Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T22:17:58.203Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Limits of Tolerance in Diverse Societies: Hate Speech and Political Tolerance Norms Among Youth

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 May 2010

Allison Harell
Allison Harell*
Affiliation:
Queen's University
*
Allison Harell, School of Policy Studies, Queen's University, Kingston, ON K7L 3N6, email: harell@queensu.ca.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Abstract. Conventional measures of political tolerance have tended to assume that people see all forms of speech as equally legitimate (or equally illegitimate). This article develops an alternative view, and measure, of political tolerance to account for individual distinctions across types of speech. Political tolerance is conceptualized using three individual-level dispositions. The intolerant reject speech rights for all objectionable groups; absolute tolerators endorse speech rights for all groups viewed as objectionable; and multicultural tolerators support free speech except when such freedoms are used to target racial and ethnic minorities. Survey data from close to 10,000 youth in Canada and Belgium show that multicultural tolerance reflects civil liberties attitudes among many young citizens. These youth do see exclusionary speech as a special category of “intolerable” speech, consistent with legal restrictions on hate speech in many industrialized democracies. Such target group distinctions are an under-studied and under-specified component of contemporary political tolerance judgments.

Résumé. Les mesures conventionnelles de la tolérance politique tendent à présumer que les gens perçoivent tous les discours comme étant également légitimes (ou également illégitimes). Cet article développe une perspective différente et une mesure plus nuancée de la tolérance politique en relevant des distinctions entre les types de propos. On distingue trois dispositions individuelles en matière de tolérance politique. Les intolérants rejettent la liberté d'expression pour tous les groupes ou propos perçus comme importuns; les gens absolument tolérants appuient la liberté d'expression pour tous les groupes ou propos perçus comme importuns; et les adhérents de la tolérance multiculturelle appuient la libre expression publique des idées, sauf quand celle-ci sert à bafouer les minorités ethniques et raciales. Les résultats d'une enquête menée auprès d'environ 10 000 jeunes au Canada et en Belgique indiquent qu'un grand nombre de jeunes citoyens pratiquent la tolérance multiculturelle. Ces derniers considèrent les propos empreints d'exclusion comme une catégorie spéciale de propos «intolérables», conformément aux lois contre la propagande haineuse adoptées dans la plupart des pays développés. Les distinctions de ce genre sont des facteurs négligés dans notre compréhension des jugements contemporains sur la tolérance politique.

Type
Research Article
Information
Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique , Volume 43 , Issue 2: Diversity and Democratic Politics , June 2010 , pp. 407 - 432
Copyright
Copyright © Canadian Political Science Association 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Billiet, Jaak and De Witte, Hans. 1995. “Attitudinal Dispositions to Vote for a ‘New’ Extreme Right-Wing Party: The Case of ‘Vlaams Blok.’” European Journal of Political Research 27: 181–202.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boeckman, Robert J. and Turpin-Petrosino, Carolyn. 2002. “Understanding the Harm of Hate Crime.” Journal of Social Issues 58 (2): 207–225.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bosmajian, Haig. 1974. The Language of Oppression. Washington DC: Public Affairs Press.Google Scholar
Braun, Stefan. 2004. Democracy Off Balance: Freedom of Expression and Hate Propaganda Law in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chong, Dennis. 2006. “Free Speech and Multiculturalism In and Out of the Academy.” Political Psychology 27 (6): 29–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cohen, Andrew Jason. 2004. “What Tolerance Is.” Ethics 115: 68–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cohen-Almagor, Raphael, ed. 2000. Liberal Democracy and the Limits of Tolerance: Essays in Honor and Memory of Yitzhak Rabin. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coliver, Sandra, Boyle, Kevin and D'Souza, Frances. 1992. Striking A Balance: Hate Speech, Freedom of Expression and Non-Discrimination. London: Article 19.Google Scholar
Cortese, Anthony Joseph Paul. 2006. Opposing Hate Speech. Westport CT: Praeger Publishers.Google Scholar
Davis, Darren W. 1995. “Exploring Black Political Intolerance.” Political Behavior 17 (1): 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Douglas-Scott, Sionaidh. 1999. “The Hatefulness of Protected Speech: A Comparison of American and European Approaches.” William and Mary Bill of Rights Journal 7: 305–46.Google Scholar
Duch, Raymond M. and Gibson, James L.. 1992. “‘Putting Up With’” Fascists in Western Europe: A Comparative, Cross-Level Analysis of Political Tolerance.” The Western Political Quarterly 45 (1): 237–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eckstein, Harry. 1975. “Case Study and Theory in Political Science.” In Handbook of Political Science, ed. Greenstein, Fred I. and Polsby, Nelson W.. Reading MA: Addison-Wesley.Google Scholar
Finkel, Steven E. and Ernst, Howard R.. 2005. “Civic Education in Post-Apartheid South Africa: Alternative Paths to the Development of Political Knowledge and Democratic Values.” Political Psychology 26 (3): 333–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fletcher, Joseph F. 1990. “Participation and Attitudes toward Civil Liberties: Is There an “Educative” Effect?” International Political Science Review/Revue internationale de science politique 11 (4): 439–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fraser, Nicholas. 2001. The Voice of Modern Hatred: Tracing the Rise of Neo-Fascism in Europe. Woodstock NY: Overlook Press.Google Scholar
Galeotti, Anna E. 2002. Toleration as Recognition. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gerber, Alan S., Green, Donald and Shachar, Ron. 2003. “Voting May Be Habit-Forming: Evidence from a Randomized Field Experiment.” American Journal of Political Science 47 (3): 540–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, James L. 1992. “Alternative Measures of Political Tolerance: Must Tolerance be ‘Least-Liked’” American Journal of Political Science 36 (2): 560–577.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, James L. 1998. “A Sober Second Thought: An Experiment in Persuading Russians to Tolerate.” American Journal of Political Science 42 (3): 819–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, James L. 2006a. “Do Strong Group Identities Fuel Intolerance? Evidence from the South African Case.” Political Psychology 27 (5): 665–706.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, James L. 2006b. “Enigmas of Intolerance: Fifty Years after Stouffer's Communism, Conformity, and Civil Liberties.” Perspectives on Politics 4: 21–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, James L. and Bingham, Richard D.. 1985. Civil Liberties and Nazis: The Skokie Free-Speech Controversy: Westport CT: Praeger.Google Scholar
Gibson, James L. and Gouws, Amanda. 2001. “Making Tolerance Judgments: The Effects of Context, Local and National.” Journal of Politics 63 (4): 1067–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greenberg, Jeff and Pyszczynski, Tom. 1985. “The Effect of an Overheard Slur on Evaluations of the Target: How to Spread a Social Disease.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 21: 61–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gross, Kimberly A. and Kinder, Donald R.. 1998. “A Collision of Principles? Free Expression, Racial Equality and the Prohibition of Racist Speech.” British Journal of Political Science 28 (3): 445–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harel, Alon. 1996. “The Boundaries of Justifiable Tolerance: A Liberal Perspective.” In Toleration: An Elusive Virtue, ed. Heyd, David. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Harell, Allison. 2008. “The Micro-Story of Multiculturalism: Diverse Social Networks and the Socialization of Tolerance.” Doctoral dissertation. McGill University, Montreal, Quebec.Google Scholar
Harell, Allison, Mahéo, Valerie-Anne and Stolle, Dietlind. 2008. “Canadian Youth Study (CANYS), Wave 1: Technical Report and Codebook.” Montreal, QC: McGill University.Google Scholar
Heyd, David. 1996. Toleration: An Elusive Virtue. Princeton: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hooghe, Marc. 2004. “Political Socialization and the Future of Politics.” Acta Politica 39 (4): 331–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Horton, John. 1996. “Toleration as a Virtue.” In Toleration: An Elusive Virtue, ed. Heyd, David. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Horton, John and Nicholson, Peter, eds. 1992. Toleration: Philosophy and Practice. London: Ashgate Publishing.Google Scholar
Huddy, Leonie, Feldman, Stanley, Taber, Charles and Lahav, Gallya. 2005. “Threat, Anxiety and Support of Antiterrorist Policies.” American Journal of Political Science 49 (3): 595–608.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Inglehart, Ronald. 1997. Modernization and Postmodernization: Cultural, Economic and Political Change in 43 Countries. Princeton: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jones, Peter. 2007. “Making Sense of Political Toleration.” British Journal of Political Science 37: 383–402.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kinsella, Warren. 2001. Web of Hate: Inside Canada's Far Right Network. Toronto: HarperCollins.Google Scholar
Kirkland, Shari L., Greenberg, Jeff and Pyszczynski, Tom. 1987. “Further Evidence of the Deleterious Effects of Overheard Ethnic Slurs: Derogation beyond the Target.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 13: 216–227.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kymlicka, Will. 1995. Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Kymlicka, Will. 2001. Politics in the Vernacular: Nationalism, Multiculturalism, and Citizenship. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lambe, Jennifer. 2004. “Who Wants to Censor Pornography and Hate Speech.” Mass Communication and Society 7 (3): 279–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marcus, George E., Sullivan, John L., Theiss-Morse, Elizabeth and Wood, Sandra L.. 1995. With Malice Toward Some: How People Make Civil Liberties Judgments. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marcuse, Herbert. 1969. “Repressive Tolerance.” In A Critique of Pure Tolerance, ed. Wolff, Robert Paul, Moore, Barrington and Marcuse, Herbert. Boston: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
Marquart-Pryatt, Sandra and Paxton, Pamela. 2006. “In Principle and In Practice: Learning Political Tolerance in Eastern and Western Europe.” Political Behavior 29 (1): 89–113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Matsuda, Mari J. 1993. “Public Response to Racist Speech: Considering the Victim's Story.” In Words That Wound: Critical Race Theory, Assaultive Speech, and the First Amendment, ed. Matsuda, Mari J., Lawrence, Charles R. II, Delgado, Richard and Crenshaw, Kimberlè Williams. Boulder CO: Westview Press.Google Scholar
McKinnon, Catriona. 2003. “Toleration and the Character of Pluralism.” In The Culture of Toleration in Diverse Societies, ed. McKinnon, Catriona and Castiglione, Dario. New York: Manchester University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mendus, Susan, ed. 1988. Justifying Toleration: Conceptual and Historical Perspectives. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mendus, Susan. 1989. Toleration and the Limits of Liberalism. Atlantic Highlands NJ: Humanities Press International.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mondak, Jeffery J. and Hurwitz, Jon. 1998. “Values, Acts, and Actors: Distinguishing Generic and Discriminatory Intolerance.” Political Behavior 20 (4): 313–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mondak, Jeffery J. and Sanders, Mitchell S.. 2003. “Tolerance and Intolerance, 1976–1998.” American Journal of Political Science 47 (3): 492–502.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mullen, Brian. 2001. “Ethnophaulisms for Ethnic Immigrant Groups.” Journal of Social Issues 57 (3): 457–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Murphy, Andrew R. 1997. “Tolerance, Toleration, and the Liberal Tradition.” Polity 29: 593–623.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mutz, Diana. 2002. “Cross-Cutting Social Networks: Testing Democratic Theory in Practice.” American Political Science Review 96 (1): 111–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nelson, Thomas, Clawson, Rosalee and Oxley, Zoe. 1997. “Media Framing of Civil Liberties Conflict and Its Effect on Tolerance.” American Political Science Review 91 (3): 567–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nevitte, Neil. 1996. The Decline of Deference: Canadian Value Change in Cross-National Perspective. Peterborough: Broadview Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nie, Norman H., Junn, Jane and Stehlik-Barry, Kenneth. 1996. Education and Democratic Citizenship in America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
O'Donnell, John P. 1993. “Predicting Tolerance of New Religious Movements: A Multivariate Analysis.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 32 (4): 356–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Peffley, Mark, Knigge, Pia and Hurwitz, Jon. 2001. “A Multiple Values Model of Political Tolerance.” Political Research Quarterly 54 (2): 379–406.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Peffley, Mark and Rohrschneider, Robert. 2003. “Democratization and Political Tolerance in Seventeen Countries: A Multi-Level Model of Democratic Learning.” Political Research Quarterly 56 (3): 243–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Plutzer, E. 2002. “Becoming a Habitual Voter: Inertia, Resources, and Growth in Young Adulthood.” American Political Science Review 96 (1): 41–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simon, L. and Greenberg, Jeff. 1996. “Further Progress in Understanding the Effects of Derogatory Ethnic Labels: The Role of Preexisting Attitudes Toward the Targeted Group.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 22 (12): 1195–1204.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sniderman, Paul M., Fletcher, Joseph F., Russell, Peter H. and Tetlock, Philip. 1996. The Clash of Rights: Liberty, Equality, and Legitimacy in Pluralist Democracy. New Haven CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Sotelo, Maria Jose. 1999. “Gender Differences in Political Tolerance among Adolescents.” Journal of Gender Studies 8 (2): 211–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sotelo, Maria Jose. 2000. “Individual Differences in Political Tolerance Among Adolescents.” Social Behavior and Perosnality 28 (2): 185–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stolle, Dietlind and Hooghe, Marc. 2006. “Comparative Youth Survey: First Wave.” McGill/Leuven.Google Scholar
Stouffer, Samuel Andrew. 1963. Communism, Conformity, and Civil Liberties: A Cross-Section of the Nation Speaks Its Mind. Gloucester MA: P. Smith.Google Scholar
Sullivan, John L., Marcus, George E., Feldman, Stanley and Piereson, James E.. 1981. “The Sources of Political Tolerance: A Multivariate Analysis.” The American Political Science Review 75 (1): 92–106.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sullivan, John L., Piereson, James E. and Marcus, George E.. 1979. “An Alternative Conceptualization of Political Tolerance.” American Political Science Review 73 (3): 781–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sullivan, John L., Piereson, James E. and Marcus, George E.. 1982. Political Tolerance and American Democracy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Sullivan, John L., Shamir, Michal, Walsh, Pat and Roberts, N.S.. 1985. Political Tolerance in Context. Boulder CO: Westview.Google Scholar
Sullivan, John L. and Transue, John E.. 1999. “The Psychological Underpinnings of Democracy: A Selective Review of Research on Political Tolerance, Interpersonal Trust, and Social Capital.” Annual Review of Psychology 50: 625–50.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Sumner, L.W. 2004. The Hateful and the Obscene: Studies in the Limits of Free Expression. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tsesis, Alexander. 2002. Destructive Messages: How Hate Speech Paves the Way for Harmful Social Movements. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Walzer, Michael. 1997. On Toleration. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Weissberg, Robert. 1998. Political Tolerance: Balancing Community and Diversity. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
Wilkes, Rima, Guppy, Neil and Farris, Lily. 2008. “'No Thanks, We're Full': Individual Characteristics, National Context, and Changing Attitudes toward Immigration.” International Migration Review 42 (2): 203–329.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Young, Iris Marion. 1990. Justice and the Politics of Difference. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar