Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-mlc7c Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-15T08:54:11.110Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Understanding Democratic Survival and Democratic Failure in Africa: Insights from Divergent Democratic Experiments in Benin and Congo (Brazzaville)

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 August 2005

Bruce A. Magnusson  and
John F. Clark
Bruce A. Magnusson
Affiliation:
Whitman College
John F. Clark
Affiliation:
Florida International University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

How do we explain adequately the relative success or failure of complex political phenomena such as democratization? In the battle between conceptual and explanatory parsimony, on the one hand, and rich, thick description on the other, social scientists often fall into traps that obscure more complete explanations for our cases from the portfolio of the possible. For example, we often unconsciously generalize from the cases we know best. In single case studies, we can fail to recognize the explanations that don't shine brightly or bark loudly. More generally, we acquire a habit of thinking that orders causality in particular ways for each of us, a result both of an empirical reliance on our own familiar cases, and the conceptual and theoretical conclusions we have generalized consciously or unconsciously from those cases. In this article, we are self-consciously engaged in two tasks: (1) comparing divergent outcomes of democratization in otherwise fairly similar cases—Benin and the Republic of Congo (Brazzaville); and (2) proposing three possible primary causal hypotheses for the successful (Benin) and failed (Congo) outcomes.

Type
Research Article
Information
Comparative Studies in Society and History , Volume 47 , Issue 3 , July 2005 , pp. 552 - 582
Copyright
© 2005 Society for Comparative Study of Society and History

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Adjaho Richard 1992 La Faillite du contrôle des Finances publiques au Bénin (1960–1990) Cotonou Editions du Flamboyant
Adjovi Emmanuel V. 1998 Une élection libre en Afrique: La présidentielle du Bénin (1996) Paris Karthala
Allen Chris Joan Baxter Michael C. Radu Keith Somerville 1989 Benin, The Congo, Burkina Faso Marxist Regimes Series New York Pinter
Barkan Joel 1995 Elections in Agrarian Society Journal of Democracy 6 4 106–16Google Scholar
Baniafouna Calixte 1995 Congo Démocratie: Les Références Vol. 2 Paris Harmattan
Bates Robert H. 1999 The Economic Bases of Democratization State, Conflict, and Democracy in Africa Richard Joseph Boulder 83–94 Lynne Rienner
Bates Robert H. Avner Grief Margaret Levi Jean-Laurent Rosenthal Barry Weingast 1998 Analytic Narratives Princeton Princeton University Press
Bazenguissa-Ganga Remy 1994 Ninja, Cobra et la malice d'Aubeville: Sociologies des pratiques de la violence urbaine a Brazzaville Isaac O. Albert et al. Urban Management and Urban Violence in Africa Ibadan IFRA, n.p
Bazenguissa-Ganga Remy 1999 The Spread of Political Violence in Congo-Brazzaville African Affairs 98 37 54Google Scholar
Bénin 0000 Cour Constitutionnelle. Décisions, nos. 16-94; 27-94; 29-94; 30-94; 31-94; Avis 001/94
Boulaga F. Eboussi 1993 Les Conférences Nationales en Afrique Noire Paris Karthala
Bratton Michael Nicolas Van de Walle 1997 Democratic Experiments in Africa: Regime Transitions in Comparative Perspective Cambridge Cambridge University Press
Chabi Maurice 1993 Banqueroute: Mode d'emploi (Un marabout dans les griffes de la mafia béninoise) Cotonou Editions Gazette Livres
Clark John F. 1994 The National Conference as an Instrument of Democratization in Francophone Africa Journal of Third World Studies 11 1 (Spring) 304–35Google Scholar
Clark John F. 1997 Congo: Transition and the Struggle to Consolidate John F. Clark and David E. Gardinier Political Reform in Francophone Africa Boulder Westview Press 62–85
Clark John F. 1998 Democracy Dismantled in the Congo Republic Current History 97 619 (May) 234–37Google Scholar
Clark John F. 2002a The Neo-Colonial Context of the Democratic Experiment of Congo-Brazzaville African Affairs 101 403 (Apr.) 171–92Google Scholar
Clark John F. 2002b Resource Revenues and Political Development in Sub-Saharan Africa: Congo Republic in Comparative Perspective Afrika Spectrum 37 1 25 41Google Scholar
Coquery-Vidrovitch Catherine 1972 Le Congo au temps des grandes compagnies concessionnaires, 1898–1930 Paris Mouton
Decalo Samuel 1990 [1976] Coups and Army Rule in Africa: Studies in Military Style New Haven 2d ed. Yale University Press
Decalo Samuel 1979 Ideological Rhetoric and Scientific Socialism in Benin and Congo/Brazzaville Carl G. Rosberg and Thomas M. Callaghy Socialism in Sub-Saharan Africa: A New Assessment Berkeley University of California Institute of International Studies 231–64
Decalo Samuel 1995 Historical Dictionary of Benin 3d ed. Lanham, Md Scarecrow Press
Decalo Samuel 1997 Benin: The First of the New Democracies John F. Clark and David Gardinier Political Reform in Francophone Africa Boulder Westview Press 43–61
Decalo Samuel Virginia Thompson Richard Adloff 1996 Historical Dictionary of Congo 3d ed. Lanham, Md. Scarecrow Press
Diamond, Larry, Juan J. Linz and Seymour Martin Lipset 1988 Democracy in Developing Countries Volume Two, Africa Boulder Lynne Rienner
Diamond, Larry, Juan J. Linz and Seymour Martin Lipset 1995 What Makes for Democracy? Politics in Developing Countries: Comparing Experiences with Democracy Boulder Lynne Rienner, n.p
Diamond Larry 1999 Developing Democracy: Towards Consolidation Baltimore Johns Hopkins University Press
DiPalma Giuseppe 1990 To Craft Democracies: An Essay on Democratic Transitions Berkeley University of California Press
Dossou Robert 1993 Le Bénin: Du Monolithisme à la démocratie pluraliste, un temoignage Gerard Conac L'Afrique en Transition vers le pluralisme politique Paris Editions Economica
Grindle Merilee 1997 Challenging the State Cambridge Cambridge University Press
Heilbrunn John 1993 Social Origins of National Conferences in Benin and Togo The Journal of Modern African Studies 31 2 277–99Google Scholar
Herbst Jeffrey 2000 States and Power in Africa: Comparative Lesson in Authority and Control Princeton Princeton University Press
Houngnikpo Mathurin C. 2001 Determinants of Democratization in Africa: A Comparative Study of Benin and Togo Lanham, Md. University Press of America
Igue John O. Bio G. Soule 1992 L'État entrepôt au Bénin: Commerce informel où solution à la crise? Paris Karthala
Jackson Robert Carl Rosberg 1982 Personal Rule in Black Africa: Autocrat, Prophet, Prince, and Tyrant Berkeley University of California Press
Joseph Richard 1992 Zambia: A Model for Democratic Change Current History 91 565 199–201Google Scholar
Le Pape, Marc, and Pierre Salignon 2001 Une Guerre Contre les Civils: Réflexions sur les pratiques humanitaires au Congo Brazzaville (1998–2000) Paris Karthala and Médecins Sans Frontières
Lijphart Arend 1977 Democracy in Plural Societies: A Comparative Exploration New Haven Yale University Press
Lijphart Arend 1999 Patterns of Democracy: Government Forms and Performance in Thirty-Six Countries New Haven Yale University Press
Magnusson Bruce 1999 Testing Democracy in Benin: Experiments in Institutional Reform Richard Joseph State, Conflict, and Democracy in Africa Boulder Lynne Rienner 217–38
Magnusson Bruce 2001 Democratization and Domestic Insecurity: Navigating the Transition in Benin Comparative Politics 33 2 (Jan.) 211–30Google Scholar
Magnusson Bruce 2005 Democratic Legitimacy in Benin: Institutions and Identity in a Regional Context” Leo Villalón and Peter VonDoepp The Fate of Africa's Democratic Experiments: Elites and Institutions Bloomington Indiana University Press
1993 Marchés Tropicaux et Méditerranéens Paris
Mozaffar Shaheen 1995 The Institutional Logic of Ethnic Politics: A Prolegomenon Harvey Glickman Ethnic Conflict and Democratization in Africa Atlanta African Studies Association, n.p
Pourtier Roland 1998 1997: Les raisons d'une guerre ‘incivile’ Afrique Contemporaine 186 (2d Trimester) 7 32Google Scholar
Przeworski Adam et al 1997 What Makes Democracies Endure? Larry Diamond, et al. Consolidating the Third Wave Democracies Baltimore Johns Hopkins University Press 295–311
Przeworski Adam et al 2000 Democracy and Development: Political Institutions and Well-Being in the World, 1950–1990 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
Quantin Patrick 1997 Congo: Transition démocratiques et conjoncture critique Jean-Pascal Daloz and Patrick Quantin Transitions démocratiques africaines: Dynamiques et contraintes (1990–1994) Paris Karthala 139–91
Reynolds Andrew 1995 The Case for Proportionality Journal of Democracy 6 1 117–24Google Scholar
Robinson Pearl 1994 The National Conference Phenomenon in Francophone Africa Comparative Studies in Society and History 36 3 575 610Google Scholar
Ronen Dov 1975 Dahomey: Between Tradition and Modernity Ithaca Cornell University Press
Ross Michael L. 2001 Does Oil Hinder Democracy? World Politics 53 3 325–61Google Scholar
Schraeder Peter J. 2000 Cold War to Cold Peace: Explaining U.S.-French Competition in Francophone Africa Political Science Quarterly 115 3 395 419Google Scholar
Smith Zeric Kay 2000 Democratisation and Ethnic Conflict in Africa. Journal of Modern African Studies 38 1 21 39Google Scholar
United Nations Development Program 1998 Human Development Report New York Oxford
Valenzuela J. Samuel 1992 Democratic Consolidation in Post-Transitional Settings: Notion, Process, and Facilitating Conditions Scott Mainwaring et al. Issues in Democratic Consolidation Notre Dame University of Notre Dame Press 57–104
Verschave François-Xavier 1998 La Françafrique: Le plus long scandale de la République Paris Stock
Villalón, Leonardo and Peter VonDoepp 2005 The Fate of Africa's Democratic Experiments: Elites and Institutions Bloomington Indiana University Press
Westebbe Richard 1994 Structural Adjustment, Rent Seeking, and Liberalization in Benin Jennifer Widner Economic Change and Political Liberalization in Sub-Saharan Africa Baltimore Johns Hopkins University Press 80–100
Widner Jennifer 1994 Two Leadership Styles and Patterns of Political Liberalization African Studies Review 37 1 151–74Google Scholar
Young Crawford 1982 Ideology and Development in Africa New Haven Yale University Press
Zartman I. William and Katharina R. Vogeli 2000 “Prevention Gained and Prevention Lost: Collapse, Competition, and Coup in Congo” Bruce W. Jentleson Opportunities Missed, Opportunities Seized: Preventive Diplomacy in the Post-Cold War World Lanham, Md. Rowman and Littlefield, n.p