Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-94fs2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T06:39:21.221Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Problem of Christian Unity in Early Nineteenth-Century America*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Lefferts A. Loetscher
Lefferts A. Loetscher
Affiliation:
Princeton Theological Seminary
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

American Protestants in the early nineteenth century faced intellectual and social challenge which made conspicuous the weakness of their own divided condition. The American Revolution—which was part of a larger upheaval in the Atlantic Community—had spread Enlightenment ideas, with their aggressive attack on orthodoxy. Quite typical was the lament of a convention of Massachusetts Congregational ministers in 1799 over “the present decay of Christian morals and piety, and the awful prevalence of speculative and practical infidelity.” Well before the middle eighteen-thirties the tide of deism had ebbed, but some, like the editors of the new Christian Review, were still building sea walls against it.

Type
Research Article
Information
Church History , Volume 32 , Issue 1 , March 1963 , pp. 3 - 16
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1963

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Cf. Palmer, R. R., The Age of the Democratic Revolution: A Political History of Europe and America, 1760–1800 (Princeton, 1959).Google Scholar

2. Panoplist and Missionary Magazine, I, N.S. (1808–1809), p. 402.Google Scholar

3. Christian Review, I (1836), p. iii.Google Scholar

4. Mills, Samuel J. and Smith, Daniel, Report of a Missionary Tour through that Part of the United States which Lies West of the Allegany Mountains (Andover, 1815), p. 47.Google Scholar

5. Berthoff, Rowland, “The American Social Order: A Conservative Hypothesis,” American Historical Review, LXV (1959–1960), p. 499.Google Scholar

6. Quarterly Register and Journal (1827), p. 5.Google Scholar

7. Mifier, Samuel, A Sermon Preached n New York, July 4th, 1739 (New York, n.d.), p. 30.Google Scholar

8. “Address to the Public.” Panoplist and Missionary Magazine, IV, N. S. (1811–1812), p. 3.Google Scholar

9. History of Religion in the United States (Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, 1960), p. 256.Google Scholar

10. Report of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions (Boston, 1813), p. 18.Google Scholar

11. (1816) Annual Reports of the Amenican Bible Society, I (New York, 1938), p. 12.Google Scholar

12. Panoplist and Missionary Magasine, X (1814), p. 1.Google Scholar

13. On American denominationalism, cf. Pauck, Wilhelm, “Theology in the Life of Contemporary American Protestantisin,” Shane Quarterly, XII (1951–1952), p. 49Google Scholar; Mead, Sidney E., “Denominationalism; the Shape of Protestantism in America,” Church History: Studies in Christianity and Culture, XXIII (1954), pp. 291–320CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hudson, Winthrop S., American Protestantism (Chicago, 1961), pp. 33–48Google Scholar; Smith, Elwyn A., “The Forming of a Modern American Denomination,” Church Histpry, XXXI (1962), pp. 74–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

14. Connecticut Evangelical Magarine, I (1800), p. 4Google Scholar; Panoplist and Missionary Magacine, I, N.S. (1809), p. 3Google Scholar; III, N.S. (1810), pp. 1, 7.

15. Baird, Robert, Religion in America. (London, 1842Google Scholar; New York, 1844; Schaff, Philip, The Prinoiple of Protestantism (Chambersburg, 1845).Google Scholar

16. Schmucker, Samuel S., Appeal to the American Churches (New York, 1838), pp. 63–99.Google Scholar

17. Yoder, Donald H., in Ruth Rouse and Stephen C. Neill, A History of the Ecumenical Movement, 1517–1948 (Philadelphin, 1954), pp. 242–5, 248–50Google Scholar; McNeil, John T., Unitive Protestantism: A Study in Our Religious Resources (New York, 1930), p. 314.Google Scholar

18. Foster, Charles I., An Errand of Mercy: The Evangelical United Front, 1790–1837 (Chapel Hill, 1690), pp. 28–100.Google Scholar

19. Miller, Perry, The New England Mind: From Colony to Province (Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1953), pp. 395–416.Google Scholar

20. On aspects of the American Board, cf.Kawerau, Peter, Amerika and die orientalisehen Kirchen: Ursprung und Anfang der amerikanisohen Mission unter den Nationalkirchen Westasiens (Berlin, 1958).Google Scholar

21. Shedd, Clarence P., Two Centuries of Student Christian Movements: Their Origin and Intercollegiate Life (New York, 1934), pp. 37–90Google Scholar; Pasioplist and Missionary Magazine, IV, N.S. (1811–1812), pp. 504–5.Google Scholar

22. (1819) Reports … American Bible Society, I, p. 78.Google Scholar

23. Cf. Report…American Board 1820, p. 74; Report of the American Sunday-school Union…1842 (Philadelphia, 1842), p. 37.Google Scholar

24. Foster, , Errand of Mercy, pp. 146–7.Google Scholar

25. (1829) Reports…American Bible Society, I, p. 442Google Scholar; Report …American S-s. Union … 1830, p. 4, 1833, p. vi, 1835, p. 13Google Scholar; Report… American Tract Society, (1832), p. 4Google Scholar; Oliphant, J. Orin, “The American Missionary Spirit, 1828–1835,” Church History: Studies in Christianity and Culture, VII (1938), pp. 130–7.Google Scholar

26. (1833) Reports … American Bible Society, I, p. 654.Google Scholar

27. Maclear, James F., “‘The True Amenican Union’ of Church and State: The Reconstruction of the Theocratie Tradition,” Church History: Studies in Christianity and Culture, XXVIII (1959), pp. 41–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bodo, John R., The Protestant Clergy and Public Issues, 1812–1848 (Princeton, 1954).Google Scholar

28. Cf., e.g., the Hon. Frelinghuysen, Theodore in Report… American S-s. Union… 1835, pp. 8–11.Google Scholar

29. The Autobiography of Lyman Beecher, ed. Barbara M. Cross, I (Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1961), p. 190.Google Scholar

30. Christian Herald, I (1816), p. 72.Google Scholar

31. Report… American S-s. Union… 1842, p. 39Google Scholar; 1844, p. 56.

32. “Constitution” in Report… American Tract Society (1826), p. 6Google Scholar; Report… American S-s. Union… 1831, pp. 14–16.Google Scholar

33. Report… American S-s.Union… 1830, p. 13Google Scholar; 1832, p. 16, Cf. also 1825, p. 23.

34. Ibid., 1829, p. 4; Cf.Sehaff, Philip, America, ed. Perry, Miller (Cambridge Massachusetts, 1961), p. 100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

35. Sumarized, in Report …American Tract Society (1836), p. 10Google Scholar, and still more briefly in the first article of the Society's Constitution.

36. Smyth, Thomas, The Fundamental Doctrines of Christianity… A Discourse … at … the American Sunday-school Union. May, 17. 1846 (Philadelphia, 1846), p. 17.Google Scholar

37. Panoplist and Missionary Magazine, V, N.S. (1812), p. 2Google Scholar; Report … American S-s. Union … 1842, p. 13, 1838, pp. 19–21Google Scholar; Sehmucker, S. S.,… Sermon… at … American S-s. Union … May 20th, 1839 (Philadelphia, 1839), p. 19.Google Scholar

38. Boudinot, Elias to Romeyn, John B..… 06 5, 1816, in (1817) Reports American Bible Society, I, p. 35Google Scholar; Spring, Gardiner, Memoirs of Samuel J. Mills (New York, 1820), p 238.Google Scholar

39. Report …American S-s. Union… 1833, p. 13.

40. Report… American- S-s. Union…1847, p. 11 1833, p. 21.Google Scholar Cf. also Pauck, Wilhelm, “The Christian Faith and Religious Tolerance,” Church History: Studies in Christianity and Culture, XV (1946), p. 233.Google Scholar

41. Miller, Samuel, Holding Fast the Faithful Word: a Sermon … August 26, 1829… (Albany, 1829), pp. 22–25.Google Scholar

42. (1816) Reports… American Bible Society, I, pp. 13–4, 1828, p. 5Google Scholar; Report American S-s. Union… 1830, p. 17, 1832, pp. 10–11, 1833, pp. 18–9Google Scholar; Christian Herald, I (1816), p. 280Google Scholar; American Quarterly Register, IV (1832), iv.Google Scholar

43. Report… American S-s. Union…1831, pp. 19–20; Report… American Tract Society (1833), p. 35Google Scholar; Maclear, J. F., in Church History: Studies in Christianity and Culture, XXVIII (1959), p. 57.Google Scholar

44. Connecticut Evangelical Magazine, 1 (1800), p. 5Google Scholar; Panoplist and Missionary Magazine, II, N.S. (1809–1910), p. 41Google Scholar; (1823) Reports… American Bible Society, I, p. 235Google Scholar, (1824), p. 284; (1838), pp. 937–8 Abraham van Dyck, Christian Union; or, an Arguinent for the Abolition of Sects (New York, 1835), pp. 156–71.Google Scholar

45. Foster, C. I., Errand of Mercy, pp. 250, 242Google Scholar; for an example of the vigorous denominationalism of the time, ef. the new Christian Review, I (1836), pp. 7–10.Google Scholar

46. Sidney E. Mead, Nathaniel William Taylor, 1786–1858; A Connecticut Liberal (Chicago, 1942).Google Scholar

47. Smith, H. Shelton, Handy, Robert T., and Loetscher, Lefferts A., American Christianity: An Historical Interpretation with Representative Documents, II, 1820–1960 (New York, 1963), 66–118,Google Scholar