Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-14T22:27:15.413Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Nation-in-Arms: State, Nation, and Militarism in Israel's First Years

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 June 2009

Uri Ben-Eliezer
Uri Ben-Eliezer
Affiliation:
Tel-Aviv University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Like many other states, Israel was forged through the struggle of a national liberation movement that likely drew inspiration from an ethnic past and that certainly worked to establish a political framework. Once the state existed, however, its leaders did not regard the ethnie as an objective category that would in large measure determine whether a nation would emerge. Instead, they viewed the ethnie as a subject susceptible, in varying degrees, to manipulation, invention, domination, and mobilization. As the prime minister of Piedmont said, “We have made Italy, now we have to make Italians”; or as Israel's first prime minister, Ben-Gurion, put it in April 1951 during the election campaign: “I see in these elections the shaping of a nation for the state because there is a state but not a nation.”

Type
Constructing Identity
Information
Comparative Studies in Society and History , Volume 37 , Issue 2 , April 1995 , pp. 264 - 285
Copyright
Copyright © Society for the Comparative Study of Society and History 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Smith, Anthony D., “State-Making and Nation-Building,” in Hall, John A., ed., States in History (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1986), 251.Google Scholar

2 An ethnic community, or ethnie, shares a common myth of origins and descent, a common history, elements of distinctive culture, a common territorial association, and sense of group solidarity. A nation is much more impersonal, abstract, and overtly political than an ethnic group. It is a cultural-political community that has become conscious of its coherence, unity, and particular interests. See, Smith, Anthony D., “Ethnie and Nation in the Modern World,” Millennium, 14:2 (1983), 128–32;Google ScholarAlter, Peter, Nationalism (London: Edward Arnold, 1989), 17.Google Scholar

3 Breuilly, John, Nationalism and the State (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1982);Google ScholarHobsbawm, Eric J., Nations and Nationalism Since 1780 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990);Google ScholarGellner, Ernest, Nation and Nationalism (New York: Cornell University Press, 1983);Google ScholarAnderson, Benedict, Imagined Communities (London: Verso, 1983).Google Scholar

4 Hobsbawm, , Nations and Nationalism Since 1780, 44–45;Google Scholar Ben-Guion in Mapai's meeting, from Kafkafi, Eyal, A Country Searching For Its People (Tel-Aviv: Hakibut Hameuchad, 1991), 3.Google Scholar

5 Kneset Protokol, August 19, 1952.Google Scholar

6 Johnson, John J., ed., The Role of the Military in Underdeveloped Countries (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1962);CrossRefGoogle ScholarPie, Lucian W., “Armies in the Process of Political Modernization,” in Johnson, The Role of the Military in Underdeveloped Countries, 69–89;Google ScholarLissak, Moshe, Military Roles and Modernization (California, Sage, 1976).Google Scholar

7 Lissak, Moshe, “The Israel Defence Forces as an Agent of Socialization and Education,” in Van Gils, M. R., ed., The Perceived Role of the Military (Rotterdam: Rotterdam University Press, 1971) 325–39;Google ScholarHorowitz, Dan and Kimmerling, Baruch, “Some Social Implications of Military Service and the Reserve System in Israel,” Archieve European Sociologic, 15 (1974), 262–76;CrossRefGoogle ScholarPerlmutter, Amos, The Military and Politics in Modern Times (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1977), 251–80;Google ScholarIdem., Military and Politics in Israel: Nation Building and Role Expansion (New York: Frederick A. Praeger, 1969);Google ScholarAzarya, Victor and Kimmerling, Baruch, “New Immigrants in the Israeli Armed Forces,” Armed Forces and Society, 6:3 (1980), 22–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

8 Luckham, A. R., “A Comparative Typology of Civil-Military Relations,” Government and Opposition, 6 (1971), 17–20;CrossRefGoogle ScholarRapoport, David, “A Comparative Theory of Military and Political Types,” in Huntington, Samuel, ed., Changing Patterns of Military Politics (New York: Free Press, 1962), 71–100;Google ScholarRoberts, Adam, Nation in Arms, The Theory and Practice of Territorial Defence (London: Chatto and Windus, 1976).Google Scholar

9 Horowitz, Dan and Lissak, Moshe, Out of Utopia (Albany: SUNY Press, 1989), 195–230;Google ScholarHorowitz, Dan, “The Israeli Defense Forces: A Civilianized Military in a Partially Militarized Society,” in Roman Kolkowicz and Andrei Korbonski, Soldiers, Peasants and Bureaucrats (London: George Allen and Unwin, 1982), 77–106;Google ScholarLuttwak, Eduard and Horowitz, Dan, The Israeli Army (London: Allen Lane, 1975);Google ScholarPei, Yoram, “Political-Military Partnership in Israel,” International Political Science Review, 2:3 (1981), 303–15.Google Scholar

10 Randall, Vicky and Theobald, Robin, Political Change and Underdevelopment (Durham: Duke University Press, 1985), 67–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

11 Horowitz, Dan, “Strategic Limitations of A Nation in Arms,” Armed Forces and Society, 13:2 (1987), 277–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

12 On the tendency to ignore the Palestinians in the Israeli Sociology, see Kimmerling, Baruch, “Sociology, Ideology, and Nation-Building: The Palestinians and their Meaning in Israeli Society,” American Sociological Review, 57:4 (1992), 446–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

13 Gilbert, F., ed., The Historical Essays of Otto Hintze (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1975), 159–77;Google ScholarHoward, Michael, “War and the Nation-State,” in his The Causes of Wars (London: Unwin Paperbacks, 1984), 23–35.Google Scholar

14 Finer, Samuel E., “State and Nation-Building in Europe: The Role of the Military,” in Tilly, Charles, ed., The Formation of National States in Western Europe (Princeton:, 1975), 84–163;Google ScholarBear, Richard, “War and the Birth of the Nation State,” The Journal of Economic History, 33 (1973), 203–21;Google ScholarGiddnes, Anthony, The Nation State and Violence (Berkeley: University of California Press), 1987;Google ScholarRasler, Karen A. and Thompson, William R., War and State Making (Boston: Unwin Hyman, 1989).Google Scholar

15 Hayes, Carlton J. H., “Jacobin Nationalism,” in his The Historical Evolution of Modern Nationalism (New York, Russel and Russell, 1931), 43–83;Google ScholarKohn, Hans, Nationalism, Its Meaning and History (Malabar: Robert E. Kreiger), 65, 82, 27–29;Google ScholarVagts, Alfred, A History of Militarism (New York, Meridian Books, 1959), 104–28;Google ScholarChallener, Richard D., The French Theory of the Nation in Arms (New York: Russell and Russell, 1965).Google Scholar

16 Ralston, David B., The Army of the Republic, The Place of the Military in the Political Evolution of France, 1871–1914 (Cambridge, MA: M.I.T. Press, 1967);Google ScholarPorch, Douglas, The March to the Marne, The French Army, 1871–1914 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

17 Gilbert, , The Historical Essays of Otto Hintze, 208;Google ScholarVagts, , A History of Militarism, 129–52.Google Scholar

18 Kitchen, Martin, The German Officer Corps, 1890–1914 Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1968;Google ScholarWillems, Emillio, A Way of Lífe and Death, Three Centuries of Prussian-German Militarism (Nashville: Vanderbilt University Press, 1986) 49–112;Google ScholarEley, Geoff, “Army, State and Civil Society: Revisiting the Problem of German Militarism,” from his Unification to Nazism (Boston: Allen and Unwin, 1987), 85–109;Google ScholarBest, Geoffry, “The Militarization of European Society 1870–1914”, in Gillis, J. R., ed., The Militarization of the Western World (New York: Rutgers University Press, 1989), 13–29;Google ScholarGoltz, Colmar Von Der, The Nation in Arms (London: Hugh Rees, 1913), 470–71.Google Scholar

19 Cook, Theodore F., “The Japanese Reserve Experience: From Nation-in-Arms to Baseline Defense,” in Zurcher, Louis A. and Haines-Jenkins, Gwyn, Supplementary Military Forces (London: Sage, 1978), 265.Google Scholar

20 Ibid, 259–73; Sunoo, Hakwon H., Japanese Militarism, Past and Present (Chicago: Nelson-Hall, 1975), 1–65;Google ScholarMeiion, and Harries, Susie, Sheathing the Sword.: The Demilitarization of Japan (London: Hamish Hamilton, 1987);Google ScholarCrowley, J. B., “From Closed Door to Empire: The Formation of the Meiji Military Establishment,” in Silberman, Bernard S. and Harootunian, H. D., eds., Modern Japanese Leadership: Tradition and Change (Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 1966).Google Scholar

21 On the concept of militarism, see Berghahn, Volker R., Militarism: The History of an International Debate, 1861–1979 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981), 31–36;Google ScholarMann, Michael, “The Roots and Contradictions of Modern Militarism,” in his States, War and Capitalism (New York: Basil Blackwell, 1988), 166–87;Google ScholarSkejelsbaek, Kjell, “Militarism, its Dimensions and Corollaries: An Attempt to Conceptual Clarification,” in Edie, Asbjorn and Thee, Narek, eds., Problems of Contemporary Militarism (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1980), 77–105.Google Scholar

22 Gelber, Yoav, “Ben-Guion and the Establishment of the IDF,” Jerusalem Quarterly, 50 (1989), 56–80.Google Scholar

23 Diary, Ben-Guion's, March 17, 1948, Ben-Gurion Archive.Google Scholar

24 Medding, Peter Y., The Founding of Israeli Democracy 1946–1967 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990), 134–37;Google ScholarLiebman, Charles and Don-Yehiya, Eliezer, Civil Religion in Israel (Berkeley: University of Berkeley Press, 1983), 81–122.Google Scholar

25 Shapira, Anita, The Army Controversy, 1948, Ben-Gurion's Struggle for Control Tel-Aviv: Hakibutz Hameuchad, 1985;Google ScholarGelber, Yoav, Why the Palmach Was Dissolved (Jerusalem: Shoken, 1986).Google Scholar

26 August 15, 1949, Kneset Protokol (Israel's parliament);Google ScholarMapai Center, February 2, 1950, Mapai Archive.Google Scholar

27 Roberts, , Nation in Arms, 37.Google Scholar

28 Mapai, Secretariat, August 7, 1949, Mapai Archive.Google Scholar

29 Vagts, , The History of Militarism, 59–60.Google Scholar

30 Ibid, 138–9. As for the French case, Challener's book, The French Theory of the Nation in Arms, provides an excellent discussion of the connection between party politics and the nation-inarms.

31 Morris, Benny, The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, 1947–1949 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989);Google ScholarIan, Lustick, Arabs in a Jewish State (Texas: University of Texas Press, 1980).Google Scholar

32 July 5, 1949, Kneset Protokol; Tom Segev, The First Israelis (New York: Free Press, 1986);Google ScholarPilovski, Varda, ed., Transition From ‘Yishuv’ to State 1947–1949 (in Hebrew) (Haifa: Haifa University, 1988);Google ScholarNaor, Morderhai, ed., First Year to Statehood, 1948–1949 (Hebrew) (Jerusalem: Yad Ben-Zvi, 1988).Google Scholar

33 Secretariat, Mapai, June 1, 1950, Mapai Archive.Google Scholar

34 Bamachane (IDF's Bulletin), November 23, 1950;Google ScholarKneset Protokol, January 29, 1951,Google ScholarBamachane, September 20, 1951;Google ScholarKneset Protokol, December 20, 1951.Google Scholar

35 Bamachane, November 23, 1950;Google ScholarBamachane, April 5, 1951.Google Scholar

36 Bamachane, September 20, 1951.Google Scholar

37 Kneset Protokol, August 18, 1952.Google Scholar

38 Challener, , The French Theory of the Nation in Arms, 3.Google Scholar

39 Birenbaum, Pierre, States and Collective Action: The European Experience (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988), 55–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

40 Protokol, Kneset, August 29, 1949.Google Scholar

41 Lissak, “The Israel Defence forces as an Agent of Siiialization and Education”; Horowitz and Kimmerling, “Some Social Implications of Military Service and the Reserve System in Israel”; Horowitz, “The Israeli Defense Forces: A Civilianized Military in a Partially Militarized Society.”

42 Gilbert, , The Historical Essays of Otto Hintze, 208;Google ScholarFiner, , “State and Nation-Building in Europe,” 153.Google Scholar

43 Cook, , “The Japanese Reserve Expeience,” 260–2.Google Scholar

44 Protokol, Kneset, August 29, 1949.Google Scholar

45 Protokol, Kneset, November 9, 1949.Google Scholar

46 Protokol, Kneset, August 18, 1952.Google Scholar

47 Hayes, , The Historical Evolution of Modern Nationalism, 43–83.Google Scholar

48 Kneset, Protokol, August 18, 1952.Google Scholar

49 Haaretz, (daily newspaper), March 12, 1950.Google Scholar

50 Bamachane, July 20, 1950.Google Scholar

51 “Draft-Cards for Mules,” Bamachane, July 31, 1952.Google Scholar

52 Cook, , “The Japanese Reserve Experience,” 271.Google Scholar

53 Bamachane, October 17, 1949;Google ScholarProtokol, Kneset, August 29, 1949.Google Scholar

54 Kneset Protokol, August 19, 1952;Google ScholarDavar (daily newspaper), August 19, 20, 1952.Google Scholar See also Baruch Kimmerling's article about Israel's conception of peace (“Exchanging Territories for Peace: A Macrosociological Approach,” The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 23:1 [1987], 13–33).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

55 Center, Mapai, January 12, 1949, Mapai Archive.Google Scholar

56 Protokol, Kneset, November 7, 1955.Google Scholar

57 Shirii, Asnat, The Policy of Settlement During the Independent War and After (in Hebrew) (Tel-Aviv: M. A. thesis, Tel-Aviv University, 1992), 197–98.Google Scholar

58 Council, Mapai, June 19, 1948, Mapai Archive.Google Scholar

59 Ben-Eliezer, Un, “Israel's Myth of Pioneering and the Elusive Distinction between Society and State,” in Megamos (forthcoming, 1995).Google Scholar

60 Haaretz, , September 28, 1953.Google Scholar

61 Tevet, Shabtai, Moshe Dayan (Tel-Aviv: Shoken, 1971), 355.Google Scholar

62 Haaretz, October 7, 12, 15, 21, 1953.Google Scholar

63 Bamachane, September 18, 1956; October 3, 1956.Google Scholar

64 Teveth, , Moshe Dayan, 399;Google ScholarBenziman, Uzi, Sharon, an Israeli Caesar (New York: Adama Books, 1985), 50;Google ScholarMilstein, Uri, By Blood and Fire (in Hebrew; Tel-Aviv: Levine-Epstein, 1975) 176–93.Google Scholar

65 Bamachane, October 5, 12, 1955.Google Scholar

66 Davar, October 21, 23, 1955.Google Scholar

67 Davar, October 24, 25, 1955; November 5, 6, 1955.Google Scholar

68 Hobsbawm, , Nations and Nationalism, 10–11.Google Scholar

69 Histadrut Political Committee, December 28, 1955, Histadrut Archive.Google Scholar

70 Hobsbawm, , Nations and Nationalism, 46.Google Scholar

71 Bar-On, Mordechai, The Gates of Gaza (in Hebrew) (Tel-Aviv: Am-Oved, 1992), 86–97;Google ScholarBar-On, Mordechai, Challenge and Quarrel, The Road to Sinai 1956 (in Hebrew) (Beer-Sheba: Ben-Guion University, 1991).Google Scholar

72 Hayes, , The Historical Evolution of Modern Nationalism, 43–83.Google Scholar

73 Kneset Protokol, March 5, 1951.Google Scholar

74 Histadrut Central Committee, July 19, 1956, Histadrut Archive.Google Scholar

75 Eshed, Chagai, “No Peace-No War,” Davar, October 26, 1955.Google Scholar

76 “Militarism,” in Kerning, , Marxism, Communism and Western Society.Google Scholar

77 Reptur, Berl, Histadrut Central Committee, November 10, 1955; Histadrut Archive.Google Scholar

78 Kneset Protokol, November 2, 1955.Google Scholar

79 Bar-On, , The Gates of Gaza, 59–67;Google ScholarBar-On, , Challenge and Quarrel, 47–50.Google Scholar

80 Bar-On, , Challenge and Quarrel, 82.Google Scholar

81 Soboul, Albert, The French Revolution, 1787–1799 (New York: Vintage Books, 1974), 268–9.Google Scholar

82 Cook, “The Japanese Reserve Experience.”

83 Kneset Protokol, June 4, 1956;Google ScholarBar-On, , The Gates of Gaza, 103–4; Bar-On, Challenge and Quarrel, 83–84.Google Scholar

84 Sharet, Moshe, Personal Diary (in Hebrew) (Tel-Aviv: Maaiv Library, 1978), 1385 (April 3, 1956).Google Scholar

85 This was also proven in the waiting period of July 1967 that preceded the Six-Days War. See Horowitz, , “Strategic Limitations of ‘A Nation in Arms,’” 285.Google Scholar

86 E.g., , Stig Forster, “Facing ‘People War’: Moltke the Elder and Germany's Military Options after 1871,” The Journal of Strategic Studies, 10:2 (1987), 209–29;Google ScholarBerghahn, V. R., Germany and the Approach of War in 1914 (London: Macmillan, 1973).Google Scholar

87 Davar, November 7, 1956;Google ScholarBamachane, January 18, 1957;Google ScholarBar-On, , Challenge and Quarrel, 328.Google Scholar

88 Shapiro, Yonatan, The Road to Power, Herut Party in Israel (New York: SUNY Press, 1990), 153–9.Google Scholar

89 Stem, Fritz, The Citizen Army, Key to Defense in the Atomic Age (New York: St. Martin Press, 1957). See also note 9.Google Scholar

90 Finer, S. E., “State Building, State Boundaries and Border Control,” Social Science Information, 13 (1974), 79–126;CrossRefGoogle ScholarHobsbawm, , Nations and Nationalism, 80.Google Scholar

91 Ben-Eliezer, Uri, “The Meaning of Political Participation in a Non-Liberal Democracy: The Israeli Example,” Comparative Politics, 25:4 (June 1983).Google Scholar

92 Yediot Achronot (daily newspaper), November 29, 1988.Google Scholar

93 Yediot Achronot, May 12, 1992;Google ScholarDavar, May 15, 1992.Google Scholar