Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T13:18:20.778Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Equality and Equity in Chinese Higher Education in the Post-massification Era: An Analysis Based on Chinese Scholarly Literature

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 January 2021

Qiang Zha Open the ORCID record for Qiang Zha [Opens in a new window]
Qiang Zha*
Affiliation:
Faculty of Education, York University (Canada). Email: qzha@edu.yorku.ca.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper examines several research questions relating to equality and equity in Chinese higher education via an extended literature review, which in turn sheds light on evolving scholarly explorations into this theme. First, in the post-massification era, has the Chinese situation of equality and equity in higher education improved or deteriorated since the late 1990s? Second, what are the core issues with respect to equality and equity in Chinese higher education? Third, how have those core issues evolved or changed over time and what does the evolution indicate and entail? Methodologically, this paper uses a bibliometric analysis to detect the topical hotspots in scholarly literature and their changes over time. The study then investigates each of those topical terrains against their temporal contexts in order to gain insights into the core issues.

摘要

摘要

本文通过梳理和分析中文文献来研究关于中国高等教育公平与公正的几个问题，进而揭示关于这一主题学术探讨的演进过程。首先，在后大众化时期，中国高等教育公平与公正状况自上世纪90年代末以来有所改善、还是退步了？第二，关于中国高等教育公平与公正研究的核心问题有哪些？第三，那些核心问题是如何随着时间演进和变化的，而且核心问题的演进揭示和意味着什么？本文在研究方法上先以文献计量分析确定学术文献中的研究热点及其变化，然后探究每个热点研究范畴以期深入了解那些核心问题的时代背景。

Keywords

equality and equityChinese higher educationpost-massification eraregional disparities公平与公正中国高等教育后大众化时期区域差异
Type
Research Article
Information
The China Quarterly , Volume 244: Change, Contradiction and the State: Higher Education in Greater China , December 2020 , pp. 1056 - 1077
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © SOAS University of London, 2021

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Bao, Wei, and Liu, Yanhui. 2009. “Gongping shi jiao xia de Zhongguo gaodeng jiaoyu ziyuan peizhi quyu jian chayi de shi zheng yanjiu” (An empirical study on regional variations of Chinese higher education resource distribution through an equity lens). Beida jiaoyu jingji yanjiu 7(1), 37–43.Google Scholar
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1974. “The school as a conservative force.” In Eggleston, John (ed.), Contemporary Research in the Sociology of Education. London: Methuen, 32–46.Google Scholar
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1977. “Cultural reproduction and social reproduction.” In Karabel, Jerome and Halsey, A. H. (eds.), Power and Ideology in Education. New York: Oxford University Press, 487–511.Google Scholar
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1990. The Logic of Practice (Nice, Richard (trans.)). Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Cao, Yan, Zhang, Ruijuan and Hou, Yuna. 2018. “Buchang hai shi xuanba? ‘Guojia zhuanxiang jihua’ buchang jihui zai diqu jian fenpei de jingzhunxing fenxi” (Compensation or selection? A precision analysis of distribution of compensatory opportunities of the State Special Recruitment Scheme among the regions). Zhongguo gaojiao yanjiu (8), 23–29.Google Scholar
Chen, Xinzhong, and Lu, Yao. 2016. “Woguo gaodeng jiaoyu gongping yanjiu de xianzhuang, redian yu qianya: jiyu CNKI shujuku 2005–2014 nian wenxian de keshihua fenxi” (Reality, foci and cutting-edges in China's research in higher education equality: based on CNKI data 2005–2014). Guojia jiaoyu xingzheng xueyuan xuebao (9), 32–38.Google Scholar
Cheng, Tianjun. 2017. “Xin jiaoyu gongping yinlun: jiyu woguo jiaoyu gongping moshi bianqian de sikao” (An introductory discussion of the new education equity discourse: some thoughts based on a paradigm shift in education equity in China). Jiaoyu fazhan yanjiu (2), 1–11.Google Scholar
Deng, Zhiqiang. 2013. “Qingnian de jieceng guhua: ‘erdai meng’ de shehui liudong” (Youth social class fixation: social fluidity of the “second generation”). Zhongguo qingnian yanjiu (6), 5–10.Google Scholar
Fan, Wankui, and Duan, Zhaobing. 2011. “Woguo gaodeng jiaoyu gongping yanjiu de guiji, tezheng yu zouxiang: jiyu 1999–2010 nian guonei hexin qikan zaiwen de jiliang fenxi” (The trajectory, characteristics and trend of higher education equality studies in China: a bibliometric analysis of articles published in core journals from 1999 to 2010). Xiandai daxue jiaoyu (4), 8–14.Google Scholar
Fang, Fang, and Liu, Zeyun. 2018. “2005–2015 nian woguo gaodeng jiaoyu jingfei touru de bianhua yu qishi” (Changes of higher education fiscal inputs in 2005–2015 and the implications). Zhongguo gaojiao yanjiu (4), 78–85.Google Scholar
Guo, Xinli. 2003. “Cong daxue gongneng leiji fenbu guilü kan gaodeng jiaoyu zhongdian jianshe” (Key project construction in higher education from the perspective of the cumulative distribution rule of university function). Zhongguo gaodeng jiaoyu 24(19), 15–17.Google Scholar
Hayhoe, Ruth. 1996. China's Universities, 1895–1995: A Century of Cultural Conflict. New York: Garland Press.Google Scholar
Hayhoe, Ruth, and Zha, Qiang. 2006. “China.” In Forest, J.F. and Altbach, P.G. (eds.), International Handbook of Higher Education. Springer International Handbooks of Education Volume 18. Dordrecht: Springer, 667–691.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kang, Xiaoming. 2007. “Cong jiegou xing yueshu kan dazhonghua jieduan woguo gaodeng jiaoyu gonggong zhengce de xuanze” (Public policy options in the massification stage of higher education from a structural restriction perspective). Gaodeng jiaoyu yanjiu (2), 11–6.Google Scholar
Li, Jianfa, and Guo, Peng. 2004. “Zhongguo dazhonghua gaodeng jiaoyu caizheng zhengce ji qi gaige wenti tantao” (China's finance policy with respect to higher education massification and an exploration of its reform issues). Jiaoyu yu jingji (4), 38–42.Google Scholar
Lian, Si. 2012. “Cong ‘yi zu’ shijiao fenxi gaodeng jiaoyu dui shehui liudong de yingxiang” (An analysis of higher education impact on social mobility from the perspective of the ‘ant tribe’.” Dangdai qingnian yanjiu (2), 1–6.Google Scholar
Liang, Chen, Lee, James Z., Zhang, Hao, Li, Lan, Ruan, Danching, Campbell, Cameron D. and Yang, Shanhua. 2012. “Wusheng de geming: Beijing daxue yu Suzhou daxue xuesheng shehui laiyuan yanjiu 1952–2002” (A silent revolution: research on family backgrounds of students in Peking University and Soochow University, 1952–2002). Zhongguo shehui kexue (1), 98–118.Google Scholar
Liu, Jian. 2012. “Examining massification policies and their consequences for equality in Chinese higher education: a cultural perspective.” Higher Education 64(5), 647–660.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Liu, Jingming. 2006. “Gaodeng jiaoyu kuozhan yu ruxue jihui chayi: 1978–2003” (Higher education expansion and access opportunity difference: 1978–2003). Shehui (3), 158–179, 209.Google Scholar
Liu, Jingming. 2007. “Kuozhao shiqi gaodeng jiaoyu jihui de diqu chaoyi yanjiu” (A study of regional disparities in higher education access in the expansion era). Beijing daxue jiaoyu pinglun (4), 142–155.Google Scholar
Liu, Liang. 2007. “Zhongguo diqu jian gaodeng jiaoyu jingfei chayi de yinsu fenjie” (A factor analysis of higher education finance regional disparities in China). Tongji yu juece (6), 94–96.Google Scholar
Liu, Ye. 2016. Higher Education, Meritocracy and Inequality in China. Singapore: Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Luo, Pushang, Song, Yingquan and Wei, Jianguo. 2011. “Zhongguo xianxing gaoxiao xuesheng zizhu zhengce pinggu” (An appraisal of China's current policy with respect to higher education students’ financial support). Beijing daxue jiaoyu pinglun 9(1), 68–79.Google Scholar
Ma, Luting. 2009. “Zhidu baozhang xia de gaodeng xuexiao wei difang fazhan fuwu” (Higher education institutions provide services for local development under institutional safeguard). In Fan, Wenyao and Watson, David (eds.), Gaodeng jiaoyu zhili de guojia zhengce (National Policy on Higher Education Governance). Beijing: Higher Education Press, 279–284.Google Scholar
Pang, Guobin. 2007. “Gongping lilun shiyu xia woguo gonggong gaodeng jiaoyu touzi ziyuan peizhi ruogan sikao” (A few thoughts from the perspective of equality theory on resource distribution with respect to public expenditure on Chinese higher education). Jiaoyu kexue 23(4), 5–9.Google Scholar
Sun, Weihong. 2010. “Zai lun gaodeng jiaoyu dui shehui fenceng yu shehui liudong de yingxiang” (Further thoughts on higher education impact on social stratification and mobility). Xiandai jiaoyu luncong (10), 52–55.Google Scholar
Wang, Shanmei. 2000. “Lun gaodeng jiaoyu de xuefei” (On higher education tuition fees). Beijing shifan daxue xuebao (renwen shehui kexue ban) (6), 24–29.Google Scholar
Wen, Wen, Lian, Zhixin and Yang, Fan. 2018. “Zhaosheng qingxie zhengce xia de ruoshi xuesheng qunti: ruxue jihui he jiaoyu gongping: jiyu mo zhongdian daxue ruxue shuju de shizheng yanjiu” (Vulnerable student groups in the context of preferential admission policy: access opportunity and educational equality: an empirical study based admission data in an elite university). Qianghua daxue jiaoyu yanjiu (2), 111–119.Google Scholar
Wu, Hongbin, and Guo, Jianru. 2018. “Gaodeng jiaoyu fenceng xitong zhong de difang benke yuanxiao: kunjing, youshi yu chulu: jiyu quanguo benke xuesheng diaocha shuju de fenxi” (Local universities in a stratified higher education system: constraints, strengths and future pathways: an analysis based on national university student survey data). Zhongguo gaojiao yanjiu (2), 75–82.Google Scholar
Wu, Qiuxiang, and Cui, Shen. 2018. “Nongcun xuesheng zhongdian daxue ruxue jihui de quyu cha: jiyu gaoxiao zhuanxiang jihua shuju de shizheng yanjiu” (Regional disparities with respect to rural students accessing elite universities: an empirical analysis based on data from the National University Special Recruitment Scheme). Zhongguo gaojiao yanjiu (4), 70–77.Google Scholar
Xie, Ailei. 2017. “‘Dushu wuyong’ haishi ‘dushu wuwang’: dui nongcun diceng jumin jiaoyu guannian de zai renshi” (“Learning for uselessness” or “learning for hopelessness”: the further knowledge of understanding of education among rural grassroots). Beijing daxue jiaoyu pinglun 15(3), 92–108.Google Scholar
Xie, Weihe. 2018. “Gaodeng jiaoyu: quyu fazhan de xin dibiao” (Higher education: a new landmark for regional development). Zhongguo gaojiao yanjiu (4), 12–15.Google Scholar
Xiong, Jing, and Yang, Jie. 2018. “Zhaosheng zhengce qingxie beijing xia nongcun, pingkun zhuanxiang jihua daxuesheng xueye shiying yanjiu: jiyu mo ‘shuang yiliu’ jianshe gaoxiao de shizheng diaocha” (An academic adaptability investigation of rural and specially recruited poor students in Chinese universities: an empirical study at a university selected for the “double first-class” project). Zhongguo gaojiao yanjiu (7), 30–38.Google Scholar
Yang, Dongping. 2006. “Gaodeng jiaoyu ruxue jihui: kuoda zhizhong de jieceng chaju” (Higher education access opportunity: stratum distance in expansion). Qinghua daxue jiaoyu yanjiu (1), 19–25.Google Scholar
Yang, Haiyan. 2015. “Woguo gaodeng jiaoyu yanjiu de redian lingyu ji qianyan: jiyu CSSCI shujuku 2004–2014 nian shoulu wenxian guanjianci gongxian de jiliang he keshihua fenxi” (Hotspots and frontier topics in higher education studies in China: a bibliometric analysis based on CSSCI data for the period 2004–2014). Fudan jiaoyu luntan (4), 45–56.Google Scholar
Yang, Kerui. 2005. “Daxuesheng zizhu de daikuan wuqu ji zhengfu zeren de shixian” (Fallacies of university student loan programmes and fulfilment of governmental responsibilities). Qinghua daxue jiaoyu yanjiu 26(4), 87–91.Google Scholar
Yu, Chunping, and Zhang, Minghao. 2007. “Gaodeng jiaoyu chengben buchang yu gongping wenti de yanjiu” (A study of higher education cost recovery and equality). Liaoning jiaoyu yanjiu (4), 25–27.Google Scholar
Yu, Xiulan, and Han, Yan. 2018. “Hanmeng ruhe chu ‘guizi’: jiyu wenhua ziben shijiao de jieceng tupo” (How could humble-family students become outstanding: the stratum breakthrough from the perspective of cultural capital). Gaodeng jiaoyu yanjiu (2), 8–16.Google Scholar
Yue, Changjun. 2015. “Expansion and equality in Chinese higher education.” International Journal of Educational Development 40, 50–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zha, Qiang. 2006. “Diversification or Homogenization: How Chinese Governments Shape the Higher Education System.” PhD diss., University of Toronto.Google Scholar
Zha, Qiang. 2011. “China's move to mass higher education in a comparative perspective.” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 41(6), 751–768.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zhang, Huafeng, Guo, Fei and Shi, Jinghuan. 2017. “Cujin jiating diyidai daxuesheng canyu gao yingxiangli jiaoyu huodong de yanjiu” (A study of improving first-generation university students’ participation in high-impact educational practices). Jiaoyu yanjiu (6), 32–43.Google Scholar
Zhang, Huafeng, Zhao, Lin and Guo, Fei. 2016. “Diyidai daxuesheng de xuexi huaxiang: jiyu ‘Zhongguo daxuesheng xuexi fazhan he zuizong diaocha’ de fenxi” (A portrait of first–generation college students in China: an analysis based on the China College Student Survey). Qianghua daxue jiaoyu yanjiu 37(6), 72–78, 94.Google Scholar
Zhang, Yulin, and Liu, Baocun. 2005. “Zhongguo de zhiye jieceng yu gaodeng jiaoyu jihui” (Social professional classes and higher education opportunities in China). Beijing shifan daxue xuebao (shehui kexue ban) (3), 25–31.Google Scholar
Zhao, Juhui, and Song, Shulong. 2008. “Woguo gaodeng xuexiao xuefei biaozhun yu jumin shouru shuiping, GDP de zengzhang fenxi” (An analysis of higher learning institution tuition fees and increases in household income and GDP). Liaoning shifan daxue xuebao (shehui kexue ban) 31(3), 59–61.Google Scholar
Zhou, Jincheng, Dai, Wenjing and Liu, Dashang. 2018. “Woguo gaozhi yuanxiao shengjun bokuan shuiping yanjiu: jiyu guoji bijiao de shijiao” (A study of per student allocations in higher vocational colleges in China: based on a perspective of international comparison). Zhongguo gaojiao yanjiu (7), 104–108.Google Scholar
Zhou, Yong. 2017. “Hanmeng xuezi de jiaoyu fendou yu shehui shangsheng: lishi shehuixue shijiao” (The educational struggle and social upward mobility of students from poor families: a historical sociological perspective). Nanjing shifandaxue xuebao (shehuikexue ban) (4), 94–99.Google Scholar