Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T07:03:37.679Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Warfare and propaganda: the portrayal of Andronikos II Palaiologos (1282–1328) as an incompetent military leader in the Histories of John VI Kantakouzenos(1347–54)

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 January 2016

Savvas Kyriakidis
Savvas Kyriakidis*
Affiliation:
Department of Greek and Latin Studies, University of Johannesburg
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The Histories of Kantakouzenos is the main source for the civil war between Andronikos II and Andronikos III which was fought intermittently from 1321 until 1328. This article examines how Kantakouzenos remodelled and fabricated events, conversations and deliberations in order to depict Andronikos II as an incompetent military leader. By criticizing Andronikos II’s military abilities and by blaming him for the military failures of the period, Kantakouzenos diverts suspicion of his personal responsibility and Andronikos III’s mistakes that led to the advance of Byzantium’s enemies and demonstrates that the elder Andronikos was not worthy of being on the throne.

Type
Articles
Information
Byzantine and Modern Greek Studies , Volume 37 , Issue 2 , 2013 , pp. 176 - 189
Copyright
Copyright © The Centre for Byzantine, Ottoman and Modern Greek Studies, University of Birmingham 2013

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 On the dating of the Histories of Kantakouzenos see Hunger, H., Die hochsprachliche profane Literatur der Byzantiner, I (Munich 1978) 469 Google Scholar; Nicol, D., The Byzantine Family of Kantakouzenos (Cantacuzenus) ca. 110-1460 (Washington 1986) 100 Google Scholar.

2 For a narrative of the events of 1321-28 see Bosch, U., Kaiser Andronikos. Palaiologos. Versuch einer Darstellung der Byzantinischen Geschichte in den Jahren 1321-1341 (Amsterdam 1321-41) 9–78 Google Scholar.

3 Angelov, D., Imperial Ideology and Political Thought in Byzantium. 1204-1330 (Cambridge 2007) 256 Google Scholar.

4 Kantakouzenos, John, Ioannis Cantacuzeni ex imperatoris historiarum libri IV, eds. Schopen, L.-Niebuhr, B., I (Bonn 1828), 14, 22-3 (hereafter, Kantakouzenos)Google Scholar.

5 Kantakouzenos, I, 26-7, 32-4, 54-5, 68-70, 210-12.

6 Kantakouzenos, I, 15.

7 Kantakouzenos, I, 425.

8 Kantakouzenos, II, 115.

9 Kantakouzenos, I, 91-3.

10 Kantakouzenos, I, 207.

11 Kantakouzenos, I, 335.

12 Kantakouzenos, I, 505-7.

13 Gregoras, Nikephoros, Byzantina Historia, ed. Schopen, L., I (Bonn, 1829) I, 434 Google Scholar (hereafter Gregoras); Kyriakidis, S., ‘Byzantine responses to the battlefield tactics of the armies of the Turkoman principalities: the battle of Pelekanos (1329),’ BZ 103 (2010) 86 Google Scholar.

14 Gregoras, I, 484-8.

15 Kantakouzenos, I, 179.

16 Gregoras, I, 484.

17 Kantakouzenos, I, 180.

18 Kantakouzenos, I, 184.

19 Kantakouzenos, I, 186.

20 Kantakouzenos, I, 187.

21 Kantakouzenos, I, 326.

22 Kantakouzenos, I, 328.

23 Metochites, Theodore, Oi δύο Βασιλικοί Λόγοι, ed. Polemis, I. (Athens 2007) 320-28Google Scholar, 338-46.

24 Anecdota graeca e codicibus regiis, ed. Boissonade, J., II (Paris 1829-33, repr. Hildesheim 1962) 21 Google Scholar, 25-8, 31 (hereafter Anecdota graeca).

25 Anecdota graeca, I, 378; Lampenos, Nikolaos, ‘O λόγιος Νικόλαος Λαμτεηνός καί τό έγκώμιον αύτού είς τόν Άνδρόνικον B’Παλαιολόγον, ed. Polemis, I. (Athens 1992) 46-8Google Scholar (hereafter Lampenos).

26 Kantakouzenos, I, 220.

27 Kyriakidis, ‘Byzantine responses,’85.

28 Kantakouzenos, I, 341.

29 For Qulaguz and Bahadur see Moravscik, G., Byzantinoturcica II (Berlin 1958) 162 Google Scholar, 205.

30 Kantakouzenos, I, 355-6.

31 Kantakouzenos, I, 362-3; Gregoras, I, 436.

32 Kantakouzenos, I, 359, 363.

33 Kantakouzenos, I, 460.

34 Kantakouzenos, I, 339-40.

35 Kantakouzenos, I, 388.

36 Kantakouzenos, I, 160, 462; Gregoras, I, 484.

37 For the revolt of Philanthropenos see Laiou, A., ‘Some observations on Alexios Philanthropenos and Maximos Planoudes,’ BMGS 4 (1978) 89–99 Google Scholar. In 1299 Orhan was married to the daughter of the governor of a Byzantine city. In 1306 the general Kassianos, who was the governor of Byzantine fortresses in Mesothynia, was accused of planning a marriage alliance with the Ottomans. Bishop Mathew of Ephesos accused the governor of Philadelphia, Manuel Tagaris, of co-operating with the Turks and of marrying his daughter to a Turcoman leader: Bryer, A., ‘Greek historians on the Turks: the case of the first Byzantine-Ottoman marriage,’ in Davis, R.H.C.-Wallace-Hadrill, J.M.H. (eds.), The writing of history in the Middle Ages. Essays Presented to Richard William Southern (Oxford 1981) 471-93Google Scholar; Pachymeres, George, Relations historiques, ed. Failler, A., IV (Paris 1999) 681 Google Scholar (hereafter Pachymeres); Matthew of Ephesos, Die Briefe des Matthaios von Ephesos im Codex Vindobonensis Theol. Gr 174, ed. Reinsch, D. (Berlin 1974) 106-7Google Scholar.

38 Gregoras, I, 369.

39 Schreiner, P., Die Byzantinischen Kleinchroniken, I (Vienna,1975) 80 Google Scholar; Gregoras (I, 458) refers to heavy tribute forced upon the Byzantine possessions in Bithynia.

40 Lampenos, 55.

41 Kantakouzenos, I, 480-2; Gregoras, I, 529-32.

42 Kantakouzenos, I, 496-8.

43 Kantakouzenos, I, 8-10.

44 For the Histories of Kantakouzenos as a work of literature see Kazhdan, A., ‘L’ Histoire de Cantacuzène en tant qu’ oeuvre littéraire,’ Byzantion 50 (1980) 279–335 Google Scholar.

45 For a detailed analysis of Pachymeres’ criticism of Andronikos II see Angelov, Imperial Ideology, 260-3, 269-80.

46 For Pachymeres see Angelov, Imperial Ideology, 262.

47 Kazhdan, A.- Epstein, A.W., Change in Byzantine culture in the eleventh and twelfth centuries (Berkeley 1985) 102-13Google Scholar; Magdalino, P., The Empire of Manuel I Komnenos. 118-1143 (Cambridge 1993) 418-23CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Angelov, Imperial Ideology, 83.

48 Macrides, R., George Akropolites. The History (Oxford 2007) 56 Google Scholar.

49 Kyritses, D., ‘H Άλωση της Κωνσταντινούπολης και το τέλος του Βυζαντινού πολιτισμού,’ in Kiousopoulou, T. (ed.), HΆλωση τηςΚωνσταντινούπολης και ημετάβαση από τουςμεσαιωνικούςστους νεώτερ-ουςχρόνους (Rethymnon 2005) 164 Google Scholar.

50 Kantakouzenos, I, 20, 334. For the identification of Angelos see Nicol, D., The reluctant emperor. A biography of John VI Cantacuzene, Byzantine emperor and monk ca. 1295-1383 (Cambridge 1996) 17 Google Scholar.

51 Kantakouzenos, I, 85-6.

52 Kantakouzenos, I, 204-5.

53 Philes, Manuel, Carmina, ed. Miller, E., I (Paris 1855) 149 Google Scholar.