Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T05:45:50.924Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The “African Enslavement of Anglo-Saxon Minds”: The Beechers as Critics of Augustine

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Peter J. Thuesen
Peter J. Thuesen
Affiliation:
Peter J. Thuesen is assistant professor of comparative religion at Tufts University.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Harriet Beecher Stowe, who achieved international fame for her 1852 antislavery novel, Uncle Tom's Cabin, is best known to historians of American religious thought as a critic of New England Calvinism and its leading light, Jonathan Edwards. But in airing her frustrations with the Puritan tradition, Stowe also singled out a much earlier source of the problem: Augustine, the fifth-century bishop of Hippo. At his worst, Augustine typified for Stowe not only theological rigidity but also the obdurate refusal of the male system-builders to take women's perspectives seriously. Consequently, in the New England of the early republic, when “the theology of Augustine began to be freely discussed by every individual in society, it was the women who found it hardest to tolerate or assimilate it.” In leveling such criticism, Stowe echoed her elder sister Catharine Beecher, a prominent educator and social reformer, whose well-known writings on the role of women in the home have often overshadowed her two companion volumes of theology, in which she devotes more attention to Augustine than to any other figure. Yet for all her extended critiques of Augustinian themes, Beecher buried her most provocative rhetorical flourish, as one might conceal a dagger, in the last endnote on the last page of the second volume. Seizing upon the African context of Augustine's career as a metaphor for his deleterious influence on Christian theology, she concluded that reasonable people have a duty to resist the “African enslavement of Anglo-Saxon minds” no less than to combat the “Anglo-Saxon enslavement of African bodies.”

Type
Articles
Information
Church History , Volume 72 , Issue 3 , September 2003 , pp. 569 - 592
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 2003

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Stowe, Harriet Beecher, Oldtown Folks, ed. Berkson, Dorothy (1869; New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 1987), 365.Google Scholar

2. Beecher, Catharine E., Common Sense Applied to Religion; or, The Bible and the People (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1857)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and An Appeal to the People in Behalf of Their Rights as Authorized Interpreters of the Bible (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1860).Google Scholar

3. Beecher, Catharine, Appeal to the People, 380.Google Scholar

4. Miller, Perry, The New England Mind: The Seventeenth Century (Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap, Harvard University Press, 1939), 4–5, 22Google Scholar. Levy, Babette May makes a similar claim about the frequency of Puritan citations of Augustine in Preaching in the First Half Century of New England History (Hartford, Conn.: American Society of Church History, 1945), 20, 128–29.Google Scholar

5. Knight, Janice, Orthodoxies in Massachusetts: Rereading American Puritanism (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1994), 1–12.Google Scholar

6. Marshall, David J., “Calvin, John,” in Augustine through the Ages: An Encyclopedia, eds. Fitzgerald, Allan D. and others (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1999), 116–20Google Scholar; and Smits, Luchesius, Saint Augustin dans l'Oeuvre de Jean Calvin, 2 vols. (Assen: Van Gorcum, 1956–1958).Google Scholar

7. van Oort, Johannes, “John Calvin and the Church Fathers,” in The Reception of the Church Fathers in the West: From the Carolingians to the Maurists, ed. Backus, Irena (Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1997), 2:671, 690.Google Scholar

8. “Mr. Cottons Rejoynder,” in The Antinomian Controversy, 1636–1638: A Documentary History, 2nd ed., ed. Hall, David D. (Durham, NC.: Duke University Press, 1990), 145Google Scholar. In his debate with Williams, , Cotton quoted from Augustine's Retractationes, Epistulae, Contra epistulam Parmeniani, and In Johannis evangelium tractatus in a single paragraph of a letter, circa 1634/35, later published as part of Williams' Bloudy Tenent of Persecution (1644)Google Scholar; see Bush, Sargent Jr, ed., The Correspondence of John Cotton (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2001), 199.Google Scholar

9. Cotton, John, The Way of the Congregational Churches Cleared (1648), in John Cotton on the Churches of New England, ed. Ziff, Larzer (Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press, Harvard University Press, 1968), 312.Google Scholar

10. Mather, Cotton, Manuductio ad Ministerium (Boston, Mass.: Thomas Hancock, 1726), 89Google Scholar. Instructions for the Education of a Daughter (London: Jonah Bowyer, 1707) was an expanded English edition by George Hickes of a 1687 French text by Francois de Salignac de Ia Mothe FenelonGoogle Scholar. On the history of this text, see Hayes, Kevin J., A Colonial Woman's Bookshelf (Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 1996), 62–63.Google Scholar

11. On the spurious status of the Meditations and Manual, see Portalié, Eugène, A Guide to the Thought of Saint Augustine, trans. Bastian, Ralph J. (Chicago: Henry Regnery, 1960), 43Google Scholar. Early English editions include A Pretious Booke of Heavenlie Meditations (London: H. Denham, 1581)Google Scholar, and The Meditations, Soliloqvia, and Manuall of the Glorious Doctour S. Augustine (Paris: Nicolas de la Coste, 1631).Google Scholar

12. An anonymous Catholic translation by SirMatthew, Tobie, The Confessions of the Incom parable Doctovr S. Avgvstine (Rouen: Permissu Superiorum, 1620)Google Scholar, drew a sharp retort from the Protestant Watts, William in St. Avgvstines Confessions Translated … and the Marginall Notes of a Former Popish Translation Answered (London: Iohn Norton, 1631)Google Scholar. On the publishing history, see Pine-Coffin's, R. S. introduction to Augustine, Confessions (London: Penguin Books, 1961), 16–17.Google Scholar

13. Quoted in Van Dyken, Seymour, Samuel Willard, 1640–1707: Preacher of Orthodoxy in an Era of Change (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1972), 175.Google Scholar

14. Mather, , Manuductio ad Ministerium, 88–89.Google Scholar

15. “St. Austir” entry on letter leaf of “Catalogue,” Jonathan Edwards Collection, box 15, folder 1202, Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University.

16. “Affections Notebook No. 7,” 1, Jonathan Edwards Collection, box 21, folder 1252, Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University. On the significance of this notebook, see The Works of Jonathan Edwards, Vol. 2, Religious Affections, ed. Smith, John E. (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1959), 73–74.Google Scholar

17. The Works of Jonathan Edwards, Vol. 1, Freedom of the Will, ed. Ramsey, Paul (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1957), 295Google Scholar; The Works of Jonathan Edwards, Vol. 3, Original Sin, ed. Holbrook, Clyde A. (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1970), 375.Google Scholar

18. The Works of Jonathan Edwards, Vol. 9, A History of the Work of Redemption, ed. Wilson, John F. (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1989), 405–14Google Scholar. On the effect of the Puritans' primitivism on their attitudes toward the church fathers, see Bozeman, Theodore Dwight, To Live Ancient Lives: The Primitivist Dimension in Puritanism (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1988), 23–32.Google Scholar

19. On the extent of Edwards' engagement with Enlightenment sources, see Brown, Robert E., Jonathan Edwards and the Bible (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2002), 1–26.Google Scholar

20. Quoted in Gaustad, Edwin S., Sworn on the Altar of God: A Religious Biography of Thomas Jefferson (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1996), 134Google Scholar; cf. the earlier anti-Calvinism of Benjamin Franklin, as described in Buxbaum, Melvin H., Benjamin Franklin and the Zealous Presbyterians (University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 1975).Google Scholar

21. Quoted in Wigger, John H., Taking Heaven by Storm: Methodism and the Rise of Popular Christianity in America (New York: Oxford University Press, 1998), 18Google Scholar. On Methodist anti-Calvinism, see also Lyerly, Cynthia Lynn, Methodism and the Southern Mind, 1770–1810 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1998), 29–30Google Scholar; and Hatch, Nathan O., The Democratization of American Christianity (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1989), 170–79.Google Scholar

22. Ballou, Hosea 2d, Ancient History of Universalism, from the Time of the Apostles to the Fifth General Council (1829; Boston, Mass.: Universalist, 1872), 237.Google Scholar

23. Ballou, Hosea Starr, Ballou, Hosea, 2d, D.D., First President of Tufts College: His Origin, Life, and Letters (Boston, Mass.: E. P. Guild, 1896), 127–28.Google Scholar

24. Christian Examiner and Theological Review 5 (1828): 320; on the author of this unsigned article, see below.Google Scholar

25. Noll, Mark A., America's God: From Jonathan Edwards to Abraham Lincoln (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002), 311–13CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Howe, Daniel Walker, The Political Culture of the American Whigs (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1979).Google Scholar

26. Beecher, Edward, quoted in The Autobiography of Lyman Beecher, 2 vols., ed. Cross, Barbara M. (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1961), 2:436.Google Scholar

27. Caskey, Marie, Chariot of Fire: Religion and the Beecher Family (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1978), 39.Google Scholar

28. Turner, James, Without God, Without Creed: The Origins of Unbelief in America (Baltimore, Md.: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1985), 90.Google Scholar

29. Harding, Vincent, A Certain Magnificence: Lyman Beecher and the Transformation of American Protestantism, 1775–1863 (Brooklyn, N.Y.: Carison, 1991), 258.Google Scholar

30. Jenks, Francis (unsigned), Christian Examiner 5 (1828): 320–29Google Scholar; Jenks, later published his full attack as A Reply to the Three Letters of the Rev. Lyman Beecher, D.D., against the Calvinistic Doctrine of Infant Damnation: From the Christian Examiner, with Additions (Boston, Mass.: Christian Examiner, 1829).Google Scholar

31. Beecher, Lyman, Views in Theology (Cincinnati, Ohio: Truman and Smith, 1836), 57.Google Scholar

32. Sweeney, Douglas A., Nathaniel Taylor, New Haven Theology, and the Legacy of Jonathan Edwards (New York: Oxford University Press, 2003), 80–83Google Scholar; on Taylor, see also Guelzo, Allen C., Edwards on the Will: A Century of American Theological Debate (Middletown, Conn.: Wesleyan University Press, 1989), 240–71Google Scholar; and Smith, H. Shelton, Changing Conceptions of Original Sin: A Study in American Theology Since 1750 (1955; New York: Garland, 1987), 86–136.Google Scholar

33. Clark, Elizabeth A., The Origenist Controversy: The Cultural Construction of an Early Christian Debate (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1992), 194.Google Scholar

34. Details on Litchfield and the Beecher children's upbringing from Caskey, Chariot of Fire, 20–26.

35. Lyman to Catharme, , 30 May 1822Google Scholar; Catharine, to Lyman, , New Year 1823, in Cross, , ed., Autobiography of Lyman Beecher, 1:355, 369.Google Scholar

36. Lyman, to Edward, , 2 August 1822, in Cross, , ed., Autobiography of Lyman Beecher, 360.Google Scholar

37. On the depravity of her own heart, see Catharine, to Edward, , July 1822, in Cross, , ed., Autobiography of Lyman Beecher, 358–59Google Scholar. On the evolution of Catharine's theological views, see Sklar, Kathryn Kish, Catharine Beecher: A Study in American Domesticity (New York: W. W. Norton, 1973), 28–42, 244–57Google Scholar. On Catharine's views in the context of the “Americanization” of Calvinism, see Noll, , America's God, 293–329.Google Scholar

38. On the influence of Scottish philosophy, see Sklar, , Catharine Beecher, 80–89Google Scholar. Hall, Mark David details the importance of Elements for Catharine's later thought in “Catharine Beecher: America's First Female Philosopher and Theologian,” Fides et Historia 32 (Winter/Spring 2000): 65–80, esp. 69–71Google Scholar. See also the introduction to the new facsimile edition of Beecher's works, The Social, Political and Philosophical Works of Catharine Beecher, 6 vols., eds. Dykeman, Therese B. and Rogers, Dorothy C. (Bristol, England: Thoemmes, 2002).Google Scholar

39. “An Essay on Cause and Effect, in Connection with the Doctrines of Fatalism and Free Agency,” American Biblical Repository 2 (October 1389): 381–408Google Scholar. On Augustine's opposition to fatalism, see Clark, , Origenist Controversy, 228–31.Google Scholar

40. Snyder, Stephen H., Lyman Beecher and His Children: The Transformation of a Religious Tradition (Brooklyn, N.Y.: Carlson, 1991), 60.Google Scholar

41. Beecher, Catharine, Common Sense, 297–300, 308–10Google Scholar; see also Snyder, , Lyman Beecher and His Children, 59–64Google Scholar. Catharine's perception of Pelagius's tragic lack of adroitness was not shared by Augustine himself, who once said of the Pelagian system: “These points are raised by great and shrewd minds”; see Brown, Peter, Augustine of Hippo: A Biography, rev. ed. (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2000), 346Google Scholar. On recent scholarly reappraisals of Pelagianism, see Lamberigts, Mathijs, “Pélage: La Réhabilitation d'un Hérétique,” Revue D'Histoire Ecclésiastique 95 (2000): 97–111.Google Scholar

42. Quoted in Franchot, Jenny, Roads to Rome: The Antebellum Protestant Encounter with Catholicism (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1994), 326.Google Scholar

43. See Beecher, Catharine, Common Sense, 308Google Scholar. Joan Hedrick persuasively argues that the real issue behind Taylor's opposition was “Catharine's usurpation of the male ministerial role by writing a volume of systematic theology” see Hedrick, Joan D., Harriet Beecher Stowe: A Life (New York: Oxford University Press, 1994), 278.Google Scholar

44. Sklar, , Catharine Beecher, 187–92Google Scholar; Sweeney, , Nathaniel Taylor, 138–41Google Scholar. For an analysis of Truth Stranger than Fiction as a protest against the intellectualism and elitism (as opposed to pastoral concern) of MacWhorter, Taylor, and allies, see Douglas, Ann, The Feminization of American Culture (New York: Anchor Books, 1977), 142–44.Google Scholar

45. Beecher, Catharine, Appeal to the People, 4, 228–30Google Scholar; cf. the similar argument in Common Sense, 291–92. Elaine Pagels is the best-known contemporary scholar who has argued (as Catharine Beecher did more than a century before) that Augustine's case for original sin rests largely on a misunderstanding of Romans 5:12–19. Pagels contends that Augustine interpreted Romans 5:12 idiosyncratically, partly because he read it in Latin rather than the original Greek, thus misreading the last phrase as referring to Adam, “in whom all sinned”; see Pagels, Elaine, Adam, Eve, and the Serpent (New York: Random House, 1988), 109Google Scholar. On Pagels and the continuing debate over Romans 5, see Quinn, Philip L., “Disputing the Augustiriian Legacy: John Locke and Jonathan Edwards on Romans 5:12–19,” in The Augustinian Tradition, ed. Matthews, Gareth B. (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1999), 233–50. 46.Google Scholar

46. Beecher, Catharine, Appeal to the People, 212–13, 294–95.Google Scholar

47. Quoted in Snyder, , Lyman Beecher and His Children, 65.Google Scholar

48. Clark, , Origenist Controversy, 238Google Scholar; and Harmless, William, “Baptism,” in Augustine through the Ages, eds. Fitzgerald and others, 90Google Scholar. Augustine also pointed to birth defects as signs of the mysterious power of sin over infants (Clark, Origenist Controversy, 240).

49. Brown, Peter, “Pelagius and His Supporters: Aims and Environment,” in Religion and Society in the Age of Saint Augustine (New York: Harper and Row, 1972), 203Google Scholar; Brown, , Augustine of Hippo, 99Google Scholar; Stortz, Martha Ellen, “‘Where or When Was Your Servant Innocent?’: Augustine on Childhood,” in The Child in Christian Thought, ed. Bunge, Marcia J. (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 2001), 95–96.Google Scholar

50. Holifield, E. Brooks, The Covenant Sealed: The Development of Puritan Sacramental Theology in Old and New England, 1570–1720 (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1974), 46.Google Scholar

51. Brekus, Catherine A., “Children of Wrath, Children of Grace: Jonathan Edwards and the Puritan Culture of Child Rearing,” in Child in Christian Thought, ed. Bunge, , 306.Google Scholar

52. Brown, , “Pelagius and His Supporters,” 189, 194, 196, 203Google Scholar; and Brown, , Augustine of Hippo, 351.Google Scholar

53. Quoted in Sklar, , Catharine Beecher, 250.Google Scholar

54. Beecher, Catharine, Common Sense, 36Google Scholar, quoted in Sklar, , Catlwrine Beecher, 251Google Scholar. On Catharine's reforming vision, see also Abzug, Robert H., Cosmos Crumbling: American Reform and the Religious Imagination (New York: Oxford University Press, 1994), 190–93.Google Scholar

55. Horsman, Reginald, Race and Manifest Destiny: The Origins of American Racial Anglo-Saxonism (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1981), 178–85.Google Scholar

56. Beecher, Edward, The Conflict of the Ages; or, The Great Debate on the Moral Relations of God and Man (Boston, Mass.: Philips, Sampson, 1853), 279, cf. 286. Even Catharine was loath to portray Augustine as malicious, noting that he was “a man of great goodness, talents, and learning” (Common Sense, 298).Google Scholar

57. Beecher, Edward, Conflict of the Ages, 306–7, 191Google Scholar; see also Caskey, , Chariot of Fire, 123–39Google Scholar; and Snyder, , Lyman Beecher and His Children, 67–81Google Scholar. On Edward's larger career, see Meredith, Robert, The Politics of the Universe: Edward Beecher, Abolition, and Orthodoxy (Nashville, Tenn.: Vanderbilt University Press, 1968).Google Scholar

58. On Universalist reviews of The Conflict of the Ages, see Bressler, Aim Lee, The Universalist Movement in America, 1770–1880 (New York: Oxford University Press, 2001), 71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

59. Beecher, Catharine, Appeal to the People, 15, and Common Sense, 305.Google Scholar

60. Beecher, Charles, Redeemer and Redeemed: An Investigation of the Atonement and of Eternal Judgment (Boston, Mass.: Lee and Shepard, 1864), ix–xGoogle Scholar. Because of his book, Charles was convicted (but later exonerated) of heresy by his local Congregational conference. On his views, see Caskey, , Chariot of Fire, 140–66, 370–73Google Scholar; and Snyder, , Lyman Beecher and His Children, 81–89.Google Scholar

61. On Henry Ward's opinion of Edward's exegesis, see Synder, , Lyman Beecher and His Children, 110–11.Google Scholar

62. Quoted in Caskey, , Chariot of Fire, 379Google Scholar; on Henry Ward Beecher's dislike of theological specificity, see 239–40.

63. Beecher, Henry Ward, Life Thoughts, Gathered from the Extemporaneous Discourses of Henry Ward Beecher (Boston, Mass.: Phillips, Sampson, 1858), 174.Google Scholar

64. Beecher, Henry Ward, “The Study of Human Nature,” in American Protestant Thought in the Liberal Era, ed. Hutchison, William R. (Lanham, Md.: University Press of America, 1968), 42–43.Google Scholar

65. Foster, Charles H., The Rungless Ladder: Harriet Beecher Stowe and New England Puritanism (Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press, 1954)Google Scholar; Caskey, , Chariot of Fire, 169–207.Google Scholar

66. Stowe, , Oldtown Folks, 365.Google Scholar

67. Stowe, , The Minister's Wooing, ed. Harris, Susan K. (New York: Penguin Books, 1999), 17, quoted in Hedrick, Harriet Beecher Stowe, 279.Google Scholar

68. Harriet recognized, however, that a mother's grief (as well as hope and prayers) stood behind Augustine's conversion and ordination; see the reference to St. Monica in Minister's Wooing, 77.

69. Stowe, , Minister's Wooing, 197.Google Scholar

70. Stowe, , Oldtown Folks, 265, 302–6, 385Google Scholar, and Minister's Wooing, 53–54. Foster (Rungless Ladder, 180–84) rightly points out that Stowe misjudged the degree of Edwards' departure from earlier Puritan tradition. Nevertheless, on the specific question of baptism, the Puritans were, as Brooks Holifield notes, “ambidextrous theologians”: “For almost every negation in their baptismal doctrine there was a qualifying affirmation” (Holifield, Covenant Sealed, 155). On Stowe's reading of the Puritan tradition, see also Felker, Christopher, Reinventing Cotton Mather in the American Renaissance: Magnalia Christi Americana in Hawthorne, Stozve, and Stoddard (Boston, Mass.: Northeastern University Press, 1993), 157–99.Google Scholar

71. Quotation about Spain from Stowe, , Oldtown Folks, 373Google Scholar. Gatta, John, “The Anglican Aspect of Harriet Beecher Stowe,” New England Quarterly 73 (2000): 412–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar; cf. Stowe's affinity for images of the Madonna, as described in Gatta, John, American Madonna: Images of the Divine Woman in Literary Culture (New York: Oxford University Press, 1997), 53–71.Google Scholar

72. Beecher, Catharine, Appeal to the People, 321–22Google Scholar; on Catharine's conversion, see also Gatta, , “Anglican Aspect,” 433Google Scholar; and Sklar, , Catharine Beecher, 260.Google Scholar

73. Stowe, , Minister's Wooing, 45Google Scholar, and Oldtown Folks, 368. On the history of American debates over unstable paradox of free will and predestination, see Guelzo, Edwards on the Will; Pahl, Jon, Paradox Lost: Free Will and Political Liberty in American Culture, 1630–1760 (Baltimore, Md.: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1992)Google Scholar; and Westbrook, Perry D., Free Will and Determinism in American Literature (Rutherford, N.J.: Farleigh Dickinson University Press, 1979), esp. 76–80.Google Scholar

74. Stowe, , Minister's Wooing, 198.Google Scholar

75. On Cram and Victorian antimodemism, see Jackson Lears, T. J., No Place of Grace: Antimodernism and the Transformation of American Culture, 1880–1920 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1981), 203–9.Google Scholar

76. Pusey, Edward Bouverie, “Tract Sixty-seven: Scriptural Views of Holy Baptism” (1836), in The Oxford Movement, ed. Fairweather, Eugene R. (New York: Oxford University Press, 1964), 212.Google Scholar

77. Preface (1838) to The Confessions of St. Augustine, trans. Pusey, E. B. (New York: E. P. Dutton, 1950), xv–xvi.Google Scholar

78. The phrase “sheer gratuity of God's grace” in reference to Augustine is from William S. Babcock, as quoted by Clark, Origenist Controversy, 230.