, 41; BP/Amoco, Environmental and Social Report 1999, 9.

86 Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 110.

87 Jones, 326–27.

88 Jones, 118–21; Lüdeke-Freund, Florian, “BP's Solar Business Model: A Case Study on BP's Solar Business Case and Its Drivers,” International Journal of Business Environment 6, no. 3 (2014): 300–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Pinkse, Jonatan and van den Buuse, Daniel, “The Development and Commercialization of Solar PV Technology in the Oil Industry,” Energy Policy 40 (Jan. 2012): 11–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Grant, Robert M. and Cibin, Renato, “Strategy, Structure and Market Turbulence: The International Oil Majors, 1970–1991,” Scandinavian Journal of Management 12, no. 2 (1996): 165–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Crawford, Mark, “ARCO Solar Sale Raises Concerns over Potential Technology Export,” Science 244, no. 4907 (1989): 918CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; Reece, Ray, The Sun Betrayed: A Report on the Corporate Seizure of US Solar Energy Development (Boston, 1979)Google Scholar.

89 Pratt and Hale, Exxon, 167, 180, 189–90, 211–14; Sluyterman, Keetie, A History of Royal Dutch Shell, vol. 3, Keeping Competitive in Turbulent Markets, 1973–2007 (Oxford, 2007), 98–99Google Scholar, 124, 236; Grant and Cibin, “Strategy,” 170–71.

90 Perlin, John, From Space to Earth: The Story of Solar Electricity (Cambridge, MA, 2002)Google Scholar, 65, 68–99n28.

91 Pratt and Hale, Exxon, 190; Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 332; Varadi, Peter F., Sun above the Horizon: Meteoric Rise of the Solar Industry (Singapore, 2014), 249–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

92 Jones, Profits and Sustainability, 335.

93 Paul Stevens, “International Oil Companies: The Death of the Old Business Model” (research paper, Royal Institute of International Affairs, Chatham House, London, May 2016), 9–11; Grant and Cibin, “Strategy,” 173–82.

94 Robert Corzine, “Altruism Is Not the Only Driving Force,” Financial Times, 28 Nov. 1997, 4.

95 RDS, Annual Report 2000, 33; RDS, Annual Report 2004, 34; Damian Miller, “Why the Oil Companies Lost Solar,” Energy Policy 60 (Sept. 2013): 53.

96 Miller, “Oil Companies,” 59; Pinkse and Van den Buuse, “Solar PV Technology,” 19.

97 RDS, Annual Report 2006, 52–53; RDS, Annual Report 2007, 37–38.

98 RDS, Annual Report 2017, 34.

99 RDS, 32–33; Total, Integrating Climate into Our Strategy (Paris, 2017), 42.

100 BP, Annual Report 2017, 42; Statoil, Annual Report 2017, 36; Ron Bousso, “Shell Ventures Back into Solar,” Reuters Business News, 15 Jan. 2018, https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-shell-solar/shell-ventures-back-into-solar-idUKKBN1F42G4.

101 Varadi, Sun above the Horizon, 445.

102 Sluyterman, Keeping Competitive, 412; Statoil, Annual Report 2002, 29.

103 Ben van Beurden, at the annual general meeting of Royal Dutch Shell plc , 22 May 2018, https://www.shell.com/media/speeches-and-articles/2018/annual-general-meeting-of-royal-dutch-shell.html; RDS, Annual Report 2017, 65; Anjli Raval, “Norway's Equinor Buys Danske Commodities for €400m,” Financial Times, 6 July 2018; Francois De Beaupuy, Ruth David, and Dinesh Nair, “Total Could Take on Shell with Bid for Utility Firm Eneco,” Bloomberg, 4 Feb. 2019, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-02-04/total-is-said-to-weigh-bid-for-eneco-in-challenge-to-shell.

104 Total, “Integrating Climate,” 42; Total, Annual Report 2016, 39; RDS, Annual Report 2017, 28; BP, Annual Report 2017, 46.

105 Backer, Lise, “When Oil and Wind Turbine Companies Make Green Sense Together,” Business Strategy and the Environment 18, no. 1 (2009): 43–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar; RDS, Annual Report 2000, 32; Annual Report 2004, 34; Annual Report 2007, 37; BP, Annual Report 2007, 38; Matt Hopkins, “The Makings of a Champion or, Wind Innovation for Sale: The Wind Industry in the United States 1980–2011” (AIR working paper no. 13-08/02, Academic-Industry Research Network, Cambridge, MA, Aug. 2013), 1–4, 6; Robert W. Righter, Windfall: Wind Energy in America Today (Norman, OK, 2011), 25–26.

106 RDS, Sustainability Report 2016, 31.

107 Statoil, Annual Report 2017, 36–37.

108 Zhong, Minjia and Bazilian, Morgan D., “Contours of the Energy Transition: Investment by International Oil and Gas Companies in Renewable Energy,” Electricity Journal 31, no. 1 (2018): 82–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

109 RDS, Sustainability Report 2008, 10, 23; Annual Report 2012, 36; Annual Report 2017, 65; Bailis, Robert and Baka, Jennifer, “Constructing Sustainable Biofuels: Governance of the Emerging Biofuel Economy,” Annals of the Association of American Geographers 101, no. 4 (2011): 827–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar; BP, Annual Report 2008, 36–37; Total, Annual Report 2016, 34; Flach, B., Lieberz, S., and Rossetti, A., “EU Biofuels Annual 2017,” in Global Agricultural Information Network Report (The Hague, 2017), 25Google Scholar; EurObserv'ER, Biofuels Barometer (Paris, 2017), 13.

110 Solomon, Barry D. and Barnett, J. Brad, “The Changing Landscape of Biofuels: A Global Review,” in The Routledge Research Companion to Energy Geographies, ed. Bouzarovski, Stefan, Pasqualetti, Martin J., and Broto, Vanesa Castán (New York, 2017), 61–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar; EurObserv'ER, Biofuels Barometer, 13.

111 Zhong and Bazilian, “Contours,” 85; Waltz, Emily, “Startups Lure Oil Giants,” Nature Biotechnology 26, no. 9 (2008): 963CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

112 Tanton, Thomas, Key Investments in Greenhouse Gas Mitigation Technologies from 2000 through 2016 by Oil and Gas Companies, Other Industry and the Federal Government (Washington, DC, 2018), 8–10Google Scholar.

113 Chevron, , Climate Change Resilience: A Framework for Decision Making (San Ramon, CA, 2018), 39Google Scholar

114 ChevronTexaco, Annual Report 2001, 23.

115 ChevronTexaco, Annual Report 2002, 23.

116 Enrico Dela Cruz, “Indonesia, Philippine Groups Acquire Chevron's $3 Billion Geothermal Assets,” Reuters, 23 Dec. 2016, https://www.reuters.com/article/us-chevron-sale-geothermal/indonesia-philippine-groups-acquire-chevrons-3-billion-geothermal-assets-idUSKBN14C0OW.

117 Deep Decarbonization Pathways Project (DDPP), Pathways to Deep Decarbonization: 2015 Report (New York, 2015), 8–10; Dennis, Keith, Colburn, Ken, and Lazar, Jim, “Environmentally Beneficial Electrification: The Dawn of ‘Emissions Efficiency’,” Electricity Journal 29, no. 6 (2016): 52–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

118 Ben van Beurden, speech delivered at the annual general meeting of Royal Dutch Shell plc, 22 May 2018, The Hague, https://www.shell.com/media/speeches-and-articles/2018/annual-general-meeting-of-royal-dutch-shell.html.

119 RDS, Shell Investors’ Handbook 2013–2017 (London, 2018), 15.

120 Oberling, Daniel Fontana, Obermaier, Martin, Szklo, Alexandre, and La Rovere, Emilio Lèbre, “Investments of Oil Majors in Liquid Biofuels: The Role of Diversification, Integration and Technological Lock-Ins,” Biomass and Bioenergy 46 (Nov. 2012): 270–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar.